Statement of the President of the Republic of Poland [FULL TEXT]

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

15 December 2022 · Presidential Palace

Context
Duda addressed Polish media at the Presidential Palace in December 2022 to present his position on KPO funding activation and ongoing tensions with the European Commission over judicial reform.
Main themes
National Recovery Plan (KPO) funding, EU-Poland relations, judicial reform, Supreme Court Disciplinary Chamber, European Commission disputes, rule of law concerns, presidential legislative initiative, Polish recovery funds, European Recovery Plan
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,270
88th percentile
Sentences
193
88th percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
11.9
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.07
57th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 58%58%
  • Geopolitical 18%18%
  • Economic 9%9%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

193 sentences in 50 paragraphs

Good morning, I welcome the esteemed Editors, and I also greet my compatriots who are watching our meeting today!

I would like to thank the media representatives for accepting this invitation and coming here, to the Presidential Palace, today because I wanted to talk with you, and above all, I wanted to present my position on two issues in light of the various discussions, debates, and information that have recently reached our compatriots, the audience, and Polish society – through the media – from politicians and representatives of various organizations; in particular, politicians.

The first issue concerns the matter related to the activation of funds for Poland associated with the National Recovery Plan, or KPO, and thus the issues related to the decision that the European Commission must make in this regard. And in connection with this – also with all the tensions that have recently existed between the Polish authorities and the European Commission regarding this issue.

In this matter – also in relation to the draft law that has been presented by the government for parliamentary work – I wanted to present my following position. As everyone remembers, the KPO issue has been dragging on for quite some time. Poland generally agreed to this entire large project of the European Recovery Plan, that is, the huge funds for the countries of the European Union that were affected – I remind you – primarily by the crisis related to the coronavirus pandemic and all its economic consequences, and the creation of special funds, as well as lines or credit actions that would help countries recover from the economic difficulties they faced due to the coronavirus pandemic.

Of course, as with any EU funds, we also counted on these. Indeed, the amount that was initially negotiated for Poland was very satisfactory. The condition for accessing this amount was the presentation of the National Recovery Plan, the acceptance of this National Recovery Plan by the relevant institutions of the European Union, and then the activation of funds from this plan. First, the plan itself was accepted, but the funds were blocked by the European Commission due to the doubts that the European Commission has regarding changes in the Polish judiciary.

These changes – as we know – have raised doubts for the Commission for quite some time. Therefore, in February of last year, even before the outbreak of war, even before Russia attacked Ukraine, I, along with my collaborators – within the Chancellery of the President and as part of the presidential legislative initiative – submitted a draft amendment to the Supreme Court Act to the Sejm. The aim was – first of all – to calm the situation within the Supreme Court and dispel the doubts that arose within the Supreme Court, primarily around the then Disciplinary Chamber of that Court, which was a result of the Supreme Court reform carried out in 2017 and 2018.

This draft was developed here, in the Chancellery of the President of the Republic, which I have not hidden – it was a presidential project. It was developed in consultation with representatives of Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki, the Prime Minister's Chancellery – representatives who were in contact with the European Commission, with lawyers from the European Commission. We collaborated with them. These issues were also agreed upon to address the concerns raised by the Court of Justice of the European Union in its rulings, as well as by representatives of the European Commission.

In fact, my intention, I do not hide, was to end the dispute with the European Commission, so that, first of all – to end the dispute in the Supreme Court, and secondly – to end the dispute with the European Commission, calm the situation, and in this way also calm the situation within the European Union itself. Because there is no doubt that if Poland is in dispute with the European Commission, it also causes unrest at the level of the Union itself.

My intention was obvious. We all realized the tension that existed at that time. Unfortunately, we expected that there might be armed aggression against Ukraine. I believed that it was high time to end these disputes – that both in the interest of our country, Poland, and in the interest of the European Union and the European Commission, it was important for us to have unity, agreement, and to achieve that agreement.

I received a very good signal at that time when, after submitting my draft to the Sejm – which I want to emphasize – I was invited by the President of the European Commission, Ms. von der Leyen, to Brussels specifically to discuss this project. Right after my return from the Olympic Games in Beijing, as you may remember, I went straight to Brussels, practically without coming to Warsaw, to meet with Ms. President, show her the project, and discuss it with her.

I presented this project to her. It was a long conversation. It lasted almost two hours, and we discussed the project in private. Later, the lawyers of the European Commission worked on this project. It was generally accepted. It was indeed a project that constituted a compromise solution.

As we all know, due to various situations that occurred later, among others – as the European Commission cites today – also changes that were later introduced to this project in the Sejm, completely independent of me, as these were decisions made by parliamentary clubs, by deputies, by the parliamentary majority that voted on it, this project was thus changed in some aspects – I believed, insignificant – compared to what I originally submitted. And these changes were later contested by the European Commission.

