Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the 15th Ordinary Federal Association Congress of the Social Association VdK Germany on May 18, 2006, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

18 May 2006 · 15th Ordinary Federal Association Congress of the Social Association VdK Germany · Berlin

Context
Merkel addressed the 15th Federal Congress of the Social Association VdK Germany in Berlin on May 18, 2006, speaking on welfare state preservation.
Main themes
Welfare state preservation, social market economy, unemployment and labor market challenges, social cohesion and solidarity, globalization and economic competition, generational equity, social security systems, regional inequality, disability and social welfare advocacy, German domestic economic situation
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,556
89th percentile
Sentences
249
93rd percentile
Readability
60
88th percentile
Grade
9.2
12th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
1.92
4th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 48%48%
  • Economic 26%26%
  • Institutional 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

249 sentences in 64 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Hirrlinger,

dear members of the VdK,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag,

ladies and gentlemen,

I already congratulated you, dear Mr. Hirrlinger, in writing yesterday on your re-election as President of the VdK. However, I would like to do so again personally today.

To gain the trust of the members of your association again and again over 16 years in this position speaks very clearly for you, for your work, your commitment, and your straightforwardness, as we have just heard again. So, congratulations on your re-election!

My congratulations also go to all the other members of the Executive Board and the members of the Federal Committee who have been elected, and I wish them success and strength in their work.

I believe we should get straight to the point. You have set the motto for the association meeting: "Preserving the welfare state." This motto expresses a clear demand. However, I believe it also expresses a concern. It expresses the concern that what is important to you – in this case, the welfare state – could be in danger. It could be in danger either from within, meaning due to the factual and problem situation in our country, or because you believe that certain political or societal forces exist that do not want our welfare state or no longer want it. – I believe we must address this very clearly.

To answer the second point, namely the question of political forces, right away; and I say this as the Federal Chancellor of a Grand Coalition and also as the chairperson of the CDU: The federal government and the CDU of Germany want to preserve our welfare state. We want solidarity among each other, between generations, between the strong and the weaker. We want what has been the hallmark of the Federal Republic of Germany for a long time to continue to succeed today and in the future. The social market economy should continue to be the social market economy. The great thing about the social market economy was and is that it must and can succeed in resolving the supposed contradiction between capital and labor in such a way that it serves not the welfare of individual people, but as many as possible.

"Well said," some of you may say now. "But what is the reality?" you may ask me. In other words: Is the welfare state, if not through political will or societal groups, perhaps still in danger?

My answer at this point, when I look at the factual and factual situation, is: "Yes." Because the reality we have is not satisfactory. We have almost five million unemployed and a not completely manageable future for the social security systems. We find ourselves in a situation where Germany is indeed the world champion in exports, but we have a difficult situation in the domestic market. We are in international competition in a world that has become more transparent and smaller, and where the question is asked more clearly: "Where are others also making an effort?"

I believe we agree in this room as well. We cannot simply deny the achievements of the social market economy – that is, what we have achieved for ourselves in Germany – to others and say: "This should never apply to you." We must therefore see that the prosperity we have worked for – and when I say "we," I mean the generation of your members – cannot be taken for granted for the next ten, twenty, thirty, or forty years.

I believe – to return to the beginning once again – that the social order of the social market economy is without any reasonable alternative. But it will only be able to convince the citizens of this country if people perceive this social market economy as an order in which they can live reasonably in their personal lives. This concerns very concrete points, namely the search for work, expectations of the education system, security in old age, and the risks of illness, health, and disability.

I know that a significant number of people in our society experience that this society is partly characterized by tendencies of division – whether those are people over 50 years of age who hardly have a chance of finding work, or young people who have difficulties finding an apprenticeship and are sometimes passed from one training measure to another. We must not accept this. Because it is about the cohesion of a nation. It is about our common understanding of nation. When we say that we live together in a community of fate, we must also feel responsible for one another.

Globalization has brought about a situation in which society sometimes divides between those who are doing very well, who cannot get enough of change, and who are looking to integrate the new times into their lives even faster, and many who, on the other side, are afraid of being left behind at this pace.

We also have tendencies of division between East and West, between the new and the old federal states. We have them also between regions in federal states. In some regions, things are progressing, while in others, very little is moving. We know that perhaps the greatest division exists between those who have work and those who do not. And what tendencies do we have between young and old? One wonders: Can we bear responsibility together, or is there also a division here?

Again, I say: We must not accept this. My heartfelt request, especially to the VdK, is: Always seek dialogue with young people. It makes no sense if, in the end, each age group discusses separately. But I believe, Mr. Hirrlinger, that our opinions do not diverge on this.

