Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the 35th Ordinary General Assembly of the German Association of Cities on May 13, 2009, in Bochum:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

15 May 2009 · 35th Ordinary General Assembly of the German Association of Cities · Bochum, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 35th General Assembly of the German Association of Cities in Bochum on May 13, 2009, discussing federalism, the economic crisis, and municipal cooperation.
Main themes
Federalism and municipal governance, economic crisis and stimulus measures, education investment, trade tax revenues and fiscal challenges, 60th anniversary of the Federal Republic of Germany, federal-municipal cooperation, infrastructure spending, Germany as export nation, social stability and balance of power
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,299
88th percentile
Sentences
237
92nd percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
9.8
18th percentile
Syntax
2.85
27th percentile
Vocabulary
1.92
4th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 51%51%
  • Institutional 23%23%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

237 sentences in 47 paragraphs

Dear Mr. President, dear Mr. Ude,

dear participants of this great German City Day!

I just said that it is almost like the Chinese People's Congress here, as far as the presidency is concerned. That has probably been said before me as well. However, Mr. Ude's speaking time made up for that. I bring you the warm greetings of the entire Federal Government. We hurried through the Cabinet meeting so that I could be here on time.

Please allow me to extend my heartfelt congratulations to the Mayor of Frankfurt on her birthday, albeit belatedly. All the best and continued good work in the spirit of the City Day!

We are in Bochum today. I would also like to warmly greet the Mayor on behalf of those who are engaged in municipal responsibilities.

We are in a year of anniversaries. This year, we celebrate 60 years of the Federal Republic of Germany and 60 years of the Basic Law. This Basic Law expresses that we are a federal state in which municipalities play an important and indispensable role. The fact that this Basic Law, although once planned as a provisional arrangement, has proven to be an extraordinarily successful constitution is also due to the fact that the various levels in our country – federal, state, and municipal – have traditionally worked well together.

Sometimes things take a little longer than one would wish. It is sometimes a bit more complicated in Germany than in other countries, where there are different structures. But what distinguishes us in the Federal Republic of Germany is that what has been decided and agreed upon together guarantees a high degree of stability for the entire country. This is something that the people in this country have repeatedly benefited from – social peace and a good balance of power.

Federalism is so successful because it is ultimately a competition for the best ideas, allows regional diversity to come to the fore, and yet has mechanisms to ensure equivalent living conditions in Germany. Therefore, I would like to say: We will celebrate 60 years of the Federal Republic of Germany on May 23, with an awareness of the great contribution that cities and municipalities have made to the success of this Federal Republic of Germany.

Mr. Ude, I would also like to emphasize that the German City Day is a reliable partner of the Federal Government. This does not exclude – I will come back to this – that there are individual points where we still need to work further. But overall, we can rely on each other. I believe this has been particularly evident now in this economic crisis, stemming from an international financial market crisis.

In the hours, days, weeks, and months in which we had to decide on meaningful measures to emerge from the crisis as strengthened as possible, we managed to set aside different responsibilities to meet the overall goal and achieve the best for our country as a whole. Therefore, the topic of infrastructure measures in the second stimulus package was not a matter where the federal government desperately tried to expand one federal project after another, but we said: It would really be the most sensible thing to invest in the future of our country now.

I believe we are almost all in agreement that the topic of education, the topic of universities and universities of applied sciences means a future for our country. Therefore, we said: Two-thirds of the relevant 13 billion euro program should be invested in education. Where can this be best and, above all, most quickly implemented? Where is the best knowledge? In the cities and municipalities. Therefore, there is a piece of hope from our side that you will implement this quickly, that you will bring it correctly to the man, the woman, and the child, and that people will see that we are standing up to this crisis. I would like to express my heartfelt thanks for the cooperation in this area! Since I have already seen Mr. Wowereit, I may also extend my thanks to the states that have, of course, worked very closely with us in this context.

However, this program must not obscure the fact that the crisis we are currently going through is a manifest one, that it particularly affects a country like Germany. What is our opportunity as an export nation in times of a booming world economy is, of course, now becoming a problem in times of nonexistent global export opportunities. Thus, all federal levels are facing extraordinarily difficult times.

I looked at it again today: The trade tax revenues of recent years were characterized by a success curve. In 2002, there was a low point after the crisis at the beginning of the century: 23.5 billion euros in revenue. In 2008, it was about 42 billion euros in revenue – so an increase. This does not mean that it was evenly distributed among the cities. But it does mean that they, like the federal and state governments, had opportunities to develop into the future. But now we will also see a significant decline in trade tax revenues with a projected minus six percent in gross domestic product.