As a result, the funds from the KPO were not activated. The issue of milestones was also raised. I must say that I was surprised by this issue, because – which I want to emphasize strongly – neither I personally, nor anyone from my representatives, nor anyone from the Chancellery of the President participated in the development of these milestones, nor did we absolutely participate in their acceptance. This was something we learned about from the outside. Moreover – to be honest – to this day we are trying to determine how it even came about that such commitments were accepted for Poland and who actually made them within the government. But I will leave that aside.

However – unfortunately – ultimately, the funds for Poland were not disbursed. I must say that I was very disappointed by this. I considered it to be a certain unfair action, because I had several conversations on this topic with Ms. President von der Leyen and was assured several times that everything was fine. Therefore, I concluded that the Commission had presented the matter too harshly and that this is not how it is done. I wanted to help the government – that did not succeed.

But at least I felt – that I had managed to resolve at least part of the tensions that existed in the Supreme Court. A new Chamber of Professional Responsibility was indeed created. This Chamber was reformed – on different principles than the previous Disciplinary Chamber; with different judges than those who sat in the Disciplinary Chamber. A new President of this Chamber was also elected. This election was made by the judges themselves. So everything took place on the principles that it should take place, absolutely in accordance with the principles of the rule of law. So from that perspective – one could say – the situation was repaired.

I said then that I wanted to help the government, because that was the truth. I wanted to help the government by preparing this project. The government had to continue negotiations with the European Commission. These negotiations – as far as I know – were ongoing. However, ladies and gentlemen – what I want to emphasize strongly, because there are many signals that I somehow participated in these negotiations, that I was involved in these talks. I did not participate, nor did anyone from my collaborators. After February, I did not participate in any negotiations with representatives of the European Commission – I repeat: in any negotiations with representatives of the European Commission – regarding the shape of the Polish judiciary.

I also did not work on any project that would concern this issue. I believed – I emphasize once again – that the issues that were significant and raised both by the European Commission and the Court of Justice of the European Union were resolved through the amendment that I prepared, which was passed by the Sejm and which I signed. And which introduced the Chamber of Professional Responsibility into the Supreme Court. However, the government participated – as it turns out – in negotiations, and their effect was recently, exactly yesterday, presented through a draft of new changes to the Supreme Court Act, which were prepared by the government.

And now, ladies and gentlemen, the fundamental matter:

I care very much that Poland receives funds under the National Recovery Plan. I consider this to be one of the absolutely fundamental issues. We belong to the European Union – I am very pleased about this, I have always supported it, and I will continue to support our membership in the European Union. I believe that we are the same country in the European Union as any other country. We have the right to discuss in various ways the shape of the European Union, what it should be like. We have our own concept.

Personally, I am against the federalization of the European Union, although – of course – there are other currents and views. But these are internal discussions within the Union – in which we are, of which we are a member. I emphasize that I am very happy about this and I want us to take advantage of all the developmental opportunities associated with this both as a state, as a whole, but also our individual citizens, enjoying all the rights granted in the Union and guaranteed by it. This is very important, it is beneficial for Poland – at least from my point of view. That is how I perceive it and I support our membership in the European Union with all my strength.

Within this membership, it is clear and obvious to me that the funds of the National Recovery Plan approved by the European Commission – I repeat: I remind you that this plan has already been approved – simply belong to Poland and should be disbursed. Everything possible and rational must be done to ensure that this money is at Poland's disposal as soon as possible. Therefore – in short – I care immensely about this. That is why I was aware that negotiations with the European Union were being conducted, I did not participate in these negotiations. Their course was not consulted with me either. I emphasize once again: ladies and gentlemen, I did not participate in these negotiations and neither I nor anyone from my collaborators was consulted about the course of these negotiations. Yesterday we saw their effect.

And now: because there have been numerous voices in recent days and hours on the political scene, in which assurances are made that this law was consulted with me, that I was almost a co-participant in the preparation of this law – I must say, ladies and gentlemen: I did not co-participate in the preparation of this project, which has been submitted to the Sejm and which the Sejm is to debate, and its provisions were not consulted with me. I saw the draft law – we saw it here, in the Chancellery of the President – when all other political groups on the political scene had access to it, that is, when it was properly announced on the Sejm's pages. That was the government's decision, and I respect that decision, as it is a submission within the framework of a legislative initiative. I have my legislative initiative, other entities have their legislative initiative.

