Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the presentation of the King Charles II Medal of the Royal Society on April 1, 2010, in London:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

1 April 2010 · Presentation of the King Charles II Medal of the Royal Society · Royal Society, London, United Kingdom

Context
Merkel addressed the Royal Society in London on April 1, 2010, upon receiving the King Charles II Medal, reflecting on science, freedom, and global competition.
Main themes
Freedom of science, history of the Royal Society, Age of Enlightenment, scientific progress and discovery, globalization and international competition, science-policy relationship, German-British scientific cooperation, framework conditions for good science
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,098
86th percentile
Sentences
183
87th percentile
Readability
40
35th percentile
Grade
13.2
59th percentile
Syntax
3.10
61st percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 22%21%
  • Institutional 18%17%
  • Social 15%15%
  • Economic 12%12%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 11%10%
  • Environmental 10%9%
  • Not in focus 3%

183 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Dear Lord Rees,

esteemed assembly,

Excellencies,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am very pleased to be here today at the Royal Society and to have the honor of receiving the King Charles II Medal. This is a great honor – both for me as Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany and for the country I represent. I am glad that the newly elected President of the Leopoldina is also among us today and that there is a piece of German-British commonality in scientific cooperation within this esteemed Royal Society.

You will not expect a scientific lecture from me, as I hope, otherwise you would be very disappointed, but I will essentially focus on the framework conditions for good science. However, I would like to remind you at the outset that the Royal Society existed in its founding year of 1660 in a world that was undergoing transformation. With the establishment of trading companies in the 17th century, something like a first wave of globalization began. More and more raw materials, goods, services, and know-how were exchanged. Technological progress already ensured a rapid development of global trade at that time, even though it was repeatedly shaken by crises.

The 17th century experienced a turning point not only in material and economic terms. It also marks the beginning of the era to which we, I believe I may say, owe our current way of life, namely the Age of Enlightenment. The natural sciences experienced a golden age. Think of Galileo Galilei, Johannes Kepler, or Newton, to name just a few outstanding thinkers. It was precisely during this phase of far-reaching upheaval that the Royal Society was founded – a child of its time, a birth of new thinking, and also an expression of the interest of political decision-makers in the sciences.

This is also represented by the motto "nullius in verba" – "On the word of no one." This revealed the Royal Society's will to develop a new, experimentally based science that never contented itself with citing authorities and the power of the Royal Society, so to speak, to venture into scientific uncharted territory, to speak the truth as it is, and not to have to fear that one might offend authorities in doing so. Today, this is taken for granted in science. Back then, however, it meant an open break with the prevailing philosophy of science. It was initiatives like this that established the natural sciences as we understand them today. The Royal Society was thus a pioneer of a modern understanding of science.

Motivated and inspired by the thirst for knowledge and the spirit of inquiry, brilliant minds have made groundbreaking discoveries, opened new worldviews, expanded horizons, and created new perspectives. For centuries, the Fellows of the Royal Society have wonderfully explained the world to us with their groundbreaking insights – whether about gravity, evolution, the electron, the double helix, and much more. I just had the honor of looking at the charter of the Royal Society and glancing at the fellows of past centuries. That is something that inspires awe and respect for what has been achieved. Robert Hooke, Michael Faraday, Charles Darwin, and of course the aforementioned Isaac Newton are found in this wonderful book. They are all pioneers of the sciences, people who have made history in science, and people who have continually ventured into new territory.

Today, we can consider ourselves fortunate that the freedom of science is one of the fundamental rights of democratic societies. Sometimes it may seem too self-evident that we have these freedoms. When one has freedoms – that is also an experience – one sometimes does not use them sufficiently. Therefore, we should always be aware that the freedom of the sciences is a fundamental freedom.

The beauty of science is this: hardly has one found an answer to what holds the world together, new questions arise again. If I may say so: when I transitioned from my life as a physicist and scientist into political life, perhaps the greatest change was that in science it does not matter if you say the same thing twice, but in politics it is absolutely necessary to say the same thing at least ten times before a relevant portion of the population truly absorbs it. This means: in science, the world is always in motion, and there are always new challenges.

We are, of course, facing these challenges today as well. Today, the situation is such that we are once again confronted with a phase of globalization, a phase in which the dominance of countries that have experienced the Age of Enlightenment is no longer as self-evident as it has been over the past centuries. When one travels to China, one does not connect to the 17th century, but rather to the 10th century, when China was at the forefront of the sciences or not only participated but determined the sciences. They say there: we want to return to this phase of the Chinese success story.

