Statement by the President of the Republic of Poland after the meeting with the President of Germany

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

12 December 2022 · Meeting with the President of Germany · Presidential Palace, Berlin, Germany

Context
Duda addressed the press after meeting German President Steinmeier in Berlin in December 2022 to discuss defense cooperation and the war in Ukraine.
Main themes
Polish-German relations, Patriot air defense batteries deployment, support for Ukraine, NATO alliance solidarity, missile defense integration, Ukrainian refugee assistance, Russian attacks on civilian infrastructure, bilateral neighborly cooperation, military aid to Ukraine
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,345
80th percentile
Sentences
134
76th percentile
Readability
44
46th percentile
Grade
12.8
55th percentile
Syntax
3.20
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
15th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 42%42%
  • Ceremonial 20%20%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Economic 13%13%
  • Social 10%10%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

134 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Highly esteemed Mr. President, esteemed Ministers, all highly esteemed guests!

Once again, I would like to express my sincere gratitude to President Frank-Walter Steinmeier for the invitation to be here in Berlin, at the Presidential Palace, and for the opportunity to hold this meeting today, which comes at a time close to the upcoming Christmas holidays, but indeed also coincides with a very difficult time in European and global politics – and this was the main topic of our discussions today.

But I want to thank you primarily for the fact that these discussions took place in a very good, friendly, and neighborly atmosphere. I am very grateful to you, Mr. President. Germany has been, and is, a great European country – one can boldly say: a great European power – it is one of the great nations of the North Atlantic Alliance and is also our great neighbor.

It is a great neighbor to Poland, with which Poland is connected by the strongest ties not only resulting from our mutual border but also from the enormous economic connections, common interests, and many important elements of our shared history, sometimes difficult – but indeed an important history. And over the last 30 years, certainly a good history. Many people have contributed to building these ties between Poland and Germany to the greatest extent possible.

That is why I am here today in Berlin, also to express my gratitude to the German authorities for the decision to send German Patriot batteries to Poland – to protect Poland. Mr. President, thank you. The Polish people have received this as an important gesture, especially after what happened at our eastern border, when an accident occurred, a missile fell, and two Polish citizens lost their lives. This obviously caused a lot of concern in Polish society. Fortunately, it was just an accident, but it is obvious to everyone that strengthening Poland's missile defense, strengthening air defense is of enormous importance for building our security.

Thank you for the German authorities' decision to send Patriot batteries to support Poland and that these batteries will protect Polish skies and Polish land. We discussed this with you, Mr. President, and we hope that in the coming days, appropriate groups of Polish and German experts will meet, determine the locations for the deployment of these Patriot system batteries, and then – that these batteries will arrive soon to physically create this protection.

Of course, it is necessary – as I told you, Mr. President – to integrate these batteries into the entire Polish air defense system, including missile defense, what we are talking about regarding the entire air defense system of Poland. There is an appropriate command in Poland for this purpose. Coordination of the tasks performed by these batteries with the tasks being carried out within the entire air and missile defense of the country is necessary. This element is essential for these systems to be able to cooperate appropriately.

There are several proposed solutions that can be applied here. I hope that one of them will be chosen and that this system will be able to operate, strengthening – as I said – the protection of the area of Poland, also as part of NATO territory, also as a neighboring state to the Federal Republic of Germany. Once again, we thank you, we perceive this gesture in Poland as a very important allied gesture within NATO and as a very important neighborly gesture in relations between Poland and Germany, between the Polish and German nations. Thank you for this, Mr. President.

We also talked – of course – about the issue of Ukraine. We share the same view with you, Mr. President: we must support Ukraine with all our strength, we must support Ukraine militarily. Poland provides the possibility of military support also by making our territory available for the implementation of this task. We ourselves have sent – within our capabilities – enormous military support to Ukraine, estimated at about 2 billion dollars. This is a very large amount for us. We continue to support Ukraine. We are pleased to receive information that weapons produced in Poland are proving effective and indeed helping Ukrainian soldiers defend the territory of Ukraine.

