Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the specialist symposium "20 Years of the Federal Ministry for the Environment – Assessment and Perspectives" on June 6, 2006, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

6 June 2006 · Specialist symposium "20 Years of the Federal Ministry for the Environment – Assessment and Perspectives" · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed a specialist symposium in Berlin on June 6, 2006, marking the 20th anniversary of the Federal Ministry for the Environment.
Main themes
20th anniversary of the Federal Ministry for the Environment, history of German environmental policy, Chernobyl disaster and founding of the ministry, precautionary environmental protection, EU environmental cooperation, political parties and environmental policy, forward-looking environmental governance, role of catastrophe in policy creation
Duration
~29 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,523
82nd percentile
Sentences
183
87th percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
11.8
42nd percentile
Syntax
2.91
35th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 32%32%
  • Environmental 31%30%
  • Geopolitical 11%10%
  • Economic 11%10%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Not in focus 2%

183 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Gabriel,

dear Mr. Trittin,

dear Mr. Pröll,

dear former colleague Svend Auken,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag,

staff of the Federal Ministry for the Environment,

friends of the Federal Ministry for the Environment,

critical companions of the Ministry of the Environment,

dear guests,

I am pleased to speak to you this morning on the occasion of the 20th anniversary of the Federal Ministry for the Environment. We have swapped the order of speakers because we have a meeting with the French President in Rheinsberg today, and I do not want to keep the French President waiting in the field in Rheinsberg, but rather want to be there before him.

It is a great pleasure for me – I just mentioned this to Mr. Gabriel – to approach this chronologically. I will simply start with the tenth anniversary of the Federal Ministry for the Environment. At that time, when I was Minister, we celebrated a large citizens' festival in Bonn with the "Höhner."

I have heard that there will also be a celebration at Palais Schaumburg, where it all began. In this respect, we can say today: The Federal Ministry for the Environment has come of age, and two years are added to that. With the 20th anniversary, it is necessary and right for this ministry to present itself confidently among the ranks of the departments of a federal government.

I still remember my start as Federal Minister for the Environment when I was first told that certain departments had effectively severed their contacts with the corresponding departments in the Federal Ministry of Agriculture and the Federal Ministry of Economics, which is why negotiations at the EU level could not be continued by the federal government for Germany. In this way, I quickly learned to appreciate and experience the various interconnections of the Federal Ministry for the Environment within the federal government.

From my perspective, life at the beginning, when I became Federal Minister for the Environment, was actually a critical collaboration with every department that existed in the federal government. There were few allies. At most, one could find like-minded individuals in the Ministry for Women, who were facing similar difficulties. Since I had previously been the Minister for Women, I was used to dealing with challenges. Therefore, I could approach the matter quite optimistically. I then experienced that the respective committee – I do not know how it is today; perhaps everything is different today – was staffed by friends of environmental policy and vigilant observers from all possible directions. Sometimes it was not entirely clear to me which group predominated.

In any case, I remember when I see Svend Auken that there was already a wonderful community of environmental ministers in the European Union back then. At that time, one could pinpoint the turning point when the establishment of environmental ministries – in Germany it was in 1986 – which often arose from catastrophic situations, transformed into institutions dedicated to forward-looking, precautionary environmental protection; a turning point that certainly reached its first peak with Rio in 1990. Since then, environmental protection has gradually developed into a true future industry. I would like to say a few words about that as well.

The founding can perhaps be described with the words of Pestalozzi: "Determination in misfortune is half the way to salvation." In 1986, the disaster of Chernobyl occurred. Forty days later, on June 5, 1986, the Federal Ministry for the Environment was founded. The same year also saw the disaster at Sandoz.

There was thus a clear realization that the consequences for humans could be severe if such disasters were not prevented. There was a feeling of great insecurity. The two major political parties certainly did not respond adequately to this feeling of insecurity that had built up over the years. I want to say this for the Christian Democratic Union. Here, we had long ignored many warnings. This has led to the fact that today we have a green party, to which we attribute this historical root, with which we do not always live in peace and friendship, but still in constructive dialogue. It has clearly shaped the environmental policy of this country. That is part of the historical truth. The major parties had to learn; and they have learned.

