Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the CDU/CSU Parliamentary Group Congress "Germany 4.0" on June 28, 2017, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

2 July 2017 · CDU/CSU Parliamentary Group Congress "Germany 4.0" · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the CDU/CSU Parliamentary Group Congress "Germany 4.0" in Berlin on June 28, 2017, outlining Germany's digital transformation agenda.
Main themes
Digitalization, Germany 4.0, digital infrastructure and broadband expansion, industry 4.0, e-health and telemedicine, autonomous driving, education and digital skills, rural connectivity, public-private cooperation, artificial intelligence, economic competitiveness, societal transformation
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,489
81st percentile
Sentences
197
89th percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
10.8
30th percentile
Syntax
2.92
37th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
11th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 37%36%
  • Technological 22%21%
  • Institutional 18%17%
  • Social 14%13%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

197 sentences in 36 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Parliamentary Group Leader, dear Volker Kauder,

dear Michael Fuchs,

dear colleagues,

dear guests of this congress,

when I show up at the end, usually everything has already been said – moreover, by those who are more knowledgeable than I can be. So my presence is essentially to show that the question, which also determines the prosperity of tomorrow, namely how we deal with digitalization, is a matter for the top leadership. This question has been taken up by us as the federal government and the supporting factions, in this case the CDU/CSU parliamentary group, as a major focus in this legislative period. This topic will also shape the next legislative period.

For years, the abbreviation "4.0" has been associated with the term industry. But I find it very good, dear Michael Fuchs, that this congress is aimed at placing "Germany 4.0" at the center. This means nothing other than that digitalization permeates all areas of life and brings about changes that cannot all be discussed within the framework of such a congress. There are a multitude of societal changes in our entire communication behavior. One only has to look at people around a dining table: they look at their plates, occasionally talk to the person next to them, but much also happens with third parties who are not at the table. This is just a small facet of what is happening.

I still remember quite well when we launched the "Platform Industry 4.0." That was at the Hannover Messe in 2015. India was our partner country. At that time, there was already talk of the "Digital India" campaign, which was driving digital transformation in India. We have caught up in many areas over the past few years. We have established a working process for this. These are the so-called IT summits, now called Digital Summits, which we hold every year. In various working groups, we identify upcoming problems together with the economy and develop solutions for them. By the way, this is a form of cooperation that we do not know from the classic interaction between associations and politics. Normally, we politicians go to large congresses where we are told what is expected, and we tell the economy what we expect from it. But here – I may no longer use the term "new territory" – we are venturing into the unknown, so to speak. We are developing solutions together. In this process, everyone relies on the other to keep up, because on the one hand, guidelines are needed, but on the other hand, not everything can be barricaded.

At this year's Digital Summit, we focused on the topic of e-health, that is, health and digitalization. The health minister promises me and keeps telling me that we are now experiencing a breakthrough with the health card. So I will no longer talk about how long it has taken. However, I believe that a lot has already changed in the healthcare sector. The opportunities that telemedicine brings for the care of rural areas are evident. Medical treatment will become much more precise because access to data will be faster and easier, and consulting specialists will be much simpler. Surgical techniques are now highly connected with digitalization. When looking at endoscopic procedures, one knows that artificial intelligence will play a huge role here. So there is a great deal of dynamism in this area.

We must first address digital infrastructure, because where it does not exist, opportunities in the field of digitalization cannot be utilized. We have made good progress, but we do not rank particularly well in some statistics because our fiber optic cabling is still relatively low. Nevertheless, we will achieve our goal of connecting every household in Germany with 50 megabits per second next year. We have a program for targeted broadband expansion in rural areas; that is, where we assume that development is not economically viable. After all, we have the constitutional mandate to ensure equal living conditions throughout Germany, which must also be taken seriously at this point.

