Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the 22nd Ordinary Congress of IG Metall on October 14, 2011, in Karlsruhe:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

16 October 2011 · 22nd Ordinary Congress of IG Metall · Karlsruhe, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 22nd Ordinary Congress of IG Metall on October 14, 2011, in Karlsruhe, discussing Germany's economic recovery and European stability.
Main themes
Social market economy, European stability and euro crisis, Germany's economic recovery, labor-management cooperation, short-time work and flexible employment, IG Metall and trade union role, tax justice and cold progression, income tax disagreement, middle class protection, unemployment and employment records, European responsibility, unified union principle
Duration
~41 min
91st percentile
Words
4,965
91st percentile
Sentences
289
95th percentile
Readability
50
63rd percentile
Grade
10.5
26th percentile
Syntax
2.84
26th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 53%51%
  • Social 19%18%
  • Institutional 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

289 sentences in 74 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Huber,

dear members of the board,

dear delegates of IG Metall,

ladies and gentlemen,

here in Karlsruhe, where you have been meeting for quite some time now, we recently celebrated the 60th anniversary of the Federal Constitutional Court. Karlsruhe stands for groundbreaking decisions that have shaken politics on many occasions and have repeatedly provided important impulses for legislation. In this respect, the choice of your conference location alone sends a certain signal. This is even more true given the many topics you have been addressing. This also applies to your board elections. The decisions have been made. Therefore, I would like to extend my heartfelt congratulations to you, Mr. Huber, and to you, Mr. Wetzel. I wish you, as well as all other board members, joy and success in fulfilling your tasks, and I hope for our continued constructive cooperation, even if it will certainly be critical at times.

I want to emphasize explicitly: For politics, it is important to have a reliable contact person in you, Mr. Huber, and in the entire IG Metall. IG Metall successfully represents the interests of its members, as evidenced by the increase in membership. This is also an indication that the principle of the unified union, which I consider absolutely important, has proven itself. "Unified union" means that the union is open to all employees, regardless of their respective political beliefs.

When I spoke at your union congress in Leipzig four years ago, in 2007 – as Mr. Huber mentioned – we were all still unaware of the international financial market and economic crisis that would hit the world starting in 2008. Since the beginning of this crisis in 2008, the cards have undoubtedly been reshuffled worldwide. From the very beginning, I set myself the goal that Germany should emerge from this crisis stronger than it entered it. I believe that today we can state: We have achieved this, and we have done so together. It has been accomplished through a joint effort of business, unions, and politics. For me, this is a piece of lived social market economy and, by the way, also an example that politics can make a difference together with the relevant societal forces.

Such a joint effort can only succeed if there is a trusting collaboration among the partners to work together on solutions. At that time, as the federal government, we cushioned the effects of the crisis with comprehensive stimulus packages. Companies largely retained their core workforce. They utilized the leeway provided by flexible working arrangements such as short-time work, temporary work, and flexible collective agreements. And the employees – we must not and will not forget this – accepted significant wage cuts in part, thereby helping their companies to get through a difficult time. This has paid off as an investment in their own future. This must not simply be forgotten again in better economic times. I say this very explicitly.

Germany has, with comprehensive measures and constructive collaboration, regained a production level like that before the crisis as the first major industrial country. Unemployment is at its lowest in almost 20 years. The number of employed persons has climbed to a new record high. And particularly encouraging is that the number of socially insured employment relationships has also reached a record.

Real incomes have been rising again for a long time. To what extent employees actually benefit from such income increases is, of course, also a question of tax policy. When we look at the progressive tax rate, we see that the issue of tax justice in terms of combating the significant effects of cold progression is indeed a topic that should concern us together. We will clarify, in light of the tax estimates, to what extent we can achieve a bit more tax justice here.

In one matter, we have a disagreement. I want to address this openly. I consider tax increases, particularly in the area of income tax, to be counterproductive, as they not only affect high earners but also medium-sized and small businesses that operate as partnerships. I believe such tax increases do not help us in the current situation. Because we all, and you at IG Metall know this particularly well: We benefit from Germany having a strong middle class that can respond very quickly and flexibly. Therefore, we should not do anything that weakens our middle class.

Germany is currently the engine of growth and the anchor of stability in Europe. Germany is the largest economy in Europe. Therefore, we share – and we are completely in agreement on this – a special responsibility that extends beyond the borders of our country. I am pleased that IG Metall and the DGB have explicitly stated: We stand for Europe; Europe is our future. Thank you for that. This is extremely important in times like these.