And here, ladies and gentlemen, for me one thing is the most important: I ask and appeal to the entire parliament, not only to the government side, not only to the United Right, not only to those who constitute the parliamentary majority, but to our entire parliamentary scene, to all groups – to work calmly and constructively on this. I understand that everyone has good will and that everyone wants the KPO funds to reach Poland as soon as possible. That is obvious. But let us remember that it is equally important to maintain social order, constitutional order, legal order, and above all also to absolutely ensure the rule of law understood as guaranteeing the rights of citizens. From my point of view – as the President of the Republic – this is a fundamental issue.

And therefore, ladies and gentlemen, I will calmly observe the work that will be conducted in parliament on this draft law, and the debate that will take place on this project. Of course, in these works – as always in the Sejm, and later in the Senate – my representatives will participate, who may take the floor there. What is important to me? As I understand – sooner or later – when the appropriate parliamentary procedure is completed, this law will come to my desk to fulfill the last part of the legislative process, which is the decision of the President of the Republic regarding the further fate of the law.

Ladies and gentlemen, I will evaluate primarily the following issues: the compliance of the introduced changes with the Constitution of the Republic of Poland, but also taking into account Poland's sovereign right to shape the judiciary in the way that we – as Poles and democratically elected authorities – want to do it, because European treaties guarantee us that. That we shape the issues of the judiciary – as internal matters – ourselves. Therefore, I will evaluate it from that perspective. Above all, from the perspective of constitutional order. As you know, this is one of the fundamental duties of the President of the Republic – and that is how I will evaluate it.

I will also assess this from the perspective of the legal security of citizens and the stability of issued judgments. Please remember that over the past years, thousands of judgments, rulings, and decisions have been issued in Polish courts – in various instances of these courts and in different courts, because we have both administrative judiciary and common judiciary in Poland, as well as the Supreme Court. In each case, these were individuals who very often received their judicial nominations in the last seven years. Most often based on provisions that have been in force for a long time, that is, for five to six years.

These are, ladies and gentlemen, about three thousand people. Among these three thousand judges, the vast majority are young people. Young people, to whom I express my gratitude at every judicial nomination for choosing the judicial service as their professional path. Service to the Polish state and service to other people. That is how I speak to them when I hand them their judicial nominations. They did not consider what the legal shape of the regulations leading them to the judicial profession was. They learned, prepared, took exams, and gained experience to serve the Polish state and society.

For me, the professional stability of these individuals is one of the fundamental issues regarding the responsibility of the President of the Republic of Poland for the affairs of the Polish state. Please remember that this was about shaping the third power in the Republic of Poland. We have the legislative power, the executive power – of which I am a part as President – and the judicial power. Three thousand representatives of the judicial power have received their judicial nominations in recent years.

I will not allow any legal act to be introduced into the Polish legal system that would undermine these judicial legitimacies. That would allow anyone to verify these nominations made by the President of the Republic of Poland.

Because that has never happened. For years, these judicial nominations have been made by successive Presidents of the Republic of Poland. The National Council of the Judiciary has been questioned, there have been many rulings of the Constitutional Tribunal that undermined the constitutionality of the KRS in various areas of its operation, including regarding terms of office, methods of selection, etc. And there has been a whole series of such rulings over the last twenty years that questioned the KRS. But judicial nominations, which are only a consequence of the work of the KRS, have never been questioned. Because first, the KRS makes the decision, which presents candidates for judges to the President, and only then does the President decide whether someone will become a judge or not.

The President's decision is final and unchallengeable. And we have, and we have established this in the jurisprudence of the courts – primarily administrative courts, I am thinking particularly of the Supreme Administrative Court. Recently, this issue has been absolutely confirmed by the Court of Justice of the European Union, which analyzed the entire process of attaining the status of a judge in Poland: through the decision of the KRS, then through the presidential nomination act, stating unequivocally that this act is unchallengeable.

Therefore, ladies and gentlemen, I will not allow any act to be introduced into the Polish legal system that would allow anyone to challenge this act. Whether they are judges or anyone else – it does not matter, because it would mean allowing provisions into the Polish legal system that, in my opinion, are contrary to the Polish constitution. A constitution that guarantees judicial independence, the irremovability of judges, a constitution that guarantees acquired rights, and finally a constitution that also guarantees citizens that their cases will be resolved by independent courts, where irremovability is of great importance for the very structure of independence.

In light of the above, I will not agree to any solutions that would undermine the constitutional system of the Republic of Poland, nor those that would undermine the structural framework of the Republic of Poland. However, I will support solutions that will allow us to exercise our rights as a member state of the European Union, and I believe that such a right is for us to receive funds from the National Recovery Plan – I repeat once again – which has already been accepted. We have the right to demand this. It is obvious to me that we must do everything within the limits of the constitution of the Republic of Poland to ensure that we can receive this money.

