Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the celebration event "750 Years of Knappschaft" on January 19, 2011, in Essen:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

22 January 2011 · Celebration event "750 Years of Knappschaft" · Essen, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed a celebration event marking the 750th anniversary of the Knappschaft social insurance institution on January 19, 2011, in Essen.
Main themes
750th anniversary of Knappschaft, history of German social insurance, mining industry and social welfare, employer-employee contribution model, social self-administration, network health insurance systems, industrial to service society transition, innovation in healthcare provision, structural change in social security
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,841
84th percentile
Sentences
183
87th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
11.7
42nd percentile
Syntax
3.04
53rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 42%42%
  • Economic 25%25%
  • Ceremonial 20%20%
  • Institutional 10%10%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

183 sentences in 47 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Greve,

dear Mr. Freese,

dear colleague Rösler from the Ministry of Health,

dear Mr. Fuchtel, Parliamentary State Secretary from the Ministry of Labor, we are, so to speak, a three-person delegation from the federal government and also here together with members of the Bundestag. We are very pleased to be here for this festive event celebrating the 750th anniversary of the Knappschaft. Normally, when one celebrates 750-year anniversaries, it is either about churches or cities, but in the case of a social insurance, it is something quite special. That is why I am particularly happy to be here.

Now you celebrate often and, as we have heard, sometimes in the exciting time between Christmas and New Year in Goslar. I would like to say: It may not be just a coincidence that the Federal CDU was also founded in Goslar. I was also in Goslar last year, but there we were only celebrating 60 years. 750 years is, of course, something entirely different.

The Knappschaft, today the German Pension Insurance Knappschaft-Bahn-See, provides a reason for recognition. It has written German social history. I do not know how well the memories of what happened between the day of its founding 750 years ago and the time about 200, 180, 130 years ago in the history of social insurance are documented. But the Büchsenpfennig, which shaped the Knappschaft, was certainly a wise and pioneering decision to support the sick, injured, and survivors of deceased miners. At that time, the high risk was essentially accepted, but it was also evidently already considered that expertise, knowledge, and familiarity with such a difficult occupation as mining should be preserved through family traditions. That is why care for the social well-being of the employees was also a priority.

Thus, the Knappschaft was something like a "social scout." It already had characteristics that still form the basis for our social security systems today. These include, for example, the obligation to have social insurance, the joint contribution payment by employers and employees, and – which the Knappschaft is still proud of today – social self-administration. Whether the German language would have expressed this in the same words 750 years ago, I dare to doubt. That might be a topic for a dissertation on the German spoken 750 years ago.

The fact that these insurance elements have persisted over the centuries shows that reflection on social contexts and social cohesion evidently leads to similar answers time and again. But back then, it was exclusively about the members in mining. It took a long time, namely until the development of industrial society, for other occupations with similar characteristics to those in the Knappschaft to be included. Society was largely an agrarian society and was essentially shaped in the Middle Ages by small craft businesses – small to medium-sized enterprises, as one would say today.

Then there was a significant leap from the agrarian society to the industrial society, which made employment relationships comparable to those in industrial mining the dominant type of work in our society. Today we are observing another shift towards a service society, which again poses some problems for social security systems – bogus self-employment and others – for which we need to find answers. But we are proud of our industrial base. That is why we are also proud of our Knappschaft. And that is why I extend my heartfelt congratulations.

Now the Knappschaft is a network system: it is a pension insurance and also one of the largest health insurance providers in the country with around 1.7 million insured individuals. The topic of network systems is certainly also an exciting one, as it allows for a manageable group of employees to have all social security systems in view at once, and thus to be better acquainted with the dynamics of the individual social security systems than in many other social security systems that today work very sectorally. Therefore, you possess – I am deeply convinced of this – very specific experiences and knowledge.

The health insurance sector of the Knappschaft and its medical network may not be familiar to everyone. Therefore, it is interesting to say: 1,500 Knappschaft doctors and 5,000 experts in medical care ensure seamless medical provision; the health services are unparalleled in Germany.

You just spoke about the many beautiful health reforms. But the Knappschaft also continually shows us new ways. Innovation has always been a hallmark of the Knappschaft's activities. Keywords like Bottrop/Oberhausen, Essen/Mülheim, Gelsenkirchen/Gladbeck – not coincidentally all rather mining regions – including the East German locations with Cottbus show that many can benefit from a unique health care provision here.