Tomorrow we will be confronted with the tax estimate. What I can assure you today is that we will not yield to any pressure when it comes to the question of whether we will touch the trade tax revenues. We will not do that. I would even say: on the contrary. We will do everything we can to mitigate the procyclical effects that exist with the corporate tax reform and the procyclical effects regarding banks due to Basel II. It is not only important that we do not change the law. If you are so affected by the interest barrier and loss carryforwards and similar issues that the trade tax revenues effectively decline, that does not help you much. We do not have a simple political discussion here, as you can imagine. We currently have many problems to solve. But we will, in some areas – I am at least hopeful – still make smaller changes to the corporate tax reform during this legislative period. And we will do everything at the European level to achieve relaxations regarding Basel II to mitigate the procyclical effects on certain sectors.

I say it very clearly to those who also have contacts across Europe: This is an infinitely thick board that needs to be drilled. It is very difficult to see how the rating, the credit volumes, and Basel II are interconnected. Committees need to be consulted, guidelines need to be changed, and so on. I say: If the cards are reshuffled in this crisis – and they will be – then it is not okay for Europe to adhere to all the rules, to suffer all procyclical measures, while in the United States of America Basel II has not even been introduced and many loose relationships in the area of money still exist.

At this point, I would like to briefly address another important question: How quickly can we recover economically? How quickly will tax revenues get back on track? How quickly will our banks get back on their feet?

Today, we made a decision in the Cabinet that, on the one hand, allows private banks and state banks to outsource so-called structured products under certain conditions. But we also adopted a framework paper that is intended to create the legal conditions for state banks to be able to outsource certain products beyond the so-called structured products. However, this is a very complicated legal matter. Therefore, we have not yet managed to implement it legally today.

I know that you have made a decision here today regarding the relationship between savings banks and state banks. Allow me to express the commitment that has spread far into the Bundestag factions about how important savings banks are, how well they act as stabilizers in this crisis, and that we will do everything to ensure the preservation of savings banks, to enable it, and not to create additional difficulties.

However, I have a request. I will say it very kindly now. I ask that you do not completely lose sight of – without me mentioning vertical integration or such things – that savings banks have shares in state banks. This is simply a legal state. This can be nice or not nice from various perspectives. But we cannot completely dismiss it. Therefore, we must find solutions that do not endanger the savings banks, but on the other hand cannot ignore that there are state banks in which savings banks have significant shares. This means that both must be considered together. It has not always been successful for the interests of savings banks to be immediately obvious with those of state banks, even though they are common owners. We are working on it. We are helping. We want to find a good solution.

Overall, we know that we only established the rescue programs for banks because we want to keep the economy running, because we want to secure people's savings deposits. Therefore, we will not burden one pillar of the banking system in such a way that it can no longer function, which is already working. Common sense tells us that. But still, we must also demand a willingness to cooperate from all sides. That is my request at this point.

It is not easy to suddenly talk about state banks from the federal level all the time. The colleagues in the German Bundestag ask: "What do we have to do with this? There are already enough things to regulate here." Then one must respond: "Because we are all interconnected, because we are a federal country, because our well-being depends on the behavior of all. Therefore, we want to seek a good solution here." Today's Cabinet decision was already directed in the right direction.

At the moment, we fundamentally need the economic activity of state banks. They will be subjected to significant restructuring requirements. But do not delude yourselves, there is currently no international bank willing to grant further long-term loans aimed at larger projects in Germany. If we want to build bridges for the real economy, as it is so nicely called today, it will be essential that financing is provided by state banks. This means that a failure of the state bank is a failure for the entire German economy.

It can be quickly said in theory: Why not merge into a bank of the German states? We are experiencing something similar with Dresdner Bank and Commerzbank. If they merge, the credit volume does not increase, but rather decreases. If risks are added, it becomes even more difficult. This means that "bashing" state banks is easy. But it is not good for Germany. Therefore, we are all in the same boat.

Indeed, very, very difficult years lie ahead of us. I advocate that we approach this crisis, into which we have fallen for international reasons, together in such a way that we do not think at the moment we reach the low point: Now the crisis is overcome. There will be another part of crisis management. It will extend far beyond the next year.

We are experiencing a very strong downturn. We have an economic forecast of minus six percent. If we look at the end of the first quarter, we have already reached minus 5.5 percent for this year with the so-called statistical overhang of the first quarter of 2008 of minus 3.5 percent. This means that if the forecast remains at minus six percent for the entire year, we have already reached the low point. I cannot make a statement to the exact percentage. But this low point – some indicators suggest this – is already there in terms of growth. However, it is not clear how the curve will look when we come out of this crisis. Unfortunately, it will not correspond to a "V." That would still be acceptable, because then we could say: 2008 started to go down, 2009 we are in the valley, 2010 everything goes back up, and by the end of 2010 it is as it was in 2008. However, there is currently little to support that, at least no one is talking about it. This means we will have the course of a low point. Then the question arises as to how steep the ascent will be.

