Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Second German Consumer Day on May 12, 2009, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

12 May 2009 · Second German Consumer Day · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Second German Consumer Day in Berlin on May 12, 2009, outlining the federal government's consumer policy priorities.
Main themes
Consumer protection, consumer policy, social market economy, informed and self-determined consumer, product safety, transparency and market information, competition and market regulation, financial products and risks, globalization and technological progress, consumer rights enforcement, balance between state protection and individual autonomy
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,184
78th percentile
Sentences
191
88th percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
2.83
25th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
22nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 45%45%
  • Economic 31%31%
  • Institutional 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

191 sentences in 40 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Rips,

dear Mr. Billen,

dear Mr. Müntefering,

dear Ilse Aigner,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag as well as from the state parliaments, whom I certainly do not want to forget, and above all, ladies and gentlemen,

I am pleased to have accepted your invitation today. Mr. Rips has already referred to our conversation at the Federal Chancellery. I mentioned there that the position of consumer associations and consumers in Germany has become so important that we should make our meeting a recurring event and hold regular discussions at the Federal Chancellery. I consider this important because I believe that consumer policy has reached the center of political responsibility – and rightly so. It is anything but a marginal political issue; rather, it is part of our social policy and thus of significant importance. It is a permanent task and – which sometimes makes it so difficult to grasp – it is also a cross-cutting task. There is probably no person who does not encounter issues of consumer protection in their life. Everyone understands something about it, but not everyone knows how to change things. That is why it is important that you are the voice of consumers and advocate for their concerns.

We all buy and think every day about what decisions we have to make. It is precisely this everydayness and normality that sometimes makes us unaware of the significance of decisions in individual cases, which can then lead to questions and dissatisfaction in the aggregate. – Mr. Rips has just illustrated this with the example of families. – Are the purchased food products really safe? Is the purchased toy actually suitable for the child? Which mobile phone plan best fits my needs?

So questions upon questions. It is often difficult to decide what speaks for a purchase and what speaks against the purchase of a particular good. Many questions are no longer even asked due to a lack of time, as one cannot delve into everything in depth. I have great understanding for the fact that people are increasingly unwilling to take risks and accept the disadvantages of a wrong purchasing decision, especially when it comes to higher price ranges and longer-lasting products. Then good advice is needed, as provided by consumer counseling.

Now one might say: It is a value in itself to have a choice between different product and service alternatives. Competition makes this possible. The globalization of markets, technological progress, and the worldwide possibilities of the Internet open up new spaces. The liberalization of telecommunications and energy supply, as well as the multitude of financial market products, have increased the freedom of choice and often lowered prices. But choice can also become a burden when one feels overwhelmed by the variety of offers – especially when there is a lack of information that is important to the consumer. Then it becomes very difficult to grasp the differences in quality and performance. Lack of transparency often leads to erroneous decisions and sometimes even to exploitation.

This is where it is good that we have consumer policy in our country and that the consumer policy of this federal government has a guiding principle. That is the informed, responsible, and self-determined consumer. I want to give a few examples of this. We want consumers to be able to rely on the technical safety and health harmlessness of products and services. Consumers should be able to assess the opportunities and risks of financial products. We want – and this is of course a central point – that they can actually enforce their rights.

But: Good intentions must not lead to consumers being unable to see the forest for the trees. That is why many consumers reject a forest of behavioral recommendations that creates more confusion or makes them feel more controlled rather than providing clarity. This means that consumer protection and consumer policy are essentially a permanent search for the right balance between consumer self-determination and maturity on the one hand and state protection on the other. This is essentially a classic task that arises from the social market economy: on the one hand, the state as the guardian of order and on the other hand, the citizen who can assert his rights. In the sense that the individual is the measure of our economic order – again in the sense of the social market economy – we want to implement this as well.

So it is not an unrestricted but an orderly competition that is at stake, in which monopolization is prevented and fair prices are ensured. – This is a topic that is currently very much on our minds in connection with milk prices. What is a fair price? This is a very difficult task, as there are certainly many unfair prices at play right now. – It is about an orderly competition that provides incentives to continually create new products to meet the changing needs of those who demand them and have specific interests. In this economic order, which connects freedom and responsibility, performance and justice, the protection of consumers also has its fixed and indispensable place.

Now one might say: That is easy to say, but what have you actually done concretely? Therefore, I want to remind you of some decisions made during this legislative period. We are protecting consumers more reliably from unwanted telemarketing as well as from hidden contracts. We have strengthened the position of consumers as policyholders and initiated better protection in consumer credit contracts. We have also ensured that train passengers can claim compensation for train delays.

I would particularly like to highlight the Consumer Information Act. With it, we have significantly improved access to information about health-endangering and risky products. Consumers now have a right to information from authorities about health hazards, legal violations, and consumer deception. I know that from the perspective of consumer associations, some questions and requests remain open. However, we have already established, keeping in mind that we first need to gather experiences, that the law will be reviewed again after two years, and we will then ask ourselves whether there is a need for further action.

