Government statement by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel on the situation in Afghanistan before the German Bundestag on August 25, 2021, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

25 August 2021 · Government statement before the German Bundestag · German Bundestag, Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Bundestag on August 25, 2021, delivering a government statement on the rapidly deteriorating situation following the Taliban's takeover of Afghanistan.
Main themes
Taliban takeover of Afghanistan, evacuation operations from Kabul, Bundeswehr military deployment, humanitarian crisis at Kabul airport, NATO alliance and international coalition, withdrawal of international troops, Afghan security forces collapse, civilian and military casualties, German foreign policy, September 11 legacy, refugee and local staff protection
Duration
~25 min
76th percentile
Words
3,015
76th percentile
Sentences
143
79th percentile
Readability
41
39th percentile
Grade
12.7
53rd percentile
Syntax
2.90
34th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 62%56%
  • Social 19%17%
  • Ceremonial 16%14%
  • Institutional 2%2%
  • Economic 2%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 10%

143 sentences in 48 paragraphs

Mr. President,

Dear colleagues,

Ladies and gentlemen,

Since the withdrawal of international troops from Afghanistan, we have witnessed how the Taliban have rapidly recaptured provinces and cities and are in the process of bringing the entire country under their control. We are witnessing the desperation of countless people trying to reach the international airport in Kabul to secure a place on a rescue flight out of the country and into safety and freedom. And we are witnessing terrible human dramas, such as parents trying to somehow get their babies and toddlers over the walls of the airport into the saving hands of allied soldiers, or people being trampled to death in the panic at the airport.

The developments of the past few days are horrific; they are bitter. For many people in Afghanistan, they are a single tragedy, especially for those who have fought for a free society, for democracy and education, and who now fear for their safety. The developments are also bitter for all allies who have fought and worked against terrorism and for free structures since the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001.

My thoughts are with the soldiers who have paid for their commitment with their lives, including 59 Germans. My thoughts are also with all those who have suffered lasting injuries to body and soul from their service in Afghanistan.

Allow me to take a moment to personally remember an official from the Federal Criminal Police Office who lost his life in a terrorist attack in Afghanistan in the summer of 2007, along with his comrades. I knew him well, as he had previously worked in my personal protection unit. He, like so many of his colleagues and comrades at that time, went to Afghanistan with great idealism. Just a few weeks later, at the end of 2007, his deployment in Afghanistan would have ended, and he would have returned to my personal protection unit.

After his death, I did not lose contact with his parents; however, I can only imagine how great their pain and the pain of all the relatives of those who fell in Afghanistan and of civilian helpers who lost their lives must be right now, as everything seems so futile, so in vain, after the Taliban takeover, including the death of their loved ones.

It was, of course, clear to everyone that the withdrawal of international troops from Afghanistan would put the Afghan government and Afghan security forces under significant political and military pressure. Otherwise, the international community would not have struggled so much in recent years with the decision to withdraw from Afghanistan. And it has always been clear to us that the entire mission literally stands and falls with the attitude of the militarily strongest in the alliance, the United States. We also expected that there could be fighting with the resurgent Taliban after the international troops had withdrawn.

However, we underestimated how comprehensive and, as a result, how breathtakingly quickly the Afghan security forces would give up their resistance against the Taliban after the troop withdrawal, or that they would not even take up such resistance at all. This was further accelerated at the moment when the political leadership of Afghanistan fled the country.

All of us together, who were engaged in Afghanistan, that is, the entire international coalition, clearly underestimated the speed of this development. This also applies to Germany.

Even though one might sometimes get a somewhat different impression in the current discussion: Germany has not taken a special path for which it should now be criticized, as in the case of abstaining in the Libya case in the UN Security Council in 2011. No, we have acted together with our allies since 2001 and are doing so now in the evacuation operation. With the rapidly deteriorating security situation, we evacuated our embassy in Kabul together with others. Like other allies, we tasked the Bundeswehr with establishing an air bridge to Kabul to evacuate German citizens, our Afghan local staff, and particularly vulnerable Afghans. Germany was among the first allies to arrive with military forces on the ground. During this phase, the federal government continuously informed the leaders and the heads of the parliamentary groups in the Bundestag.

Since last Monday, the air bridge has been in place. It is already the largest evacuation operation in the history of the Bundeswehr. More than 4,600 people have been evacuated from Afghanistan by German forces and brought to safety – German citizens, Afghans, and nationals from about 45 countries in total. Almost half of those evacuated are women. Many other countries are participating in the air bridge. This is an international operation.

The Bundeswehr is deployed at Kabul Airport and in Tashkent with nearly 500 soldiers and robust capabilities. They are not only bringing German nationals and other vulnerable individuals to safety but also supporting our American partners in enabling people to access the planes. Employees of the German embassy in Kabul are also assisting in this effort.

