Statement by the President after the meeting with the Speaker of the Sejm

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

8 January 2024

Context
Duda addressed press after meeting Speaker Hołownia on 8 January 2024, explaining his position on the disputed 2015 pardons and MPs' parliamentary mandates.
Main themes
Presidential clemency powers, Mariusz Kamiński and Maciej Wąsik pardons, parliamentary mandates dispute, constitutional legality of clemency, Sejm tensions, Central Anti-Corruption Bureau, rule of law in Poland, political controversy, Speaker of the Sejm meeting
Duration
~9 min
33rd percentile
Words
1,136
33rd percentile
Sentences
55
36th percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
10.6
28th percentile
Syntax
3.00
48th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
50th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 87%87%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

55 sentences in 18 paragraphs

Good morning, ladies and gentlemen!

Ladies and gentlemen, I have just finished my meeting with Mr. Marshal Hołownia. I am glad that we were able to talk. I decided to invite Mr. Marshal for a meeting because the situation we are observing today in the Sejm and around the Sejm – also around the person of the Marshal – is becoming increasingly tense and is affecting the entire situation in our country.

In this regard, I decided to talk to Mr. Marshal because I believe that this loop, which is becoming more and more complicated, should simply be cut in some way. The situation is constitutionally and legally very difficult. And I would give a horse with a saddle to anyone who still understands what it is all about – especially when it comes to ordinary citizens. Lawyers have a problem with precisely understanding it from a legal perspective.

Ladies and gentlemen!

However, what are the facts? The facts are that in 2015, four individuals who held public office were convicted for activities related to the functioning of the Central Anti-Corruption Bureau; to put it simply, related to the fight against corruption. We remember the land scandal, we remember the case of the PO MP, Ms. Sawicka. This aroused enormous social emotions.

As a result, just before the elections in 2015, primarily Mr. Ministers – Mariusz Kamiński and Mr. Minister Wąsik – were convicted by the court under very controversial circumstances at that time: multiple allegations of irregularities in the procedure of selecting the judge who dealt with the case, as well as the drastic politicization of the entire matter.

After the judge issued the verdict at that time, I decided to grant clemency to those convicted individuals, primarily the Ministers. This clemency has recently been described in the media as almost textbook. Why? For a very simple reason.

It was a precise implementation of the constitutional prerogative of the presidency, which is the right of clemency, combined with what has been written for, one might say, decades in textbooks for law students – young lawyers, trainees studying law, when it comes to criminal procedure – where there were two possible types of clemency: so-called abolitional and amnesty. And that, namely, the one that releases from prosecution, was an abolitional clemency; a form that was described in those textbooks, which absolutely fell within the framework of the prerogative – I emphasize – of the presidency, which is the right of clemency.

Initially, it was absolutely not questioned in any way by the District Court, to which this case went immediately after the presidential act, but later it was challenged by several judges of the Supreme Court and caused a whole avalanche of various judgments – through three subsequent judgments of the Constitutional Tribunal, which recognized the correctness of the actions of the President of the Republic, through later court judgments.

In general, this led to a terrible legal complication, which has now also transferred to the issue of the expiration – or non-expiration – of the mandates of the MPs currently. Because in the last elections, both Mr. Minister Mariusz Kamiński and Mr. Minister Wąsik received parliamentary mandates once again from the voters, which is a sign of trust and a kind of recognition of their previous public service.

The matter is very complicated. It raises enormous concerns today. It also raises increasingly greater legal controversies: what will happen if – as we have recently heard – the MPs are not allowed in, [are] forcibly detained by the Marshal's Guard, are not allowed into the Sejm, are not allowed into the chamber, and cannot perform their parliamentary duties? Therefore, I decided to invite Mr. Marshal to explain to him what my position is.

Well, ladies and gentlemen – it is unequivocal: the presidential prerogative was effectively executed in 2015. The gentlemen – all four – were effectively pardoned by the President of the Republic. This definitively closed the matter. Thus, I have no doubt that the gentlemen today have parliamentary mandates, which were granted to them by the citizens in the last elections, and they have the right to perform these mandates. They therefore constitute part of the legislative body of the state, which is the Sejm. And I have no doubts about that.

I communicated this to Mr. Marshal, while also proposing to Mr. Marshal that in order to close this matter, to avoid unrest, to avoid further piling up of controversies and unnecessary state, social, and constitutional anxieties in this matter – simply recognize today that the clemency from 2015 was and is effective. In other words – to put it briefly – it was carried out in 2015, as it should have been recognized from the very beginning. I do not want to engage in a discussion here about the political nature of subsequent decisions made by judges, particularly the Supreme Court and later.

The facts are that over the years since the adoption of the constitution in 1997, we have had various cases of clemency in Poland, and you know them. Some of them were very controversial. They were never questioned in such a way, even though they concerned individuals who indeed committed crimes. Today, however, there is a group of people holding responsible positions in Poland who want, at all costs, to send to prison those who carried out their tasks in the fight against corruption. I believe that from the perspective of the Polish state, this is an unacceptable situation.

In a democratic state, there is no place for corruption; in a democratic state, there can absolutely be no shadow… there can be no tolerance for corruption. This was one of our greatest achievements in the last 20 years since the famous Rywin affair, that to such a significant extent corruption has been fought in Poland. A great deal of this is due, among others, to Mr. Minister Mariusz Kamiński and his colleagues from the Central Anti-Corruption Bureau. This is therefore a state matter.

And I also told Mr. Marshal Hołownia today. This is a state matter. If we take this into account, if we add the element of social and constitutional peace and order, the only reasonable solution is simply to close this matter. In order to prevent the unrest that has arisen in connection with this from spreading further. Because this is a situation that is otherwise, in fact, unsolvable.

I can tell you that Mr. Marshal and I presented our positions to each other on this matter. Our conversation took place in a calm atmosphere, with all the principles of political culture being observed. We did not reach an agreement, we shook hands. Further decisions will be made by Mr. Marshal within his responsibility and the responsibility associated with the office he holds.

Thank you very much.