We will have to ensure the availability of gigabit broadband everywhere between 2018 and 2023 until 2025. From today's perspective, this is still a huge task. It is not only about residential areas, but also about commercial zones. The infrastructure minister, Alexander Dobrindt, has now also made commitments in this regard. In the next legislative period, there will also be a stronger focus on connecting schools. The keyword "education" has already been mentioned; I want to pick that up again. It will also be about ensuring the availability of high bandwidths along existing infrastructures when we think of applications such as autonomous driving.

Four billion euros are currently being made available for broadband expansion. This money is flowing well. New commitment authorizations had to be given. There is a high willingness among local officials in the municipalities and districts to take on this issue because everyone feels: broadband connection is a location factor that will decide many things.

Alexander Dobrindt, as minister, founded the "Network Alliance Digital Germany." We will launch the "Future Offensive Gigabit Germany," as I have already mentioned. The technical standard 5G plays a crucial role in this. It will also be about creating a digital internal market in Europe and having cross-border digital bandwidths available, for example, if we want to make progress with autonomous driving and not want to run aground at every border crossing.

The Network Alliance provides for 100 billion euros in investments for the entire period from 2014 to 2023. We now need to ensure that our planning and construction capacities do not become completely overheated, as this would lead to price increases that we cannot afford. In this respect, the question of planning necessities and planning capacities in many investment areas is therefore very crucial.

We need the 5G standard and we need gigabit availability because we need real-time availability. Not only will people be connected – that has already happened to some extent – but things will also increasingly connect with each other. That is why we speak of the "Internet of Things." Things will communicate with each other – for example, in production, logistics, and ideally in real-time in autonomous driving. We are actually already moving to the next level. "Industry 4.0" is one thing – digital manufacturing, digital development. At the next level, it will increasingly be about what can be replaced by robotics or done in cooperation with humans. The question of how intelligent robots can become – that is, the topic of artificial intelligence – will shape the coming time.

With regard to consumer applications, the question already arises: Do I even need to write at some point, or can it already be recognized when I think about what I want? There are some very interesting things. Concentrated thinking can already lead to reactions from "digital entities," as I will now call them. They sometimes get human names and respond to them. A lot is happening in this area. In addition to automatic translation programs, there are also logical sequences of certain commands and then the ability to learn from mistakes. All of these are things that not only play a role in chess computers but go far beyond that.

For us, given an industrial value-added share of over 20 percent, it is crucial that we integrate digital development into real economic value creation – hence this effort in connection with Industry 4.0. The crucial interface will increasingly be the one between the producer and the consumer, that is, the customer: B2C or C2B – customer to business. This is where the innovation leaders from the consumer sector meet the innovation leaders in the production sector. All German industrial companies must understand that their relationship with the customer will change completely. Those who know everything about the customer and their wishes in internet companies will also be able to obtain individual offers from anywhere, which could turn our industrial companies into an extended workbench. However, an extended workbench knows much less value-added returns than one that has the entire chain under control. This means I must know my customers, I must do something with the consumer behavior of my customers, and I must offer my customers exciting, good offers.

The exciting, good offers will not solely be a great car model or a great train vehicle. Customers will rather ask: I want to go from A to B; who has the platform that opens the way for me to get from A to B efficiently and well, and through which my special requests are taken into account, for example, if I want to drive a piece on the highway and perhaps ride a piece on a bicycle. It is therefore about offering all possibilities of mobility, so to speak. I suspect that there will be certain platforms that will not only offer mobility options but also gifts for visiting relatives and even manage my account.

Is the German economy ready to think from the customer's perspective, to create such platforms, and to network with each other in such a way that inclusive offers can be made? A question I have only recently come to is: Is our antitrust law actually set up to allow us to do that? I believe this will be one of the most pressing questions, as it also concerns agreements that are actually illegal in the classical sense of German antitrust law. It is worth it – perhaps also a suggestion for economic policymakers for the upcoming parliamentary recess – to take a look at what cases the antitrust office currently has regarding such agreements. I believe we need to think about new approaches.

