Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the celebration "60 Years of the Federal Constitutional Court" on September 28, 2011, in Karlsruhe:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

28 September 2011 · Celebration "60 Years of the Federal Constitutional Court" · Karlsruhe, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 60th anniversary celebration of the Federal Constitutional Court on September 28, 2011, in Karlsruhe, honoring its role as guardian of the Basic Law.
Main themes
Federal Constitutional Court anniversary, rule of law, Basic Law, constitutional supremacy, fundamental rights, freedom of expression, separation of powers, judicial independence, democratic governance, German constitutional history, Lüth ruling, checks and balances
Duration
~11 min
38th percentile
Words
1,290
38th percentile
Sentences
70
46th percentile
Readability
39
33rd percentile
Grade
12.3
49th percentile
Syntax
2.83
26th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
52nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 79%79%
  • Ceremonial 19%19%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

70 sentences in 23 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Federal President,

dear Mr. President of the Bundestag,

dear Mr. President of the Federal Constitutional Court,

dear Mr. Vice President,

dear Ministers-President,

dear Mr. Lord Mayor of Karlsruhe,

dear judges,

dear colleagues from the parliaments,

and now I simply say: esteemed guests,

Pope Benedict XVI addressed no lesser question in his speech last week in the German Bundestag than what constitutes the foundation of a rule of law. He emphasized that political success is subordinate to the standard of justice, the will to uphold the law, and the understanding of the law.

Yes, this form of political humility, this rejection of a claim to political omnipotence, is not only worthy of a democratic rule of law, but it is also indispensable. Paying attention to this in the concrete interpretation and jurisprudence is the great merit of the guardians of our Basic Law.

Today we celebrate the 60th birthday of a constitutional organ, without whose lived independence our republic would be a different one. We celebrate the birthday of a constitutional organ that has shaped our democratic community for 60 years – not only through its decisions in constitutional law but also through its impulses for the further development of the law. We celebrate the birthday of a constitutional organ that, in light of the failure of the Weimar Republic, holds an extraordinarily strong position within the constitutional framework.

The fathers and mothers of the Basic Law assigned a guardian function to the Federal Constitutional Court. In doing so, they sent a clear signal for a new beginning as a rule of law that lives up to its name. For it was the contempt for the law that preceded the unspeakable horrors of Nazi tyranny. Thus, the creators of our constitution drew two central lessons from history: law before power and effective control of power through the law.

As a consequence, the Federal Constitutional Court received its extensive competencies. The young democracy in Germany had found a reliable backbone. The court resolutely took on its role as the guarantor of constitutional supremacy. This was particularly evident in the so-called and much-cited Lüth ruling of 1958. With it, the Federal Constitutional Court underscored the fundamental importance of fundamental rights. According to this ruling, the Basic Law constitutes an objective value order that radiates into all areas of law and must therefore be observed by every court of instance; every norm must be interpreted in the spirit of fundamental rights. On the other hand, the Federal Constitutional Court elevated the fundamental right to freedom of expression to – I quote – "the foundation of all freedom whatsoever."

This may seem self-evident to us today, but at that time it was not self-evident. For the ruling came at a time when Germans looked, partly in admiration but partly also in wonder, if not even skepticism, at places like Speakers' Corner in London, the place in London's Hyde Park where, since a parliamentary resolution in 1872, anyone can give a talk on any topic without registration – except about the Queen and the royal family.

The Lüth ruling on the fundamental right to freedom of expression was thus decisive and pioneering for the liberal development of Germany. Also due to such impulses, the Federal Constitutional Court enjoys great trust among the citizens. They see it as a guarantor of objectivity, which can also be uncomfortable – especially for politics. Thus, the decisions of the Federal Constitutional Court can, on the one hand, clarify the limits of legislative discretion, and sometimes they even impose absolute limits. An example of this is the decision on the Air Security Act from 2006. On the other hand, the Federal Constitutional Court can also describe the leeway of the legislator. In this way, the words of the judges open up new legislative options.

However, the Federal Constitutional Court also speaks where it remains silent in its results. By exercising judicial restraint, it points to the core competencies of other constitutional organs. What the Federal Constitutional Court decides and how it decides thus affects politics in many ways. That one or another report from Karlsruhe can stir emotions in Berlin or in the state capitals is, I believe, part of the nature of things. The judges of the U.S. Supreme Court, so to speak the American sister of the Federal Constitutional Court, have once been described as "nine scorpions in a bottle." As an outsider, I cannot ultimately judge whether this assessment is truly accurate; but to stay with the image: the stings of the scorpions sometimes also hit the other constitutional organs.

Power can and will therefore be curtailed. That is what fundamentally characterizes our democratic rule of law. That is why people trust it.

The Federal Constitutional Court is solely committed to the standards of the Basic Law. Nevertheless, in the past, the question has sometimes arisen: Where does the Federal Constitutional Court derive its own extensive legitimacy in relation to the democratically legitimized legislator? Some democracies have structured the relationship between legislation and judiciary somewhat differently. But I allow myself to state here today: The court has succeeded in managing this tension between legislation and judiciary, as it is often simply referred to with respectful conciseness. Its role in the framework of the Basic Law is beyond all doubt. Its independence has justified itself in the best sense.

Every constitutional organ has its tasks to fulfill: government and parliament in political design, the judges in Karlsruhe as guardians and interpreters of our constitution. There are also sufficiently current reasons to talk about this. For we see that there are always very exciting constellations between the constitutional organs – increasingly also with regard to European integration. In this context, the Federal Constitutional Court has comparatively clearly defined the immutable essential characteristics of our nation-state. Currently, politics is rarely utilizing the leeway provided by the Basic Law as never before, in order to meet the expectations from our partners in Europe and in the world, which Germany faces, while also working on the basis of the Basic Law.

What I can say as the German Chancellor, given 60 years of experience with the Federal Constitutional Court, is this: We will certainly continue to make compromises in our daily political life in Europe and in the world as well as at home – even arduous compromises, where in the end the advantages outweigh the disadvantages. But there can be no compromises when the foundations of the understanding of democracy, as prescribed by the democratic principle in the Basic Law, are called into question. This applies especially to the outstanding position of the German parliament. Even if it may take a few days longer for a parliamentary decision to be made, there can be no concessions and no automatism at this point. We must make this clear everywhere. We owe it to the Basic Law. And the Federal Constitutional Court has reminded us of this, should we have forgotten it.

All constitutional organs share the common responsibility for our free community, the structure and statics of which are defined by our Basic Law. We share the common responsibility for the common good. In this repeatedly proven unity lies the key to our ability to look back with pride and look forward with good hope and say: Yes, our state is in good shape.

Current and former judges of the Federal Constitutional Court have excellently shouldered their share of this great responsibility. For this, I would like to express my heartfelt thanks. Today's celebration underscores the great respect you enjoy. So I warmly congratulate you on the anniversary and wish you and our country much success in your further work for the benefit of our lived rule of law and democracy.