Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Annual Conference of the German Insurance Association e.V. on November 18, 2010, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

18 November 2010 · Annual Conference of the German Insurance Association (GDV) · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Annual Conference of the German Insurance Association in Berlin on November 18, 2010, discussing financial regulation and the insurance sector's role post-crisis.
Main themes
Insurance industry resilience, financial crisis response, financial market regulation, German insurance sector significance, risk management, investment stability, G20 and global financial governance, primacy of politics in financial oversight, long-term investment horizons, economic growth and prosperity
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,501
81st percentile
Sentences
181
87th percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
3.00
47th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 72%72%
  • Institutional 17%17%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

181 sentences in 38 paragraphs

Dear Mr. President, dear Mr. Hoenen,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am very pleased to have accepted your invitation. I want to assure you, who count insurance as part of your business or business model, that the concerns and problems you have certainly find a receptive audience with us. I will come back to this later.

First of all, I would like to sincerely congratulate you, Mr. Hoenen, on your re-election as President of the Gesamtverband der Deutschen Versicherungswirtschaft. Congratulations, all the best, and I look forward to good cooperation. Your introductory words also made it clear that the association is in good hands with you. It is a powerful representative of interests and a valued partner for the ministries of the federal government and for us in the Chancellery.

I also agree with you that insurance is, of course, indispensable in our society. Therefore, I am pleased that German insurers have weathered the crisis well. We are all convinced that insurance is an integral part of our daily lives. This applies to personal matters – you just spoke about life insurance – and it also applies to the entire economy.

The importance of insurance is obvious. For growth and prosperity require investments. Investments are associated with risks. It is always good to try to secure these risks. This means that whether you are building a factory, buying a house, or acquiring a new car – property must be insurable.

However, it is no longer just everyday matters; there are also major challenges such as climate protection, education, research, and development that require significant investments, and we are, of course, dependent on stable framework conditions. The truly impressive figures also show the significance of insurance for the functioning of our society. With 555,000 employees, the entire insurance industry is a powerful economic sector; this is something that should be remembered on such a day. It generates an annual turnover of 200 billion euros and holds capital investments of around 1.2 trillion euros. This shows the values that are entrusted to you.

Therefore, I can rightly say: The insurance industry is one of the most significant sectors in Germany and a truly important player in the capital markets. You place your investments – which is also very important for the rhythm in which our society functions – often with long time horizons. I believe that the entire banking crisis is largely due to short-term thinking. In this respect, it is good that insurance companies have a stabilizing effect on the financial markets when it comes to long time horizons.

I believe you can be proud that the business model of German insurers has proven to be robust during the financial crisis and that their risk management has overall proven to be very resilient. Of course, this has been aided by the fact that politics has also done what was necessary to rescue the banks. Otherwise, not only would the real economy have been drawn into an even deeper spiral, but of course, the insurers as well.

The financial crisis has kept us on our toes for the last two years. I also agree with you, Mr. Hoenen, that this crisis is not over in all its facets. We do not yet have the solid ground beneath our feet that we had just a few years ago. What the crisis has shown us, namely that the functionality of the entire financial and goods markets can be endangered, was, of course, an incredible shock to trust in economic mechanisms. It has made us aware of what globalization means, namely an incredible interconnection and a systemic relevance of actors in many places where one might not have suspected it before.

Therefore, we also agree here that the financial markets must look different in the future than they did in the past. Your constant question is: To what extent must this also be applied to the insurance industry? I add: To what extent must this be applied to the German insurance industry, which has proven to be very robust?

We in politics are, of course, fighting and working to re-establish what we describe as the primacy of politics, so that societies can once again have confidence that individual actors in the financial markets cannot call entire societal models into question or bring them to the brink of existence. The question of what regulation we need has certainly been one of the most difficult for us in recent years. On the one hand, you cannot always ask the actors themselves what they believe the lessons of this crisis should be. On the other hand, we know that state actors certainly sometimes tend toward overregulation. But the trust that market-based mechanisms are the most efficient means of securing prosperity has not been lost to us. So this is certainly a balancing act, especially in a very complex world where the traditions of individual actors – whether they are European, Asian, American, or political actors – are completely different.

Therefore, it can be said that the G20 has played a very important role at the level of finance ministers, but also at the level of heads of state and government in this crisis and has for the first time truly practiced global cooperation. Our starting point, that every financial actor, every product, and every place where financial transactions are conducted should be subject to regulation, is correct. We are now essentially in the implementation phase – on the one hand, nationally, often for us European; and then also aligning with what is happening internationally. In this regard, quite a bit has happened.

First of all, we established the Financial Market Stabilization Fund and the stimulus programs. That was right and necessary. It has been shown in Germany that several banks urgently needed help; I do not want to go into detail about that now. We still have a way to go with the state banks, where we really need to achieve the necessary restructuring. We have provided guarantees and we have invested capital. We will only be able to see in due time what burden will remain for the taxpayer. This cannot be foreseen today. But in any case, it can be said that the precautionary measures to ensure that banks are able to cope with such crises on their own have not been sufficient.

