Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the German-French Digital Conference on December 13, 2016, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

13 December 2016 · German-French Digital Conference · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German-French Digital Conference in Berlin on December 13, 2016, alongside French President Hollande to advance bilateral digital cooperation.
Main themes
Digitalization and digital transformation, German-French cooperation, European digital single market, General Data Protection Regulation, 5G infrastructure, cybersecurity, social market economy adaptation, data protection, autonomous driving, digital copyright law, critical infrastructure protection
Duration
~17 min
57th percentile
Words
2,018
57th percentile
Sentences
99
62nd percentile
Readability
45
50th percentile
Grade
11.9
44th percentile
Syntax
3.08
58th percentile
Vocabulary
1.92
4th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 34%33%
  • Institutional 20%19%
  • Technological 16%16%
  • Social 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 7%7%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

99 sentences in 25 paragraphs

Dear Mr. President, dear François Hollande,

dear Minister Sapin,

dear Minister,

dear Federal Minister Gabriel,

ladies and gentlemen participating in this digital conference today,

this is the follow-up conference to the conference in Paris that took place in the autumn of 2015. As François Hollande has just said, this demonstrates in a very practical area that Germany and France want to be engines of development, that they want to learn from their respective experiences, and that they also want to network, which is a central concept in the age of digitalization.

We are all in a time of radical, rapid changes that are taking place in all areas – in production, in the service sector, in administration – and that have an impact on our working world, which – as the French President has just mentioned – affects our education system as well as all communication. We feel that the dynamics of this change are very high. We see that some are already fully living and working in this new digital world. However, we also see that parts of society are still struggling to understand everything that is happening.

We have political leaders and political parties that are fully occupied with shaping this development. We are used to securing our economic and social order, so to speak, with guardrails; in Germany, we call this "social market economy." But now, suddenly, many people who do not understand the actual technological development as much as the experts must provide the framework for this development to take place quickly and efficiently in terms of value creation, while also being socially compatible. This is where we are challenged.

Our first German-French response to this is, wherever possible, to seek joint answers that also benefit from the advantages of a European internal market. This means developing the digital internal market within the European Union.

François Hollande and I have actually been meeting for years with large European companies at the round table, together with the Commission or the respective Commission President, to discuss the framework of digital development. What stands out is that, on the one hand, there is a great deal of openness, but that processes within the European Union do not move too quickly. This also applies to our own laws. I would say: The adoption of a copyright law, to name a topic of this week, takes years in Germany. At some point, however, a political agreement must also be reached.

Therefore, it was good that we adopted a General Data Protection Regulation, so to speak, the framework for how we want to handle data in Europe in the future, at the European level. Germany and France have also been very engaged in this. But we have also seen in our respective governments how much data protection on the one hand and the need to deal with large amounts of data on the other hand stand in contradiction to each other.

The General Data Protection Regulation is now a framework. However, it contains many vague legal terms. We will now have to see in our countries how we can implement this nationally – with our data protection authorities and, of course, with those who handle large amounts of data and create value from it. Therefore, my proposal is that we, Germany and France, work very closely together in implementing the European General Data Protection Regulation so that we do not create two different worlds in our countries over the not clearly defined legal terms, but rather that our companies can really work well with it.

We need a new infrastructure in this revolutionary time. 5G certainly represents this as a new generation. Now it is about rolling out the 5G network as quickly as possible across Europe. It would also be good if Germany and France are at the forefront of this. Because if, for example, in autonomous driving we experience what can still happen today with mobile communications at the borders, namely that there is no reception for three kilometers, then one can only rely on the car's own sensors. But it might not be bad to have a good environment that allows real-time data transmission. We have made provisions for this in Germany. The corresponding frequency network is there. But now it is about advancing this throughout Europe.

It is also about questions of protection. Every spectacular case of cybercrime receives significant public attention, which of course does not contribute to building trust, but rather leads to reflection on where the dangers lie. Therefore, it is good that we have a federal authority, the Federal Office for Information Security, that tries to categorize things, and that we – especially the Federal Minister of Economics and the Federal Minister of the Interior – are in close dialogue with our economy. Security is, of course, of crucial importance. Germany and France must also exchange ideas on how we can secure the critical infrastructures of our countries to have a safe working environment. It is noticeable that security plays a central role, especially for German medium-sized companies; for example, questions about where to store data and where one feels safe from attacks are very significant.

