Statement of the President of the Republic of Poland regarding the laws on the judiciary

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

24 July 2017 · Presidential Palace

Context
Duda addressed the public at the Presidential Palace on July 24, 2017, announcing his decision on controversial judicial reform laws passed by the Senate.
Main themes
Judicial reform in Poland, presidential mandate and duties, rule of law, judicial ethics and integrity, public trust in courts, separation of society and state, justice for ordinary citizens, Supreme Court legislation, consultations with legal experts
Duration
~18 min
61st percentile
Words
2,172
61st percentile
Sentences
81
53rd percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
13.0
57th percentile
Syntax
3.42
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 73%72%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Social 13%12%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

81 sentences in 16 paragraphs

Good morning, I warmly welcome you all. I have invited you here, to the Presidential Palace, to communicate my decision regarding an issue that has recently sparked enormous controversy in our country and which requires urgent and decisive resolution.

Ladies and gentlemen, during the presidential campaign, when I was running and speaking about the office of the President of the Republic and its duties, I emphasized several times that the President is elected in general elections by the Nation and that this is a beautiful statement in the Polish Constitution, which also gives the President a very strong, the strongest mandate in Poland to make important decisions. But I also said that the President of the Republic should serve two great entities: the Polish society ‒ the Nation ‒ and the Polish state. And that it is very difficult to separate these two services, and above all, it is very difficult to separate these two entities.

I also spoke, ladies and gentlemen, about a just, strong Poland, about a state that will be able to defend its citizen, but at the same time a state that will ensure peace for its citizen and create conditions for them to build their prosperity, to develop, to create a family in peace, to live normally – as we desire. This is a very important element, because in this element, the judiciary plays a fundamental role ‒ for the sense of security of Poles, the work of the courts, the service of judges to the Republic, a well-structured judiciary, a well-distributed jurisdiction and cognition. But also ethics, which must certainly be demanded from judges as one of the most important professions or states, as President Professor Lech Kaczyński once emphasized in our country. But I emphasize once again: the state of service to the Polish state and Polish society. Because judges too – as a state structure – have an obligation to serve the state and society by administering and realizing justice. And being an example of worthy and ethical behavior for their fellow citizens.

In recent years, the call for reform of the judiciary has been repeated many times. People talk about it very often. Many people are desperate that they have been wronged by the judiciary, they have a deep sense of being wronged. The judiciary certainly requires repair in Poland – and on many levels. It requires repair on the procedural level, on the formal level, but it also unfortunately requires repair on the ethical level – and in many cases. I speak about this in every judicial nomination, what my expectations are as the President of the Republic from judges: that they will be professionals, that they will be ethical and crystal clear honest, and that judicial immunity will indeed be only a technical matter, that they will issue judgments, as they swear – impartially, according to their conscience. But also, that they will always remember that they are administering justice towards people, that a judge will see beyond the stack of files a person who stands before the court perhaps for the only time in their life and expects justice.

This is very important not only for those who stand before the court. I assure you, it is very important for the entire Polish society. It goes very badly when representatives of the judiciary say that judges are the most important or the highest caste, it goes very badly when important representatives of the judiciary say that 10,000 zł ‒ which is a decent salary in Western Europe, and excellent in Poland – is money that is hard to live on. Because what is an ordinary person, who earns the national average or below the national average, or who receives the minimum wage, supposed to say to that? Ladies and gentlemen, all of this requires change. But the change must occur in such a way that there is no division between society and the state, because that division occurs when people have a sense of injustice from the judiciary, but also when the state becomes oppressive to them, when they begin to fear their state.

And that is why during this past weekend, since the Senate passed the law primarily concerning the Supreme Court, I held many consultations as the President of the Republic – with my lawyer colleagues, with judges, lawyers, but I also spoke with professors and lawyers, sociologists, philosophers, I also spoke with politicians, I spoke with many people. But above all, I spoke with Ms. Zofia Romaszewska ‒ a person who probably needs no introduction – a lady of the Order of the White Eagle, but above all, a woman who is a symbol of the fight against oppression, who is a symbol of the fight for a free, sovereign Poland, but above all for human freedom and justice towards human beings. And this has always been the case: since the 1970s, from the Intervention Bureau of the Workers' Defense Committee, through the Intervention Bureau of the Senate Chancellery, to finally supporting me in the realization of what we call Dudapomoc – first during the campaign, and then here, in the Presidential Chancellery.

And Ms. Zofia said to me words that struck me the most ‒ apart from all the legal arguments that I was realizing and discussing over the weekend. Ms. Zofia said to me: “Mr. President, I lived in a state where the Attorney General had an incredibly strong position and could basically do anything, and I would not want to return to such a state.” Let us add that in the Polish Constitution and in Polish constitutional tradition, the Attorney General has never had any oversight over the Supreme Court. Of course, they had lesser or greater ‒ it varied ‒ oversight over common courts. The increase in oversight over common courts was, by the way, known to all those who read the program ‒ it was a programmatic electoral postulate of Law and Justice. But not over the Supreme Court – there was no such provision. It was also not stipulated that the Attorney General would decide to a significant extent who could be a judge of the Supreme Court and who could not. It was not, ladies and gentlemen, also stated that the work, the way of working, the rules of work and the functioning of the Supreme Court would be significantly determined by the Attorney General through establishing regulations for that court.