Germany benefits from the internal market and also from the euro in a very special way. Forty percent of our exports go to countries in the euro area, and sixty percent to the countries of the European Union as a whole. 1.5 million employees work here in companies from euro states that have established themselves in Germany. Therefore, if we ensure a stable economic and monetary union, it means that we secure the international competitiveness of our companies, that we secure jobs in Germany, and that we secure prosperity in our country.

I agree: Europe is much more than just economic data. When you travel to other regions of the world, you see – you only need to go to the edge of Europe, for example to Serbia and Kosovo, to see – that questions of war and peace can quickly come back to the agenda. Therefore, Europe is our great political project.

But now we have a situation – I have said: the cards in the world are being reshuffled in such an international financial crisis – in which the view of realities in Europe has sharpened and in which it has become clear that we do not have a crisis of the euro, but a debt crisis in various countries and in the countries of the eurozone with relatively weak competitiveness. I do not say this to single out individual countries; I say this so that we can come closer to a solution. Because if you define the causes incorrectly, you will certainly not find the right answers.

The Bundestag and Bundesrat expanded the existing euro rescue fund at the end of September, giving it more instruments. I am very pleased that the unions have also approved this decision. The goal is for the euro area states to respond more quickly and flexibly to crisis developments and also to financial market speculation. We must above all ensure that we can contain contagion risks from country to country. Otherwise, the stability of the euro as a whole is at risk, which must be absolutely prevented.

We pursue

three

principles:

First:

The principle of solidarity: We help in emergencies when the stability of our currency as a whole is at stake.

The

second

principle is the principle of personal responsibility: We help when the respective country also takes all possible measures to improve its situation.

Thirdly,

there must be the principle of control: We help based on a sound analysis conducted by the European Commission, the European Central Bank, and the International Monetary Fund, the so-called Troika.

The cause of the current crisis lies fundamentally in a disastrous combination of excessive debt and lack of competitiveness, whereby we – as you know as employees and as works councils – do not define competitiveness alone. It is relative; it is a global issue. Competitiveness must always be measured against the strongest in the world.

When I speak of debt and competitiveness, the difficult news is that this crisis did not come to us overnight. Debt accelerated during the international financial and economic crisis. We had to implement global stimulus programs. As a result, public debt has increased. This has made the debt even more visible, but it has been built up over years, indeed decades, in almost all European countries. Because this crisis did not arise overnight, it will not be resolved overnight either. Time and again, there is a call for a single solution; it is said that there must be this one solution. I understand this desire for a one-time breakthrough. But I tell you and say this over and over again: There is not one solution, there is not one big hit, one thunderclap that will make everything end. Those who nurture such a longing either lose patience or do not recognize the dimension of the challenge, or both.

I say this so clearly because this longing is also spreading again now, before the next European Council on October 23. Almost euphorically, some are now talking about a so-called debt cut, for example for Greece, after which everything will change immediately.

I advise – as I have since the beginning of the crisis – to exercise great caution, because the crisis teaches us two things

:

First,

nothing should be declared unthinkable, and secondly,

everything must be carefully examined for its risks. The principle of hope must not, under any circumstances, be the measure of decision-making. There is no way around a prudent examination of the pros and cons of each next step.

Even the currently hotly debated debt cut for Greece should, if at all, only be attempted if it is prepared to the best of our knowledge and belief, in order to prevent worse and to be able to initiate structural reforms. As a kind of desperate act, as the last bullet in the magazine, as some even formulate it, it would be irresponsible. I know that many experts, including self-proclaimed ones, advise such and similar decisions for a so-called grand design. However, those same experts would be the first to accuse politics of irresponsible action if we in politics had not considered all risks and the problems afterwards were greater than before. We should not forget: In everything we are currently doing, we are constantly treading new ground.

In a word: The issues of debt and the issue of lack of competitiveness must be considered together and solved together. This is a long, arduous process, a process of many steps and measures that must each be chosen so that they bring more advantages than disadvantages at the time of the decisions – no more and no less.

In this context, a word about euro bonds, which for a few weeks in the discussion were considered the breakthrough in itself. They are also not a miracle cure. Because what would happen? They would reward highly indebted states with low interest rates and burden us with higher interest rates, which in the end would be a burden for all taxpayers. You can still say: Out of solidarity, we do this. But the most important question is: Where then are the incentives to develop more competitively and to reduce debt? Therefore, I am deeply convinced that euro bonds will not help us under the current conditions. – Convincing work still needs to be done, but at least.

