Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the BDI Infrastructure Conference "Network Industries in the 21st Century – Quality of Life, Security, Prosperity" on May 26, 2008, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

26 May 2008 · BDI Infrastructure Conference "Network Industries in the 21st Century – Quality of Life, Security, Prosperity" · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the BDI Infrastructure Conference in Berlin on May 26, 2008, speaking on the role of network industries in sustaining Germany's economic competitiveness in the 21st century.
Main themes
Infrastructure networks, private initiative and open markets, social market economy, globalization and competitiveness, investment in modernization, competitive framework conditions, broadband and telecommunications, energy sector reliability, transport infrastructure, privatization policy, Germany as export champion, cross-departmental policy coordination
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,232
87th percentile
Sentences
232
92nd percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.82
24th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
26th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 64%58%
  • Institutional 16%15%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Not in focus 9%

232 sentences in 48 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Thumann,

ladies and gentlemen!

I am very pleased to have come to this conference because I believe, and I would like to emphasize this with my presence – which, so to speak, has made it a top priority – that the topic of infrastructure networks is a central issue for a modern industrial society.

I hesitated a bit earlier when you suggested that we write a new report that should not create any additional bureaucracy. Perhaps the BDI could create such a report and show us how to achieve that without bureaucracy. I believe that would be the very best. The VDA, the energy suppliers, and the telecommunications companies would certainly have a great interest in that, and we would be happy to take note of it. – I don’t mean that in a negative way. However, I do mean that it is not that simple.

Nevertheless, I am very glad to be here. I believe the matter of the wake-up call is also correct. What I particularly appreciate about the topic is that we gain a cross-departmental view of the lifelines of our modern society.

I have already made it clear at a congress on the logistics industry: Things are interconnected to a large extent today. The attractiveness of a business location is no longer defined solely by the road, the port, or the railway, but the elements are interlinked. For example, transport routes are connected with internet and data processing structures, thus with highways in another form. Especially in the energy sector, we face a significant task and very large challenges.

We may not be good enough yet, but we are not bad either. We have a rail network of nearly 40,000 kilometers in length. We have 50,000 kilometers of highways and federal roads. The number of broadband connections has now grown to 20 million – with a quite significant gradient. In terms of the reliability of power grids, we are leaders in Europe. Power outages in this country average around 22 minutes per electricity customer per year. The EU average is over 120 minutes. This is just to point out where we stand.

We are firmly convinced that high-performance infrastructures are a prerequisite for smooth production and rapid transport of goods worldwide. They are also a prerequisite for the reliability of producers towards their customers. Without a reasonable infrastructure, Germany could not have become the world champion in exports, nor can Germany maintain a leading position in exports.

When we talk about the opportunities of globalization and if we want to take advantage of them, it also means that we need to create a completely new understanding of the interconnection of infrastructures extending into the political sphere, as well as into the economic and social spheres. This needs to be worked on. Thus, you have indeed focused on the right topic.

What do we need to consider from a political perspective? Of course, financial resources – I will say something about that at the end – are very important. Without them, little can be achieved. However, I believe it is also about three points that I would like to discuss in a comprehensive manner. It is about strengthening private structures and competitive conditions. Furthermore, it is about creating reliable framework conditions for the network industries. This includes, of course, the financial question, but also many other questions. Additionally, it is about advancing investments in modernization, whereby today investments in modernization are not always just about money. For example, coal-fired power plants could be built. However, they are not being built. Power lines could be constructed. Often, however, that takes too long. This means we often have a web of conditions that need to be improved.

Let me briefly explain these three points.

First:

I believe that wherever possible, we should give priority to private initiative and open markets. I say this especially in the 60th year of the social market economy. The priority for private economic engagement is, of course, a cornerstone of our economic system. That is why we have – and this is very much understood in the context of social change – pursued a privatization policy.

When the current president of the VDA was still the Minister of Transport, we talked about the privatization of airports. We discussed how we could privatize in other areas as well. The major privatizations in the telecommunications sector have enabled us to meet today’s investment requirements. The privatizations in the railway sector have occupied us and will continue to do so.

We must note that concerns about privatizations have increased, and internationally, experiences have been made that serve as warning signals against pure privatization. I think, for example, of the repurchase of the British government’s railway network. Privatization must be accompanied by a very balanced set of state framework conditions. Because ultimately – this is also a core component of the social market economy – orderly competition is the interesting question. What does this competitive order look like in the infrastructure sector? This concerns us today and will continue to concern us in the future.

The experiences in the telecommunications sector are clear evidence that we are on the right track. Of course, Deutsche Telekom still has a dominant market position in various sub-markets. Of course, we could not immediately release employees from state conditions into the conditions of the free market. This means that we had to manage very difficult transitional processes. I want to say at this point that they have been managed to a large extent in the spirit of the social market economy in Germany, both at the railway and telecommunications sectors as well as at the post office. For this, a heartfelt thank you goes to both those who lead the companies and the works councils.