When we look at the challenges posed by globalization, it makes no sense for a country like Germany to simply run behind, to go along, to seek some niche, or to isolate itself for a while longer; rather, we must face international competition. We must reflect on our strengths and enable people to have a say in this development at the forefront.

I believe one of the great challenges for politics is – beyond party membership: Can we convince citizens that we are shaping politics, or are we just trailing behind economic processes and no longer have the strength to shape?

Because the world is changing, I am convinced that we must also change and further develop the welfare state. It is about the questions: What has made the welfare state strong? What is our goal? The answer is: balance instead of division and the fact that performance must be worthwhile for the individual. We must consider: How do we do this?

I must tell you that I have been politically active for about 16 years now. One difficulty we are in is the fact that, in my view, in these 16 years – I explicitly refer to this period – expectations have repeatedly been raised among citizens that were subsequently met with disappointments. I believe this has sustainably disturbed trust in politics. We must be careful that it does not destroy trust in politics. Sometimes it may seem to one that the citizens' balance is: First, expectations were disappointed, and in the end, only disappointments are expected from the citizens.

I am aware of the limits and also the opportunities of every coalition. I believe that if any political constellation in Germany can break this cycle – and I am deeply convinced of that – it is the Grand Coalition. The Grand Coalition of the two major parties will also present you with decisions where we will not always agree and with which we will demand quite a bit from the people in the country, not just from the members of the VdK.

I do not want to beat around the bush. I know, for example, that many of you will suffer greatly from the financial consequences of the increase in value-added tax. One percent of the three percentage points will be used to reduce labor costs. However, the seven percent of the reduced value-added tax rate will remain. That is also part of the truth.

Nevertheless, it is the case that you are being asked something with the increase in value-added tax and some other financial policy decisions. It is a difficult path, and I do not want to start in any way to sugarcoat anything. Saving hurts, and it hurts the citizens; many who cannot cope with it so easily.

I tell you this because we do not make things easy for ourselves. We have a budget according to which we will spend 260 billion euros this year. We are taking on new debts of 40 billion euros because we do not have all the money for what we are spending. And we are paying almost 40 billion euros in interest on debts we incurred in the past. This has nothing to do with the policies of the current federal government. It is simply what we are starting with. So, 40 billion euros more in expenditures than revenues and 40 billion euros in expenditures for interest. Then we have about 77 billion euros for pension subsidies and about 40 billion euros for unemployment benefit II subsidies. And then only between 60 and 70 billion euros remain that we can spend on family policy, transport policy, infrastructure, research and development, and investments in the future. That is the situation.

I want – this is also the common will of this federal government – to bring expectations and results back together. Because if we want to preserve the welfare state, we cannot simply continue as before; rather, we must look and understand that we will not be successful with simple transfers alone. This means we must further develop the welfare state. We must do what we call structural reforms. I tell you with full conviction: With these structural reforms, many things, especially at the beginning, will be very difficult. But without these structural reforms, nothing will succeed that preserves the welfare state. That is the situation we are in.

Now let us get specific.

First, regarding pensions.

We have a demographic change – these are all technical terms. I want to explicitly say: This demographic change has very positive components. One of the positive components is that people are living longer, that they can shape their lives in health for longer. This is an incredible success of the social market economy, and we are pleased about it. Our problem is not that we have too many older people, but our problem is that we have too few children in this society. That is what should concern us.

Do you not think that we have too few children? I am not quite sure why you are murmuring. But I think we must be careful together that, in the end, there is not a discussion in which some older people feel in any way aggrieved. We are glad to have the older people in our society. I consider it unacceptable to speak of a humane society in which, for example, experience and routine – things that can only be learned through time – are no longer wanted in the world of work. A society that does not see this misses incredible opportunities.

But now let us get specific and come to pensions. We have the demographic change. You know that current pension payments are not financed by taking what you have earned in your lifetime. Instead, those who are currently paying contributions finance your pensions.

Here we have a problem or at least a change: In 1960, there were nearly two retirees for every ten working-age people; today, there are already three retirees for every ten working-age people, and by 2030, there will be about five retirees for every ten working-age people. Additionally, those who are of working age are unfortunately not all employed, meaning they are not gainfully employed. But only those who are gainfully employed contribute to ensuring that retirees also receive a pension. This means we will find ourselves in a situation where, by 2030, there will be fewer than two gainfully employed people to support the pension of one person. – I say "gainfully employed" because not all those of working age are also gainfully employed. – The situation will be alleviated if we significantly improve the employment rate – that is part of our policy – so that the revenue situation of the pension insurance becomes significantly better. This means that retirees must have a fundamental interest in reducing the number of unemployed in our country because this is a good message for pensions. I believe you have that too. I do not blame you. I just say: The things are very closely related.