We support them with all our strength. We also support them by taking in Poland, on our territory, their wives, their children. We try to provide them with the best possible conditions, shelter, and above all safety, so that they can find refuge in our country from bombs, from Russian occupation, from – in short – death at the hands of Russian soldiers.

This problem, unfortunately, is now also growing in light of how Russia is waging war against Ukraine, bombing critical infrastructure serving the residents, serving the heating of residential buildings, serving the supply of electricity. The current Russian tactic is to destroy this infrastructure in many places in Ukraine, depriving people of the ability to heat their homes, depriving them of the ability to have electricity in their apartments.

With winter approaching, with the frost that is coming and has already arrived over the territory of Ukraine – the difference between Berlin and, for example, Warsaw or eastern Poland is that while we do not see snow in Berlin at the moment, in Poland it has been snowing for two days, and there is already a lot of snow at the border with Ukraine; so one can only imagine how much snow there is in Ukraine, especially in the more continental part, where the frosts are also greater – and in light of the Russian invasion, the number of fleeing people is obviously increasing. In short, very often they are fleeing simply from the death of freezing that threatens them, but also from Russian missiles and bombs. The number of refugees in Poland has increased in recent months and weeks – we estimate that there are currently about 3 million.

We discussed this with you, Mr. President, because it will probably also mean an increase in the number of refugees from Ukraine in Germany. We are neighboring countries. Some refugees from Ukraine treat Poland only as a transit country, heading to Germany, often having relatives here. So Germany should also expect that the number of refugees from Ukraine will be increasing.

I told you, Mr. President, that I believe we should appeal to the European community, to the European Commission, for special financial support dedicated to our countries that bear a particular burden in connection with the acceptance of refugees fleeing from the Russian invasion, from the destruction that Russia, the Russian army, is wreaking in Ukraine. This was the second very important topic of our conversation with you, Mr. President.

Of course, we also talked about economic issues, energy issues, and issues of mutual support in policies that will help us overcome the energy crisis. We talked about oil supplies, also with the support of the Polish Naftoport that we have in Gdańsk, and our capabilities. Of course, we will strive to achieve the best possible cooperation here, the most neighborly cooperation. It is the case that we also have secured gas supplies to Poland through the diversification that we have been implementing for years.

I would like to take this opportunity to thank many German politicians who recently – in a sense, one could say – restored our honor, restored the honor of Polish politics, telling us that we were indeed right to be concerned that at some point Russia might resort to gas blackmail; that becoming dependent on Russian gas supplies is dangerous and that we should seek other sources of supply; that we warned against Russia; that we did so rightly and we were correct. I want to thank you for these words. I know that in politics it is not easy to express such words and to admit someone is right.

I do not want to express satisfaction from this place. But I want to say that I deeply believe that in the future we will pursue a policy that will be safe for our countries – for Poland, for Germany – for the countries that border my country, Poland; for our neighbors to the east, for Ukraine; for our neighbors to the south, with whom we are also connected today by interconnectors, such as with Slovakia, with the Czech Republic; for our neighbors from further southern countries, from the Three Seas Initiative countries; but above all for the entire European Union. Because I believe that the policy of wise diversification of supplies, and above all a lack of trust towards partners who are not reliable, is simply sensible and far-sighted. And I believe that we will pursue such a policy together in the future.

Ladies and gentlemen, we talked with you, Mr. President, on various topics. Some topics concerning our economic cooperation, our joint building, our joint overcoming of the crisis, where we also support each other – these are easy topics that are easy to discuss.

Of course, we also have difficult topics between us, but we are ready – as Presidents – to talk about them. It may not be the case that decisions are made on all these issues here, at the presidential level, no. But we also address difficult topics – especially those that often have a moral dimension, as well as the dimension of eliminating certain historical grievances, barriers, such as the issue of reparations for Poland for World War II, for the destruction of World War II.

