Statement after the meeting regarding the ecological situation on the Oder River.

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

30 August 2022 · Meeting regarding the ecological situation on the Oder River

Context
Duda addressed officials after a meeting with voivodes to discuss the ecological disaster caused by golden algae on the Oder River in August 2022.
Main themes
Oder River ecological disaster, golden algae toxin, fish and crustacean deaths, river contamination investigation, crisis response and barriers, water salinity and low water levels, voivodeship coordination, human health safety, environmental protection, fish stock losses
Duration
~13 min
46th percentile
Words
1,559
46th percentile
Sentences
75
49th percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
11.6
41st percentile
Syntax
3.13
64th percentile
Vocabulary
2.32
78th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 84%83%
  • Institutional 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

75 sentences in 23 paragraphs

Good morning, Ladies and Gentlemen!

I have just finished a meeting with the voivodes. I would like to thank the Lubusz Voivode for inviting the West Pomeranian Voivode and the Lower Silesian Voivode as well. The meeting concerned the disaster that occurred on the Odra River. There were representatives from Polish Waters led by the President, representatives from the Ministry of Environment, and Minister Golińska also participated in this meeting. There were also representatives from services, inspections, and emergency services who took part in the entire crisis action, as well as representatives from the Environmental Protection Inspectorate and the Sanitary Inspectorate.

We discussed the course of the entire event that unfortunately took place on the Odra, but also on some of its tributaries, as the problem of dead fish appeared not only on the Odra itself but also, of course, on other rivers, albeit on a smaller scale. The Lower Silesian Voivode stated that the whole matter actually began at the border of the Opole and Lower Silesian voivodeships, where the first dead fish were found, which, as was claimed at the time, resulted from someone contaminating the river with some oxidizer.

However, it turned out that this had nothing to do with the facts; there was no physical or human contamination that would have directly caused the fish to die. In fact, today we know that the cause of this disaster—the death of fish that occurred in the area of three voivodeships—is the golden algae. More specifically, the direct cause of the fish deaths was a toxin released by this algae.

This phenomenon is very difficult to ascertain. It is so difficult that there is still a question mark, and studies are currently being conducted by experts. There is still no clear answer as to the specific circumstances under which the golden algae, this type of algae, releases this toxin. Because it is a normal situation that these algae—according to experts—simply coexist with the fauna and flora of the river, water bodies, fish, and crustaceans.

The deaths concerned fish and crustaceans. Under certain conditions, these algae do not release this toxin. In some specific conditions—still not precisely determined—this particular toxin is released, and it is indeed toxic to fish and crustaceans.

The phenomenon occurred— as I said—over the area of three voivodeships. On the largest scale in the West Pomeranian Voivodeship, of course, because—as we know well—the Odra River flows in that direction, and along the way, it is also a catchment area for many other rivers. Consequently, this phenomenon simply expanded, and indeed the greatest losses in fish stocks were actually in the lower part of the Odra, in the West Pomeranian Voivodeship, significantly smaller in the Lubusz and Lower Silesian voivodeships.

Fortunately, this phenomenon was managed to be stopped. There was very intensive intervention, especially in the West Pomeranian Voivodeship—29 barriers were erected in 17 locations to stop the dead fish and also to hold back some of the water. As a result, it was achieved that neither contaminated water reached Lake Dąbie nor, even more so, the Szczecin Lagoon, and fortunately, there were no fish deaths in those bodies of water.

The toxin-contaminated water was essentially stopped at the height of Szczecin itself. The last fish deaths occurred in Szczecin—this is clearly indicated by the reports from the Voivode. Fortunately, also as a result of actions taken by the Voivode and the appropriate services, a huge number of fish were saved in the area between the Odra branches. The Voivode mentioned that today in the Odyńca Canal—between the two branches of the Odra—there is a huge number of fish that have actually taken refuge there, and no deaths occurred there.

At this moment, research is still ongoing regarding the ultimate cause of why the toxin was emitted by the algae. However, it can certainly be said today that it was a certain set of causes that occurred. Firstly—a very low water level in the Odra and its tributaries. Secondly—a relatively high salinity at this low water level, high air temperatures, and—as we know—the river itself. However, at which exact moment the toxin was emitted is currently under investigation.

