Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at Stanford University on April 15, 2010, in Palo Alto:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

15 April 2010 · Stanford University, Palo Alto, United States

Context
Merkel addressed students and faculty at Stanford University on April 15, 2010, delivering a lecture on global challenges requiring international cooperation.
Main themes
Global security and NATO partnership, Afghanistan mission, nuclear security, international financial crisis, transatlantic cooperation, asymmetric warfare, development policy, shared responsibility, terrorism, multilateralism
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,467
81st percentile
Sentences
193
88th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
11.2
34th percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
12th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 37%35%
  • Economic 21%20%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Social 14%13%
  • Environmental 5%5%
  • Institutional 4%4%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Not in focus 6%

193 sentences in 55 paragraphs

Dear President Hennessy,

dear President Emeritus Casper,

dear Chair of the Board of Trustees Leslie Hume,

esteemed guests,

members of the faculties,

above all, of course, dear students,

at the beginning of our gathering here, we have thought about the fact that today four German soldiers have fallen in action in Afghanistan – in a mission to guarantee our freedom and security. The sad experience that we must face today in Germany is one that you are experiencing in the United States as well. Today, we are together in many areas sharing responsibility.

I would like to talk to you today about the fact that in the 21st century we have many responsibilities, regarding which only a joint approach holds a chance of success, and that we must jointly try and make every effort to successfully address the truly important questions of our time.

I would like to illustrate this to you with three examples.

My

first

example relates to the shared responsibility we must take on to tackle the great challenge of security. Security is the prerequisite for us to live in freedom. If I take the mission in Afghanistan as an example again, I know that both here in the United States of America and at home many people have doubts about whether this mission is necessary and right. I respect these doubts; I want to make that explicitly clear. But I also want to add that I consciously stand behind this, our joint mission in Afghanistan, so that the country can be stabilized until it can ensure its own security.

You know that September 11 has a lot to do with why we are in Afghanistan today. At that time, our security was in danger. We had terrible terrorist attacks, under which the United States particularly suffered. At that time, we jointly decided to stand for stability and security in Afghanistan so that we can live in safety and freedom.

After years of our massive engagement there, we know: We will only succeed if we convince the people there that we stand by the side of the Afghans. We have developed a new strategy in our alliance, NATO. This strategy places the Afghans at the center and makes them our partners. Because we must and want to hand over responsibility to them, but we must also empower them to do so.

We have taken a very long time – some might say: too long – to jointly understand that a military engagement alone will not solve the problem, that military engagement must be combined with development to confront adversaries who do not act like in conventional wars, but who appear asymmetrically. This means: Unlike during the Cold War, when deterrence was a way to maintain peace because each opponent refrained from self-destruction, today we are dealing with asymmetric conflicts in which the attackers do not fear for their lives.

This shows us: To tackle such new challenges, we need to know more. We need to research more. We need to know more about countries and cultures like Afghanistan, about the interrelations of ethnicities, tribes, and religions, about the embedding in the region, the concerns of the people, and the roots of violence, which seem very difficult for us to contain. When we think of the numerous countries and regions in the world to which we must pay great attention for our own security, I must add to Afghanistan that there are countries like Somalia, Sudan, central parts of Africa, the Near and Middle East, as well as parts of Latin America or Asia.

We are facing other, new challenges in the area of security. I was at the conference convened by American President Barack Obama this week, which dealt with how we can ensure nuclear security. One of the great challenges that we can no longer exclude is that individual states may pass nuclear materials to terrorist groups, thereby conjuring up an unprecedented threat. It was very good to see that 47 countries have committed to the same goal of taking decisive action against this. But it is completely obvious that such a challenge cannot be managed by any one country alone, not the United States alone, not Europe alone, and certainly not China and India alone.

This means that our freedom today depends much more than before on us pursuing a security policy that is oriented towards global dangers, which is complemented by a credible, strategically designed, and locally supported development policy. Freedom, solidarity, and partnership are inseparably linked today. Only in this way can we tackle the challenges we face.

In addition to security, I would like to mention a second challenge. It is the management of the international economic and financial market crisis. This crisis broke over us a year and a half ago. Its effects are felt across the globe. Excesses in the markets have led to many people, who had nothing to do with it, being affected. In a flash, immeasurable values were destroyed. Countless savings and jobs were lost, both in the United States and in Europe, Asia, and elsewhere.

We know: The consequences of this financial market crisis will accompany us for a long time. Record public debt, declining growth forecasts, rising unemployment – all of this is a heavy burden. We should also not forget: The effects of the crisis are far more devastating in developing countries – which certainly did not cause this crisis – than they are at home in the industrialized countries.

Therefore, because we have caused this crisis in our countries, we now have the duty and responsibility to do everything we can to overcome the consequences of this crisis as quickly as possible and to ensure that such crises do not recur. This means we need a new, global financial architecture. We must do everything to ensure that protectionism and isolationism are not the answers to this crisis. Above all, we must ensure free trade worldwide.

