Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the 34th Bavarian Economic Conference of the Association of Bavarian Business on July 9, 2013, in Munich:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

9 July 2013 · 34th Bavarian Economic Conference of the Association of Bavarian Business · Munich, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 34th Bavarian Economic Conference in Munich on July 9, 2013, speaking on Bavaria's economic strength and European fiscal policy.
Main themes
Bavarian economy and competitiveness, European debt crisis and fiscal consolidation, structural reforms, growth and entrepreneurship, eurozone stability, German-European economic interdependence, Fiscal Compact, state investment vs. private sector growth, global competition, competitiveness parameters
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,683
83rd percentile
Sentences
216
91st percentile
Readability
50
62nd percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
2.79
21st percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
15th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 61%61%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Environmental 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

216 sentences in 40 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Gaffal,

dear Mr. Rodenstock,

dear Mr. Brossardt,

dear Deputy Prime Minister Zeil – I have not yet seen the group leader Ms. Stewens; if she is here, I would like to greet her –, dear colleagues from the parliaments, ladies and gentlemen,

I am pleased to be here as a guest once again today. Normally, I am only a guest in this room during the Security Conference, but I am very happy to be here this evening as well.

Bavaria – one can certainly say this; and especially in Munich – is known to people almost everywhere in the world. If you ask in some regions of the world what is associated with Germany, you often hear answers that refer to Bavaria. Bavaria can hold its own in the world. The quality of the Bavarian economy contributes to this.

The Bavarian industry generated over half of its revenue abroad last year. This was even above the high federal average of nearly 47 percent. This means: You are connected to the world in the truest sense of the word. But it also shows that you must struggle daily for competitiveness, that you must measure yourself against the best in the world, which also has the advantage that you know what is happening in the world. There are several countries that have very low export rates and therefore cannot experience the dynamics of global competition. This is indeed a problem in our European discussions.

The high competitiveness of the Bavarian economy is, of course, also a topic that concerns the Association of Bavarian Business. It is a well-heard voice. I have just been informed again about the issues that particularly concern you. It is good that we have the opportunity to talk about this this evening. It is indeed extraordinarily important for the prosperity of our entire country that the economy is strong not only in Bavaria.

“Strong Bavaria – strong Europe” – under this motto, you succinctly summarize two things.

On the one hand, Europe’s regions are economically closely interconnected. Hence my conviction: Germany will only thrive in the long term if Europe thrives as well. We can only be strong together if, above all, everyone first makes every effort to be strong themselves.

On the other hand, every member of the European Union bears responsibility in our European community of fate. This means, on the one hand, consolidating public budgets and, on the other hand, implementing structural reforms. This has played a significant role in this legislative period. We have achieved quite a bit.

The word “austerity” is often thrown around. That is not what it is about. By the way, I had not even known the word “austerity” before the European debt crisis. Back then, people spoke of balanced, sound budgets, but not of austerity. It is about nothing more and nothing less than adhering to the stability pact we have set for ourselves and making it more binding. That is why we have introduced the Fiscal Compact in all Euro countries and, beyond that, in many other countries as well. It is also about implementing structural reforms. Because budget consolidation is a necessary but not sufficient condition to truly become competitive. Efficient state structures, sensible structural reforms in the labor market, and in many other areas must also be added. The issue of privatization also plays a role in many countries in Europe.

When we talk about growth in Europe, I repeatedly experience among my colleagues in the European Council that it is often associated with the statement: Growth can only occur if there are additional state investments. I believe that this is far too one-sided a perspective. Of course, state investments are part of it. But the real driving force of growth comes from a strong and efficient economy that creates jobs – from a good collaboration between companies and employees. Ultimately, growth arises from this.

As politicians, we can do a lot; we can regulate many things by law. But what we cannot do is compel people to want to take action. Entrepreneurs are people who have an idea, who develop a product, who bring it to market, who take a risk, who do not know if they will have enough customers. Promoting entrepreneurial spirit means creating an environment in which trust is built and in which working opportunities and conditions are designed so that one can compete globally.