In 1986, a new ministry had to be established. There was already a department in the Federal Ministry of the Interior. But a proper decree for the establishment of a new ministry is rare in the history of long-standing governments. Walter Wallmann was the first Federal Minister for the Environment for a short time. He was followed by Klaus Töpfer, with whom the entire environmental policy of the Federal Republic of Germany gained a very clear profile. Helmut Kohl gave a government statement in 1987 after the Bundestag elections. It was under the motto: "Preserving Creation – Winning the Future." This showed the dimension of environmental policy that was developing and then found an international spirit of renewal in Rio de Janeiro in 1992.

The commitment to sustainable development in the early 1990s, the Agenda 21, essentially provided an incredible impetus for the sense of belonging of the world. When we talk about globalization today, 14 years later, the feeling of what globalization means in terms of a sense of belonging was already present in 1992 among those responsible for the environment; and they had managed to convince heads of state and government of the necessity. That was a huge step. Sometimes between 1994 and 1998, I thought: If this impulse had been maintained at such a high level a little longer, perhaps many things would have progressed even faster.

Germany played a leading role in this Agenda 21 process in the preparation for Rio and in the subsequent debates. I believe we can and should be proud of that as the Federal Republic of Germany. When I became Minister for the Environment in 1994, we were able to hold the first climate conference in Berlin. This Berlin Mandate was the precursor to the Kyoto Protocol. At that time, as a newly appointed Minister for the Environment, I experienced the incredible cultural breadth of a world coming together. When 140, 150 countries are struggling to reach an outcome from very different perspectives, it is always associated with very complicated negotiation processes.

Even then, there was already the discussion: Is it even necessary to hold this whole travel circus? Is it necessary for all the people, for the supporters and the NGOs to come together? I give a very clear commitment to this international negotiation process. They would never achieve such results merely through the theoretical exchange of papers. I know that progress is slow. But international negotiation is the basis for better understanding; and therefore it must continue, ladies and gentlemen.

It quickly became clear that the results of Rio, the Agenda 21, were supported by all or quite a few. However, the question of who grants how much development to whom and under what conditions and restrictions still determines our dialogue with developing and emerging countries today. The question of whether the West, the highly developed industrial countries, have only chosen the sustainability issue to restrict the development of others has not yet been sufficiently answered in the eyes of those living at a low standard of living. We will need much more trust-building to convince the responsible parties in the relevant developing and emerging countries that sustainability also has to do with their future.

When we visit China today, we see from the state of the air and the difficulties that arise when resources are consumed without placing the thought of sustainability too much in the foreground, how quickly industrial economic development can be hindered if environmental considerations are not sufficiently taken into account.

I am firmly convinced that our current responsibility as developed countries – and this includes the countries of the European Union – in, for example, the climate protection process, is to exemplify how economic growth and environmental development can go hand in hand. That this does not happen without contradictions in daily life is perfectly clear. When I was Minister for the Environment, the most feared calls were those from the Chancellor personally when the chemical industry or the automotive industry had come forward again. – I did not have to call Mr. Gabriel in such matters yet. However, that does not mean that it could not still happen. This is not an absolution for the future.

So those were often the most feared calls. I still remember the "Euro IV" standards in the automotive sector. It was said to be technically completely unattainable, as was said at the time. Since I am a physicist, I was repeatedly told that it was completely impossible to achieve. However, it then became clear in a relatively short time that it had already been accomplished by the technicians at the time when it was still said that it was unattainable. When I asked, "Why do you say you can't do it when you have almost done it?" I was always told: If we reveal that too early, you will immediately come up with "Euro V." I say this very seriously: An intensive dialogue between business and environmental policymakers naturally requires a degree of reliability. This does not include the repeated premature introduction of new conditions before the first has even been achieved. I understood that well at the time.

So back to the relationship of developed countries to developing countries. When climate protection is discussed today, the argument is repeatedly raised in the debate – I do not need to elaborate on this further here – that the CO2 emissions of the European Union are low and negligible compared to the CO2 emissions of the world, and therefore we cannot solve the CO2 issue, and thus cannot stop climate change.