From this point of view, I will assess this project as the President of the Republic – I announce this in advance. And I ask that this be taken into account during the parliamentary work. I ask that this work proceeds efficiently, but I ask that it proceeds with caution, because we need to adopt solutions that will allow us to benefit from the right to these funds, but at the same time, this must happen within the limits of our sovereign rights as a member state. And such a right – I repeat once again – is the right to independently shape the structure of our judiciary, but also within the limits of our constitution, the significance of which was recently defined very clearly by the Constitutional Tribunal in relation to the functioning of European law, both primary, that is, treaties, and secondary law, that is, post-treaty law, as well as the actions of the Court of Justice of the EU. I hope that calm and constructive work will be carried out in parliament, and that this law – I hope in accordance with our constitution – will be adopted by a parliamentary majority not only consisting of representatives from the ruling camp.

Ladies and gentlemen, the second matter I wanted to inform you about today... We all know that discussions have been ongoing here for some time, and I am also receiving correspondence related to changes in educational law, which has recently sparked a whole series of discussions and controversies. Since this law has been in my resources for some time now, and a decision – in accordance with constitutional provisions – must be made in this matter, I want to inform you what this decision is.

Well, ladies and gentlemen, work has been ongoing for a long time. As you know, the whole issue was once initiated by me – a long time ago, two years ago, during the period when the presidential election campaign was still underway. At that time, parents of children approached me, believing that a solution should be adopted in Polish law that would allow parents to decide whether certain organizations – for example, social, non-governmental – would be able to enter schools and convey various content to children. These parents believed that this issue should be regulated, but it should be regulated with a clear right of parents to decide in this matter.

I then prepared an appropriate draft law, coordinating it with those parents who were my representatives. It was then – perhaps you remember – publicly presented. There was a press conference, and we were together then. Later, my law, which was submitted to the Sejm, was joined by a project prepared by the government side. However, this project unfortunately did not fulfill that assumption – it was also the subject of many social disputes. And – as you probably remember – about a year ago, I decided to refuse to sign this law, that is – as we say – I vetoed this law.

The minister then immediately began work on a new law – as he called it: lex Czarnek 2.0. We observed this work, constantly raising the issue of my project, which was then in the parliamentary resources – as a presidential submission. To some extent, the proposals we submitted were taken into account, although it must be clearly stated: not all of them. The law was ultimately adopted. It was sent to me. I had to make a decision in this matter.

Well, ladies and gentlemen, I received exactly one hundred thirty-three protest letters. Some of these letters are signed, some even by dozens of social organizations. So it is not the case that one hundred thirty-three organizations wrote letters. No – there are many more. Some of these letters are signed by private individuals, but there are even those signed simultaneously by tens of thousands of people.

Therefore, my conclusion is as follows:

despite the fact that work on this law has been ongoing for a long time, unfortunately, it has not been possible to achieve what I would call a social compromise. There was no public hearing, because a public hearing was not agreed upon.

The project was a parliamentary submission, which obviously limited – in accordance with applicable provisions – the process of social consultations. And in fact, there were no such broad social consultations.

As can be seen, this project did not gain broad social acceptance. I will tell you this: when one reviews the protest letters that came in regarding various parts and various solutions contained in this law – starting from the fact that the final decision regarding the admission of organizations will still be made by the curator – assessing this, of course, from the perspective of compliance with the law – but still the curator... That is, this element, as emphasized by the protesters here, is bureaucratic and an element of authority, and not parents, who were supposed to have the freedom and freedom to decide according to their beliefs. The issue of home schooling and various other issues is also raised.

Protests are being submitted by organizations and entities – as for the ideological spectrum – ladies and gentlemen, from the far left to the far right. The entire spectrum. Entities from every side of the political scene find points in this law that they have very serious doubts about and against which they protest. In short, one thing can certainly be said about this law – it does not provide what I care about very much today.

I care about us simply having peace.

Today we have a war – I have emphasized this many times over the past months. Today we have a war at our eastern border. Today, unfortunately, we also have an economic crisis, related to this war, with rising energy prices. We have enormous anxiety. We have very, very costly loans that cause a huge increase in the cost of living for families. People are anxious. We do not need additional tensions in Poland today, completely unnecessary tensions.

Therefore, ladies and gentlemen, I have made the decision that I will not sign this law. I refuse to sign this law.

I understand that some people will be disappointed, but I understand that a large part of our society will also be calmed by the fact that this decision is what it is.

We need peace today. Just as we need peace in the European Union. Just as we need political peace in Poland. The less friction and conflict, the better. We also need social peace. I ask that we work in such a way that this social peace can be maintained. So that people can also have peaceful holidays.

Thank you very much.