Today, we must face a completely new competition in Europe and also in the United States of America. I am deeply convinced that we can only win this competition or only be at the forefront if we pool our European strengths. When one looks again at the wonderful Fellows’ Book of the Royal Society, one realizes: Europe has not been a lived reality only since our times. Alexander von Humboldt is there, as is Max Planck and many others. Among scientists, it has always been known what is good and what should come together to create something even better.

For us today – in the scientific field as well as in the political field – it holds true that we need cooperation between European states, that we can only realize many projects if we develop a multilateral or at least a bilateral partnership. Germany, I may say, is happy to be involved when it comes to international scientific cooperation. Germany values the close relationship with British sciences. I believe this is always a mutual enrichment for both of us and strengthens our overall relations.

There is a strong bond between Germany and Great Britain not only in the sciences but also in political and personal relationships. I have just come from Chequers after a meeting with the British Prime Minister. Today, we maintain a regular exchange on the entire range of political issues within the framework of European unity and work within the European Union. In the public interest, what is usually highlighted is what we do not agree on. However, when one reflects on how many things we do agree on, it is indeed very impressive. We work together in international alliances. Today, it also shapes the image of every political decision-maker of a nation-state that one can no longer think solely nationally, but must always also connect this with the thinking of the European Union and the transatlantic community.

I have said that we face the great challenge of maintaining our leading position. Sometimes I have the impression – now I am speaking about Germany – that the effort we face may not yet be sufficiently known to everyone. Therefore, during my time as Chancellor, we as a federal government have repeatedly stated: A resource-poor country like Germany must seek its prosperity by investing disproportionately in research, education, and science. For the Federal Republic of Germany, the task also lies in managing a demographic change in the coming decades, that is, a dramatic change in our age structure. This means we must empower every young person through education so that they can contribute their abilities to the community and that we can fully utilize our, if I may say so in quotation marks, "human resources."

It is about how we manage to design institutions sensibly. Germany is a federal country, which raises problems that you do not know in this way in Great Britain. The federal states are responsible for school education, but of course, the students who come out of school are part of the society for which all levels of government and also the federal government are responsible. We have found in Germany – also as a result of the PISA study – that we need to become more competitive in education. This means, above all, that our school education must produce better qualifications. This, in turn, means that we must invest more strength and also more money in the education system overall.

For many years in Germany, it has been said – this is something like a German proverb – that the seriousness of life begins with entering school. This already shows that in Germany, it is strongly assumed that one has a playful, beautiful life until school and then a hard time begins. However, modern educational sciences have brought us the view, and I completely share it, that a person is a learning being from birth and that learning and self-formation is so much fun that the cut of going to school should hardly be noticeable.

In the future, we want and must invest seven percent of our gross domestic product in education. We must do this also because we have the great task of integrating migrants. I think this is also a commonality with British society. The question of how this integration can succeed is one of the tasks that we have not yet conclusively solved and over which there could certainly be increased and more intense discussions between educational scientists in Great Britain and Germany.

We have focused a lot of effort on and will continue to do so in Germany to strengthen interest in mathematical, engineering, and natural science education programs. We have rather too few students in this area than too many. Therefore, it is one of the tasks, if we want to maintain prosperity and living standards in our countries, to promote the joy of scientific education. It turns out that the natural science and engineering programs are considered rather difficult. It has repeatedly been shown regarding career prospects that the acceptance of these professions is very good in good economic times, but that when there is an economic downturn, there are also significant difficulties in finding a position. Therefore, it is also a task for economic and educational institutions to ensure a permanent acceptance of career opportunities for graduates of mathematical and natural science subjects. Because the speed of obsolescence of scientific knowledge is rapid. Therefore, there must be no gaps.

We have made progress on this path, although there is a problem that perhaps all developed industrial countries struggle with, namely that skepticism towards the natural sciences and the overvaluation of certain risks pose problems that certainly somewhat diminish the acceptance of the natural sciences. From this, in my opinion, arises a task for the scientists themselves, namely to open up to the rest of society in a language that the rest of society with a middle school education can also understand. The expertise, the specialized knowledge, the technical terms are wonderful, but the great scientists of their time could always present their difficult research tasks in simple words so that neighboring disciplines and perhaps also scientifically uneducated people could understand them. Therefore, my plea in Germany is always to open up to society – that is indeed the task of the Royal Society – and to engage in a dispute with society about the natural sciences.