We cannot avoid it: Solidarity and personal responsibility must form a balance. Therefore, it is right not only to set up a rescue umbrella but also to give more weight to the European Stability and Growth Pact. Look, we have a European Stability and Growth Pact: three percent new debt per year; no country may have a higher new debt than 60 percent of its gross domestic product. This pact has been violated almost a hundred times without any clear sanctions ever being imposed – partly also because member states have fought each time to ensure that nothing is done against them at the relevant moment.

Therefore, I say: At this point, we need more Europe. What use is a Stability and Growth Pact if, in the end, everyone can violate it whenever they deem it appropriate? We need European rights that allow for intervention in countries that repeatedly do not adhere to guidelines and thereby endanger the euro as our currency overall and also endanger our jobs. Furthermore, we must work more closely and bindingly together on issues of economic and financial policy. I want to explicitly echo what Mr. Huber said: It is not only about punishing and cutting; it is equally about generating growth. Without growth, we will not succeed.

But I will only mention the example of Greece. Of the structural funds and cohesion funds that have been specifically allocated in the European Union to make countries with lower competitiveness more competitive, Greece has not applied for about 70 percent of the funds during the period from 2007 to 2013, which is the phase that is soon coming to an end. This is currently not a question of money, but a question of capability. Therefore, it was right for the European Commission to send experts to Greece to help the Greeks apply for the funds that can lead to more growth in this country. We must continue on this path.

Still – and this is part of the truth – there are far too many weaknesses in the regulation of financial markets. I want to say this explicitly. With a G20 summit approaching, I also say: We must succeed in effectively eliminating these weaknesses. Otherwise, the policy of responsibility will not do justice to establishing boundaries for the markets. That, however, is our understanding of a social market economy. Otherwise, the markets will dominate us; and that will not end well.

Ultimately, it can only succeed together with our European and international partners. Even if this is laborious and sometimes unsatisfactory, there is no way around it. In Germany and Europe, for example, we have increased the capital requirements for banks, and the remuneration systems now have much clearer rules. There is now a more effective European banking supervision. Hedge funds and rating agencies will be supervised in the future.

But two central questions remain unanswered in the G20 process; we will address these questions again in November in France.

First: How can we prevent a shift to less regulated areas of the financial market? We have always said: We want to regulate every financial market participant, every financial product, and every financial center worldwide. Because if we create the best regulations in Europe – which is already quite laborious – it does us no good if actions can be taken from other parts of the world and no one applies the rules here because all the actors are elsewhere.

Second: How do we deal with large, so-called systemically important banks in the future? A framework must be created to wind down troubled banks in such a way that the entire system does not stumble and taxpayers do not have to bear the costs again. We have achieved this in Germany with our bank restructuring law, it is at least in progress in Europe, and it must now succeed globally through the G20 summit, otherwise we will ultimately still have areas in the world where this is not regulated.

I want to say something very openly regarding the financial market transaction tax. It cannot be that those outside the euro area, who repeatedly call on us to take comprehensive action to tackle the debt crisis, simultaneously refuse the introduction of a financial market transaction tax. I find that unacceptable. We want and must involve financial market participants in the costs of crisis management. I will advocate for this until we succeed – at least in Europe, better yet worldwide.

For we must understand: The financial market crisis and the debt crisis are both fundamentally a crisis of trust, where freedom and responsibility have completely gone out of balance. If we do not restore this through reasonable regulation, then trust will not return. The trust in the reliability and competence of many financial market participants has been damaged. We may not always see it ourselves, but there is this lack of trust. There is also a lack of trust in the solidity and performance of individual European economies. I advise all of us not to simply brush this aside, but to take it seriously.

All the more important is Germany's role as an anchor of trust in Europe. With this – that is my goal – we can also achieve in Europe what we have achieved in Germany, namely that Europe emerges from the crisis stronger than it entered it. Because we are so closely connected to Europe, it cannot go well for us in the long run if it does not go well for Europe. Therefore, all of Europe must also emerge stronger from this crisis.

Germany itself has done a multitude of its homework. Companies know that they owe this largely to their employees. This is also evident in the fact that we have collective agreements where this assumption of responsibility in the crisis is now reflected in better pay. It becomes increasingly clear: Social partnership has proven itself in Germany, especially in times of crisis. This is the secret of success of collective autonomy. It is also very interesting to see, even in the international trade union sphere, that even those who never wanted to know anything about the social market economy before the international financial crisis, who sometimes looked somewhat disparagingly at German collective autonomy – this has even been the case in the international trade union sphere – today ask: How does that actually work in Germany?