That you are innovative was also demonstrated when you took action in 2003. Structural change also plays a role for you. In this respect, you thought that having another pillar could not hurt. You quietly but joyfully took over the mini-job center. The fact that around 6.8 million employees can now process their matters there shows the magnitude of the work. So you have at least 1.7 million health insurance members and 6.8 million mini-jobbers. I believe there have never been major complaints; it has always worked out. You have also found a good field of activity in the new federal states. A little over 20 years after German reunification, one can say that you managed to integrate 540,000 insured individuals in the new federal states into your network system in a very short time and to establish a system of offices and administrative units that is unparalleled. In this respect, I want to say: Congratulations on that as well. Let's see what other tasks we can find for you in the coming decades.

This event is taking place in a place with a rich tradition. The Ruhr area is accustomed to structural change. Here you had to face structural change, and you did. Structural change is a permanent phenomenon, which is also reflected in health reforms. We had some difficult days last year when the European Union suddenly had the very critical idea of ending the subsidized support for hard coal, the termination of which we had agreed upon in a major joint effort for 2018, earlier. I believe it was right and important that we worked together and brought calm to the matter. We have talked for many decades about the issue of subsidized hard coal mining in Germany. We have managed to initiate a process in a truly worthy collaboration of trade unions, state government, federal government, and employers that particularly affects the Ruhr area; it also affects it emotionally. Therefore, I find it very, very important that we advance structural change together, that we respect traditions, and that we do this in a continuous process that the Germans can follow, in which we can all participate. I believe that has been successful.

So one can say: There is tradition, but also very innovative areas, such as the Technology Center Dortmund. Bottrop is the site of the first zero-emission industrial park and the largest geothermal settlement in North Rhine-Westphalia. There is the former blast furnace and steelworks site "Phoenix West" near Dortmund with new jobs in key industries. All of this shows where we want to go. The topic of energy policy has always been a contentious one in Germany. But the energy sector is also undergoing a dramatic transformation – gradually moving away from fossil fuels towards more renewable energies. Just as there have always been controversies about nuclear energy, there are still controversies about coal today.

I say: If we do not construct reasonable transitions, we will not be able to bring together what is so necessary for our industrial society – we want to remain an industrial society – namely affordable energy, environmentally friendly energy, and supply security. Therefore, it is important that we do not throw the baby out with the bathwater, but rather take step by step towards the era of renewable energies. That is why it is always about – the Knappschaft has also understood this – talking with people about what is happening.

Regarding the question of how people accept their social life, the welfare state is, of course, also part of it – the state of the Federal Republic of Germany, which is shaped by the social market economy. It is no coincidence that Bishop Overbeck and the superintendent are here as representatives of the churches. The social market economy is inconceivable without the church's social teaching – the Catholic social teaching, the social ethics of the Protestant Church. It has something to do with the image of man – a person who takes responsibility in freedom but also needs solidarity. These fundamental values have held our country together. I believe they could and were truly lived even in the difficult times of the international financial and economic crisis in our country. We have shown that politics has made offers with economic stimulus programs, and that these offers were also accepted – both by employers and employees. Thus, the social market economy, with the experience of the welfare state, was accepted in a critical phase as we wish and was brought to life with many, many individual contributions.

Now the 750-year history of the Knappschaft teaches us that a welfare state, a country where the social market economy applies, can only truly bring about prosperity if we face the changes in the world. I spoke about structural change here in the Ruhr area; it is a dramatic structural change. I can just as well speak about the change in social security systems that we must also face. It is right that we not only think of ourselves today but also think into the future. The Knappschaft as a pension insurance is, of course, like all other parts of the pension insurance dependent on facing demographic change so that pensions can still be a piece of remuneration for life achievements in the future. It will no longer be the exclusive building block; we need additional systems. But I believe that in the international financial crisis, we also took a breath and said: The pay-as-you-go pension system has proven itself. Where everything is invested in capital, the fluctuations were much stronger. We have thus been able to maintain a piece of security and continuity in this crisis.

Today we can say that the statutory pension insurance is secured not only for the present but also for the future. This is not fully accepted by many people. Interestingly, it is particularly retirees who have difficulties with this question, who are not actually affected by it, but rather those who are currently in the labor process.

