Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Association Conference of the Association of Municipal Enterprises e.V. on March 14, 2017, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

14 March 2017 · Association Conference of the Association of Municipal Enterprises e.V · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Association of Municipal Enterprises conference in Berlin on March 14, 2017, speaking on public services, digitalization, and energy policy under the motto 'A New Beginning in Public Services.'
Main themes
Public services, digitalization, energy transition, renewable energy policy, municipal enterprises, EEG amendments, affordability, planning security, tender system, local governance, public trust in politics, globalization and competition
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,727
90th percentile
Sentences
263
94th percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
2.90
33rd percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 27%27%
  • Institutional 23%22%
  • Environmental 21%21%
  • Technological 11%11%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Not in focus 0%

263 sentences in 50 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen from the family of municipal enterprises,

It can be said: The weather in Washington had a heart for the German municipal enterprises. So here I stand not in a snowstorm in Washington, but before you. I am truly delighted, because I know what is being accomplished at the municipal level, because I know what public services mean for the people in Germany, and because I also know the upheaval you are currently experiencing with your activities. The challenges are great, which is why it is truly important to me to speak to you today on these issues – under the motto "A New Beginning in Public Services."

The debate among you is primarily shaped by digitalization and the energy transition. We are, so to speak, constantly connected, because everything we pass in terms of laws in the areas of energy, water, and waste means new framework conditions for you each time; it means rethinking and adjusting again. This raises questions – whether fees will increase and what people on the ground will say.

I always say: The difference between local politicians, those who work at the municipal level, and federal politicians is that a federal politician is everywhere once, but nowhere consistently, while local politicians meet the people for whom they make decisions every morning at the bakery or in the evening over a beer, for whom they must justify their decisions locally and argue. That is precisely the source from which trust or distrust in politics arises. I just said to Katherina Reiche: "Actually, half the cabinet is here." Then she said: "What does that mean, half the cabinet?" – All those who make decisions for those present here, and that is indeed true.

I am pleased that you are fundamentally tackling the challenges you face with determination. We must continually create the right guidelines under changing framework conditions. The expectations of you are high, as the population wants affordable public services, but at the same time has high demands for quality. It is not the case that the energy transition, proper waste management, or clean water do not interest people.

First of all, I want to say: I explicitly commit – I think I can say this on behalf of the entire federal government – to the issue of public services. In globalization, we are constantly faced with the question of what must be subjected to pure competition and what has such broad significance that it is so important for the quality of life of people that we need other or additional standards than just cost-effectiveness. In this context, the protection of public services is a guideline that promises a certain protection, not to subject everything solely to efficiency – which, of course, on the other hand, is not a free pass for you to work as expensively as possible, you know that too. But this protection is important. We also advocate for it at the European level. Especially with regard to rural areas and demographic changes, its importance is growing and not diminishing. We are committed to this.

I want to start with energy policy. Things are constantly happening there, and you are affected by it. In this legislative period, we have passed two major amendments to the Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG): the amendments of 2014 and 2016. Given that renewable energies are now the most important pillar of our energy supply, we have tried to bring more predictability and reliability into the entire energy policy. This includes that we have agreed with the states on an expansion corridor of 40 to 45 percent for renewable energies by 2025. Such a stable expansion corridor is important. It means more planning security. Nevertheless, we know that we face significant difficulties if we do not underpin this expansion corridor with methods to ensure compliance, because the currently applicable EEG, which grants everyone a right to feed-in who invests in renewable energies, does not provide the planning certainty we need.

We therefore need supply security, system stability, affordability, and then the transition in energy supply towards more renewable energies. That is why the 2016 amendment, with the introduction of tenders for the majority of plants for generating renewable energies, is a paradigm shift, because from 2018 we will have a situation where quantities are tendered, which will greatly improve predictability.

Cost limitation is crucial for the acceptance of the energy transition. We believe that through tenders we will achieve more cost efficiency. We have conducted pilot tenders in the area of photovoltaic ground-mounted systems. We have gained interesting experiences from this. Initially, it was said: This will not yield anything; the quantity is far too small – just forget it. Interestingly, the tenders resulted in a price drop of 28 percent – from 9.17 cents per kilowatt-hour to 6.58 cents per kilowatt-hour. If this continues with other forms of energy, then I think that is quite impressive.