I return to telecommunications. The successes are obvious. Among the new telecommunications service providers, at least 50,000 new jobs have been created. Further jobs have been created in the very dynamically developing supply industries. The fact that this was possible for us – I often say this and want to remind you of it once again – is also due to smart framework setting. For example, the mobile communications sector was able to develop very quickly in Germany and Europe due to the forward-looking decisions of the then Post Minister Schwarz-Schilling, because the radio network frequencies were uniformly distributed and no patchwork was created.

Mr. Thumann rightly spoke about the 59 regulatory areas of the "Single European Sky." But, of course, there are also vested interests behind that. Dear Mr. Thumann, I will take you to a negotiation once. Then you will see that it is not only the will of the federal government that is lacking, but that the various cultural conditions of 27 member states collide. But the goal must, of course, not be lost sight of, and it is completely clear.

We have experienced during the privatization how the prices for telephone calls have fallen and how various services have developed. In connection with the abolition of the letter monopoly, where we still have a huge task ahead of us in Europe – this is so to speak an invisible infrastructure – we have repeatedly discussed: What actually happens when monopolies are abolished? There are then statements like: A letter must always be delivered from A to B, and it does not matter who does it. But it does matter. Because under the conditions of freedom and competition, completely new market segments and new products suddenly emerge. It unleashes creativity. What was previously unimaginable suddenly becomes possible. This means we must not think statically in this regard.

However, regarding the noticeable improvement in the quality of networks and the double-digit growth rates of broadband connections, I want to say: We have a structural problem with these rapidly changing infrastructure tasks between urban areas and metropolitan regions on one side and rural areas on the other. I would like to point out once again: 50 percent of the people in Germany live in rural areas. Ensuring connections there is a task where the state can also provide assistance. But it is also a task for private providers to keep life in rural areas attractive. I predict to you: If our society is only organized in metropolitan areas, it will lead to serious secondary damages that we will all have to deal with. Therefore, there is much to be said for engaging strongly in this area.

It is therefore, I believe, undisputed that we have successes in the telecommunications sector. And we want to use this positive experience now in the railway sector. You have all followed the discussion. We have made some progress. We will soon involve private investors with 24.9 percent in the transport and logistics sector of Deutsche Bahn AG. I believe we can first say that with this step towards privatization in the railway sector, where the federal government still holds 100 percent of the shares in all areas, much has already been set in motion.

You can see at the railway, so to speak, exemplarily what kind of rethinking is taking place. On one side, there is the question of regional transport – understandable and tangible for everyone – and on the other side, there is the question posed to Mr. Mehdorn regarding the corporate strategy – I have not seen him here; he is probably busy with his global task, and I say this with great respect – who is now positioning the railway as an international logistics company and who is, of course, repeatedly asked questions like: Why do you have to be in the Emirates, and what does the port in Slovenia have to do with you?

We are learning painstakingly, so to speak "bottom-up," how logistics is developing today and how it is important today to have the right port connection, the right rail connection, and the right truck connection to be able to assemble completely new companies, as the post office has done with DHL. That is why we have said at the railway: Now 24.9 percent will go to private investors – we are taking a continuous path – while the network, stations, and energy are held 100 percent by the DB AG holding owned by the federal government. However, we will look at what new opportunities arise.

The debts of the railway have, if you think back 20 years or to the beginning of the 1990s, continuously increased despite high federal subsidies. The railway did not improve by accumulating debt. However, this has changed significantly since we embarked on the path of privatization. The increase in debt no longer exists. We now have the opportunity to use what the state provides in funding for the expansion of infrastructure. We spend 2.5 billion euros per year for this – one could say that it could be more; however, the market shares of the railway have certainly increased again in recent years – and we also provide the states with six billion euros to maintain the possibility of regional transport. This should not be forgotten here either. The possibility of using public transport to get to work is crucial for millions of people.

Second

, we need a reliable framework for investments in the networks. In this regard, I say, also in light of our discussion with the European Union, where it is not 100 percent clear how far the influence of a unified internal market in the infrastructure sector extends and how far – I say this particularly in relation to the current discussions about the electricity and gas networks – national regulations can be implemented: In the energy sector, Mr. Thumann, we are completely in agreement. We need a reliable energy mix in Germany. I am absolutely of the opinion that an industrial country like Germany – we do, of course, have a unified European market or are working towards it – should fundamentally produce the electricity it needs itself; a country like Germany certainly should. This is best achieved on the basis of an energy mix. This energy mix will change over time.

