Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Annual Meeting of the German Research Foundation on May 31, 2006, in Munich:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

31 May 2006 · Annual Meeting of the German Research Foundation · LMU Munich, Munich, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the annual meeting of the German Research Foundation at Ludwig Maximilians University in Munich on May 31, 2006, emphasizing research and innovation as key to Germany's prosperity.
Main themes
Research and innovation policy, German Research Foundation, excellence in science, university tradition and freedom, basic and applied research, prosperity and economic competitiveness, R&D investment goals, global challenges, unemployment and social security, industry-academia cooperation, internationality in research
Duration
~23 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,809
73rd percentile
Sentences
131
75th percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.04
53rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 35%35%
  • Institutional 31%31%
  • Social 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

131 sentences in 32 paragraphs

Dear Mr. President Prof. Winnacker,

Mr. Prof. Kleiner,

State Minister Goppel,

Colleague Schavan,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am, of course, pleased to be here today in Munich and simultaneously at the annual meeting of the German Research Foundation. I have not yet counted my stays in Munich, Mr. Huber, but perhaps you could continue to keep track so that I am always well-informed. Then I will know where to retrieve it.

I am glad to be here at LMU, because your university truly has a long history. It goes back to the year 1472. But it is also a place where the "White Rose" and the Scholl siblings worked, a place that has become a home for freedom, commitment, and civil courage. It is thus exemplary of the idea of universities in Germany. It not only has a long tradition, but – one must say this for today's Ludwig Maximilians University – it is also a place of outstanding achievements. As a representative of that, I can certainly mention Prof. Hensch, the last German Nobel laureate who has his roots at this university.

The German Research Foundation is, when it comes to performance, the institution that can be described as the engine and guardian of this performance. I hope I do not offend the self-governing universities by saying this. It promotes excellence, competition, and internationality not only at universities but, of course, also at research institutions or in cooperation with industry.

When I mention the three words freedom, excellence, and internationality, it is something that must always be worked on structurally and institutionally. Therefore, we can be proud of the institution of the German Research Foundation. I would like to connect this, Mr. Prof. Winnacker, with a heartfelt thank you to you, to your colleagues, to those who work full-time at the German Research Foundation, but especially to those who dedicate many hours as reviewers and otherwise support such an institution. This is a system that is respected and admired worldwide, that has proven itself, and for which I wish you, Mr. Prof. Kleiner, all the best in leading this system.

When I speak here today at this festive assembly, I do so for a federal government and also as Chancellor who is certain that the question of research and innovation today, perhaps more than ever before, will determine how Germany will cope with its challenges and problems, how we will be able to secure our prosperity in the coming years, and how we will meet the global social and ecological challenges.

This meeting those challenges is, of course, no longer a given. Many people feel this. As of today, we have over 4.5 million unemployed. We have an uncertain future for our social security systems. We have rapid intensifications of competition. We have countries that also feel the need to provide prosperity for their people. Therefore, we stand before a great test of endurance with all that has made the Federal Republic of Germany strong; foremost among them are the institutions that guarantee that innovation and creativity can again become the foundation of prosperity and progress.

What once seemed self-evident to many, namely that Germany was a country of Nobel laureates, of ideas and new products, that groundbreaking inventions were not only made in Germany but also implemented afterwards, is no longer self-evident today.

"Chopping wood is so popular because you can see the success of this activity immediately," Albert Einstein once said. I believe he considered that in science and innovation, it is less about chopping wood and more about drilling thick planks, about the ability to have confidence in basic research, to correctly connect basic research and applied research, and then to turn ideas into products.

We can be proud of our tradition, but we must rethink our framework conditions today. Therefore, the federal government is called upon at this point. We know that regarding the goal I mentioned – namely that we can maintain our prosperity, perhaps even increase it if things go very well; but even to maintain it, we will have to work hard – it is a minimum requirement that we spend three percent of the gross domestic product in Germany on research and development.

Three percent of the gross domestic product – this means that on the one hand, the federal government and the states must contribute to this. We will do that. By the year 2009, we want to spend six billion euros more on research and development than we have done so far. The states must contribute their part – about four billion euros – to this. Here in Bavaria, the situation is that the Free State will contribute its share, which is not so complicated. In other places, a little more encouragement is needed.