From the perspective of Poles, these are important matters. We also discuss these topics and we will continue to discuss them. I believe that in time they will be positively resolved – positively for Germany, positively for Poland, and as a result positively for the entire European community. Because such issues should be resolved.

Just as the issue of the reconstruction of Ukraine and the costs of this reconstruction should be firmly raised by all of us in the international forum. We want to participate in the reconstruction of Ukraine, we want to cooperate here with the Federal Republic of Germany and with other European countries, including the G7 countries. We – Poland – are a country that borders Ukraine directly, and therefore also through our territory, there is access to the territory of Ukraine. It is therefore a natural matter for us that support for Ukraine – also that related to the reconstruction of the country – will certainly require Polish transit in some part.

But we have no doubt that not only do we want to, but that we primarily have the potential to participate in the reconstruction of Ukraine together with our other partners. I believe that we will be able to cooperate in this process with the Federal Republic of Germany and also with German companies and that we will be part of the great project of rebuilding Ukraine, which I hope will soon be realized.

Ladies and gentlemen, of course, we all realize that this reconstruction will entail enormous costs. The World Bank recently provided a preliminary forecast that the reconstruction of the infrastructure that is currently destroyed in Ukraine will probably cost about 350 billion dollars. We realize that this reconstruction must be carried out as quickly as possible and that funds will need to be sought everywhere.

But we will certainly insist on one thing, namely: that these costs must ultimately be borne by those who caused the war. It is Russia that attacked Ukraine, it is Russia that is destroying Ukraine, it is Russia, conducting an unjust, aggressive war, that is destroying infrastructure in Ukraine, destroying Ukrainian homes, neighborhoods, and destroying road, rail, transmission, and energy infrastructure. And it is Russia that should bear all the costs of rebuilding this infrastructure. It is Russia that has the obligation to carry out the reconstruction of Ukraine. And I deeply believe that sooner or later the international community will force the Russian state to bear the costs of its unlawful, unprecedented, unjust aggression against a free, sovereign, and independent state.

We will certainly strive for this. We believe that it is an important obligation of the entire international community, indeed not only to end the war but also to effectively deter all future potential aggressors – wherever they may be in the world and whoever they may intend to attack – by sending a clear and unequivocal signal that if someone attacks someone else, they must then pay dearly for it. This should now be the case with Russia.

Ladies and gentlemen, once again, thank you for today’s visit, once again, thank you, Mr. President, for the discussions. I would like to thank all members of the German delegation who accompanied you, Mr. President. These were very good discussions. We thank you for this neighborly relationship, which translates into strengthening the security of Poland. This is very important to us.

Poles see such actions, such as the presence of the United States Army on Polish territory; the presence of the armies of other NATO countries, which today guard, for example, the Suwalki Gap; the German promise to send Patriot batteries to protect Polish skies and Polish land – these are evident positive aspects of our participation in the North Atlantic Alliance.

I can only promise our allies from this place that we are doing everything as Poland to strengthen our defense, to create the best possible conditions so that any potential aggressor who would want to attack us is stopped by us. We are working in this direction with – I can boldly say – the full approval of Polish society, which understands perfectly what it means to ensure security for the country and what price it has.

Once again, thank you very much, Mr. President.

Marcin Wikło, weekly "Sieci" and portal wPolityce.pl: Good morning, I have a question for both Presidents. How do you assess the coherence and unity of European policy towards Vladimir Putin and his criminal actions? I ask this in the context of two statements that have recently appeared in the public space. The German Foreign Minister said that there is no need to organize any separate tribunal to judge Vladimir Putin. And the second statement, which particularly shocked public opinion in Poland, was made by Mr. Emmanuel Macron. The French President said that Vladimir Putin should be given some security guarantees if he were to decide to engage in talks about ending the war. So how is this European unity? Thank you.

Mr. Editor, I will join in what the President said regarding the first question. Because indeed such actions are being taken, and prosecutors – including international ones – have been and are continuously gathering evidence of Russian crimes in Ukraine. This process is supported by us as members of the international community.