We also have the task of providing sufficient resources for the sciences. This is primarily about money, but also about adequate organizational structures. It has been mentioned by my predecessors that in Germany, there are quite good structures in this regard with the Max Planck Society, with the research societies, and also with the academies that we have. What has always proven difficult in Germany due to the federal structure has been to establish a National Academy. We are very pleased that today we have Mr. Hacker, the president of a National Academy, namely the Leopoldina, among us. It took us decades to create such an academy. It required the German reunification and a good research minister, Annette Schavan, who managed to ensure that the regional academies did not feel that their significance was diminishing with the existence of a central point of contact in Germany, to which, for example, the Royal Society could turn. We are pleased that this cooperation is working so well.

We have also developed a high-tech strategy for the organization of science in Germany – particularly in the natural sciences and engineering sciences – within which we have conducted an analysis regarding where Germany stands in various areas of scientific research and what needs to be done if we want to be at the forefront of the world. We have, of course, focused on certain areas where we want to set priorities. Energy research is certainly one of them, also connected with the questions of climate change. I am very glad to be at the place where the Stern Report was presented today – an important contribution to the question of how we can address climate change.

I believe that in the entire question of climate change and its management, we are currently facing a certain crisis after the Copenhagen Conference. We want, of course, to turn this crisis into an opportunity, in line with a Chinese proverb. If we want to do that, it is very important to closely examine the scientific basis regarding climate change, because there have been irritations over statements from the IPCC, which, by including exaggerations about climate change, could now lead to a contrary effect, so that the topic of climate change is no longer considered so important, especially in times of an economically difficult situation. Therefore, I believe that all scientific institutions should have a strong interest in realistically presenting the issue of human-caused climate change in order to restore or increase acceptance for its management.

The Stern Report was so important because it posed the question in a completely different way, namely not what happens if we do something and how much it costs us, but what happens if we do nothing. By contrasting these two scenarios – what happens on one side if we do something and how expensive that is, and what happens on the other side if we do nothing and what that costs us – one gets a much better sense of the urgency of the tasks ahead of us.

I believe that the United Kingdom and Germany are working together in an excellent manner both politically and scientifically in the field of energy research and also in the area of international frameworks for addressing climate change. We have great experience in developing energy supply using renewable energies. There is a very critical discussion in Germany about the necessary energy mix of renewable energies, nuclear energy, gas power plants, and coal power plants. It is very interesting to observe the development here in the United Kingdom, where the societal discussion about the future of nuclear energy may not be as intense as we know it in Germany. We can certainly exchange ideas on this matter.

A second major area that is indirectly related to climate change and also to resource scarcity is the topic of mobility, such as electric mobility and more. We should and will work closely together in the future on this as well. The entire health research is, of course, a top topic for aging societies like Germany, the topic of medical technology and its development, as well as the entire field of information and communication technology.

Time and again, it will be about making it clear to the population: Our prosperity can only be maintained in the future if we give the sciences, research, and their application in our societies a chance. It is particularly important to fight for basic research to have its place in our societies, which is not constantly required to report on results, but can be conducted for its own sake, because the discoveries that result from it are hardly predictable in annual plans. I always say, if a topic has reached a feuilleton or something similar: If politicians believe that they now know how scientific developments will continue, then one should actually be particularly skeptical and not believe that one has recognized the zeitgeist particularly well. There is, as I believe I can say, today even in scientific publications in certain fields a certain rush regarding the belief that one has already described the course of time through the quasi-popular scientific presentation of discoveries. But one should look into all areas of basic research and not believe too early that one can politically categorize what is important and what is not. In any case, I will always fight for basic research based on my experience as someone who was previously involved in basic research – also in the future.

Acceptance of science also means accepting new scientific developments in society without prejudice. I have spoken about nuclear energy. I can also talk about green biotechnology in Germany – a topic that is extraordinarily difficult to convey in a country that has enough to eat, and in a European Union that is more concerned with the question of how to avoid overproduction in agriculture, and less with how many people worldwide are starving and what blessings green biotechnology can bring. In the case of so-called red biotechnology, we have seen that acceptance is present at the moment when people can derive a benefit for their own health from it. Perhaps this can serve as an example of how we can better anchor green biotechnology internationally.

Modern natural science also means international cooperation. There are projects that we can no longer carry out alone. I have strongly advocated within the European Union that we shape the European Research Council in such a way that it truly judges based on performance and not based on which countries from which regions of Europe are as fully involved in a project as possible. This way of thinking is not self-evident in Europe. It is also not so easy to ensure a constant operation of this European Research Council. But I believe we must repeatedly make it clear, even in political discussions: Science is only worthy of support if it truly produces top performance. One must not make regional compromises – otherwise Europe would be weakened overall – but one must focus on performance. This is a truth we must face.