We also want to continue to have a broad energy generation mix, because we are keeping an eye on the target triangle of supply security, environmental compatibility, and affordability. We know that we cannot phase out certain energy forms overnight. I believe we must not constantly unsettle people. I think, for example, of Lusatia or North Rhine-Westphalia regarding lignite. We will have a step-by-step transition, but we cannot proceed too hastily. That would put entire regions in a completely unacceptable situation. – A few from Lusatia and North Rhine-Westphalia seem to be here. – But be supportive. Eventually, it will affect you too. Then it is always good to stick together.

A central challenge – as you know – lies in the expansion of the networks. This initially concerns the transmission networks. We need, especially in light of the wind expansion in the north, a faster network expansion from north to south. This is stalling, partly due to legal proceedings for which no public authority can be held responsible. Nevertheless, we need transmission lines, because electricity must go where it is needed.

We have already defined so-called electricity expansion areas, in which the tenders for renewable energies will take place to a lesser extent, in order to somewhat compensate for that. But especially with regard to offshore wind energy, it is urgently necessary that we get the north-south lines. We do not yet have sufficient synchronization of the expansion of renewable energies and the expansion of lines. That must simply be stated. Therefore, special attention must be paid to the expansion of lines, particularly with regard to transmission networks.

What sometimes gets a bit forgotten in the general political discussion is what is now also very much on your minds. These are the distribution networks, which are of great importance for municipal utilities and regional suppliers. Therefore, we fundamentally modernized the investment framework last year. You as operators should be able to make the necessary investments and refinance them in a timely manner.

With the law on the digitalization of the energy transition, we have also initiated the start for more intelligence in the grid. This will facilitate the management of the networks. We will then also have the opportunity to better enable consumers – keyword: "smart home" – to handle electricity efficiently and cost-effectively at home. Here we see that the digital transformation will gradually change the business models of the actors. This has been theoretically known for a long time. Practically, it has not yet been fully implemented. But the faster we do this, or the faster you do this, the more interesting and better it will go, and the more modern and cost-efficient we can also work.

I want to make an interjection here, which is not directly important for you now, but which is overall important for the country. We have achieved a significant point in the negotiations on federal-state finances from the federal perspective. We have agreed with the states that we will develop a citizen portal for every citizen, that is, a unified digital access to public administration. This will, of course, also include the municipalities in the next step. This will naturally also mean financial challenges. We will then have to respond to this on the federal side in the next legislative period. Every citizen, regardless of which service they use from the state, should have a unified internet access – a portal that they can work with and through which the services of the state are simply offered digitally.

Why do I mention this at this point? I say this because I believe that in a society that is becoming increasingly older due to demographic change, it is very important that the state also communicates with citizens within the framework of digital possibilities, because otherwise citizens will not have the right understanding of what is happening in terms of technological revolution. If I still have to fill everything out by hand, if I still have to go to the vehicle registration office and stand in line there, if I get an appointment at the citizens' office, and the only digital access is that I have to grab my appointment within three minutes, because otherwise nothing will be available until next month, then that is not an experience that citizens have with digitalization that makes them curious to continue. Therefore, I believe this will be very important. Thus, digitalization will not only occupy the large energy suppliers but will also be of great importance for you at the municipal level.

When we are on the topic of energy, I want to briefly mention the promotion of combined heat and power generation: We have doubled the maximum funding volume from 750 million euros to 1.5 billion euros per year. These were difficult parliamentary discussions. We also reached an agreement with the European Commission on this; that was not easy either. That we can maintain and further expand this efficient form of energy generation is therefore, I believe, rather good news for you.

With that, I am already at the topic of gas, because gas will continue to play an important role. We need baseload-capable forms of energy supply as we advance the expansion of renewable energies. The natural gas infrastructure is an important building block of our diversified energy supply in Germany. For more than 40 million people in Germany, natural gas serves as a source of heating. That is half of the population. Therefore, we must closely consider the feed-in of renewable energies and the gas sector.