We must know that the economic framework conditions are changing rapidly nowadays. Companies must respond quickly and flexibly to this. That is why it is so important that collective autonomy proves itself. The federal government supports the social partners. Thus, upon their request, if certain criteria are met, we can extend their already negotiated collective results across the entire industry through the Employee Posting Act. We are currently reviewing how the industry-specific minimum wages will impact in detail. But I will say quite honestly: I have no signs that this has had a very negative effect.

Regarding temporary work, the federal government has now created the conditions for a wage floor. A corresponding legal regulation is to be issued at the proposal of the social partners. This will prevent employers from deviating from the principle of equal pay indefinitely at the expense of employees. In addition, we have introduced a so-called revolving door clause. Because – we agree on this – it cannot be that a company dismisses employees from the permanent workforce just to rehire them later as temporary workers, possibly under worse working conditions. Such abuse will be excluded in the future.

The new rules are an important signal to handle various employment opportunities responsibly. Many companies do this, not least because they depend on a committed workforce. They are in competition for the best talent. Given the demographic development, it is foreseeable that this competition will become increasingly fierce. But I also say: The problem of the shortage of skilled workers, which sometimes comes up too quickly on the agenda, cannot be solved by simply calling for international skilled workers and essentially meaning wage cuts. We will not endorse that.

That is why I am very pleased that the federal government has intensively discussed the issue of securing skilled workers with trade unions and businesses this year. We agree that all labor potential must be better utilized. For us, this task is one of the essential societal challenges. At the end of June, we adopted a comprehensive concept for the long-term securing of the skilled labor base. It emerged that we still have many opportunities at home to effectively tap into potential – including through integration.

With the integration of young people with a migration background, we must succeed in improving the school qualifications of these young people and thus their ability to train. I have discussed this with the ministers of education and the prime ministers of the states. Soon I will visit the conference of education ministers. This is an unusual step. I was told that a federal chancellor has never spoken with education ministers. Yes, the education ministers are responsible for school policy; but if at the end of the school period many young people receive a "not trainable" status because companies say they cannot meet the requirements, then federal policy must also address how to improve this. The number of school dropouts must be halved.

It is also of no use to beat around the bush that the connection between social background and educational success in Germany is still too great. We are addressing this issue with the training pact between the federal government and business. We believe that the strengths of dual education must be better utilized. We are now promoting career entry companions nationwide. These are so-called educational guides who accompany disadvantaged students from grade seven through to their training. I find it terrible when we simply lose young people because we do not know what has become of them. That must not happen. We want to give them early insights into professional practice. I thank the trade unions for always constructively supporting such efforts.

It is – I say this very clearly – worth every effort to give even seemingly less capable young people a future. It cannot be that we have a difficult demographic problem, that everyone laments that we have too few young people, yet young people aged 25, 26, or 27 are unemployed, and remain in Hartz IV for eternity. We must never accept that. Yes, we are better than most European countries with over nine percent youth unemployment. But that cannot satisfy us, because that is still far too much. I am deeply convinced that we can give more young people a chance.

A second point for us is the issue of women, the compatibility of work and family. The task is to improve this compatibility. Therefore, we advocate for more family-friendliness, especially for the expansion of care options for children under three years old. A lot is currently in flux. But when you see how many single parents still do not have a childcare place for their children, that cannot satisfy us yet.

You have themed your trade union congress "Course Change: Together for a Good Life." To achieve a good life together, in my opinion, measures are also necessary that are clearly unpopular, but which I consider essential, such as raising the regular retirement age to 67 by the year 2029. I cannot spare you from this topic. The continuing increase in life expectancy is a welcome fact, but longer periods of pension payments are the consequence. We cannot change the declining birth rates in the short term, especially not retroactively. That is the reality; that is our problem. If you were to make comprehensive promises about how you would handle this in the future, one could reconsider. But so much time has already passed. Therefore, we must face this: Rising contribution rates are bad for competitiveness, and the pension level would drop significantly. That is what the calculations show. It is not good to disbelieve calculations that are very valid.