In the spring of this year, we experienced something that probably very few expected in this form, namely a destabilization of the entire currency system, which was first tied to the question of Greece and later necessitated a large Euro rescue umbrella. The decisions made here were also correct, made quickly and comprehensively. In all the discussions we have had, it can be said: In the last two years, our state and the international community have proven to be capable of action, which is a rather reassuring experience.

Now we must see how we can ensure that the success of the measures that have been effective so far and are of a temporary nature – including the stimulus programs and the rescue umbrella for the Euro – can now be secured by the actors themselves in a future financial market architecture. This means that the taxpayer does not have to step in. Therefore, we have initiated a number of legislative proposals. The Financial Market Stabilization Act was aimed at rescuing banks, but from 2011 onwards, the measures will fundamentally no longer be carried out under this law, but only under the future restructuring law. This future restructuring law also includes the participation of the actors in a restructuring.

We must now also ensure that we implement the exit strategies purposefully. We have managed to achieve the economic revival you mentioned through the bank rescue actions and the stimulus programs. This is extremely encouraging for Germany. We will be able to record a growth rate of about 3.4 percent this year; that is the forecast. We will have to take on less new debt than we thought at the beginning of the year. We were expecting 80 billion euros, but now we will probably be at just under 50 billion euros in the budget. However, I would like to remind you – because I am already reading every morning about tax reduction possibilities – that new debt of 50 billion euros in a budget of 320 billion euros must be an absolute exception, and therefore, budget consolidation must be by far the number one priority that we must adhere to; and that for many years to come.

It has also been shown that the vulnerability of countries with large deficits in budget consolidation is so great that one becomes politically completely dependent on market mechanisms. This must not happen under any circumstances. Therefore, we – I also thank you for your support – have taken a rather tough stance in Europe; that is correct. I have always said: Of course, we have an interest in saving the Euro as a whole. That is our currency. The success of the German economy is closely linked to a strong Euro. One cannot imagine how we could have managed this economic and financial crisis with so many different currencies, as there used to be in the European area. Therefore, the stability of the Euro is of paramount interest to Germany.

But it is not the one who helps quickly who is the one in solidarity, but in my firm conviction, it is the one who helps in such a way that a stable foundation is truly restored under the mechanisms. Therefore, it was right to impose conditions on both Greece and potentially future users of the Euro rescue umbrella and to establish a unity of the IMF, ECB, and European Commission to fend off different signals regarding what the appropriate programs for the respective countries are.

There is currently again a discussion about the question of Ireland. I just want to say: We have a Euro rescue umbrella. If a country believes it wants to use it, then I can only say that it was created exactly for this case. Therefore, it was right to take the necessary measures for it in the spring. However, we will still have a lot of work to do in the Eurozone for a considerable time.

It has not only been right to tighten the sanction mechanisms within the framework of the Stability and Growth Pact, but it is equally right that we have agreed on a strengthened coordination of economic policies in the Eurozone and in the internal market as a whole. Here lie the opportunities to seek macroeconomic indicators within the framework of the Stability and Growth Pact in the future, in order to be able to detect as early as possible that certain things are going completely wrong in some countries. We can only achieve the long-term stabilization of the Euro through greater coherence among the Euro countries and the European member states. This means: On the one hand, budget consolidation, but on the other hand, of course, also strengthening the forces of growth. Because if the forces of growth within the member states of the European Union are distributed completely unevenly, we will not achieve the necessary coherence. There are still significant problems and tasks ahead of us.

Therefore, the rescue umbrellas are not only designed for one year or a few months, but for three years. But by the year 2013, we must use this opportunity within the European Union. Three years is not too long for improving the performance and growth capacity of a country. This means that there is much work to be done. However, I am also very pleased that many countries are not only implementing budget consolidation measures but also structural reforms in the labor market in the area of privatization. These are things that are absolutely necessary to achieve better economic performance.

We have said that on the one hand, we must always be aware that, because the crisis is not yet completely over, the euro is currently somewhat wrapped and enveloped in protection – it is correct that this time must be used – but that afterwards we also need a permanent crisis mechanism. We in the federal government are absolutely convinced that it is necessary for creditors to be involved in the costs in a future mechanism – I emphasize this three times so that all market participants understand it correctly. It cannot be that one can communalize any risks in dealing with states and that the actors do not also have to bear a part of the risks. Therefore, it is right and important that we clarify the conditions for the future as soon as possible. Then, no uncertainty will arise in the markets.

For me, it is a fundamental question to what extent politics also expects market participants to stand up for their risks to some extent. This applies, by the way, to every businessman in the real economy. Why what applies everywhere else should not be the case in dealing with states is something that no one can explain to me quickly. Now, it is the case: For economic actors, the best thing is when the risk is minimized. Therefore, one cannot really hope for support from the areas of the actors themselves. But those who think of the common good at least tell you as citizens of this country in a generally oriented conversation and not in a self-interested discussion that this approach is reasonable. I believe we should leave it at that.