It is also about how the state reacts to these developments. We have begun to engage more intensively with the topic of e-government. Germany is not particularly fast in this regard; one must honestly say that. For many years, we have tried to introduce an electronic health card and have had lively debates about how many PINs an older person can remember. We have now created the possibility with our new ID card to open certain access points for citizens via chip.

However, we need more applications. Therefore, it is a great result of the federal-state financial negotiations that we have agreed on an amendment to our Basic Law so that the federal government and the states can work together on this issue. In France, I believe this is simpler because it is a centralized state. But even in Germany, with its federal structures, citizens are eager to receive all services from their state through a portal and not first have to take lessons to know which level in the federal structure is responsible for which service. I think this will be an important topic in the next legislative period.

Why do I consider e-government so important? I consider it important because digitalization becomes a matter of course in the relationship between the citizen and their state. Employees, all those who depend on the digitalization of the economy, those whose working environment is changing, will take this for granted. This will lead to the entire population being introduced to these technologies. Especially in a population that is tending to age, as is the case in Germany, this is very important.

Regarding education: Essentially, all age groups need to be educated. This starts in school. The federal level in Germany actually has no means to influence the school system. On the other hand, we know how existentially necessary it is for our children to receive the education they need to live and work well in the digital world of the future. We will continue to support this from the federal government within our means. The recent IT summit has already brought us significant progress in this regard. There are many initiatives from companies in the education sector. I believe that the ability to program will become one of the basic skills of young people alongside reading, writing, and arithmetic. These will not disappear, but programming will be added.

It is also about an exciting process: How can I keep a population curious to continue learning throughout their entire working life? There are interesting ideas, for example, from our Minister of Labor, who says that our employment agency should no longer just be an agency that mediates jobs, but that it must also become an agency that is much more committed to lifelong learning. We need to adapt job profiles. We must try to avoid disruptive developments, that is, too strong jumps, and allow people to grow into the working world where the digital and real economies merge.

Another point is, of course, value creation. I believe that regarding start-ups, the sensitivity and openness of politics have changed significantly in many areas in recent years – also due to clear statements from those working in start-ups. However, we will also need to discuss what this actually means for working conditions, for the legal framework of work. I just heard that someone at Airbus worked day and night for three months, as it was said, to immerse themselves in an Airbus to look into every corner and see the reality digitally. When I heard "day and night," I immediately thought of the European Working Time Directive, which does not actually provide for such a thing. Now, a certain form of employment must have been found. But we do not want everyone to have to become pseudo-self-employed to be able to work in the future working world.

The question is: How do we organize work without people having to be reachable 24 hours a day? This will require many discussions because we naturally have the two worlds – the old industrial world, which is slowly transforming, and the new world of start-ups – side by side, and we must not discourage either group; neither the one through too rapid change that is not yet necessary, nor the other by not being able to progress because one cannot operate properly within our framework, which then leads everyone to leave Europe.

Issues of venture capital and support also play a role. In this regard, Germany and France are also in close exchange. The more we can achieve together, the better. What we are learning is that without state support, development would not progress as well in our two countries. This means we need to engage with competence centers for small and medium-sized enterprises, with hubs as offered by the Federal Ministry of Economics and in France, with standard-setting, also with questions of cooperation, for example, in microelectronics and chip manufacturing – in Dresden and Grenoble, we now have a joint cluster – and with much more, so that Europe strategically has full control over the value chains and does not fall into dependencies that could later become costly for us.

All in all, this is an extremely exciting time – a time that demands decisions from us that are often to be made more quickly than we might have to in a saturated and long phase of classical industrial development. We have an emerging association scene that is not yet as established as the Federation of German Industries or the Confederation of German Employers' Associations. However, it is very important that start-ups – whether in Germany or in France – come together to tell politics what they need. Because we cannot speak with each individual, even if each individual has an incredibly interesting project.

What I have noticed repeatedly – and I have the impression that it is the same in France – is that the discussion about what guardrails, what political framework we need, does not take place as controversially as we know it from classical industry, where everyone has their list of demands. Here, however, there is much more of a shared struggle for shaping the future, which is much more interactive and, indeed, less controversial. We should continue to take advantage of this opportunity. I have the impression that these German-French encounters at all levels – whether at the political level or at the level of start-ups – contribute significantly to intensifying this process.

Therefore, I would like to express my heartfelt thanks to all who have contributed here. A healthy competition between our two countries is highly welcome. But we also always have the claim that Germany and France, wherever something can be solved together, also offer joint solutions. Therefore, thank you very much, dear François, thank you very much, dear Ministers Sapin and Gabriel, for continuing on this path. And thank you all for being here today.