Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Central Commemoration Event for the 80th Anniversary of the Reich Pogrom Night on November 9, 2018, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

13 November 2018 · Central Commemoration Event for the 80th Anniversary of the Reich Pogrom Night · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed a central commemoration in Berlin on November 13, 2018, marking the 80th anniversary of Kristallnacht, the November 1938 pogrom night.
Main themes
Kristallnacht anniversary, Holocaust remembrance, antisemitism in history, National Socialism, responsibility and complicity, lessons from history, civilizational break, rise of hatred, Jewish persecution, German historical memory, moral and political responsibility
Duration
~17 min
59th percentile
Words
2,083
59th percentile
Sentences
124
73rd percentile
Readability
45
47th percentile
Grade
11.2
34th percentile
Syntax
2.72
14th percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
63rd percentile

Translated from German

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

124 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Federal President,

dear Mr. President of the Bundestag,

dear Mr. President of the Federal Council,

dear Mr. Schuster,

Excellencies,

dear colleagues from the Cabinet, the Federal Government, and the state parliaments, esteemed guests,

80 years since the Night of Broken Glass – why am I speaking to you about this topic today? The first obvious answer is the simple fact that the Night of Broken Glass is now 80 years in the past, and it is only proper that the events of this day be contextualized by the Federal Chancellor. The events of the November pogroms in 1938 were a significant milestone on the path to the civilizational break of the Holocaust. The result was six million murdered Jews and unspeakable suffering for many millions more. All this suffering cannot even be named. I lack the words here.

That is why I am speaking to you today primarily for another reason. I speak to you because these historical events – the civilizational break of the Holocaust – were unique, singular, never before seen in their form with all their abhorrent facets, culminating in – if we were to put it cynically – factories for industrialized mass murder or – to be precise – in concentration camps and extermination camps. I would like to use this day and this opportunity to reflect together with you on three aspects: How did it come to this? How did the majority of the population react? What can we learn from this?

November 9, 1938 was a day in a series of days and nights in which National Socialism showed its terrible face. About 1,400 synagogues, prayer rooms, and Jewish gathering places were plundered, destroyed, and set on fire. 7,500 Jewish businesses were demolished and looted. Neighbors became perpetrators and criminals. Many enriched themselves, condoned the violence, or became violent themselves.

Since 1933, anti-Semitism had been in power. The new political conditions allowed many Germans to express long-held resentments, to express hatred and violence. It did not stop with the destruction of Jewish houses of worship, businesses, and livelihoods. In November 1938, about 400 people were murdered or driven to suicide. 30,000 Jews were imprisoned in concentration camps, hundreds of them murdered. With the November pogroms, the path to the Holocaust was clearly marked.

We humans tend to focus our remembrance solely on these important commemorative days and too easily overlook that they usually do not stand alone but are part of a process. November 9 did not stand alone either. We all know what happened afterward – the civilizational break of the Holocaust. But the Night of Broken Glass on November 9, 1938 was also preceded by something without which it would not have been possible. To understand this, it is worth taking a look back at history. Of course, this can only be very cursory in the context of such a speech.

Hatred of the Jews has existed in Europe since the Middle Ages. Until well into the 19th century, this hatred was primarily justified religiously. By the end of the 19th century, with the industrial revolution, social questions became pressing, and secular nation-states gained importance. In this context, what was called racially motivated anti-Semitism emerged. It aimed at racial exclusion, expulsion, and ultimately annihilation. In the Weimar Republic, Jews were allowed to rise to the highest state offices for the first time in 1919. Nevertheless, anti-Semitism remained on the agenda – especially among those who were hostile to democracy.

As early as 1920, the NSDAP published its so-called teaching and principles of anti-Semitism. With them, Jews were to be excluded from being citizens. In the 1920s, during which the NSDAP formulated these demands, many events stood for an increasing anti-Semitism – both in words and actions – such as the murder of Foreign Minister Walther Rathenau in 1922 or the attacks on Jews in the Berlin Scheunenviertel in 1923.