Ladies and Gentlemen, what is the most important thing in all of this? From a purely human perspective, the most important thing is that this toxin itself, as well as—one can boldly say—this situation, was not harmful to humans, meaning that this toxin does not accumulate in fish at all. Detailed studies were conducted on both dead fish and live fish taken from the Odra—no toxins were found in their bodies.

As a result, the conclusion of the experts here is unequivocal: the toxin affected the nervous system of these fish and crustaceans, but it did not accumulate in their bodies. The toxin is not harmful to humans, so there was no situation in which the emission of this toxin was harmful to people.

Of course, it was an unfortunate situation—potentially dangerous—that so many dead fish were flowing down the river. Therefore, it was and is necessary to take actions, as much as possible, to clean the river of dead fish. These actions are ongoing. However, the phenomenon itself was not harmful to humans.

Ladies and Gentlemen, studies were also conducted—because I was assured here by representatives of the Environmental Protection Inspectorate and the Sanitary Inspectorate—whether there was any contamination of groundwater. No, there was not. The groundwater is clean.

Cows from farms along the Odra were also examined. No poisoning was found in the cows themselves, nor—importantly—were any toxins found in the milk of these cows. There was even a herd that, thanks to monitoring of the Odra, was observed in the river itself—cows were simply standing in the river, drinking water, cooling off. These cows were examined, and their milk was tested—no contaminants were found. Therefore, the mere fact of the emission of these toxins into the river by golden algae did not pose a danger to humans.

Unfortunately, there are enormous damages concerning the fauna of the river. We all know that over 200 tons of fish and crustaceans have died, the most— as I mentioned—in the West Pomeranian Voivodeship. Consequently, in this regard, the river will require restoration. Restoration is—of course—always a certain natural process, and nature rebuilds itself. But here, representatives of Polish Waters assured that they are preparing a special law specifically to help the Odra recover, to assist the Odra in species restoration—and special actions in this regard are being undertaken.

Therefore, I can draw a final conclusion for the future from this entire situation, from what we discussed today. Firstly—we will, absolutely of course, based on what the experts and scientists ultimately say here, seek the cause, at which moment, under what specific conditions, and why the emission of this toxin from the golden algae occurred, which ultimately led to the disaster. So that in the future we know under what conditions this could potentially happen and try to find ways to prevent such a situation in the future.

And secondly—a system of continuous, 24-hour monitoring of water quality will be established. The waters are monitored in terms of their flow rates. We know the daily states of the rivers and individual watercourses—the Institute of Meteorology and Water Management deals with this, such studies are conducted on a daily basis. However, 24-hour studies of the composition of the Odra River, the quality of the water, have not been conducted until now.

It is partly thanks to the fact that the Odra began to be observed 24 hours a day that this cause was established. And it was established by simply noting changes in the daily oxygenation of the river. And after that, it was recognized that the cause is most likely the algae.

This was the first signal indicated by scientists—which, from the suspicion of contamination by human hand, directed all attention to the biological situation, to the fact that it could be a biological cause. Although, of course—as we said—there is also the issue of the salinity of the river, which is not natural, which is salinity resulting from the discharge of mining waters into the Odra and its tributaries.

So a whole range of factors are components here, and therefore actions are needed for the future to try to find ways to potentially prevent such phenomena in the future. Establishing under what conditions such a disaster can occur and what we can do, what actions we can take to try to prevent it in the future—that is one.

Two: the biological restoration of the Odra River, which requires a special law, also requires support from scientists, and appropriate actions need to be taken here. I believe that there will be many people of good will who will also want to dedicate their time and direct their attention to ensure that the Odra can recover as quickly as possible in the places where fish have been so significantly reduced. Because, of course, it is not the case that this disaster completely wiped out fish in certain sections of the Odra—no. However, unfortunately, we must clearly state that especially in the south of the West Pomeranian Voivodeship, the number of fish in the river has significantly decreased.

That is all I can tell you at this moment; these are the conclusions from our meeting today. Thank you very much.