However, I want to emphasize one more thing, namely that perhaps the Minister was more concerned with legal issues. That is to say, there is a legal discussion about which tribunal such a case should potentially be held before. That is – before which tribunal proceedings should be conducted that will aim to establish responsibility, including criminal responsibility, for war crimes and crimes against humanity that are being committed in Ukraine. And this is a legal issue: whether it is really necessary to establish a special tribunal for this purpose, or whether it can take place before one of the already existing international tribunals.

However, from my side, I can only say one thing: I believe that such responsibility must be enforced, meaning that those guilty of crimes against humanity and war crimes in Ukraine must be – firstly – identified, and secondly – judged and appropriately punished. This is also an absolute action that not only signifies penalization, that is, punishing the guilty, but it is also a preventive action that aims to show other potential aggressors what the consequences will be if they engage in criminal activities. This has enormous significance for future peace in the world. Similarly, enforcing compensation for destroyed infrastructure, property, murdered people, compensation for families, etc., etc. – all of this is, for me, a natural consequence of the fact that someone has brutally attacked their neighbor.

As for the words of President Macron, I will say this: what we can certainly guarantee to Russia – as honest people, but also as politicians, members of the North Atlantic Alliance, a defensive alliance – is that none of us intends to do to Russia what it does to its neighbors. That no one intends to attack Russia, that no one intends to kill ordinary Russian citizens. There is no intention and there never has been.

This is what we can guarantee to President Putin today – that what he does to his neighbor, which is Ukraine, what he has done and is doing to the Georgians, occupying their lands, and in other places in his surroundings, in the vicinity of his country, his neighborhood – we do not intend to do this to Russia. And I guarantee this to Russia: that we do not intend to do this to Russia.

Andreas Rinke, Reuters: Mr. President, you speak of Polish-German relations, presenting them as friendly, neighborly, harmonious in Germany. But there are concerns that now – in the pre-election struggle in Poland – the PiS party is playing on anti-German sentiments, using them in the electoral battle. Are these concerns justified?

Mr. Editor, I will answer this question as follows: in every country, there are different moments. In democratic countries – the Federal Republic of Germany is a democratic country, Poland is also a democratic country – political processes run in a sense from election to election. Every election campaign – and one could say that in Poland, although informally, the election campaign for the upcoming parliamentary elections is already underway – indeed causes an increase in political tensions, political discussions, sometimes very heated. In these discussions, various arguments are often used.

Fortunately, in democratic states, there are also such important state bodies – I would say: even very important state bodies – that do not participate in the campaign, remain outside the current political current that is moving so quickly at that moment. We, together with the President, are certainly such entities here.

Not long ago, we even discussed with the President – not today, but during our previous meeting – that a lot is happening in these relations and not all voices are always as we both would like to hear. This often happens in my country, in Poland, as you just mentioned, but it often happens in Germany as well – just read the German press over the past few years to be convinced of this; various things have been written here about Poland and the Polish authorities.

I said then: "Mr. President, you have always told me one thing – that we are here to build a good relationship between our nations; that it is our duty as Presidents." I completely agree with that. I fully share that sentiment. We, Presidents, who in many aspects have a symbolic role, are here to build a good relationship; we are something that runs above current politics. We implement a policy that is then responsibly passed on to our successors.

This is perhaps a very characteristic element of the presidential office, that the presidential office in virtually every country has significant stability in continuing a certain general line of policy – to a much greater extent of continuity than occurs in governments, where the political parties leading them in democratic countries often change. The role of presidents is a stabilizing role.

And we, together with the President – an extraordinarily experienced politician who has also led foreign affairs for many years in the Federal Republic of Germany – are fulfilling such a role today, also in Polish-German politics. I have no doubt – as I know you, Mr. President – that we will strive to fulfill it as best as we can. I assure you of that, Mr. Editor.