I want to say clearly and unequivocally: we have no tradition for the Attorney General to be able to interfere in the work, in the functioning of the Supreme Court as an institution in any way. I will not even mention judges. And I agree with all those who claim that it should not be so and that it must not be allowed. Therefore, ladies and gentlemen, I regret that the draft Law on the Supreme Court was not presented to me as the President of the Republic before its submission to the Sejm and that, as a result, I could not hold consultations on this matter, just as most other interested parties could not hold consultations either.

And therefore, dear ladies and gentlemen, the decision is as follows: I have decided to return the Law on the Supreme Court for reconsideration to the Sejm, that is, I will veto the Law on the Supreme Court, as well as the Law on the National Council of the Judiciary, because the Sejm has led to the situation that they are interconnected. And I have said that judges to the National Council of the Judiciary cannot be elected by a simple majority of votes, unfortunately – in the current state they would be. And I, as President, do not agree to that unequivocally. Poland very much needs judicial reform – I am an absolute supporter of this reform, but I am a supporter of a wise reform, one that will ensure the proper functioning of the judiciary, and one that will increase the sense of justice in Poland. I, as President, feel deep down ‒ and this is my decision and my responsibility ‒ that this reform in its current form will not increase that sense of security and justice.

Ladies and gentlemen, as I told you, I held many consultations over these past few days. And many people called me. People who know me, who often have views different from mine, but we have known each other for years. Many lawyers also called me. I am very grateful that many people offered me help in fixing these laws, so that they would be in accordance with Polish legal customs, so that they would be in accordance with the Polish Constitution, so that they would also be in accordance with social expectations ‒ in every direction. So that on one hand they would ensure the non-oppressiveness of the Polish state ‒ or that there would be no fears of oppression ‒ and on the other hand, that the judiciary in Poland would be as good as possible, or at least better than it has been so far. I care very, very, very much that we have such solutions in Poland, because I deeply believe that it is precisely such solutions that people in Poland ‒ whether young or old ‒ are waiting for.

That is why, ladies and gentlemen, such a decision, and not another. And that is why a quick decision. A decision without delay, because it is clear how great the anxieties and fears are. Yesterday there was a demonstration outside Jarosław Kaczyński's house, but today, from what I heard, there was a demonstration outside Mr. Grzegorz Schetyna's house. I do not want this situation to deepen, because it deepens the division in society. And Poland is one, and Poland needs peace. And I feel co-responsible for that as President. But I want to say one thing: politicians are also co-responsible for this.

I realize that the decision I have made will be criticized ‒ perhaps by both sides of the political scene. It may be criticized by many citizens and many of my voters, but I assure you that I make it with a great sense of responsibility for the Polish state, which I have committed to lead in an honest, reliable manner and with the greatest care. A state that is torn by anxieties, a state that is torn by political war, is not a state that can develop, as it could develop if it were a peaceful state. That is why I appeal for this peace and prudence ‒ both to those who make laws in Poland, to those who today have a parliamentary majority, and to the opposition politicians.

Ladies and gentlemen! It cannot be that politicians, who took an oath in the Sejm, who are ‒ or are to be ‒ responsible people, go out and call for riots and for committing crimes. There is a difference between calling for committing crimes, for riots, for de facto street fighting, and calling for demonstrations. A demonstration is something legitimate in a democratic state. Riots, calling for the overthrow of power – no. The overthrow of power is done in elections. Power is overthrown in elections, not on the street. On the street, one can demonstrate, express their dissatisfaction.

That is why I very much ask that politicians, especially in the opposition, whose statements in recent days have absolutely crossed any barrier of common sense, come to their senses. I appeal to both sides, realizing that the assessments of my decision may be critical, both among politicians and among society. This is, ladies and gentlemen, my responsibility and that is why I declare: The Law on the Supreme Court and the Law on the National Council of the Judiciary will not become part of the Polish legal system. These laws must be repaired so that they are acceptable to everyone ‒ including those who will not be delighted with them. Because there cannot be such laws that everyone will be delighted with, but they cannot provoke such controversy ‒ that is absolutely unacceptable.

And therefore, ladies and gentlemen, I take on myself as the President of the Republic of Poland this responsibility that I will prepare these laws. If those who have approached me in recent days with various comments and requests – whether critical or supportive of the laws ‒ but also offered their help, if I wanted to make improvements. Yes, I want to make improvements to these laws within the framework of the presidential legislative initiative, so that the Polish judiciary and life in this regard in Poland can be repaired, so that Poland can be better, more friendly to its citizens, and at the same time, so that it can become an increasingly strong state, but just, safe, and one in which people will feel good. This is my responsibility as President. I hope that with the help of experts, these laws can be prepared within two months.

Thank you very much.