Of course, there are questions about the pension at 67 – to be fully implemented in 2029 – when one knows that the number of employed individuals between 55 and 65 years is currently too low for one to say that everyone believes they can still be in the workforce at 63, 64, or 65 years. Nevertheless, it is our task to point out that where today three employed individuals work for one retiree, in 20 or 25 years there will only be two employed individuals, and that where one currently has an average of 18 years of pension receipt, in the future it will be over 20 years.

This means we must make provisions. Anyone who wants intergenerational justice must never suddenly burden one generation with all the burdens but must make provisions step by step for the future. Therefore, in my firm conviction, it was the right decision to legally describe the path to retirement at 67 now. But it remains an ongoing task to create better employment opportunities for older employees. Otherwise, this pension will always suffer from insufficient acceptance. We have made progress there, but we need to do more.

Companies must also do more. Given a number of just under three million unemployed, we are already talking a lot about the issue of skilled labor shortages. However, there will only be acceptance for the immigration of skilled workers if skilled workers in our country really have a chance to find work in companies. Everything else will not find acceptance. I am deeply convinced of that.

In the pension insurance, the generations stand in solidarity with each other. Therefore, this pay-as-you-go system is more than just a financing instrument. We must keep explaining this. Sometimes one thinks that when a country is over 60 years old, like the Federal Republic of Germany, everyone must have understood everything, and one forgets that new generations are constantly emerging, who grow into a system that seems almost natural to them, and whose understanding they no longer need to develop. Therefore, it is our task, in order to secure this generational cohesion and also to secure the welfare state, to make the functioning of our social security systems clear again and again.

I had the chance to experience German reunification. I entered this Federal Republic of Germany with curious eyes and an open mind, convinced that everything functions according to common sense. I had to accept certain disappointments; fundamentally, however, everything was correct. Thus, I cheerfully engaged with the functioning of our social security systems. I always wanted to understand exactly why the contribution assessment ceiling in the different security systems is slightly different. I found it questionable that if there are concerns about contributions, one could simply raise the contributions. I then allowed myself to be more or less convinced by the insurance principle.

Today, after more than 60 years of the Federal Republic, not everything is completely arbitrary, but the fundamental ideas were correct; and they are still correct today. One must understand them; and I wish that alongside all the great essays written in German schools, the basic principles of the German social security systems would occasionally be included as a final project, so that one can see whether the fundamentals have been understood.

I would like to inform you: The sustainability reserve in pension insurance has grown again. This could indicate possible contribution reductions at some point, but it primarily indicates that we are on solid ground and that the labor market situation at the moment allows the social security systems to breathe a little easier.

Therefore, our fundamental approach must also be to enable work for everyone in this country as much as possible. Not only does work mean participation – of course, above all, participation in social life – but it is also the foundation of justice in society. Therefore, we must never accept that having under three million unemployed people is a satisfactory state; rather, we must strive to give everyone a chance. The better this works, the better our social security systems will function.

We have supplementary elements in the pension area with capital security through Riester contracts. 14 million people have voluntarily insured themselves additionally. However, we are not yet talking about the various aspects of occupational pension insurance, which is, of course, also a very important pillar.

As you are a network system, you are not only aware of the dynamics of pension provision – which is relatively manageable and also predictable – but you are also aware of the challenges that repeatedly arise in the health system. It is not just the inability of the respective health ministers over 34 years, but also the fact that there has been so much going on in the medical field that there have been 13 health reforms. So, there has been at least one in every legislative period. We have, of course, already made one. I would like to say a few words about this health reform because I consider it groundbreaking, even though it has not yet been fully accepted by the population. Therefore, I do not want to miss the opportunity to explain what we have done.

In principle, we have the participation of employers and employees. This works well when labor costs can grow, and the costs of social insurance do not grow faster than the gross domestic product or the overall revenues of a society. If the increases are approximately in a balanced ratio, I can represent the coupling of wage additional costs and costs for social insurance relatively well.

In the healthcare sector, we have a very specific situation that is exacerbated by the dynamics of the development of medical possibilities on one side and the demographic change in our country on the other side. This means I have more older people, and I can do more medically. Thus, we find – I believe no one can dispute this finding – that healthcare costs will grow faster than wages and incomes on average; at least, we must reckon with that.