However, I believe that we have a moral responsibility here with our technical capabilities to show ways for the future that can also be used worldwide as export successes, meaning that we must be trendsetters. With that, we can also reduce CO2 consumption in other parts of the world. Of course, the credibility of our discourse on sustainable development is also measured by the actions we implement in our own country under sometimes difficult conditions.

The idea of Agenda 21 is actually one of the most charming, to bring together environment, economic growth, sustainability, and social development in a balance. We know how difficult that is in individual cases. We know how much the focus of the discussion shifts in light of 4.5 million unemployed in Germany. But I believe the fundamental approach that it is our obligation to balance social, economic, and ecological development in the sense of sustainability is absolutely correct. It is a truly forward-looking approach. The really charming and good thing about it is that environmental policymakers can say: You have recognized this sign of the future. Economic and social policymakers only later absorbed the importance of this balance. Today, it has become common knowledge in politics, even if it is difficult to address in individual cases.

In the Rio process, in which climate development certainly stood at the forefront for many years, we reached further international agreements, of which I would like to briefly mention biodiversity. Biodiversity has, in essence, a difficult existence as a sister of climate protection because it is harder to grasp. From my perspective, it is just as important. We celebrated 100 years of state environmental protection together a week ago. I am pleased that Germany will host the next Conference of the Parties for the conservation of biodiversity. I consider this topic to be one of the most important because it also relates to the protection of humans through a rich nature. This idea of nature conservation is also far too little recognized.

Moreover, I consider many environmental protection issues in Germany to be relatively well solved when I think of waste management, water protection, and air quality control. However, I believe that the issue of land consumption, which is directly related to nature conservation and biodiversity, is also not resolved in our country. It will require a profound discussion process to make people in an aging society, which is not fundamentally geared towards population growth, clearly understand that the continued use of ever more settlement areas has something very destructive for the future of our biodiversity. Here, I see a long process of persuasion and discussion ahead, from local politicians to family policymakers. It is about the ideals: Where does one live best? How does one manage to harmonize city and nature? – So here we still have a real task.

We are currently having a discussion – the new federal government has taken this on very intensively – that goes beyond CO2 minimization. This is the discussion of a sustainable energy supply. We have set ourselves a challenging task. We want to address how the energy supply of the Federal Republic of Germany could look by the year 2020. I believe that this is a great necessity in order to bring a degree of predictability into the development of an economic and industrial nation like the Federal Republic of Germany. We in the Grand Coalition have taken on this task, even though we know that there are very different opinions on individual issues. Nevertheless, in my view, we have the responsibility to develop a clear strategy here to make investment decisions and future paths visible, thereby bringing a degree of sustainability into the entire debate.

I am very pleased that the European Union, particularly the Austrian presidency, has taken up this topic. At the last Council of Heads of State and Government, we used the evening discussion to talk about a common energy policy of the European Union. We must acknowledge that – regardless of which energy concept we pursue – the European Union's dependence on energy suppliers and raw materials outside the European Union will increase. We must take this increase in dependencies into account. I believe we must do everything we can to make ourselves as independent as possible, and at the same time, we must bridge the gap from environmental and resource policy to foreign policy. For it will become evident that foreign and sustainability policy are increasingly interconnected.

When we look at which countries have the largest energy resources available, we quickly find ourselves at the conflict zones of this earth. It again shows that a very intertwined diplomatic foreign policy will have to include entire areas of environmental policy in the future. In other words, it becomes clear that an environmental policy focused solely on the national or the European Union will not be sufficient.

We advocate for a maximum level of transparency from resource suppliers in energy policy in the spirit of the social market economy. I have repeatedly advocated in Russia for Russia to ratify the Energy Charter. This would bring a bit more reliability. I believe we should also advocate for a consistent energy policy within the European Union that is not directed against other countries. There are fears here; there are concerns. We all know that. Therefore, a significant task lies ahead of us.