Because we in the European Union and in the European Council among the heads of state and government do not yet have a common understanding of what the decisive parameters for growth and competitiveness are, we will now – as I have agreed with French President Hollande – discuss until October which parameters are crucial to improve competitiveness in the individual countries so that we can work towards this in Europe in a targeted manner. Because we have now understood: Those who work and live in a common currency union must strive for more than just budget consolidation; they must also have a comparably competitive position. This does not mean that every country should be the same. But it does mean that every country can compete with other providers in the world in the area where its value creation is located.

The European Union, with its 500 million inhabitants, accounts for about seven percent of the world’s population. We have a value creation of about 25 percent of the world’s gross domestic product. We bear over 40 percent of global social expenditures. If we want to maintain this ratio, if we want to finance far more than 40 percent of social expenditures with nearly 25 percent and at the same time want to have sound budgets – and that on a continent that is very much subject to demographic change – then we must be innovative; we must also have a working environment in which we can compete with other competitors. Moreover, considering that the growth regions of the world are mainly outside Europe, that in normal economic times 90 percent of global growth occurs outside Europe, one realizes that growth in Europe can only take place if the competitiveness of European providers is truly given. Working towards this will be our next major project after the introduction of the Fiscal Compact and the banking union, which we are currently building.

A word about the situation in the Euro countries that are facing difficulties. They have largely undertaken structural reforms and are working on budget consolidation, with some successes. However, we primarily have a phenomenon that is currently throttling economic growth. This is the fact that despite structural reforms, lending to small, medium, and even large companies in the affected countries is extremely difficult, or the interest rates are very high, which partially negates the effect of lowering labor costs and unit labor costs.

What is the reason for this? Ultimately, it is because investors do not have confidence in a large number of European banks, so they do not invest, and because banks, partly due to high debt, first buy government bonds, believing they are on the safer side, and do not invest in companies. This is again a reason for budget consolidation. Therefore, we have decided to establish a central banking supervision in Europe that will create more trust. I believe this is not necessarily a project that is of central importance for Germany, as international investors have confidence in our supervisory authority, which they do not have in many areas of European banks. This trust must be established to improve lending and thus also increase the chances for economic growth. We as the federal government – Wolfgang Schäuble together with Philipp Rösler – have offered assistance through the KfW Bank to initiate lending programs specifically for small and medium-sized enterprises in Portugal, Spain, and probably also in Greece.

We have a second phenomenon. We have very high youth unemployment. This is partly due to the fact that labor law has been made more flexible, especially for young people. Whenever economic downturns occur, young people are the first to become unemployed, while those who have been employed longer still have job opportunities. If we want to do something about youth unemployment, it is important that not only incentives, for example through wage support for companies that provide training opportunities for young people, are set, but that these companies also have access to loans. Therefore, such incentives should also be combined with German assistance in the fight against youth unemployment alongside activities of the European Investment Bank.

The fight against youth unemployment must, however, primarily take place at the operational level. Large state programs can at best be a small bridge. We know from the time after German reunification that it is very important to strengthen training in companies, especially. I would also like to take this opportunity to thank the Bavarian economy. Our dual education system is currently also achieving triumphs outside Germany. It took a long time for the quality of this education system to be recognized. It is also good if we give young Europeans opportunities to complete their training in our companies or strengthen dual education in other countries. The Federal Employment Agency supports language courses. We are very interested in giving as many people as possible a chance.

Another growth program could be a transatlantic trade and investment agreement. Negotiations began yesterday. However, I also say: I am pleased that the negotiations are running parallel to discussions on data protection issues. Because this is a very sensitive topic for us in Germany, but also in Europe. If trust is to grow, both must proceed in parallel. It was important to me that the transatlantic trade talks begin as agreed. Because from all free trade agreements, we know that they ultimately brought growth. Especially the two largest markets could become a truly important free trade zone.

Germany is currently in a relatively good position compared to others. But we know that we must continue to work. Therefore, the topics you have raised are of course also our topics. I want to address them.