With that, we are almost at the topic of climate protection. The Paris Agreement is known to you. We have a lot to do. The general international agreement is to limit global warming to no more than two degrees – better: no more than 1.5 degrees. That is the international goal, of course, also during our G20 presidency. However, there are also ambitious European targets: at least a 40 percent reduction in CO2 by 2030. For Germany, this applies already by 2020.

We have also achieved reasonably sensible agreements in Europe regarding emissions trading. The Environment Council has agreed to strengthen the instrument and accelerate the reduction of surpluses through the market stability reserve, so that we can achieve a reasonable price for CO2 sooner. In addition, we have had to strive and struggle to maintain the framework conditions for a competitive European economy. The benchmarks for free allocation should only be moderately reduced. This means that we have achieved good results for our economy.

However, there is still the allocation of the target in the area not covered by emissions trading. – We actually still have too many instruments. – We have, for example, the building sector and the transport sector, which are not covered by emissions trading. Other parts are covered by emissions trading. Therefore, we must again apply regulatory instruments or other instruments. Here we still need to manage the national allocation within the European Union, which will be quite challenging. But I believe you are interested in receiving a clear regulatory framework in this regard – especially concerning the building sector.

We have discussed a lot about the Climate Protection Plan 2050. This has been adopted, but it still has many elements that need to be discussed. I believe it was right not to set everything in stone yet, but to say: We need a discussion phase. I ask you to participate intensively in this. This also applies to the German economy. We must proceed together, as simply imposing requirements from above does not necessarily help everyone.

Our problem is – I think we need to make a decision on this in the next legislative period – that we always say: By 2050, we want to achieve a CO2 reduction of 80 to 95 percent in a technology-neutral and cost-efficient manner. But there is, of course, a big difference between 80 percent and 95 percent. Whether we align ourselves towards 95 percent or 80 percent by 2050 is a significant question. I do not want to preempt this discussion here, but in my view, it needs to be decided at the beginning of the next legislative period, as much depends on it. The next legislative period will extend beyond 2020. We then have about 30 years left. Thirty years is actually not much; it is the same period as from 1990 to 2020. Therefore, clarity needs to be established soon.

Now, of course, it is also about the question: What are you doing at the municipal level? Here, the member companies come into play quite concretely. They will also incorporate these targets into their work. This applies to renewable energies – there is still a lot of work ahead of us – but it also applies to other issues where we repeatedly set regulatory requirements, for example, for waste and wastewater.

But back to renewable energies: The vehicle fleet plays a huge role, of course. I want to briefly draw attention to this again. For example, I know that cities like Hamburg are already taking new paths regarding low emissions, air quality, and so on. This fundamentally also concerns the issue of CO2 emissions. I know that many municipalities are leading by example in this regard, with natural gas buses and much more. So I can only encourage you. When I see what, for example, Deutsche Post AG has done with its transport vehicles, I say: It is possible. Be pioneers in this field wherever it brings you joy. I believe it will pay off. We will also support you with our National Climate Protection Initiative.

One

keyword besides the vehicle fleet is the energy and resource efficiency of data centers, another is the beautiful LED technology. The street lamp of the future can do almost everything. It is just, I believe, a bit more expensive than the previous one, but otherwise, there are great models, as I see again and again at trade fairs. – Someone in the front is laughing, but that is the case. – I say: If you were to receive a lot of money from your municipalities, I would love to buy modern street lamps. Just think of all the things you can do with them. Of course, it is also about reducing greenhouse gas emissions in closed landfills. All of these are small contributions that will lead to much greater efficiency in total.

The

second

topic besides energy is water management. After a long discussion, we have changed the limits regarding nitrates in groundwater and amended the fertilizer law. That was an eternal discussion. The Bundestag has now passed it. The fertilizer regulation must also be adjusted according to the fertilizer law. There will also be new requirements for the storage of water-polluting substances. All three measures are expected to pass the Bundesrat by the end of the month. I believe this is fundamentally good news for you, as water quality will improve. Farmers will have a harder time with this; that is in the nature of things. However, I believe that water protection and clean drinking water are indeed important areas.