When we talk about energy mix and electricity consumption, we should never forget that energy saving is still one of the best ways. But anyone who believes they can simultaneously phase out coal and nuclear energy makes Germany irresponsibly dependent on foreign energy suppliers, harms the economy, and does absolutely no good to this country. I want to state this explicitly.

The discussion has changed dramatically in recent years; it has become psychologically very different and extends far beyond the spectrum of a single party, for example, there are reservations against nuclear power plants, but above all, and increasingly, against coal-fired power plants. We have positioned ourselves very clearly on this issue – you mentioned the Lubmin topic. But you have an audience to which you must answer, which goes far beyond the voter base of a single party. We must face this, and that means engaging in a reasonable discussion mode and countering arguments. One cannot simply say: This is how it will be, end of discussion. It is not that simple anymore, as municipal planning authorities and many other factors can significantly prolong the processes. Political determination alone is therefore no longer sufficient.

I believe we need to consider how we handle the networks overall. You mentioned that we should create a law to accelerate the planning of network infrastructure in the electricity sector. It is true that underground cables are expensive. On the other hand, we must always find a balance in the discussion with the people. We now need to consider whether we want to conduct pilot projects in the area of underground cables and whether we want to save an instance in the judicial complaint options. This could prove to be more sensible in some areas than trying to force everything through the air, while all possibilities for planning delays remain.

We are currently having this discussion within the federal government. I think we will reach a reasonable compromise in connection with the climate package. We must, because our network infrastructure is at risk due to an incredible shift in the locations of electricity generation, which today, due to renewable energies, are often further away from the locations of electricity consumption than they used to be. In the past, a power plant was placed next to a large industrial facility, and that worked reasonably well. With renewable energies, you cannot do that in urban areas. Therefore, we have a huge task ahead of us regarding network infrastructure.

This coincides with a contentious discussion with the EU Commission. The Commission believes that a European internal market in the field of electricity generation can only be guaranteed if the generation and transport of electricity – similar rules should apply to gas – are strictly separated in terms of ownership. I have had numerous discussions with the Commission about this, and others are doing the same. We have proposed a compromise model in which we say: Yes to transparency, but we cannot see why a situation with four or perhaps only two providers for electricity generation – there are no merger plans, this is just a model case – and perhaps one that operates the network should automatically be associated with more competition than if a multitude of providers both generate electricity and provide networks.

I do not believe that the European Commission can intervene in traditionally grown structures here. It should demand transparency, but it should not impose the most detailed regulations on us in these matters, which would not lead to a unified European energy market for a long time. I can explain and illustrate the many obstacles to a unified European energy market. Given these obstacles, we are better advised to first build a few interconnectors at the borders and ensure that we can cross the Pyrenees and do not always have to take the detour through France to get to Italy. This would already facilitate the formation of a unified electricity price.

There are also interesting questions about how the regulatory authorities should operate. I find this question really exciting. Because at the moment when there is more transparency in the networks, a regulatory authority, like the one we have that is now also dealing with the energy sector, must practically determine which return expectations are still legitimate and which are not. This brings us to a very interesting point: Who still invests in areas that are so regulated that state bodies decide how much return one can get and how much one cannot? We are currently in a very exciting learning process. It must not be the case that due to excessive transparency, no investor can be found to make the investments. Because if the state also has to invest in the electricity grid, even less will come out for the roads. Therefore, I can only advise against that. We must maintain private engagement here. Of course, one must give operators certain competitive leeway and cannot assume a uniform regulation.

When I was Minister of the Environment and we passed the energy reform, the then Minister of Economics, Rexrodt, believed that everything could be achieved through self-regulation. However, there is hardly anyone left who says that it can be done without a regulatory authority. In the rail and telecommunications sectors, it has proven effective for a neutral body to keep an eye on the competitive situation. We have now extended this to the electricity sector. Long story short: We are currently negotiating a so-called third way in Europe, where we have more leeway. I am for absolute transparency, I am also for regulation. However, I am not in favor of a form of regulation that repels investors and ultimately leads to a standstill in certain investment areas.

I believe I do not need to give you long lectures on the advantages of modern power plants. If we can no longer manage to build modern coal-fired power plants, it will also lead to our export product power plants no longer being in demand as they once were. The efficiencies – as Mr. Thumann has said – have dramatically increased in coal-fired power plants. The possibilities of combined heat and power generation and many other technical options should be utilized. We must not forget: Energy generation from coal currently covers about 25 percent of global energy consumption. It accounts for 40 percent of international electricity generation. The energy source coal is available worldwide, it is easy to store, and it has remained relatively price-stable to this day. This will continue to be the case due to its high availability. If we look at the developments in the oil and gas markets, we see that this also provides a degree of stability in the energy sector. I believe we can make good use of that.