So, for the German economy – machinery, automotive, and chemical industries, to name just three keywords – a lot is at stake. In the automotive industry, we have the situation that we essentially have three revolutions happening at once, intertwined: At the moment autonomous driving becomes more relevant, the question of car ownership and the question of the type of engine will also gain a new quality, especially in urban traffic. Because in autonomous driving, for example, the question of whether I am the first to leave the intersection and whether the acceleration is particularly high is no longer so relevant. Rather, the optimization question arises: how do I get from A to B the fastest and safest overall, and no longer the question of who gets through intersection one, two, or three the fastest. This means the premises will change completely. Therefore, we must link these three revolutions well together. Above all, we as a population must be curious about these revolutions; that is also a point. Because those who live with good products in a state of advanced saturation always run the risk of not being curious about quality leaps. Therefore, we must observe very closely what is happening elsewhere and how we can keep up with new developments.

We must not only provide the classic medium-sized businesses with a good production environment but also create an environment for innovations for start-ups, which often approach things with a completely different philosophy. In this legislative period, we have achieved a lot in hard battles. The issue of tax loss offsetting is one where it is hard to grasp how many people have spent how many hours until a distinction was found from the classic medium-sized company. However, I believe that we have now set signals with better financing options to promote the start-up culture and also to take risks. You have just spoken about the culture of failure. I do not know, Mr. Pfeiffer, whether failure should be tax-privileged right away, but it must not be culturally punished at all; rather, there must be founder loans for several attempts. One must not have jeopardized one's entire fate at once. That is definitely clear.

We certainly need to define strategic areas once again in which we can permanently preserve the opportunities of digitalization. In the European Union, we have what you might call strategic sectors where we are not obliged to comply with all state aid rules. We have tried this for the first time in the field of microelectronics because we have almost no chip production left in Europe, but have delivered well over 50 percent of the machines that produce chips to the Asian region, where chips are produced with European machines. One can calculate that those who produce chips will, after a decade or at some point, also be able to produce the machines for that purpose. Then all our know-how would be gone. That is why we, together with the Netherlands and France and also with the help of EU funds, have made strategic investments. This has, for example, led to investments by Bosch in Dresden. Globalfoundries would also not be as active in Dresden if this had not been pursued very decisively and strategically.

The question we face is: Should we also consider this for battery and cell manufacturing; do we need this in the field of artificial intelligence? I answer the question regarding artificial intelligence with a clear yes. We need to work on that. As for cell manufacturing, I am not sure. The domestic automotive industry has certainly not decided to demand this from us. And imposing something politically against economic wishes would also be a strange thing. We would need signals from the economy to really make progress in this area.

I have briefly touched on the topic of education. There is, of course, a great deal to be done. This applies first and foremost to the education of those who are young and going to school. Recently, I had the group of award winners from "Jugend forscht" visiting me. The question of who is satisfied with the digital equipment in their own school was answered with yes by two percent, but 98 percent of those present said no. Something needs to happen. Perhaps the most complicated aspect is that we need to quickly advance the further training of teachers, including vocational school teachers, to be able to offer digital instruction at all. The federal government can provide a cloud for teaching content. The federal government can connect the schools. The states can distribute tablets. None of this is necessarily the problem. The problem is that the corresponding willingness, self-confidence, and drive must also be present among the teaching staff to really push this forward. Universities and technical colleges will also need to open up more. We also need more targeted career counseling. Furthermore, we need to develop professions in the dual training sector that correspond to the digital age. I must say, the shortage of skilled workers is particularly threatening in the IT sector. Therefore, targeted advertising for such professions must be done, as we cannot outsource IT tasks indefinitely. The security interests of medium-sized companies will lead to the necessity of having skilled workers in the company and not being able to leave IT security tasks to others somewhere in the world. Therefore, there is also a very significant focus there.