In the area of waste management, we have a new packaging law. To be honest, I do not know what you think about it. The joy is limited, right? Good. Well, take it as it is and comply with it. I say: Since my time as Minister of the Environment, so much has happened in the packaging world that I sometimes have difficulty keeping up. But you know all this, and you will also make it clear to the citizens how things have changed. This is also a communication task.

Now I come to something nice, namely the digital transformation. New data-driven business models and platforms are conquering the markets. I suspect that you are not entirely happy with everything, as some people are also taking shortcuts. Just platforms and marketing are a bit too little to ensure a sustainable energy supply and a sustainable water supply. I believe there are already first examples showing that people have learned that the cheapest provider is not always the most sustainable one. It is actually a nice example of public services in their entirety when one says: Okay, we want to have differentiated offers, but we also have to see that someone has to generate the energy and someone has to take care of the lines. We have the same situation in broadband supply, which I will address shortly.

Nevertheless, the value chains are changing. When we talk about Industry 4.0 – this also applies to "public services 4.0" – the following must be considered: One aspect is the digitization in the production of the product, such as in waste management, renewable energy generation, and water management; but the actual point, where we are not leading in Germany – even when I look at the economy as a whole – is that the relationship with the customer is being revolutionized. The customer is becoming more empowered, the customer expects a tailored, individualized offer in everything and anything. And the one who is first able to know the wishes of their customers and respond to them best knows how to manage digitization best.

Therefore, my heartfelt request is: Do not stop at digitizing production, generation, or management in your own company. That is important, that is self-evident, and we can do that quite well. But the actual point, where we are also competing with the Americans and Asians, is: Who knows the most about their customers? For example, if you look at the new models in public transport, you will find that it is very important to know a lot about your customers. Katherina Reiche was the first to ask about "door to door." This is now an example; I am not advertising for anyone, there may be other examples. But if you know the wishes of your customers – whether in the city or in rural areas – you will be able to meet these wishes in a truly revolutionary and more efficient manner. And then you will, for example, be the "front runners" in the question of mobility.

We need to go through this carefully and attentively: What stands in the way? If I think of a district or a city – there is, for example, public transport, there are collective agreements for bus drivers or tram drivers. And now someone comes in from the outside and says: Look, I will make it all very simple for you – between 8 PM and 5 AM, you do not need any of these large offers at all; you can do everything individually, and your people will be twice as happy. What do I say to the bus driver? How do I need to retrain him? Is he willing to drive a small van and only transport six people? How do I achieve flexibility?

My request is: We need to talk about this important topic with the trade unions as well. – The wrong person is sitting here right now, as this concerns Mr. Bsirske more. – But I mean this very seriously. If we take 20 years to restructure everything, private providers will come in and do everything somehow better. They will then be able to hire everyone because no one will use the bus that only comes every three or four hours or in the morning during school hours; and in the evening, when the child returns, the grandmother can also somehow go shopping again.

Doing this in such a way that people do not get scared, do not panic, and saying "Okay, we will go along with this" and from your companies saying "We care about each individual, we do not want to destroy jobs, we do not want wage dumping," will be, in my view, very, very important. – You are so quiet that I am getting quite restless, but I believe I am right. I am even quite sure that I am right.

Yesterday, someone from Thuringia told me at the trade fair in Munich what is not working in his industrial area and said that I should stop with my digital dreams because he first needs a broadband connection. That is true, which is why we have also launched a funding program and the so-called "DigiNetz" law – also a strange name – to better promote the expansion of fiber optics.

As you know, we have set the goal of 50 megabits per second for every household. However, that does not help you in an industrial area at all. The industrial areas must also be properly connected. Schools must also be connected – we will also address this. And the connection must be such that it reaches into the 5G generation and we can have real-time data transmission so that all the beautiful, modern technologies can actually be used. The bandwidth must be there so that in an industrial area, if there is a school next door, one does not only have access to the internet for a few hours but has permanent and reliable access. The federal government will spend an additional four billion euros by 2019 to promote expansion in rural areas. By the middle of the next decade, we must then move into the gigabit region – and as quickly as possible.

