Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the celebration of the 60th anniversary of the Federal Intelligence Service on November 28, 2016, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

29 November 2016 · 60th anniversary celebration of the Federal Intelligence Service · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 60th anniversary celebration of Germany's Federal Intelligence Service (BND) on November 28, 2016, in Berlin's Kreuzberg substation.
Main themes
Federal Intelligence Service anniversary, BND history and future, German security architecture, jihadist threats from Iraq and Syria, Ukraine geopolitical situation, refugee security challenges, cybersecurity and cyberattacks, counterterrorism cooperation, intelligence oversight and rule of law, fundamental rights and democracy
Duration
~18 min
61st percentile
Words
2,166
61st percentile
Sentences
113
69th percentile
Readability
38
31st percentile
Grade
12.5
51st percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
38th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 49%43%
  • Geopolitical 24%21%
  • Ceremonial 20%18%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 12%

113 sentences in 31 paragraphs

Dear Mr. President, dear Mr. Kahl,

esteemed former presidents,

esteemed colleagues from the German Bundestag – both from the services sector and from the budgetary sector, as I see here; this is a good dual presence –, esteemed employees of the Federal Intelligence Service, ladies and gentlemen, many do not make their age a secret. Much at the Federal Intelligence Service is also subject to confidentiality. That must be the case. However, the BND does not keep its age under wraps. Fortunately, because this allows me to congratulate openly today: Congratulations on the 60th anniversary of the Federal Intelligence Service, congratulations to all employees who – as you just said, Mr. Kahl – serve our country, sometimes at the risk of their lives. I am particularly pleased to be able to participate in this anniversary celebration and to convey my thanks to everyone – including those who are not here.

I believe that the Kreuzberg substation provides a fitting setting for your anniversary. The old generator hall, where we are located, has a multifaceted history – just like the BND. Here, work was literally done under power; and the BND today often works, of course in a figurative sense, under high pressure.

At a milestone birthday, especially a 60th birthday, one would typically look back, recalling past times. This could easily be done here and today. However, many books have already been written about the history of the BND since its founding in 1956 – Mr. Kahl mentioned quite a few volumes.

Additionally, we hope that the work of the independent historian commission appointed by the BND to research the early history of the BND will soon provide a solid scientific foundation to comprehensively assess the work of the BND at that time and its significance. With its initial publications, the commission has already provided valuable insights. I wish the commission much success in its further work.

Today, however, I would like to focus primarily on the future of German intelligence services, particularly that of the BND. The Federal Intelligence Service has seen much movement recently. This generator hall is also a symbol of that, as it has undergone a transformation process and is now part of modern Berlin.

I am aware that dealing with intelligence services is particularly difficult in Germany. There are current reasons as well as historical ones for this – let us think of the Gestapo during the National Socialist era and the State Security during the GDR. The fundamental rights enshrined in the Basic Law of the Federal Republic of Germany were and are precisely the response of the rule of law in our country to this. Within this framework, intelligence services can today be an indispensable part of our security architecture; even more: they can not only do this, but they must do so.

To illustrate this, I would like to give you four brief examples.

First: Iraq and Syria. The situation in Iraq is extremely precarious, and the situation in Syria is a tragedy. Everything must be done to put an end to the suffering there. Furthermore, we must prevent the further spread of the wildfire in the region. In addition, we must address the threat to our security posed by jihadists returning from this region to Europe.

Second: Ukraine. The situation there remains very tense. We are observing developments on the eastern edge of Europe with great concern and must be able to accurately assess the impact of current geopolitical changes on this fragile region.

Third: the refugee situation. It challenges us both socially and in terms of security policy – for example, in combating smuggling crime, identifying migration routes, and conducting security checks on the people who come to us and want to live here.

Fourth: the security of cyberspace. We are observing an increasing number of cyberattacks on sensitive infrastructures in our interconnected world. Cases of cyber espionage are also commonplace. This poses a significant threat potential that we must respond to flexibly and innovatively.

In all these exemplary fields – I could name many others; Mr. Kahl spoke of Afghanistan – we face the challenge of developing not only short-term solutions but also long-term strategies. In this regard, the work of the Federal Intelligence Service is of great importance. It contributes to ensuring that we – and I include myself in this – have good, well-founded information bases to make decisions.

At the same time, the BND makes a significant contribution to the work of other security authorities with its findings. A prime example of this is its work in the investigation of international terrorism. In order for police authorities to carry out interventions and arrests as part of measures to prevent danger or in investigative procedures, it is often the intelligence services that do significant preparatory work. The BND investigates terrorist activities abroad. It identifies networks. It identifies potential threats. In close cooperation with domestic authorities, it helps to thwart terrorist planning.

I therefore emphasize once again: The work of the intelligence services is indispensable for the Federal Republic of Germany. We need their information as the basis for effective security policy. In doing so – this goes without saying – the services must always use the tools available to them not only in accordance with law and legislation but also with a sense of proportion.

It should also be self-evident that intelligence-gathered information must be complemented by a crucial component in order to be valuable and remain valuable: that is confidentiality. Intelligence information loses its value and thus its utility for the security of citizens when it is also known to those who threaten our security.