It should also be noted that, due to the longer life expectancy, the duration of pension payments has increased by more than two-thirds between 1960 and today, namely from ten to 17 years. That is also a fact.

The federal subsidy for pension insurance – so that we can finance things as they are today – amounts to 77 billion euros. This is really not about pitting one generation against another. It is about ensuring that in politics – and this ultimately happens with the Federal Chancellor and the Federal Government – all aspects are taken into account.

Now we have done something, Mr. Hirrlinger, that you have criticized. You said the conditions for this are not in place. We have said that the retirement age must be gradually raised by one month each year between 2011 and 2029, ultimately reaching 67 years. We are not starting this today because we know that the employment opportunities for older people are currently unacceptably poor. That is why we will only begin in the next legislative period. But so that people also know what to expect – as this is also related to life decisions – we are making this proposal today and passing it, so that there is a degree of predictability in this regard. Minister Müntefering will specifically improve the employment opportunities for older people in the labor market through a program for older unemployed individuals. This remains a very important issue.

Look, you can say: "This won't work anyway." We can approach things that way too. If I get up in the morning and, when I consider the problems of this world, say: "This won't work anyway," then it certainly won't work. That is why I tell you again: I cannot promise you the success of such a program one hundred percent. I can only tell you: If politics does not take care of it, if the responsible minister does not take care of it, then nothing will happen for sure. And between these two things, you have a choice.

I know that you have often been disappointed – I have spoken about that – and therefore you do not need to place your complete trust in us at this point. But please do not prevent us from doing what we believe is right. Because if we do nothing, then it certainly will not get better. But give us the chance to at least try in a difficult environment.

Now we come to the next point. We have passed a law – Mr. Hirrlinger, you have really named almost everything, but you forgot one thing: that is the law on the continued validity of current pension values. – By the way, we have also removed one-euro jobs from the calculation of wage sums, which was also an important step. – We have passed the law on the continued validity of current pension values and have politically committed ourselves for the entire legislative period – I want to state this explicitly – that there will be no pension cuts. This also puts the issue of health insurance contributions to rest, to make that clear.

Now I must confront you with reality. The pension insurance system, as it is designed, links the amount of pensions to wage development. This is the solidarity pension system. If we had applied this system this year, in the way that has always been dear and costly to us, it would have led to pensions in the West being cut by nearly one percent and in the East by more than one percent. This means that we have consciously made a political exception to this mechanism because we believe that it is unreasonable and politically unacceptable to impose a pension cut on retirees in a difficult environment.

Of course, this must also be seen in connection with a catch-up factor. It is less about the question of whether this will come into play in the current legislative period. But we must ask ourselves: When the economy improves again, when the labor market situation is better, is it not also unfair to future generations that we do not take into account in a catch-up factor what we have not imposed on you now? That is the political debate.

Mr. Hirrlinger, I would like to stay in conversation with you on this point. – He is shaking his head, but I believe that we will still come together again. I want to stay in conversation with you because I am absolutely convinced that it is right not to impose pension cuts – and this will also apply for the coming years – but I also carry with me a contribution that does not correspond to the mechanisms of the pension system that has been in place for decades. We need to discuss together which generation and who in that generation should bear this.

We must improve purchasing power by also improving the employment situation. That is why we are not talking about introducing the catch-up factor next year. I just cannot promise you that we will not introduce it at all because I simply believe that we should first accept the political commitment that we will not impose pension cuts in this legislative period.

Secondly

on the topic of health.

Ms. Ferner spoke about this topic. This has also been accompanied by a certain skepticism from you because many feel – and I can only confirm this – that there is a risk of different treatment of health risks in our country. Nevertheless, I tell you: We do not want to go down the path of a two-tier healthcare system, and this applies to the entire Grand Coalition.

This is a political will that is not so easy to implement in detail. I know that every person in our country today receives the medically necessary care when they are seriously ill. I believe that is the case. But I also know that in many areas – let’s talk about disabled children or adults with disabilities – much is stretched, and perhaps more medical applications could achieve more quality of life. It also makes no sense to close our eyes to the fact that there are waiting times for certain things. All of this encompasses the situation we are in. That is why we want to set the course with our health reform to counteract these developments.

This means that we first look at what improvements we can make in the healthcare system. There is currently no transparency between outpatient and inpatient care. But to achieve this transparency, to name just one example, I must also be able to compare costs in a hospital with fees that a doctor charges in outpatient treatment. We have no fee schedule. A doctor takes an X-ray today, and at some point at the end of the half-year, he finds out what he gets for that X-ray procedure.

This means that, in my firm opinion, we can improve many things in the structures. We must above all ensure that we have reasonable care offerings in rural areas. We will have to conduct a political discussion about how many hospitals we consider necessary so that people have a hospital close to where they live. But not every hospital will be able to do everything due to the high specialization of medicine.