As the wisdom in the downturn consisted of launching certain programs, the entire political wisdom must now consist of promoting the upswing as much as possible through state support. This means that we are not yet at the end of considering how we can achieve growth again. There will be other necessities. For example, when we talk to countries about science pacts and promoting excellence, this is even more necessary in the crisis than before the crisis. We need security, we need predictability. Therefore, the federal government will not hold long debates at the conference of ministers-president about whether we can make budget commitments for the next six years or not, but we will say: Our common political will from the federal and state levels is to promote education, research, and innovation in such a way that we can emerge from the crisis stronger than we entered it.

When I recently visited the Hannover Messe with the Prime Minister of South Korea, I first became aware that Korea will not spend three percent of its gross domestic product on research and innovation in 2012, but five percent. There are many countries in the world that are, of course, also ready to go. When we look at the stimulus programs of other countries, it is not guaranteed that we will emerge as the strongest again with the strengths we have today; we have to work for that. That is why we have also invested in innovations in the automotive industry. That is why – I keep saying this – Germany will face the great challenge of treating everything related to innovation well and not standing on the sidelines being picky and asking: Is it too difficult or not too difficult? We really have to seize the opportunities. I know how much depends on the local decision-makers when they are asked and approached about how to make technological progress.

In connection with the Federalism Reform II, we made a second important decision. The so-called debt brake is not to everyone's liking. But it is absolutely right in the medium term for the next decade.

How did this crisis arise? This crisis essentially arose internationally. Germany was not at the forefront, but we were not completely outside when we look at the problem. The Anglo-Saxon world was certainly at the forefront. The crisis arose because it was also politically tolerated to live beyond one's means. After September 11, 2001, everything was done to maintain economic growth, also in light of the Asian crisis – the shock at the end of the 1990s – and thus to take high risks in the financial markets, to have too much money, and to grant loans under risk conditions that were not responsible.

When I look at the problems we will face in connection with the crisis regarding unemployment, issues of justice, and the understanding of the people that we had to provide 400 billion euros in guarantees for the banks, 80 billion euros in capital, and much more, I can only say: In the interest of the stability of the Federal Republic of Germany, we must do everything we can to ensure that such a crisis does not happen again. To ensure exactly that, we are acting internationally as we are.

A second point. We must set an example ourselves with changing demographics that we invest in the future. But we must do everything we can to not constantly live beyond our means. The interest on debt is already considerable today. That is about 15 cents of every euro. If we impose all of this on future generations with a declining working population, it will be a very difficult situation.

In this context – the mayors of the large cities know this – the demographic change is not only such that the number of older people is increasing, which we are happy about – keywords: life expectancy, medical possibilities. In addition, the number of younger people will have a higher proportion of children and adolescents with a migration background. This means that the population structure will change. Therefore, the absolute goal must be – the federal government has set important course corrections for this legislative period – that we advance integration. I would like to thank the municipalities! Without them, our National Integration Plan would not be possible at all. They do an incredible amount on the ground. However, we are far from the end of the road; we must continue to strengthen all of this.

If we do not succeed in empowering young migrant children through education policy so that they can become the skilled workers, masters, and engineers of the future, the emigration from Germany will no longer be determined by the question of how high the corporate tax rate is – which is now somewhat attractive internationally – but by the question of what the skilled labor situation is. We actually need everyone here to contribute to prosperity. Otherwise, we will find ourselves in an incredible situation in the next decade regarding the security of social security systems.

We know that our systems are very stable. But we also know: They must be financed sustainably. We have experienced in the three years of growth in this legislative period that growth and more employment automatically relieve the pressure on social security systems and that any form of downward development in employment presents us with major problems again. Therefore, my credo is: We should not pretend that the bottom has already been reached, but we must carefully consider how we can create growth for the coming years. I hope for your support in this.

To address a topic that has also played a role here: I know that you are not satisfied with the federal government and the German Bundestag regarding the fact that there will be no solution in the area of job placement and job centers in the foreseeable future. I could take the easy way out and say: If the municipal associations were ever in agreement on this matter, the chances of us finding a solution at the other level of federalism would be much better.