We know that the entire topic of consumer protection is strongly subject to the technological changes in our world. This means that new products are constantly coming onto the market, which is why different information is always required. That is why it is so important that consumers can also inform themselves without great effort, as Mr. Rips has already mentioned.

If we choose labeling as a means of information, our goal must be that it is easy to understand and focused on the essentials, although there is always a comprehensive discussion about this. Personally – this may be related to my increasing age – I repeatedly find that user manuals for technical devices are often very difficult to understand. I have studied physics and think that I am not entirely uneducated. One is glad when one finds the text somewhere in German. When one then has their glasses ready, they can also read the fine print reasonably well. It is good that there are children who intuitively handle all of this, and usually nothing breaks when they practically try out the device.

Especially for seniors, it is important that information is really prepared in a generally understandable form. With aging, the difficulties, as I said, gradually become noticeable. Train stations, the Internet, and shopping centers are full of Anglicisms and neologisms that make life unnecessarily difficult for not only older people. Therefore, providers are called upon to formulate their information clearly, unambiguously, understandably, and in a readable font size. These are actually quite simple things. One wonders why our German language is so rarely used to present simple matters.

It is also in the providers' own interest to pay more attention to the group of older people. They are a group of financially strong and increasingly decisive consumers. Therefore, I believe that we should have our information ready in an age-appropriate manner for all age groups – from the very young to the older ones.

But information alone is, of course, not enough. Because a flood of information does not necessarily make consumers more independent. Often, the opposite is the case: insecurity, confusion, deterrence. That is why the relevance of information and the confident handling of it are so important. When consumers are overwhelmed, the imparting of basic knowledge about the economy and markets, rights and obligations comes into play. Consumer competence is something very important. Children, young people, and also adults must increasingly acquire this competence. Otherwise, there will be no informed consumer.

That is why I find it very important that you simply say here on this Consumer Day: Family in consumer policy is very close to life. Everyday skills and awareness in consumer issues are first conveyed in families. One must also listen to families. You have created a family-friendly situation here on the stage where discussions will take place later.

Schools and educational institutions also play an important role. That is why I explicitly welcome initiatives such as the consumer education internet portal of the Federal Association of Consumer Centers. Here, among other things, teaching materials and modules on topics such as nutrition, health, finance, and media competence are made available. I believe that such positive examples should certainly be more widely adopted, to stay with the metaphor.

As a federal government, we not only want to encourage this but are also actively involved – well aware that consumer education and competence are ultimately not a question of age but concern everyone. Therefore, we have jointly launched the education campaign "Retirement Provision Goes to School" with the vzbv, the German Pension Insurance, adult education centers, and social partners. Especially in retirement provision, there will be more individual contractual relationships between providers and consumers. Understanding the products offered is often not easy. This is about long-term decisions. We want to help here together with our campaign.

Again, it is the case that as effective, important, and indispensable as campaigns are, consumer protection needs more. It also requires clear and practical laws.

I want to mention two examples from the past months that stand for the necessity of better consumer rights.

The first is data protection. The parliamentary discussions on this are ongoing. I hope that they will lead to a truly reasonable conclusion. Federal Minister Schäuble agreed on improvements in the protection against data misuse with the institutions responsible for data protection at the data protection summit last autumn. This agreement is to be implemented with the amendment of the Federal Data Protection Act. I will advocate for this to be brought to a good conclusion.

It is also a topic that cannot be ignored that we need more transparency in so-called address trading. We want to strengthen informational self-determination as a fundamental right. This means that in the future, the use of personal data for advertising purposes should generally only be permissible with the consent of the affected individuals. Everyone knows that exceptions are not excluded when the word "generally" appears. We have also discussed that "generally" means that more transparency must be present. I hope that we will agree on this. Data about place of residence, name, and purchasing behavior should not be sold, traded, or used for profiling without consent. This is the core of this amendment to the Data Protection Act.

My second example that I want to mention is closely related to the international financial market crisis. It has highlighted significant gaps in consumer protection. Many private investors have lost a lot of money with partly risky financial products without being truly aware of the risks beforehand. Many investment decisions did not meet the expectations or life situations of the investors due to inadequate or poor advice. While there is already a situation today where banks and financial service providers are required to comply with certain consumer protection regulations, we are firmly convinced – especially the responsible minister – that there is a need for action here.