The same discussion exists in Germany. For example, when we selected excellence universities in Germany, they were all located in southern Germany. The north was, of course, not pleased with this. But it is not a solution to the problem if one then distributes the money with a watering can; rather, one must tell the universities in the north: Become like those in the south, then you will also have a chance.

We also face the societal and political task of creating the infrastructure for the practice of science and the implementation of scientific findings. The implementation of modern technologies is the driver for achieving further technological progress. This applies to renewable energies as well as to the provision of broadband connections and, of course, to the question of smart grids in energy supply and much more. Here presents an exciting challenge, as we are essentially back in a time comparable to when railway tracks and trams were built. Back then, it was largely a task of the public sector, while today we are heavily relying on private investments.

I believe it is indeed a task of politics in the respective countries to ensure comparable living conditions for all parts of the population. This means, when I speak about Germany, above all to provide urban and rural regions equally with the opportunities of new technologies. This raises significant problems. I suspect that this also poses problems in England when I look at the beautiful English countryside, which is certainly not only characterized by urban areas. The question of how rural areas develop, however, also depends on the question of supply with modern infrastructure.

We also face the task that our growth strategies, which we need to maintain or even develop our standard of living, must comply with the mandate of sustainability. Industrial societies have developed in such a way that they consumed more resources than they returned to nature. This will no longer be so easily possible in a world where growth rates in emerging markets are dramatically rising. Therefore, we do well to direct our scientific strength towards using resources sparingly and to comprehensively implement what has emerged in Germany, namely the concept of sustainability. The concept of sustainability originated in German forestry when afforestation and planting of forests were organized in such a way that timber harvesting and forest regrowth were brought into a reasonable balance. This principle has then prevailed up to the Rio process, but unfortunately is still not adhered to worldwide. This should also be a task for the sciences.

The Royal Society repeatedly demonstrates exemplary character in all the areas I have mentioned and, of course, presented from a German perspective. They invigorate education in the natural and technical sciences. They promote young talent and have made this a strategic priority. I believe this is exactly the right decision. Because who, if not the scientists themselves, can most successfully advocate for the sciences?

Sciences thrive on curiosity and the ability to form one's own judgments. Scientific progress arises from our constant questioning of what we believe we know. Engaging in scientific activity is, so to speak, the foundation for our continuous development.

Scientific policy advice has a long tradition for the Royal Society, also true to its guiding principle. The first report was published by the Royal Society in 1664. It has maintained its excellent reputation as an independent voice of science in the UK, in Europe, and in international politics to this day. Even in its 350th year of existence, it has set the course for progress and the future. With the establishment of the "Science Policy Centre," it has further expanded its field of activity. This aims to further establish the Royal Society as a hub in the debate about the connections between science, society, and politics. Perhaps this is also an inspiration for our National Academy, the Leopoldina.

Now, I am not only pleased that the new president of the Leopoldina, Professor Hacker, is here today, but also particularly pleased that there is a close cooperation. Together, the Royal Society and the Leopoldina want to better prepare themselves for the demands of policy advice. The moment we finally had a National Academy, I decided to establish policy advice in Germany on new foundations, similar to the British model. In this way, we as the federal government will also seek advice from the Leopoldina and acatech – a technical academy that also has a national character – in the future.

Later this year, the European Academies Science Advisory Council, a coalition of national academies from EU member states, will move from the Royal Society to the Leopoldina in Halle. We are, of course, proud of this. It was actually quite amusing that when Germany held the G8 presidency in 2007, we did not yet have a national academy and were essentially the only country without a natural point of contact, but even then we wisely chose the Leopoldina, which has proven to be the right decision.

In closing, I would like to express my heartfelt thanks once again for the extraordinary honor I have today, namely to speak to you and to receive the King Charles II Medal. This is, of course, also a painful reminder of all that I have forgotten from my time as an actively working natural scientist. But on the other hand, it is a great challenge for me to translate the knowledge about the general connections of scientific work that remains in my mind into political actions. I always find that enjoyable. One can shape, one can set priorities.

When we, as the federal government, spend twelve billion euros more on sciences and education in this legislative period, it is a way to set the right priorities in practical work. I ask you, the scientists: Do not hesitate to tell us if you believe we are spending the money incorrectly. Because money is one thing, and doing the right things with it is another. Therefore, I must tell you: The dialogue between science and politics must become closer rather than less close.