The question of changes in employment also arises – for example, from the perspective of an employee at DHL, at Deutsche Post. Do the blessings of ordering options at Amazon and elsewhere look like a fate that means parking in the third lane, quickly going up three flights of stairs, down three flights of stairs, meeting people, not meeting people? There is already a lot of pressure. The question of how we can take people along will be a very, very big task. This will be determined by the extent to which it will be possible to create other, new jobs in sufficient numbers in Europe and in Germany for jobs that are disappearing in certain areas. I believe – and studies from the Institute for Employment Research at the Federal Employment Agency also indicate this – that fundamentally, the number of employees will not decrease, but the nature of employment will change.

We now need to create a new environment for dealing with large amounts of data. We need an appropriate regulatory framework so that this is not outsourced. After long discussions, we have made a first attempt with the General Data Protection Regulation. However, it remains to be hoped that, given the multitude of indeterminate legal terms, these will not all have to be clarified through legal proceedings. That is why, at the last Digital Summit in Ludwigshafen, we considered whether we could develop model applications of this General Data Protection Regulation for certain industries in Germany – together with companies and perhaps also as a Franco-German project, in order to define a level playing field for Europe, so that perhaps courts could also somewhat align with this interpretation.

So, as

First

, it is about the willingness, creativity, and possibilities to create new applications from large amounts of data. This will also determine whether we can maintain customer relationships. As

Second

, it is about making skilled workers who today work with machining technology fit for completely different tasks in this area. Creating the appropriate conditions for this, without making it too centralized and rigid, will be one of the major tasks. If I simply say: "Everyone has a legal right to further training," that does not necessarily lead in the right direction. I experienced this during German reunification. In the end, we had an almost endless number of florists, but hardly anyone who had the purchasing power to buy flowers. So, this must go together sensibly. This will be one of the major tasks, in which social partnership can also play a role.

I have heard the keyword working hours. That is a very sensitive keyword. We must not have only individual self-employed people who are not bound by any working hours, but we also need reasonable working time regulations within the framework of what digital value creation requires. Personally, I advocate discussing this with social partners and placing as much value as possible on ensuring that not the entire digital economy is an economy without social partnership. Otherwise, this would make political life relatively difficult for us. If the elections go the way I wish or we wish, I will very quickly seek a conversation with the relevant business associations to find out how willing they are to develop appropriate forms of social partnership, because otherwise we will have a difficult time ahead of us. However, we do not have time to engage in major controversies; we need to move forward.

With that, I have indeed focused quite a bit on economic issues and addressed fewer societal questions. Everyone who is currently campaigning knows how localized the offerings from Facebook and others are, and how one can respond to the individual wishes of citizens through this. That we, as a people's party, are of course facing huge challenges is also clear. With a general address, with meetings and gatherings where the entire bouquet of all problems is discussed, we do not reach one young people anymore. They want individual addresses on the topics that interest them. We need to get used to that.

The

Second

is: If voters express their individual wishes everywhere like customers, how willing are we then to find consensus? That is becoming increasingly difficult. The next party congress is often still far away when a very timely decision is required. The third challenge for us in political work is that we can no longer say: Thank you for your inquiry, but in 14 days I have my next meeting week; then I will go to my colleagues and then we will discuss in this room; then I will give you feedback on how I stand on this or that question. That no longer exists. Responses are therefore quick. This, in turn, is digitally available, never disappears. Then there is almost no way to get out of a given promise. How are representatives supposed to explain to their voters that they have changed their opinion? For the entire political opinion formation, these are indeed challenges that we still need to discuss together.

I believe that, overall, we should be grateful to live in such an exciting time. But we also need to use our heads and find reasonable solutions – based on a firm value foundation that we also have with the social market economy. It is not the case that the fundamental values by which we decide simply change and everything is completely new. It is also not the case that we should not have the expectation that people determine the direction in which they want to go. But we still have a lot to do, especially in the international alignment of regulations in the level playing field. In this respect: Thank you for conducting this congress. It is a pity that I could not hear everything. But thank you for listening to me.