Therefore, and also for climate protection reasons, our goal must be not only to have the most modern coal-fired power plants in Germany where necessary but also to advocate for this in emerging countries and to lead the existing coal-fired power plants and new constructions as quickly as possible in the right and most efficient direction. However, if we have discussions about whether to upgrade an older power plant to a newer one, it will be much more difficult to convince emerging countries that this is urgently necessary.

There are methods for CO2 separation and storage. These will bring about entirely different infrastructure problems. Here, too, it is the case that the storage spaces in Germany are more likely to be located where the large power plant capacities are not present. As someone who has at least dabbled in physical chemistry – I am a physicist – I find it intellectually very unsatisfactory to separate CO2 and just store it somewhere. One always thinks that one must be able to do something with it. If nature can do it, then humans must also be able to manage it somehow. This means I strongly advise – as many companies in the international arena do – to consider how to catalytically or otherwise convert CO2 to create something useful from it again. Storage alone will not be the answer to the problems of CO2 reduction. Just a side note.

In all matters concerning the Renewable Energy Sources Act, the Combined Heat and Power Act, and the Renewable Energy Heat Act, we continue to work and strive to achieve an optimum of innovation, efficiency, and CO2 reduction.

Third:

Preservation and modernization of the networks.

Of course, all – federal, state, municipal, and corporate – must meet this requirement. The federal government set itself the task of "Renovating, Investing, Reforming" at the beginning of the legislative period – we have not given that up. For us, these are not contradictions. However, it is automatically the case that when there are higher growth rates, there is more leeway, and certain tasks can be fulfilled more easily.

We have invested a lot in the networks, especially in transport infrastructure. At the latest since the 1990s, the federal transport infrastructure plan has been underfunded. I have not given up on this either – I want to expressly assure you of my support – that we make better progress with public-private partnership projects.

The number of legal questions that arise in this context – one must not underestimate what is pending in Germany, especially regarding public constructions that are privately used – as well as the questions of implicit burdens on households cannot be completely ignored. We have a great interest in not always discussing new attractive shadow budgets.

Mr. Thumann, I am on your side: We must focus our priorities on investment tasks. Therefore, we believe that the fight against unemployment is paramount, where we must not make mistakes. The poverty and wealth report that was recently debated and which we will return to in the cabinet in June is a report that includes statistics up to 2005, so it does not pertain to this legislative period. It states that the greatest danger of poverty arises from long-term unemployment. Long-term unemployment must be combated. The more the overall unemployment figures decrease, this remains our problem because the less qualified are more difficult to reintegrate into the labor process. Therefore, everything must be done to increase the opportunities for advancement for those who have not had a share in it for years. This is why there are heated debates within the federal government about the question of a uniform statutory minimum wage, as this can block more than it opens up opportunities.

I say this because at the moment we achieve this, the additional wage costs can decrease. The possibilities for reductions in unemployment insurance are mainly caused by the better revenue situation and the lower number of unemployed – partly also due to structural measures, but much more due to the decreasing number of unemployed. We must push this path forward so that we can be in a position to spend more in the investment area.

Mr. Thumann cleverly asked where the 107 billion euros are. I cannot yet provide a conclusive account of that. I just want to say: We have already spent a few billion euros on the corporate tax reform. We have set ourselves an investment program of 25 billion euros over the four years, from depreciation regulations to many other things. We are spending six billion euros more on research and innovation. Not everything is being consumed or stashed away in the cracks and crevices of the federal government; we have made significant progress. I can understand your admonition that this is still not enough.

This is not the only point concerning infrastructures. It is about a modern understanding. It is about removing obstacles to creating modern infrastructure. It is about providing the financial means, which are partly of a private nature. This is exciting. Today we are talking about three infrastructure areas. In telecommunications, almost everything is invested privately, except for support measures in rural areas. In transport infrastructure, the railways are still largely funded by public budgets, but the transport mode itself is being renewed privately. I need a decent train that runs on a decent track. There are the roads, where we largely work in the public sector except for the truck toll. Here, we must also see that beyond tunnels and bridges, we need to achieve more public-private partnerships in the long run.

In this regard, I would like to extend a heartfelt thank you to the BDI once again. Because this is a topic that quickly falls by the wayside at all annual congresses, as the focus tends to shift to wage supplementary costs, tax frameworks, and the labor market. However, I believe – as evidenced by the number of attendees here – that this topic is of the utmost importance. I also find it extremely exciting because it continually forces us to think completely anew: in the transition from state structures to private ones, in many questions – What does the regulatory framework look like? Where are we overregulating? Where are we underregulating? – in the division of responsibility and in international networking. If you present us with a small report in two or three years, I would be happy to come back and discuss it with you.