The first topic concerns the tax environment. Here it is such that we – when I say “we,” I am speaking as Chancellor for the Christian-Liberal Coalition – are against any form of tax increases. Why? We are against them because we are operating in a fragile economic environment, because we have an excellent employment situation, but any economic uncertainty, especially in the medium-sized sector, could lead to a deterioration of this employment situation and consequently a decline in tax revenues. Then we would have the opposite effect. It can very easily happen that tax increases create such great uncertainty that in the end we have less tax revenue than without a tax increase. Since we have experienced in recent years that tax revenues have developed very well, we say: We want to continue on this path, give no cause for uncertainty, but rather, where it is possible considering the necessary budget consolidation, offer further small reliefs.

This legislative period was initially marked by the international financial and economic crisis. You remember: The economic downturn in Germany amounted to over five percent. We had implemented intelligent economic stimulus programs – short-time work, municipal investment programs, scrappage bonuses. However, this significantly increased state borrowing, so that we started this legislative period with a structural deficit of around 50 billion euros in the 2010 budget. Nevertheless, we made tax cuts – improvements in inheritance and corporate tax – which were not possible in the Grand Coalition. We increased the child allowance and child benefit. We did everything to promote domestic demand. We were able to present a budget plan for 2014 two weeks ago, according to which the structural new borrowing will be zero at the beginning of the new legislative period instead of 50 billion euros, and the cyclical-related new borrowing will be 6.2 billion euros, of which 4.7 billion euros are intended for contributions to the European Stability Mechanism.

We have implemented tax cuts and at the same time invested over 13 billion euros more in research and education. We have taken over the basic security from the municipalities amounting to around four billion euros annually and will take another step forward next year. We have improved the education package for the long-term unemployed. We have invested more in infrastructure. In this current period, where we have had growing real wages again after a long time, we would have liked to curb cold progression. We would have liked to return the additional tax revenues from cold progression to the employees. The Social Democrats and the Greens – I do not want to polemicize here, but I must present the facts – have rejected this, even though the federal government would have covered all revenue losses – except for those that are constitutionally mandated by the increase in the basic tax allowance. One must really ask what this means for the employees. I did not understand it.

To immediately address your second topic: We have also said that we would like to promote building renovation through tax incentives. Although there was support for this from economic to environmental associations across Germany, there was no way forward there either. This would have been another major stimulus program and would have provided support for the issue of energy efficiency.

In the next legislative period, we will try to continue working on some points. But we have set the goal of budget consolidation at the very top of our agenda. The federal government has been meeting the debt brake requirement since 2012, which we were actually supposed to meet only from 2016 onwards. We are sometimes accused of being able to consolidate much more. To that, I say: We also have an international and European responsibility. At the moment, our modest growth this year, which will likely be around 0.4 percent or a similar percentage, is largely due to domestic demand. We have a very difficult export situation in the European context. If we want to help other countries import better from Germany, it makes sense to support domestic demand here. Therefore, what we currently have in Germany is a fairly good balance.

The next point is the energy transition. Here, it is indeed the case that we have a large task package ahead of us at the beginning of the next legislative period. So far, there has been no willingness from the states to change the Renewable Energy Sources Act. However, due to the massive expansion of renewable energies, there have been significant price increases in the energy levy that need to be curbed. I believe that we could best achieve this by combining the incentives for the expansion of renewable energies with increasing responsibility for grid expansion and for storage or base-load capable power plants. In this combination, we could achieve something good. We have experienced an explosive expansion of photovoltaics. This shows how difficult it is for states to set subsidies or fees in advance when they cannot accurately predict research and technology development.

Today, we can generate around 30 gigawatts of photovoltaic power in Germany. We have installed over 25 gigawatts of wind energy. On normal days, we need a capacity of 65 to 70 gigawatts. When wind and sun are available – which they usually are in parallel – we therefore need almost no base load. When both are not available, we need a backup with very high base-load capability.

We have made relatively good progress in expanding the grid. I am familiar with the Grafenrheinfeld issue. We actually discuss the Thuringian power bridge every four weeks and regularly at meetings with the prime ministers. The Federal Administrative Court – that is the good news – processes the lawsuits, which do not have to go through all instances and which concern the projects according to the Energy Line Expansion Act, within three months. If everything takes place with great concentration, we can achieve this. Bavaria is counting on this, Thuringia is counting on this. The federal government is keeping a close eye on it; we are not responsible, but we are aware of the strategic importance of this issue.