By the way, there is currently a certain struggle taking place regarding what power the financial markets will have and what design options politics will have. If I have understood the social market economy correctly, then a man like Ludwig Erhard has always ensured through clear guidelines that fair competition – competition that did not ruin societies but enabled prosperity – was possible. If one had asked the actors back then whether a law against restrictions on competition should be introduced – which corresponds to our current antitrust law – one would certainly have heard from the actors, at least from the large ones, the answer: Under no circumstances. However, the fact that Ludwig Erhard did it is the foundation for the fact that we today have a medium-sized economy in Germany, which is our strong backbone and which many in the world truly envy us for. Therefore, I openly admit: We are currently in uncharted political territory. Therefore, we must repeatedly discuss together what further regulation we still need.

For the future financial market regulation, it is completely clear that we need restructuring options for banks. I have spoken about the national law. The European Union has taken this up and will implement it at the European level. We need improved financial market supervision. The necessary measures have been initiated in the European area. We also need better monitoring of hedge funds – the guidelines have been established in Europe and also in the United States – and we need more transparency for the so-called over-the-counter derivatives markets.

All these goals were reaffirmed in Seoul. Therefore, one cannot say that nothing has happened in terms of financial market regulation in the last two years. Things have been accomplished that would have taken decades before. For example, the fact that "Basel III" could be adopted for banks, meaning that the regulations for capital adequacy have been improved, is a huge step forward. Many years were spent negotiating "Basel II." Now the only question remains whether everyone will implement "Basel III." National implementation is, of course, always important.

We need better risk management and better incentive systems. For this, "Basel III" is an important regulation. We also need increased resilience of financial institutions. We also need an answer to the problem of "too big to fail." Here, we have not made as much progress in Seoul as I would have liked. But the work on this is being driven forward by the Financial Stability Board.

You have pointed out that "Solvency II" worries you. I would like to point out that discussions are taking place on this and that Germany will contribute to the negotiation process in such a way that it does not lead to the kind of permanent engagement with forms and reports that no one can read anymore. We will certainly try to pursue a reasonable path here. You have described the danger of overregulation quite clearly. This will be taken into account in our further work.

You can also assume that we consider life insurance to be a very essential element of long-term provision and therefore, of course, want to do everything to ensure that this product remains an attractive product.

You then mentioned the point that low interest rates are manageable for a short time but, of course, pose a significant earnings problem for you in the long run. We believe that exit strategies from the crisis mechanisms should take place relatively quickly. However, we have a problem here, because globally harmonized, coherent mechanisms would need to be applied. If one part of the world exits and another part does not, this will naturally create tensions that cannot be ignored.

Therefore, it is right that Germany and the European countries as a whole pursue this exit strategy and that we also discuss this with our transatlantic friends. We agreed in Toronto that all industrialized countries must halve their deficits by 2013. This means that, of course, the exit must begin in all countries within this timeframe. However, the timing is still a matter of international debate.

We are politically in a relatively good position. We have an independent European Central Bank. We do not influence the interest rate level. But the European Central Bank is, of course, also oriented towards not producing disadvantages for Europe globally. Therefore, interest rate policy requires a degree of coordination, to which, however, politics – we do well to maintain this – does not exert influence from Germany.

The sooner there is a recovery phase, the better. However, I also agree with you: The upswing, that is, the growth rate of 3.4 percent, is still very export-driven this year. This mainly depends on the Asian markets and their very, very good development. But due to the good labor market situation, we can say: This is now also driving domestic consumption. This, in turn, should be of great benefit to your industry. The growth of next year will be determined to a much greater extent than this year's growth by domestic economic conditions.

Now it will be important to pursue a wise overall policy that does not forgo further structural reforms, that secures social security systems, and that strengthens flexibility in the collective bargaining areas rather than weakens it. I believe that the flexible collective agreements that have now been developed have proven themselves very well in the crisis and, in combination with short-time work, have led to a very good employment situation, which in turn has stabilized the psychology of society as a whole, even though a slump in the economy of almost five percent of gross domestic product hardly changed the fact that we looked relatively positively into the future. This is a classic example of Ludwig Erhard being right in his view that the economy is 50 percent psychology. The social market economy has actually worked wonderfully in this crisis.

However, we certainly still have a lot to discuss together. I would like to thank you especially for the support you give us when we are strict from time to time regarding the foundation of our economic and monetary union in the European Union. This strictness is necessary because otherwise we would be building on sand and not consolidating things as they need to be.

Europe is an aging continent. For all of us, it is of course true that we have our hands full with igniting and strengthening our innovative power and enthusiasm for innovation. The world – one sees this especially when leaving Europe – is not sleeping. Many countries are in a very dynamic growth process. If we want to remain at the forefront, as we are today, we must make a great effort.

This includes a prosperous insurance industry. Therefore, I wish you, the actors in this industry, much success. Support us in the necessary regulation. Also keep us from exaggerations. But argue confidently, for nothing is worse than always being a little distrustful of the actors. We all have long-standing experiences. I was Minister of the Environment for four years; when one spoke with representatives of the industries back then about what exhaust standards and emission protection could be managed, one always heard only 60 or 70 percent of what was really possible. I always say: Put the cards on the table so that credibility is established and we know which regulations really harm you, which we do not want. In this spirit, let us continue our discussions.