We feel that in such difficult situations it often happens that each country first thinks of itself. But I am convinced: That would be exactly the wrong answer. If we want to prevent such a crisis from happening again, and we must, then we need to achieve much more than what I have said so far. We need a new balance between economic freedom and transparent rules. We need rules that prevent an entire community of nations from suffering harm because of the actions of a few. This crisis has particularly shown that such rules can only be created globally. It has also shown: Freedom always requires responsibility. Freedom requires solidarity.

One must also – this is a statement to the economic sciences – honestly say: Science has not sufficiently recognized this problem. We are often very optimistic about forecasts. But the forecasts that existed did not help us to recognize such a crisis early on. Therefore, research on the mechanisms of international financial markets will certainly need to be intensified.

In the crisis, however, we must stand by the fact that we need open markets, that we must not abandon the rules of freedom. We are therefore faced with the great challenge of creating a system for global markets that combines freedom, solidarity, and worldwide partnership. In this regard, the group of G8 countries – the major industrialized nations plus Russia – which have worked very closely together in the past, will certainly continue to play an important role. But this financial market crisis has shown us: That is no longer enough. We also need the emerging economies like China, India, Brazil, South Africa, and we must shape our future together with them. This is yet another example of how global cooperation is absolutely necessary to find the right answers for our security and our success in our own countries.

The

third

great challenge alongside security policy and the financial crisis is climate protection. Professor Casper has addressed this. I am convinced that this is one of the great challenges of humanity. Climate policy and energy policy in the broadest sense are today peace policy for the world.

It was disappointing what the outcome was at the climate conference in December in Copenhagen. We made little progress and once again saw how difficult it is to find common answers to a challenge that is undisputed among more than 100 states. We had the objective scientific results before us and still failed to draw the right political conclusions from them.

I am very glad that the discussion in the United States has gained some momentum in this regard. But I want to say quite frankly: I am not yet fully satisfied. I hope that perhaps the younger generation – those who study here at Stanford and know much better how limited our resources are worldwide – will exert some pressure on those who bear political responsibility. Because clean energy, renewable energy – these are not only exciting fields of research, but they are necessities to ensure that we do not leave an unbearable balance to our children and grandchildren in the 21st century.

In climate protection, Europe and the United States must not allow themselves to be divided. Because the more united we are, the better we can convince countries like China and India. One thing is also true: We, the industrialized countries, are responsible for the major part of the warming of the Earth's atmosphere. Those who are now just beginning their economic development, which we have already completed, are understandably concerned that this development may be denied to them. That is also why research and innovation are so important, to clearly demonstrate: We can still meet our energy needs; we just need to apply different methods. We can create sustainable development. We can tap into new resources.

I believe that the protection of our climate and access to energy will become a central test of whether and how we, as free, highly developed societies, are willing to connect freedom and solidarity in partnership across continents. We owe this to ourselves; I am convinced of that. But we also owe it at least as much to the poor regions of this world. If we do not understand this, we will again face conflicts worldwide that threaten our security at home. This means we must understand it.

Time and again, it becomes clear that our common challenges, which no one can tackle alone, must be addressed in the way we understand from our fundamental values. That is the wonderful thing that connects Europe – especially Germany, the country I represent – and the United States, namely the idea that the individual person matters. In our German constitution, the Basic Law, it states: "The dignity of man is inviolable." From this arises our understanding of freedom. This is not a freedom from something, but a freedom in responsibility.

This freedom is what matters in so many areas. For example, for scientists, it is about the freedom to research and continually push the boundaries of knowledge. It is about the freedom of thought and opinion. For young students, it is certainly first and foremost about leading a life of independence, enjoying freedoms outside the parental home, but also taking on responsibility. For us politicians, finally, freedom may be the most important and central political good that is entrusted to us. We must protect it, we must nurture it, and we must promote it.

To fulfill this mission of preserving freedom, we must all strive together. That is why solidarity and responsibility for one another are, for me, indispensable parts of freedom. Both belong together. Just as the longing for freedom unites us all here in California, in the United States of America, in Germany, and in Europe – yes, on all continents – so too does the need for cohesion and solidarity.

The few examples I have provided from the areas of the financial crisis, climate and energy policy, and security policy make it clear: A lot is at stake because all these challenges affect us equally. Simply closing our eyes to them would be wrong. They also show: We can only succeed together.

For example, we will not be able to control climate warming without China as a responsible partner. We will not be able to create rules for financial markets without countries like Brazil or India. The Iranian nuclear program will also not be effectively stopped without China and Russia. But we know: We must stop it, because it threatens not only the security of the State of Israel, it threatens us all.

This means: When we talk about partnerships, it has the consequence that Europe and America are natural and thus the best possible partners for each other, because we agree on almost all future issues. We share common values. I spoke about the dignity of man. It is at the core of our political action.

Some of you may think that we Europeans are quite complicated: 27 member states in a European Union, each self-confident, and decision-making takes a long time. True, but it also happens in America that decisions take a long time. The European continent has achieved something that was not possible for centuries. The nation-states of Europe waged wars against each other for centuries. The European Union is the guarantor that this will no longer happen.

In the search for partners, it also becomes clear that we must look far beyond our transatlantic borders. You on the West Coast of America understand this very well. That is why building a good relationship with China is a real question for the future for both America and Europe. We must learn to understand China in its cultural greatness and with its enormous potential for the future.