Our health experts are currently dealing with nothing related to debts, etc., but only with these structural measures because we say: If anyone can really achieve structural improvements and more transparency in this system, it is the Grand Coalition.

I believe that patients also have a right to see what has actually happened, what costs how much, and which doctor offers what. Society is very mature today and has an interest in this. We will, of course, maintain a solidarity-based financing system. But I also tell you: It is simply the case that we will have significant deficits in health insurance funds starting next year if we do not implement structural reforms. You know that.

It is also true – and we must face this truth – that in a society where medical and technological progress is thankfully increasing and where we know that the number of older people will be greater, responsible politicians must not tell people that this whole thing can tendentially become cheaper. It will not become cheaper. That is why we must think about the future of financing this system in such a way that we do not drive jobs abroad, which will then be missing elsewhere in the form of contributors. This makes the discussion so difficult, but it will take place in a good climate and in a constructive atmosphere.

Thirdly:

You mentioned long-term care insurance.

Here too, we must change many things. You have named some points that we can discuss very openly. When visiting a nursing home, I personally find the bureaucratic burdens we have imposed to be extremely contrary to the human approach. We must give back some trust to those who perform heavy caregiving tasks and help people in this regard.

I want to say a word about people with disabilities. Yes, we have decided, even in a not entirely easy situation, to include disabilities and age, as well as sexual identity, in the civil law part of the anti-discrimination directive, so that no discrimination may occur here. This is a bit more than what was required in the EU directive. There, it only applied to the labor law area. But I find that people with disabilities have rightly asked: What is the reason you do not include this? That would create distrust. We have neither deserved this distrust nor is it appropriate. It is about protection. People who have a harder time in many areas of life have a right to this protection. I represent this with all my heart and will also advocate for it.

We must carry out structural reforms in the social security systems – we are in the midst of this work – also in the areas of labor market and family policy. I hope that you, many of whom will be grandparents, have followed our discussion about parental allowance with interest and anticipation. Sometimes you may have followed it with shaking heads because it also concerns the role of fathers.

I want to say in advance: Sometimes the whole discussion about the compatibility of work and family is understood a bit as if the older generation, from which perhaps more women have exclusively or for a large part of their lives decided on child-rearing, is asking: Did I do the right thing? Is our kind of commitment still valued? I tell you very explicitly: We do not want to dictate to anyone how to live. We respect every decision. It is not the state's job to judge this.

But you, who are grandfathers or grandmothers, also know that times have changed. If you have daughters or granddaughters, they have a different education. They have studied. They are capable. They know that they are just as capable as the young men. When the topic of family comes up, we suddenly find that 40 percent of those who have completed a university or college degree do not choose to have children. I am firmly convinced that they do not do this because they do not want children, but because balancing work and family is a very complicated issue.

No political measure will be able to turn people's decisions around by 180 degrees. But politics can set signals. Politics can say: There are not enough childcare options, and therefore we must do something for childcare. We also know that the decision to have a child cannot mean the immediate continuation of a career right at the beginning of a child's life.

That is why we are now saying something very interesting: We continue to care for those who are socially disadvantaged. There is a basic amount for parental allowance. But we also say: For those who earn more, the decision to have a child and to take a year off from work is a loss of living standards. We want to help young people and say that society pays a wage replacement benefit for many things. Why not also for a couple's decision to have children?

In addition, there is a second point that I also find exciting. This concerns the role of the father. I tell you: Children always need time. We cannot expect that only women's lives in society will change. We also know that young fathers today deal with children quite naturally. But when a young father goes to his employer and says: "Look, I want to stay home for two months with my little baby," many men who say this are viewed much more critically than women. We want to contribute to making it normal for a father to also take an additional two months to care for his child without a major societal discussion breaking out about it. This will help women. This will help men. This will help society as a whole.

You must know that this federal government has taken office so that Germany can say in ten years: We are not in the back group of the European Union, but we are, in terms of employment, growth, education, and innovation, back in the top group, among the top three. This is good for the welfare state. However, if we do not succeed in this, we will also have to make more cuts to the welfare state. We in this federal government know that everything is interconnected: investments in education, investments in families, investments in infrastructure, reforms in pensions, in the healthcare system, and in nursing care.

We know that the older generations in this society have laid the foundation upon which we can live today. We will never forget this in our policies – hence the clear decision against any pension cuts in this legislative period. But we must – and this will sometimes make a difference – also tell you what we already know today, so that you are not disappointed tomorrow because we indulged in a nice hour today and I agreed with you on everything. It is personally very important to me that expectations are also met.

I believe that with the VdK we always have a conversation partner who is open-minded, listens, and brings in arguments. I thank you all for contributing to the necessary changes in this society.