In particular, investors must be able to successfully assert their claims due to violations of regulations. It has been shown that investors generally find it very, very difficult to prove misadvice. Therefore, the Federal Cabinet has already taken an important step towards better investor protection with its draft on bond law from February 2009. Investment advisors will in the future be required to create and sign a written protocol for each consultation. This must be handed over to the customer before the business transaction is concluded. In this way, clarity about the content of the consultation will be established. Investors will thus be able to better prove any misadvice. Additionally, the limitation periods – which is also very important – will be extended. This will give investors more time to pursue their claims. This means: consumer rights must not only exist on paper, but must be enforceable within a timeframe that is relevant in practice.

The economy is called upon to provide simple and clear complaint procedures. However, we cannot rely on this happening automatically. Therefore, consumers must be able to assert their rights. When it comes to enforcing one's own rights, many first think of a legal dispute. But as the saying goes: mediation is often better than litigation. There are many cases where mediation has advantages. A mediation process is often faster and less bureaucratic than a exhausting legal dispute. Many things can be more consumer-friendly because a mediation process is generally free of charge.

I believe we are on a good path in Germany to make mediation more popular. Numerous mediation offices have been established in various fields. However, this must not mean that legal proceedings are eliminated without replacement. Legal disputes as a last resort must be available. Otherwise, mediation can quickly become a farce.

Individual rights have proven effective for consumer protection overall. We have additionally created opportunities for collective enforcement of claims through consumer associations. Collective legal protection comes into play whenever there are a multitude of similar disputes, where it would not be worthwhile for the individual to go to court due to the low value of the claims. We now need to see if the new procedural forms can really pass the practical test. Therefore, I say: it may still be a bit too early to make yet another amendment to the legal instruments. But we know that we must be open to your practical experiences. Therefore, we will continue to discuss this.

For me, consumer policy is not only called for when something goes wrong in the markets. Consumer policy means more than acute consumer protection. Consumer policy is a policy that helps shape economic activity, social life, and consumption habits, and, where necessary, to change them. Therefore, the idea of sustainable consumption is an essential part of the National Sustainability Strategy of the entire Federal Government.

More and more consumers are informing themselves before making a purchase decision not only about the quality and price of a product. They also inquire about the ecological and social costs of production – about the "second, invisible price tag," as Federal President Köhler referred to it at the last Consumer Day. I find it right and good that more and more consumers want to know whether manufacturers act responsibly, whether they are socially and societally engaged. Consumers want to be sure that products are not made through child labor.

Sustainable consumption goes hand in hand with great market opportunities, especially for the German economy. Because it can take pride in having high quality and high resource efficiency. For example, German manufacturers are leading in the world in water- and energy-saving household appliances. This means that the more sustainability we incorporate into consumer policy, the better the chances for our domestic products.

In order for consumers to truly exercise their power of design in the interest of sustainable development, they again need information about the nature of production and the origin of products. I think that the Fair Trade label or the "Blue Angel" – the oldest and best-known environmental label in Germany – are important indicators in this regard.

The Federal Government supports numerous measures for more transparency. However, we also expect – and I want to make this very clear – a voluntary contribution from the provider side. We rely on joint efforts. Therefore, we have begun to develop a national strategy for promoting and disseminating corporate responsibility with representatives from business and society. The vzbv is an indispensable partner in this process for us. We need your expertise and support to ensure that responsible corporate behavior truly becomes a bestseller. You are informed. You can provide helpful insights to politics. Therefore, we should continue this process with all intensity.

In light of the rapid technological, economic, and social changes, it is clear: consumer protection, consumer information, and consumer rights will become increasingly important in the future. For consumers, it is therefore very, very good to know that the consumer centers, many consumer initiatives, and Stiftung Warentest are there to support them with advice and assistance. They help consumers find their way in the jungle of offers and save money and trouble. They promote the idea of sustainability in the economy and society. I think, for example, of energy consulting – a very important component in climate protection. Many always say: It doesn't make any difference how I behave personally. The opposite is true. The individual can do a lot, but they must also know what impact their behavior has.

There are therefore many good reasons why we should not only find good words for you at meetings like today’s, but also support you financially. We have multiplied our project funding for the vzbv. The foundation assets of Stiftung Warentest are to be increased – we recently discussed this – so that a degree of independence from current budget policy can be created in this area in the coming years.

The Federal Government will – I say this on behalf of all members of the Federal Government – continue to support your work. We need your critical voice as independent organizations – organizations on whose expertise and advice consumers can rely and, above all, trust. Trust is the highest good that you have earned through your work.

Therefore, I would like to wish you all the best on the path of your further work as I conclude my remarks. Remain a constant, sometimes uncomfortable and demanding partner when it comes to consumer issues. I want to express my heartfelt thanks to you because I know that working in consumer associations is part of the work that cannot be accomplished with a normal service mandate alone. It is work that requires constant reflection, where one must always bring in a piece of emotion, where one can help people back on their way, but where one also experiences many disappointments and sees how desperate people can be. Therefore, a heartfelt thank you for the paid and voluntary work in your areas. We need you. We are dependent on you.