I know that you say: It must be achieved above all that the actual retirement age comes closer to the legal one. In this regard, we have made progress, but we are still far from where we want to be. Nevertheless, I believe that a longer working life is a question of generational justice. This also depends on the acceptance of our old-age security system. You must never forget: If generational justice is too far out of balance with us, then in today’s united Europe, in an open world, it quickly leads to the effect that young people seek employment elsewhere. That would be a catastrophe for our generational balance. Therefore, it is necessary that we address this issue.

But it is also necessary that we deal with the issue of poverty in old age. 2.4 percent of people in retirement currently rely on basic security. However, we know that this number could rise. I also want to point out: The federal government has now transferred basic security payments in connection with the negotiations on unemployment benefit II from the municipalities to the federal level. This is a rather unique step, as the municipal umbrella associations tell us, because we relieve the municipalities of a growing burden and give them more strength for their actual tasks. Nevertheless, old-age poverty must be combated more comprehensively than simply transferring basic security to the federal level. Therefore, the pension dialogue has been initiated. I am pleased that IG Metall is participating.

This concerns three points.

First:

We want to reward people's contributions more fairly than before. It must make a difference whether someone has paid contributions and made provisions or not. Insured individuals should therefore be able to rely on receiving a retirement income above the basic security level if they have worked throughout their lives and made additional provisions.

Secondly,

we are looking for a way to improve the situation of people with reduced earning capacity in old age.

Thirdly,

we want to make it easier to combine pensions with additional earnings. Employees should have more freedom to decide on their work rhythm before reaching the standard retirement age. This is particularly important, as IG Metall rightly emphasizes, in professions with significant physical demands. The key term here is age-appropriate work. Trade unions and employers should be given more room to ensure flexible and individually tailored transitions from working life to retirement within the existing pension law.

The concern for the further development of old-age security is a good example that IG Metall is not only focused on its core business, on today's employees, but thinks far beyond that. This far-beyond-thinking is not only evident in your motto but in much of what we discuss together. It is primarily about the question: What are our sources of growth and prosperity in the future? A continuation of the status quo is not possible and will not happen in a world with seven billion people today. Therefore, we share the conviction that in Germany there must be firstly, an industrial base, secondly, growth must continually emerge, and thirdly, this growth must be sustainable and not mean short-term exploitation.

The federal government will do everything it can to ensure that we continue to achieve success in international negotiations on resource conservation, environmental protection, and climate protection, even though the current focus of the world is much more on overcoming the crisis first.

In this context, the question of energy production is of great importance. Achieving a sustainable and rapid transition to renewable energy is essential, but for you as employees in energy-intensive sectors, it is also crucial to keep electricity prices affordable – that is the task. We have a lot of work ahead of us together, but especially the federal government, to keep energy prices at a level that prevents companies from relocating outside Europe at the expense of German employees and producing in a more environmentally harmful manner.

We have now established a consensus in Germany on the energy transition and the expansion of our renewable energy system, but we are only at the beginning. If every new construction in the power sector, if every form of energy storage encounters insurmountable difficulties, we will not achieve the energy transition at affordable prices. Therefore, my request to the industrial union metal: Please continue to support us on a reasonable path that reconciles sustainability, affordability, and job security. We must achieve this. Otherwise, a good life in the future will not be possible.

This brings me to another area that is also a core part of your employment: the automotive industry. The question of electromobility and the future of the automotive location in Germany is of existential importance to us for growth and prosperity. Therefore, it is good that we have a National Platform for Electromobility and that we have developed a government program for electromobility. But it is also good that IG Metall has actively contributed to this. I would like to sincerely thank Mr. Huber. He has taken on the important role of coordinator and has taken a risk by sitting down with many business people and a federal government whose alignment with your interests is not always clear. Thank you for doing that. I believe we have made good progress.

Let us continue to address problems together in the coming years, to talk to each other, and to maintain the dialogue. Thank you to all of you who provide us with valuable insights from your experience in companies, with your participation in global developments, as many of you also work internationally, on what secures our prosperity in Germany as a whole. I cannot promise you that we will always agree, but we should always see ourselves as partners on a common path.

When the Federal Republic was founded, there were about 2.5 billion people in the world. Today, seven billion people live in the world. Germany has a population share of just under 1.2 percent worldwide, while the European Union accounts for at least over seven percent. With these seven percent of the world's population, we still produce around 30 percent of global economic output today. This shows how important Europe is. We have relatively common ideas in Europe about what a social market economy means: prosperity for as many as possible. If we do not stick together, if we do not strive to walk our path together, we will fail. I do not want that. I believe we have every reason to work together for a good life tomorrow.