On the other hand, we have the task that industry must contribute two-thirds to the current distribution of research and development tasks, meaning it must significantly increase its share. There must be an intensive dialogue about whether this is achievable, which the Federal Minister of Research and Education will conduct with the business enterprises. I would like to encourage all of you here to discuss this with your business partners – many of you have such partners. It is also important to perhaps rethink some business plans. It is certainly also important that the federal government not only provides money but also creates the respective framework conditions under which companies can conduct research and development in Germany. Our will is present on one side, but on the other side, the integration with the economy still needs to take place.

We want to spend this additional money in three major areas, firstly for the strengthening of key and cross-sectional technologies. There are 17 such technology fields, and this includes what is well known to all of you: IT technologies, bio-, nano- and aerospace technology, health and energy research, as well as security, environment, and mobility.

What I can report to you from the new federal government is that we are currently working in a spirit – I hope this spirit will continue – in which departmental thinking, which often dominates the allocation of available funds from the respective departments, has receded in favor of a collective strategy for research and development tasks, that this is being coordinated by the Minister of Education and Research, and that the federally owned research institutions have now also agreed to undergo evaluation. We have advocated that the respective results are not only acknowledged but also implemented. I believe this is an important, correct, and necessary step for the government to simply prove that we are facing the quality benchmarking. I also think this deserves a bit of applause. This is not so easy. When I was once Minister of the Environment, they also wanted to close something on me. One quickly loses courage in such situations. Therefore, we still need a lot of encouragement from those who create evaluations.

The second point of approach is the strengthening of the innovation engine of small and medium-sized enterprises. The Mittelstand is, on the one hand, the backbone of employment and training. On the other hand, it has great difficulties in adapting to the challenges of globalization. The equity capital is often insufficient, and therefore it is very important that small and medium-sized enterprises have the necessary resources and capabilities to participate in research and development. Because innovation today also determines the future viability of companies – not only of large companies but also of smaller ones.

We also need to strengthen the performance and international attractiveness of the German scientific system itself. This is primarily about promoting young scientists and talent development. This must also be an important focus. In the summer, so that we really know what we will do with the six billion euros, we will adopt a so-called "High Tech Strategy" so that the money we have is spent sensibly.

I believe we have made a really important step in the Federal Republic of Germany with the Excellence Initiative at universities and research institutions. A new wind has come to the universities. Mr. Prof. Winnacker, we have talked a lot about the design of this Excellence Initiative in a different constellation when I was not yet Chancellor. It took a long time, but I am proud that it is now structurally somewhat successful. A necessary prerequisite for this is to accept that such an Excellence Initiative really leads to what is happening now, namely that there is joy and sorrow. It was clear: When it comes to real excellence, there will not only be joyful signals but also painful signals. That is exactly what is happening now. Those who are considered or have been considered are very pleased. Munich emerges from this with its head held high. In the north, the heads are somewhat lowered.

There is now, of course, a debate about how we can achieve a balanced research landscape. But I am deeply convinced: We will never achieve a balanced research landscape if we do not first account for the capabilities of the individual research institutions. Only a clear analysis can help us strengthen the strong and also help the weaker ones to become stronger. Therefore, this step was absolutely necessary.

Here, too, a heartfelt thank you goes to the German Research Foundation and the Science Council, who have excellently implemented the competitive process and are still busy with it. This has led to an incredible revitalization in many areas and, by the way, also to a great willingness to cooperate across individual university and college boundaries. This networking idea can, of course, spread much better if it succeeds in creating incentives to bring people together for projects that make sense. Therefore, I consider this to be an excellent idea.

At this point, Mr. Prof. Huber, I would like to address your concerns regarding the EIT, the European Institute of Technology. I share these concerns and will – although it is always difficult to approach things that already have a history – try, together with Ms. Schavan, to make something reasonable out of it, also taking advantage of our presidency. The difficulty with this matter is that the ideas about what the end product should be are relatively vague. When the ideas about what should come out of it are vague, then naturally the paths to it are also very unclear. My objection, whether this could not be evaluated by the European Research Council, initially caused a lot of head shaking, to which I replied that then it could not possibly become what I envision as an excellent university, college, or institute like the EIT; because then the European Research Council would have to have something to say about it.