In the coming years, we will certainly have to discuss the question: Which instruments of modern environmental protection fit best into the social market economy? We have long talked about market-based instruments. Now that the trading of certificates for CO2 emissions has become a reality, the pitfalls of market-based instruments have also become apparent. We certainly still have a long discussion ahead of us within the European Union regarding the comparability of legal systems in the individual European member states. The Anglo-Saxon legal system has a completely different perspective. It is based on current, specific risks, while the continental European legal system is much more focused on boundary conditions and limits. Thus, within the European Union, the same directive repeatedly leads to the realization that it must be implemented in all member states and yet can result in completely different approval conditions.

I just had a long discussion about the English system. I believe that with our deterministic system, we are actually doing quite well in many areas. Because when we ask the economy whether we should also consider liability risks more strongly, as in the very risk-oriented legislative system of the Anglo-Saxons, the enthusiasm of the economy for this is actually very limited.

At this point, after 20 years at the Federal Ministry for the Environment, I would also like to say a good word for those who issue permits in Germany. Anyone who issues a permit for a large facility under the 13th, 15th, 17th, or any other Federal Immission Control Act regulation does not belong to the best-paid people in Germany. However, making a mistake in the permitting process is one of the highest risks someone can take. Therefore, I must say – despite everything that could be said about the duration of permitting procedures – a heartfelt thank you to the many who have shown great responsibility in these permitting processes. This has led to relatively few accidents occurring in Germany with large facilities. This has, of course, also led to an incredible specialization. When I was Minister for the Environment, it was said that there were about four people who understood the 17th Federal Immission Control Act. I do not know if that number has now increased to eight, including those responsible in the states. In any case, a high level of expertise is necessary to accomplish all of this.

I must also make a remark about the European legislative system and the development of directives: A transparent environmental law in the European Union should have more elements of regulation in the directive and fewer elements in the annex than is currently the case. Most of the interesting content is in the annex, while the generalities are in the directive. Through annexes, almost everything can be regulated in Europe, from the size of Italian shoe factories to the size of German paper factories. This is where the great bargaining takes place. When we then come to those who set the standards beyond the directive regulation, it becomes even more complicated. Therefore, we really need a democratization of these procedures in the comitology processes. I will certainly fight for this at all levels, especially in the environmental area.

To give one last example, we also have new challenges regarding the Lisbon Process. The European Union is not economically as dynamic as it needs to be to maintain and increase prosperity for citizens in the European member states. Therefore, it has set itself the goal of becoming the most dynamic continent again. This Lisbon Process dominates the agenda of discussions. It must, of course, be conducted in the spirit of Agenda 21 and sustainability. But we certainly have areas of tension in this context. When I think of the history of chemical legislation in Europe, it has reflected this tension like no other. There will also be differences between the various parties in the future. The Grand Coalition almost managed to find a, in my opinion, viable compromise during its formation. But I also say: Here it becomes clear to what limits we again encounter with legislation in Europe.

If we have free world trade – free imports from all countries of the earth – on one side and at the same time enact specific regulations in Europe, we must be careful that in the end we do not lose the chemical industry in Europe and instead receive Chinese or other imports that will certainly not lead to more environmental protection.

This brings me back to the initial process. Environmental policy can today be understood and operated nationally as a signal; in certain areas, it can certainly also be regulated nationally. There are areas in which we are fully integrated into global thinking. Therefore, international environmental policy is always intertwined with foreign policy. It is an interest-driven policy in the sense of a long-term stable development.

I still remember how we discussed between 1994 and 1998 whether we should send a representative from the Ministry of the Environment to the not particularly beloved World Trade Organization. The question was whether one would lose one's own strength, forget the environmental thought, or whether the Ministry of the Environment had enough strength to introduce the idea of sustainability into the World Trade Organization. It seemed a bit like the battle of David and Goliath. Nevertheless, I am firmly convinced: Just as environmental policy has managed to set standards with Rio and Agenda 21, environmental policymakers should not be afraid to participate in international organizations and to tackle the tough issues in order to ultimately achieve sustainable and compatible development.

I wish all those who bear responsibility today, especially you, dear Mr. Gabriel, and the employees of the Federal Ministry for the Environment, all the best, much strength, and not too much opposition – but enough that it is good for the environment. I know that this is necessary.