I cannot promise you here that we will find a solution before the federal elections that will apply beyond 2010. The Federal Minister of Labor has indicated and guaranteed the extension of the situation until 2010. I know that this is not a satisfactory statement for many affected individuals. But I ask you, along with the assurance that we will tackle this with all our energy after the federal elections. Let us try to make the best of the situation! We could spend the entire election campaign and the months insulting each other, but that ultimately does not help us. I am aware of your difficulties. But I also tell you: The constructs that were found were not trivial either. If the Federalism Reform states in great friendship that we will never again have mixed administration, only to then make a constitutional amendment in which one point decides exactly the opposite, one should see that this raises at least question marks from a legal perspective.

On the other hand, you are practitioners. You have the people, you have the employees, you want motivated mediators. But the differing opinion on whether placement should be a task of the Federal Employment Agency or a task that is handled locally – I only mention the keyword "option municipalities" – is something that has accompanied us since the beginning of this Hartz IV regulation and has never really let us go. That is the problem. Therefore, we will do everything to bring calm to this question. There are ideas. However, we will not be able to implement them anymore. We will take them up again immediately after the federal elections and will find a satisfactory solution. Mr. Ude, if one day you came to me and said that the District Association and the City Association had agreed on how this should look, I would jump for joy or buy you a beer or do something like that.

We want to continue to work together in many areas. I have talked about education. In recent years, the issue of improving the situation of childcare places for children under three has been an important project. Here too, we will have to work hard in the coming years to ensure that we do not end up with the places but no educators. We must work together on this issue. That is why I have discussed with the responsible ministers in the federal cabinet that we now try to design retraining measures in this crisis so that they lead to future-proof professions.

We have a very, very difficult situation, especially with temporary and agency work. If we could give interested people a perspective in care and childcare professions, those would be secure jobs. We would not find ourselves one day again facing a shortage of skilled workers.

I believe that we have excellent initiatives in many areas regarding the compatibility of family and work. I would like to remind you of the topics that deal with the new city that we will need in the second decade of our century. The topic of multi-generational houses is a model example of how we can show how to promote the cohesion of generations.

These are the topics we need to address together. Difficult months lie ahead of us. It does not help at all to beat around the bush. I know that your leeway in times of crisis to pass budgets, which vary a bit from state to state, is of course significantly more limited than at the federal and state levels. I think this will naturally lead to the need for discussions. We cannot allow things that have been well developed and that express the cohesion of our country to be put at risk.

We have a multitude of federal programs that we will not cut and on which we will not make any reductions. We have also said this for the budget of the next year. It makes no sense to cut in a crisis. I also want to say again that we have received significant praise internationally after initial criticism. With the short-time work regulations, with the non-cutting of all social expenditures, and with the announcement not to reduce wage-related costs, we have managed to keep domestic demand relatively constant so far.

This means nothing more and nothing less than that this will also have an impact on Germany's trade balance, which is expected to change by around 170 billion euros in favor of our importers this year. This means that we are currently in a situation where we cannot export well, but we are a reliable importer for other countries.

This is at least as important for cities and municipalities as other things, such as maintaining purchasing power, maintaining a piece of confidence and trust. Even if this will certainly not become easier in the coming months, we have set this as a firm guideline, just like the preservation of as many jobs as possible.

I think that in the 61st year of the Federal Republic of Germany, it will become even more necessary for municipalities, states, and the federal government to remain in intensive dialogue. We all have great respect for the work you do. We all at the federal level know that how our country continues to develop also depends on how municipalities, states, and the federal government work together. Therefore, I must tell you not only out of self-interest and great respect for your work: We need our cooperation – probably more in the next one or two years than in many times before in the history of the Federal Republic of Germany. One must not forget: This country has experienced negative economic growth multiple times. But the largest that has ever occurred was around minus 0.9 percent. Now we are at minus six percent. We are relatively well prepared due to the last few years. But it will be a dramatic effort.

I say: We have overcome many challenges in the history of the Federal Republic of Germany. Sixty years – this also reminds us of the time when most German cities were still in ruins. We have succeeded. On November 9, we will celebrate the 20th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall. We have managed German unity very well in many areas. But it would be wrong not to see that this anniversary year 2009 also brings significant challenges for us and for the coming years. They are not as visible as after German reunification in the new federal states. They will hit other regions in Germany more strongly.

It is very interesting to look at what is happening now. The export-strong federal states are those in the south. For many decades, they have benefited from this strength and have developed well. Suddenly, they will find themselves in the most difficult situations. For others, less will change. Therefore, national cohesion, if I may say so, will be put to the test in a completely different way. I want us to succeed. I believe we can achieve this together. Therefore, here’s to good cooperation between the German Association of Cities and the Federal Government!