Our approach now is – always with the help of this European Research Council, which we believe will become something that structurally corresponds to the successful German scientific institutions – to ultimately produce a product that can either develop in peace or is a network of excellence, where excellence is also continuously reviewed. We all know that there is fundamentally no completely excellent institution and that you cannot create one from nothing, but that there must always be subsequent evaluations, growth, and interconnections. It is clear that this entire design is not an easy process for the European Union.

So it is about networks, but these networks must not be fixed for 100 years; they must, of course, prove themselves repeatedly. For this, I need the community spirit. Perhaps we will then find a place in Brussels or somewhere else where a good wine cellar for this EIT will be established. That will be the place where people gather and where otherwise the excellent research groups will be active. This is now a somewhat offhand remark.

I am fully aware of the matter: When money is invested in Europe for such purposes, it must be done with a chance of success. Therefore, we will keep a close watch on this, and I ask all of you: Motivate your research colleagues in other European countries not to follow the regional principle, but truly the principle of success. Europe is committed to being successful, in accordance with the Lisbon Strategy. That is why, during our EU Council Presidency, the topic of research and development will also be one of the most important tasks we will address, as we see this as a crucial focus of European activities. But it must also succeed that quality is truly the benchmark for the allocation of European research funds and not effects of sympathy or certain constellations of member countries – that is not enough, and it will never enable Europe to be truly successful.

We will only be scientifically successful if we create an overall climate of freedom and trust in those involved, especially in our universities, but also in research institutions, so that they can solve some problems on their own. This applies to the selection of students. It also applies to specializations and the development of a unique profile. It applies to the possibilities of collaboration with the economy, of course also to the possibilities of spin-offs, where real "incentives" are set, so that one benefits from it and not just anonymous institutions. Furthermore, it is about the management of financial resources.

Wherever one enters universities these days – at least in union-governed countries – one is mostly confronted with demonstrations. I had the impression that this has turned out relatively mild here, or you have ensured today that it looks somewhat festive, and otherwise, everyday life is a bit more somber. With the increasing age of the protesters, the anger will probably also grow, as the fees to be paid, of course, also increase. I must honestly tell you: There is no pardon for long-term students anyway, because the funds that are currently being invested in university education are so large compared to things that we can no longer afford elsewhere, that there is an obligation for every student to finish quickly and complete their education properly.

The second point is that I consider what can now be collected for universities in terms of tuition fees to be really justifiable. This is about a loan. This is also forgotten in public discussion. But I am preaching here anyway in a church where this sermon is not necessary. I just believe that the entirety, that is, the selection of students, the retention of one's own financial resources, and the development of one's own focuses, is very important for further developing the university landscape in Germany towards excellence.

In order to achieve our goals for the Federal Republic of Germany as a whole, we urgently need the dialogue between politics, business, and science. For this reason, I am glad that Heinrich von Pierer was willing to take the chair of the Council for Innovation and Growth – a small body that is intended to support the federal government, me, the Federal Minister of Education, and the Federal Minister of Economics personally in dealing with the instruments of research science and development research, as well as to advise on new trends and developments that we need to keep an eye on. We know that there are incredible international developments underway in both copyright and patent law. We know that the protection of intellectual property in the new era is a tremendous problem. We know that the question of how to link public research with financial instruments of the free financial market, and all these questions need to be thought through. For this, we need new instruments and also qualitatively new approaches. Politics can only face these if it truly seeks advice at this point. You know: In four years, the knowledge of humanity doubles. Hopefully, that of politicians does not halve in that time. But we certainly have all the trouble of legally setting the framework for already occurred developments. With this awareness, we work, and that is why we need this close dialogue.

Such a ceremonial assembly provides the opportunity to also thank you all for being ready for such a dialogue, for taking the time again and again, and certainly sometimes groaning about the lack of learning ability of politicians and the difficulties of implementation. But since you are all also involved in institutions, you know something about the slowness of progress. However, if we agree on the direction, and we do, namely that research, development, and creativity in a free atmosphere are the foundation for prosperity in the future, then it will succeed in making something beneficial for people from Germany's strengths again in the 21st century. I invite you to be part of this, I also invite you to criticize us if we do not do enough, but I tell you: We do our work with joy.