On Sunday, I spoke with Brigadier General Arlt, who is leading the Bundeswehr's mission on the ground and described the conditions of this mission to me. I believe I may express our recognition and deepest gratitude to him and all soldiers, of course also to the federal police officers, on behalf of all of you from this place for the professionalism and endurance with which the Bundeswehr and allied troops are managing this extremely demanding situation.

My thanks also go to our forces in Tashkent, Uzbekistan, as well as to the Uzbek government, which is enabling us to provide for the incoming people. And last but not least, I thank the staff of our embassy in Kabul and the crisis staff of the federal government, who are working around the clock.

We continue to make every effort to assist Afghans in leaving the country, especially those who have stood by Germany as local staff of the Bundeswehr, the police, and development cooperation and who have worked for a safe, free country with future prospects.

Many have asked why we did not evacuate the local staff earlier. I can understand this question and would like to address it in detail. The picture is nuanced. Since 2013, we have continuously brought endangered local staff of the Bundeswehr and the police and their family members to Germany through the local staff procedure when they were threatened by the Taliban. Between 2013 and August of this year, over 1,000 local staff with their family members entered through the regular procedure, totaling over 4,800 people. After the withdrawal decision of the allied troops, 2,500 local staff and family members received visas in an accelerated procedure, and with the escalation of the situation in the country, a visa was no longer required. – That was one side.

On the other hand, we have always been guided by the conviction that we wanted to continue our German development cooperation for the people in Afghanistan even after the withdrawal of international troops. We wanted to stand by them even under increasingly difficult conditions. For this, we depend on people on the ground, that is, on our local staff. Many of them were also determined to continue working in Afghanistan. And when I say this, I do not want to shift the responsibility for decisions made onto these people with their willingness to help. But I would like to point out a dilemma in decisions of this kind. Let us imagine for a moment that Germany had not only begun the withdrawal of the Bundeswehr in the spring but had also begun the withdrawal of employees and local staff of German aid organizations. Some would certainly have seen this as prudent foresight, while others would have rejected it as an attitude that would leave the people in Afghanistan in the lurch and abandon them to their fate. Both perspectives have their validity.

But please allow me a somewhat pointed personal remark in this context: Making precise analyses and evaluations in hindsight is not really complicated. Knowing everything exactly and predicting it accurately in hindsight is relatively easy. However, we, the international community, could not decide in hindsight but had to act in the situation at that time, in which there were very good reasons to continue to stand by the people in Afghanistan after the withdrawal of the troops, at least in development cooperation, to provide very concrete basic assistance, from maternity wards to water and electricity supply.

Now, however, as the situation is what it is, we are focusing all our efforts on the evacuation flights at Kabul Airport. We are advocating for access for our nationals, local staff, and vulnerable Afghans to the airport. We are also discussing this with the Taliban.

The end of the air bridge in a few days, for which American President Joe Biden did not provide a new date yesterday in the G7 discussions – I reported on this yesterday – must not mean the end of efforts to protect Afghan local staff and to help Afghans who have been plunged into even greater distress by the Taliban's advance.

Therefore, intensive work is being done at all levels these days to find ways to continue to protect those who have helped us, including through a civilian operation of the airport in Kabul.

In addition, it is about providing humanitarian aid to those who need it now more than ever. The United Nations and, in particular, its aid organizations intend to continue their work in Afghanistan as long as the situation allows. I am very grateful for that. Thousands of people have been fleeing within their own country since the Taliban's advance or are trying to flee to neighboring countries. Therefore, it is now important, on the one hand, to help the people in Afghanistan who need it, and on the other hand, to ensure that refugees in the immediate neighborhood, in the neighboring states of Afghanistan, find safety, protection, and prospects.

For this, the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, the World Food Programme, UNICEF, the World Health Organization, and Afghanistan's neighbors need our support. The federal government therefore intends to provide an additional 500 million euros for humanitarian aid in Afghanistan and as assistance for neighboring countries that are taking in refugees from Afghanistan, in addition to the 100 million euros in immediate aid. I have spoken about this with the High Commissioner for Refugees, Filippo Grandi, as well as with the Prime Minister of Pakistan, Imran Khan, and the Turkish President, Recep Tayyip Erdogan.

Despite the rapid takeover of power by the Taliban, I am convinced that the international community has also achieved good things in Afghanistan over the past 20 years. Germany has made a substantial contribution to this and has taken its share of responsibility, not least through the continuously broadly supported deployment of the Bundeswehr in Parliament. We have achieved the goal that was set at the beginning of the mission in 2001: Since then, no international terrorist attacks have originated from Afghanistan. – This was a concrete contribution to the security of our country and is a lasting achievement of our soldiers. For this, they deserve the thanks and recognition of our country.

Nevertheless, we must not close our eyes to the danger that Afghanistan could again become a haven for international terrorism with the withdrawal of the allies. This must be prevented. The international mission in Afghanistan was not in vain for the people of Afghanistan, at least not for many individual fates. We can see this just by looking at very basic things. For example, child mortality has been halved in the last 20 years. Almost 70 percent of Afghans have access to drinking water; just ten years ago, it was only 20 percent. Over 90 percent of the Afghan population has access to electricity; in 2011, it was not even 20 percent.