Just as freedom and security are interdependent, so too are oversight and confidentiality two sides of the same coin. Confidentiality without oversight is unthinkable. It would contradict our free democratic basic order and create distrust. Oversight without confidentiality is also unthinkable. It would jeopardize the work of the intelligence services and thus the state's task of ensuring the safety of its citizens. Therefore, secrets must be able to remain secret, within the framework of what law and legislation provide; that is, within the framework of an intensive oversight of the secret that is always possible in the designated rule-of-law institutions.

In recent legislative periods, the intelligence services and thus the BND have repeatedly been the subject of parliamentary inquiry committees. I think, for example, of the BND inquiry committee in the 16th legislative period, the various NSU committees in the 17th and 18th legislative periods, the Kunduz inquiry committee in the last legislative period, or the currently ongoing NSA inquiry committee. The NSA committee, in particular, has developed into a true second BND inquiry committee due to the expansion of its mandate.

I am aware that inquiry committees always represent a significant workload for the employees in the affected authorities, which must be managed alongside their core work – especially when the subject of the inquiry dates back a long time. Nevertheless – and I say this as a member of Parliament – such committees are indeed important: on the one hand, to clarify the specific allegations and draw the right conclusions from them; on the other hand, to continually reaffirm the foundations of our work.

Inextricably linked to this is the need to find an appropriate balance between the undeniable right of the public to information and the confidentiality of sensitive information. In this context, the ongoing inquiry committee has indeed had positive effects. Many have become aware through this committee of the significance of international cooperation. Moreover, many only engage with the legal framework that governs the work of the intelligence services through the inquiry committee.

The public discussion about the work of the intelligence services contributes overall to more people being able to think about the important, I say: yes, indispensable contribution that intelligence services make to the security of the Federal Republic of Germany. My conclusion is: The Federal Intelligence Service can be proud of its work and must at the same time remain open to a critical yet fair accompaniment of its activities.

I said at the beginning that much has been set in motion at the BND in recent months, much is new.

Two of these changes are clearly visible.

The first visible novelty is your new president, Bruno Kahl, who took office on July 1 as the 13th president of the BND. With Bruno Kahl, the BND has gained a man with extensive experience in political and administrative processes, who has already gained valuable experience in other difficult and responsible tasks. I wish you much success once again at this point.

The second completely unmistakable novelty is located about five kilometers in a straight line from here: it is the new building of the BND in Berlin-Mitte. The move to Chausseestraße, with a staggering 1,800 truckloads, is now in sight. The new building will certainly contribute to improving the operational capability of the BND. Moreover, the new house in the center of Berlin offers the BND the opportunity to present its work to a broader public. The BND will open itself to interested citizens in a visitor center on the southern part of the site in the future.

In addition to these visible novelties, there are of course also less visible but no less important changes. First and foremost is the amendment of the BND Act, which will soon be published in the Federal Law Gazette. With this reform project, the federal government is setting standards that are unique internationally. With the law on foreign-foreign telecommunications surveillance of the Federal Intelligence Service, passed by the Bundestag at the end of October, we have ensured legal certainty and clarity in a central area of intelligence work. The work of the Federal Intelligence Service – we have taken care to ensure – is not restricted by this. Rather, the formal and material conditions under which the BND may use telecommunications surveillance are clearly regulated. The legal certainty thus created also serves the employees of the BND. I believe many see it the same way. At the same time – this was also very important to us – the law strengthens the indispensable cooperation with foreign partners through clear regulations on joint data storage and international cooperation.

The new BND Act is accompanied by a reform of the law on the Parliamentary Control Panel. The federal government has supported this parliamentary initiative from the very beginning. It is no coincidence that a further improvement of parliamentary oversight was already agreed upon in the coalition agreement. For the federal government, effective oversight of the intelligence services is just as important as ensuring the effective work of the intelligence services. Only in this way, understood as a unit, can the necessary trust of citizens in their intelligence services be ensured and justified.

Politics, for its part, has the task of equipping the intelligence services so that they can adequately fulfill their demanding tasks. That is why we have equipped the BND with resources for modernization on an unprecedented scale. – Here, the presence of the budgetary authorities becomes clear; but I would like to thank both the budgetary authorities and the policy experts for the result of good cooperation. – Approximately half a billion euros will now be invested in technical developments in the coming years so that the BND can truly keep pace with today’s requirements in this area. This will also make it even more valuable for international cooperation. We have also significantly improved staffing for the year 2016.

Much has already been accomplished or set in motion. But at 60 years, the BND is far from reaching the end of its development. And as the world evolves, it really does not look like that. Therefore, for example, cooperation between our own intelligence services must continue to be strengthened. An important step in this regard is the planned joint master's program in intelligence studies. Of course, cooperation with foreign services must also be further deepened. At the same time, however, the BND must also further strengthen and expand its own capabilities. We cannot afford to sit back and rely on the efforts of others.

But in conclusion, I would like to say something: Today there is an exception. Today you – at least some of you; I believe others are just as active today as usual, and I hope so too – can rest your hands in your laps. Because today is a day to celebrate; a day to look back on 60 eventful years of the Federal Intelligence Service and on what you have accomplished. I wish you much joy in doing so, and I would like to once again express my heartfelt thanks to all those who work at the BND, who embrace change, who have to relocate. I hope that in the future your work will be just as successful as it has been in the past. Thank you very much for allowing me to be here with you today.