If that is the case, then we must consider: Is the full coupling of this dynamically growing system to labor costs still correct? Or what consequences would we then have?

We can have two consequences.

The first consequence is that wage additional costs grow too quickly. This weakens competitiveness. Since competitiveness is highly sought after in our time due to strong global competition, this is a difficult situation. Or I have, because labor costs must not grow too quickly, such pressure on the funds available for the healthcare system that I gradually and insidiously move towards a two-tier healthcare system, because there is never enough money available in this system, as one does not want to lose jobs constantly.

Then, practically two values compete with each other: On the one hand, our welfare state value, which we must and want to uphold, that everyone receives the medical care they need, regardless of their income, and on the other hand, the necessity to keep up with profitable jobs under international competitive pressure.

To get out of this dilemma, we said: We keep the basic structure, but we must represent the dynamics of the system through additional contributions, where we must not overburden the individual insured. Therefore, we say: Two percent of one's own income may never be exceeded by one's own contribution to healthcare. What the individual cannot afford will be supplemented from tax revenues. The tax revenues are, of course, calculated much broader than the income of those subject to social insurance, because ten percent of income taxpayers already contribute 50 percent to income tax revenues; and these individuals all earn above the contribution assessment ceiling. This means I create, in addition to the parity insurance in the healthcare system, a solidarity basis through the entirety of taxpayers.

Theoretically, this is good, many tell me, but with the use of tax funds, I enter into competition with other interests of the state. This perhaps raises the biggest question of credibility – will the state be able to sustain this, will it truly live this welfare state principle in the future, or will there be an annual struggle for tax funds? – which we must answer in the future. I say: Yes, we will do it, we must do it. But I have also explained to you why the other system will gradually end up in more and more undersupply and hit a limit.

Unlike the last health reforms, this time we did not ask the sick to contribute additional payments, those who need to go to the doctor or need medication, but we chose a system where everyone, namely all taxpayers, will contribute something to the solidarity of the healthcare system in the future.

I allowed myself this excursion because 750 years ago, dramatic innovations could be introduced. 750 years later, one must also talk about the news of today. Since I believe that the healthcare system is understood even less than the pension system, I allowed myself this somewhat detailed excursion.

It is about the question of whether our state, whether our community carries the confidence for people that in the fundamental emergencies of life, when one cannot shape one's life on one's own in old age, in case of illness or care, it will be there. Whether we are reliable in this regard, whether we stand by each other, is perhaps one of the strongest questions we must answer positively to create a sense of community in our society.

Since we have, when we look at the path from the miners to our modern welfare state, a very high degree of anonymity today – it is not a professional group like the miners that is secured in itself, but all employees, who receive their benefits often far removed from the actual insurance – it may be good from time to time to look back at the miners, at the network system, and at the way you work and provide the necessary social benefits in a somewhat more manageable system.

It is exciting that the miners actually perform quite well in these comparisons. One might say: Well, the circle of insured is also great. But I believe one cannot simplify it that much. You also work well. You have repeatedly shown that you are willing to face new challenges. You have also responded to the changing world of work by being willing to take care of mini-jobs.

In this respect, one can say as a birthday recognition that you really provide a social security system that is exemplary in many ways, which gives many people security in life and thus also contributes to the cohesion of our society.

Therefore, I do not want to wish you another good 750 years right away, but I will tell you: You will have to continue to change, you will also continue to embrace change, as I know you at the miners. You will need allies – whether they are churches, municipalities, employers, and employees, and thus also the trade unions. All of this will continue to occupy us, as there are a multitude of questions that will necessitate reforms in the coming decades.

We have the issue of old-age poverty, which we did not have to this extent in earlier times. Basic security is one answer to that. Basic security will increase in importance, especially in the new federal states, when we look at the employment biographies after the reunification of Germany. However, I am not worried that we will not continue to work well together.

I have come to you today out of deep conviction to say thank you – to thank all those who ensure every day that we are a country where social security is not written small but large, where people can reliably count on receiving their pension, their healthcare, their long-term care insurance, and the necessary benefits. Therefore, I thank not only those who work in the administration of these security systems, but I also thank all those who contribute their strength every day to the people in hospitals, in care stations, in nursing homes, and senior residences. These are the places where humanity is lived. Thank you very much.

Congratulations on 750 years. Be proud of it; and continue to make something of it in the coming decades.