Yesterday I was at the Getty Center in Los Angeles. There were medieval European manuscripts on display that had already brought our knowledge into the Arab world at that time. It became clear to me again: In the tenth century, China was leading in mathematics. When you talk to Chinese people, they say: We want to connect to this period. We want to be the country that is the leader in the world again. This has happened before in history. This means we need to know much more about other countries.

For us Europeans, just as for Americans, it is important to include Russia in our Euro-Atlantic structures. I believe that the recently signed START agreement between President Obama and the Russian President was an important milestone to show: Yes, there is a willingness for disarmament!

We will have to build entirely new partnerships in various regions of the world so that problems arising from crises there do not quickly become our own again. I am convinced that these partnerships will only succeed if we truly convince people in other cultures that we are not against them, that we do not simply want to continue our lives and that they must change, but that we stand by their side.

Jonathan Sacks, a British scholar, once coined a term in a different context that I find particularly apt for global future issues. He spoke of the "dignity of difference." To recognize this dignity of difference, we must engage with it. This means we must have respect and, above all, knowledge of other cultures.

This brings me back to research and innovation. Your university is the center that is leading in cutting-edge technologies in many areas. My discussions here in the Bay and in Silicon Valley have impressed me greatly today. I believe your region is one of the most important laboratories for the global future.

There are many reasons for this: the close networking and cooperation between universities, research institutions, and companies, an excellent infrastructure, a vibrant market for venture capital, and the many people who bring their skills, creativity, and commitment to innovative companies and products. I was also impressed by the close collaboration with German research institutions and the German economy.

You should know: Germany has always valued inventiveness and creativity. We are proud that Germans invented the automobile, the computer, the fax machine, the MP3 player, and much more. Yes, we invented the computer, whether you like it or not! I would like to invite you to the Konrad Zuse Center for Information Technology in Berlin. You can be glad that you are making so much money with the computer industry today – it sometimes annoys us that we are not as involved, and that is why we are trying to become stronger – but nonetheless: Do not think that Americans invented everything!

Education, research, and innovation – I believe we agree – are essential for sustainable growth, secure jobs, and our prosperity. We know that we are not the only ones in competition. Emerging economies like China have now made the leap from being science importers to science producers. They are playing an increasingly important role. If you listen here in California, you will also find out how many Chinese have now returned to China to seek their future in their home country. In this regard, it is also true: If we want to maintain our innovation advantages, Europe and the United States must work very closely together.

When we held the presidency of the European Union, we proposed the establishment of the Transatlantic Economic Council to then-President Bush and brought it to life. It continues under President Obama. The aim is that we do not build barriers among ourselves in standardization, standards, and many other issues, but that we pool our strengths and try to maintain our innovative advantages.

I also believe that we could do much more in scientific cooperation. A common space for science and research in the transatlantic area could be a very good idea for the future, even if it cannot be realized immediately.

I believe there is a very strong interest, especially among the scientific youth in our respective countries. The number of German students in the USA increased by nine percent in the academic year 2008/2009. There is renewed interest in going to America. We also welcome every American student studying abroad. There are also significant growth rates in this regard.

There are more than 50 bilateral cooperation agreements. In space travel, environmental technology, medicine, astrophysics, and the joint use of large scientific equipment, there are very close cooperations. Right here at Stanford, I would like to point out that, for example, the German Electron Synchrotron DESY in Hamburg and the SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory at your university are intensifying their collaboration. For example, a joint graduate school is to be established, which is of great interest to both our countries. So we have a good foundation to expand our cooperation opportunities, of course also involving the economy.

Dear Professor Hennessy, Professor Casper, I would like to end with a personal remark: Speaking to you here in Stanford today makes me think back to my own years as a student of physics and as an academic assistant. In what was then East Germany, access to American scientific research was quite limited and controlled by the ruling communists. Even if we managed to read some papers produced by Stanford scientists, "Stanford" for us was just far, far away, a scientific paradise unreachable from behind the Iron Curtain. Then, when the wall fell down 20 years ago, my husband and I did what we had dreamed about for so long: we came to California and traveled around this beautiful state. Today, as the Chancellor of Germany, I feel honored and privileged to be your guest.

Therefore, I would like to thank not only your current President John Hennessy or your former President Gerhard Casper. I would like to thank the very first president of Stanford, David Starr Jordan, who made the wise decision to choose a very special quote as the motto of your university: "Die Luft der Freiheit weht!" Note that I pronounced it correctly. What a great quote from the philosopher Ulrich von Hutten!

"The wind of freedom" – this is what I felt when 20 years ago the wall came down, when Berlin, when my divided country Germany and my continent Europe were reunited after decades of painful separation, and when I finally could visit California. That your University is still proudly displaying this originally Latin motto in German in its seal is very moving for me.

So I end my remarks with the motto of your University, which is as European as it then became American: "Die Luft der Freiheit weht!" To me this motto is filled with life whenever our common American and European values are translated into reality through a shared sense of responsibility and partnership, through knowledge and innovation and respect for human dignity. Thank you very much for the invitation.