In cooperation between the federal and state governments, we have achieved that for the expansion of direct current lines, the large overhead lines, the federal government has planning rights. This has minimized the difficulties of cross-state planning. The Federal Network Agency will deal with this. In this respect, progress has also been made here. But the Renewable Energy Sources Act remains the major task at the beginning of the next legislative period.

The next point you raised was labor costs and the entire working environment. I want to make it clear: I still stand by the Agenda 2010. I cannot help it if those who introduced it no longer love it. I am not responsible for that. Since much of the Agenda 2010 was also the intellectual property of the Union and the FDP – it began in 1996 with the first Schäuble proposals – the topic was not foreign to us. Therefore, we will stick to it.

We will not undermine the pension at 67 in 2029. There is no point in burying our heads in the sand now, only to have to tell a generation one day that a major break is taking place. We must create a continuous transition. We can say that the employment of older workers has increased significantly in recent years, just as the employment of women has. Both are part of the fact that we have such a good employment situation today.

Temporary work should remain as a flexibility instrument. I believe there are also collective agreements that are very reasonable. Therefore, we do not need to interfere further at this point. With regard to contract work, there is no general attack. We just need to observe some things. If we are honest with each other, we must see that, for example, Industry 4.0 will massively change the world of work. This massive change will also have consequences for certain types of employment. I believe that we need the flexibility instrument of contract work. But we will also keep an eye on whether there is any abuse in this regard. However, there are currently no regulatory intentions in our programs.

The next point is the minimum wage. I am against a minimum wage being politically agreed upon. I believe this would also be very dangerous. The 8.50 euros that we are now hearing make sense to many. This is not an issue for many companies in the Bavarian economy. But the idea that, depending on the interests, politics decides on further wage increases is wrong. I also find it detrimental to collective bargaining autonomy. Collective bargaining autonomy has proven itself to a high degree in Germany. It is one of the great strengths of our economy. However, it must be said: A look at the collective bargaining landscape shows that it no longer represents the majority in terms of wage conditions today – especially not in the new federal states. In the old federal states, it is much more present in the industrial sector than in the service sectors. This does indeed create a responsibility for politics.

Now I will speak for the Union – I do not want to completely co-opt the FDP here, but I believe we will also talk about this if we have the chance to continue the coalition –; we say: minimum wages should be regulated through collective agreements. We simply need to look at the white spots in the collective bargaining landscape and then create incentives for the bargaining partners to reach agreements with each other. I believe this is the way that also accommodates trade unions and various corporate structures. We should pursue this.

Regarding the working environment, we also have the task of strengthening our research and innovation landscape. When this goes well, it usually does not come to the fore. In Germany, we are currently spending around 2.9 percent of our gross domestic product on research and development – from both the business and state sides. Some countries in Europe, on the other hand, are below one percent, even though research and development is an incredibly important factor for competitiveness.

We must strengthen our dual education system. We have a slight tendency towards academicization. Currently, 50 percent of young people begin a higher education. This is encouraging, but we must be careful that a two-class society does not emerge. Dual education in Germany is one of our great strengths. We must not allow ourselves to export it to Europe while weakening it at home.

Since we also want to have time for discussion, I will simply conclude my speech here and say only this: We have successfully overcome the very crisis-ridden situations since 2008. In this, alongside other measures, the Agenda 2010 played a significant role. The good development and especially the introduced debt brake have shown that one can achieve a lot in the cooperation of the social market economy – politics, businesses, and employees – and also bridge difficult situations. This whole process has a lot to do with trust and cohesion. Therefore, the task in the next legislative period will be to work together with the various groups to create a spirit of togetherness.

At the beginning of this century, around the year 2000, we were considered the sick man of Europe. The member of parliament Ernst Hinsken carried a red lantern around in the German Bundestag at that time. We have shown that one can really make progress within ten years, which was not always easy. But I am deeply convinced that it is good that Germany has undertaken reforms to be a stability anchor in Europe today. I am also deeply convinced that Germany cannot stand still, otherwise others will overtake us again. You have seen this in the example of unit labor costs in other European countries. Therefore, there is still much to be done and discussed together.