But it is clear: The Taliban are now a reality in Afghanistan. And many people in Afghanistan are very afraid; this is evidenced not least by the dramatic scenes at the airport. This new reality is bitter; but we must confront it. Our goal must be to preserve as much as possible of what we have achieved in the last 20 years in terms of changes in Afghanistan. The international community must also talk to the Taliban about this; however, there can and must be no unconditional agreements. We all know: This will be difficult. But we must try.

We will coordinate very closely with our European and international partners on how we proceed. In the EU, NATO, and the G7, discussions on this have already begun; I have also spoken about it with Russia's President Putin. This dialogue must continue. Nevertheless, we have temporarily halted German development cooperation with Afghanistan. This was essential. The EU, the World Bank, and the IMF have also decided to suspend payments to Afghanistan for the time being. This was also essential.

Let me summarize what we are doing now in and for Afghanistan in three points.

First. We will continue the evacuation operation for as long as possible to enable Afghan women and men who have worked with us for security, freedom, the rule of law, and development to leave the country.

Second. We support the United Nations humanitarian organizations in providing emergency assistance to the people in Afghanistan, particularly the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees in assisting displaced Afghans in the neighboring countries. We will also advocate for this within the European Union.

Third. We do not shy away from engaging in talks with the Taliban to preserve some of what has benefited the people in Afghanistan over the past 20 years and to continue protecting people after the evacuation.

In a few weeks, we will commemorate the devastating terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, on the United States of America. The attacks were planned from Afghanistan at that time. The Taliban had harbored the terrorist organization Al-Qaeda in the late 1990s, enabling them to train jihadists and plan attacks. It was the fight against the terror emanating from Afghanistan that prompted us to begin the Bundeswehr's deployment in Afghanistan after the USA requested assistance from NATO under Article 5 of the NATO Treaty – in solidarity with our American allies, but also for our own security.

The statement of former Federal Minister of Defense Peter Struck, that our security is also defended at the Hindu Kush, encapsulated this goal like no other. And this mission was fulfilled by the Bundeswehr in NATO.

What began as a mission against international terrorists soon became a larger effort. Thus, former Federal Foreign Minister Joschka Fischer addressed the Afghan guests at the opening of the United Nations Afghanistan Conference at Petersberg near Bonn on November 27, 2001, with the following words, among others:

"I appeal to you: Reach a truly historic compromise that will permanently and sustainably change the fate of your tormented country and its people for the better. (...) The commitment of the international community will not end with the coming spring. The people of Afghanistan should know that they will not be left alone after the fight against the terrorists of Al-Qaeda and against the Taliban regime."

In this spirit, the international community set itself the goal of building free structures, training security forces, strengthening the rule of law and democracy, defending human rights, especially the rights of girls and women, and promoting journalists, artists, and entrepreneurs to strengthen civil liberties. That was worthy of all honor.

And yet today we must ask critical questions in light of the situation. Why has the historic compromise among Afghans, so rightly invoked by Joschka Fischer nearly 20 years ago, never come to fruition in a way that could lead to long-term stability? Were our goals too ambitious? Did these goals and the values associated with them truly resonate with the majority of the people in Afghanistan, despite all the support from Afghan civil society?

Should the significant cultural differences have been taken more seriously, and should historical experiences have been weighted more heavily?

Did we underestimate the extent of corruption or its impact on those responsible in Afghanistan?

Did the international community do enough to promote political reconciliation and a genuinely inclusive political process?

Was it not at least extremely risky, if not even wrong, to have fixed withdrawal dates in the agreement between the USA and the Taliban regarding troop withdrawal, which was negotiated in Doha in 2020? Was the combat readiness of the Afghan forces also overestimated in this context?

I ask these questions knowing that it would be presumptuous to provide well-founded or even conclusive answers today.

We will need time for that, and we should take that time. Because the answers will determine what political goals we can realistically set for future and current further deployments abroad. It is clear that each engagement is different and therefore must be evaluated individually. It is equally clear that such an analysis must be conducted together with our allies in NATO and within the European Union.

Our immediate attention is now focused on the evacuation operation. In light of the imminent danger, the federal government has begun the operation before obtaining the approval of the Bundestag. The mandate presented contains all necessary military capabilities and legal options to fulfill the evacuation mission as best as possible under the difficult conditions.

Since the first deployment of Bundeswehr personnel to Afghanistan in 2001, all mandate adjustments and extensions have received broad support in this Parliament. I also ask for your approval of the mandate for the evacuation mission, knowing how bitter it is for the federal government to have to present such a mandate at all, but also with the awareness that much in history requires a very long breath. Therefore, we must not and will not forget Afghanistan. Even if it does not seem so in this bitter hour, I am and remain firmly convinced that no violence and no ideology can permanently stop the human drive for freedom, for justice, and for peace.

Thank you very much.