We have an ambivalent relationship with large amounts of data in Germany. Constitutional jurisprudence has always emphasized data economy with regard to data protection, but what digitization requires from us is actually data abundance. The better you, as municipal companies, know the data and wishes of your customers, the more you can do with it. Of course, this must happen on a legal basis, but do not hesitate to really get to know the wishes of your customers. Because this is the starting point for new business models that you can utilize. At the same time, one must also ensure that there is no misuse of this data. Many citizens can indeed benefit from providing their data to private providers. In a private car, in the future, one will almost provide everything about their behavior to the car manufacturer. However, the question still arises as to who owns what.

But you should not hesitate, because your future business models are all the better the better you know your customers. You are locally based and have good opportunities and good relationships to talk to your customers about this. I would proceed very transparently and, if I were to develop new public transport models or "smart grids," I would hold town hall meetings, talk a lot with the citizens – I believe you are already doing this – and build trust.

I do not know if there are any of your start-up companies that deal with the topic of security. We have incredible opportunities today to paralyze infrastructures through cyberattacks. This is, of course, very, very difficult concerning public services. There are already examples from Ukraine that are truly frightening, which is why cybersecurity is of utmost importance.

The federal government has therefore updated the cybersecurity strategy. We are very willing to cooperate with municipalities in this regard, to inform them, to provide them with our knowledge. Do not hesitate to report anything that seems suspicious to the Federal Office for Information Security. It is essential to inform about this, as otherwise entire areas can be paralyzed. Therefore, from our perspective, the quality feature "IT Security made in Germany" is an important quality feature. We also deploy mobile teams to respond immediately to attacks when they occur, to learn from them repeatedly.

Now, the question is: How do we take care of the municipalities? When we are not enacting nice laws like the ones I have just outlined, the financial resources of the municipalities are also very important to us. This is of great significance for you, as capable municipalities are a prerequisite for you to be able to work properly, to have satisfied customers, to have district councils and city parliaments that can also make reasonable decisions. Therefore, we have done various things. You know that we have taken over the costs of basic security in old age and for reduced earning capacity. We will give municipalities shares in the topic of integration because the integration costs in the municipalities are rising massively. There is the Municipal Investment Promotion Fund for financially weak municipalities. There will also be support in connection with refugees.

However, it must be said that the path from the federal level to the municipal level is a long and winding one, because the municipal financial equalization laws of the states are highly diversified. For example, when we say, "We are giving the municipalities four billion euros," and add up what ultimately comes out for the municipalities, there is likely to be some kind of gap. However, such gaps are also legitimate. It is not the case that one can blame anyone. But understanding the winding paths of the municipal financial equalization mechanisms of the individual states is really difficult, also because different principles are applied in the process.

Therefore, it is not easy for the federal government. We practically have no way to give money directly to the municipalities—except in relation to housing costs (KdU). But mostly everything goes through shares of value-added tax, and these shares are always somehow offset. We will take another look in connection with the federal-state financial equalization starting in 2020, so that when the states receive so much more, this also has value for the municipalities—that funds are not simply claimed by the states and, if necessary, municipal financial equalization laws are changed. There are always representatives of the states in the room. Therefore, it makes no sense to incite each other against one another. I just believe that we need more transparency; that is part of honesty. The diversity of our federalism system leads to the fact that the circumstances are simply different. But it must be clear what comes out of it, because otherwise we create dissatisfaction—because otherwise, when we talk to the municipalities and think we are doing something good, something completely different happens than we thought. We still need to work on that, because it is important.

I would like to conclude with two things. First, a thank you. Everyone who works at the municipal level has done an incredible amount in connection with the additional task of receiving refugees, especially in 2015, but of course also into 2016—voluntarily, professionally, and to the limit of their capacity. A heartfelt thank you for that. It was anything but a given.

If you need curious young people among the refugees for your municipal companies, do not hesitate to take the effort to prepare them, to make them open-minded. In my speech manuscript, there is an example of companies from Dresden that do this. I believe that this is not the only example. It is worth investing in the future of these people, if they have a right of residence with us.

Overall, therefore, a heartfelt thank you. We can make laws, we can provide money. But you play a significant role in ensuring that all of this contributes to a quality life for the citizens. Therefore, I thank you once again for your daily work, which significantly shapes the lives of people in Germany.

Thank you very much for the invitation.