So we can already see from this brief historical overview that the calamity of National Socialism did not come overnight, but grew steadily. Why do I speak so extensively about all that happened before November 9, 1938, that is, 85, 90, and 95 years ago?

Because I am convinced that we can only draw the right lessons for ourselves today and in the future if we understand the November pogroms of 1938 as part of a process that was followed by a terrible aftermath with the Holocaust, but that also had a preceding context.

Because we can see where it leads when – as in National Socialism – previously punishable behavior is first tolerated and ultimately declared to be the desired behavior. Preconceived prejudices could now turn into open violence without punishment. This was accompanied by looking away, silence, indifference, and above all, the complicity of a large majority of the German population.

With the liberation of Germany in May 1945 and the subsequent new beginning, the political conditions changed. The normative distinction from racism and anti-Semitism was fundamental. But racism, anti-Semitism, and prejudices did not simply disappear.

When we look at the situation today – 80 years after the November pogroms and almost 70 years after the founding of the Federal Republic of Germany – we see a mixed picture. There is once again a flourishing Jewish life in Germany – an unexpected gift after the civilizational break of the Holocaust. Yet at the same time, we are experiencing a worrying anti-Semitism that threatens Jewish life in our country and in other places in the world that were once thought to be safe. This anti-Semitism is increasingly manifesting itself openly in a partly unrestrained hatred on the internet as well as in the public sphere.

Unfortunately, we have almost become accustomed to the fact that every Jewish institution must be guarded or specially protected by the police – synagogue, school, kindergarten, restaurant, cemetery. But we are shocked by attacks on people wearing a kippah and stand aghast at the right-wing extremist motivated attack on a Jewish restaurant in August of this year in Chemnitz. This is a form of anti-Semitic crime that evokes terrible memories of the beginning of the persecution of Jews in the 1930s.

But such incidents must not only alarm the survivors of the Holocaust – they are terrible for all of us. Yet our shock and disbelief are not enough. Even with the appointment of a Federal Government Commissioner for Jewish Life and the Fight Against Anti-Semitism – as right and understandable as that is – it is not enough. Because we must answer two pressing questions.

First:

What have we really learned from the civilizational break of the Holocaust?

Second:

Are our democratic institutions strong enough to prevent a further strengthening or even a majority acceptance of anti-Semitism in the future?

Perhaps let us imagine for a moment how people from a distant future – say, in the next century – will look at our world today; at a world that is once again threatened to lose sight of the common good because it excludes people based on their faith, their origin, their differences, seeks to deny them a place, and threatens them. How, then, might we be viewed in a distant future, where the way we interact with one another is becoming increasingly harsh on many levels? Probably with complete incomprehension; and perhaps also with regret for us today, that we are still in danger of repeating terrible mistakes and experiencing where the attempts at division by a few can lead.

Our Basic Law draws the lesson from the horrors of National Socialism and the failure of the Weimar Republic by stating in Article 1, Paragraph 1: "The dignity of man is inviolable. To respect and protect it is the duty of all state authority." This must absolutely be the guiding principle of our actions; both politically and socially. What does this mean in concrete terms?

First:

Every person is unique. Groups must never be qualified en masse, and our society must not be divided into "us" and "them," "we" and "the others." Everyone has the right and the claim to be recognized and treated as an individual by state institutions.

Second:

Democracy is the best of all conceivable social orders, even if life in it can sometimes be complicated. Democracy is more than the safeguarding of majorities. It relies on balance and compromise between majority and minority, government and opposition. It relies on the separation of powers and needs the freedom of the press, opinion, and art as much as humans need air to breathe. Democracy protects minorities. This means that the best possible participation of all in social life must be guaranteed.

Third:

The state must resolutely and consistently combat defamation, exclusion, anti-Semitism, racism, and right-wing extremism. The state must also act consistently when hatred against Jews and hatred against Israel is expressed verbally and non-verbally by people living in our country who have been shaped by a different religious and cultural background. Specifically: Just as there must never be a general suspicion against Muslim people when violence is committed in the name of their religion, it is equally clear that everyone living in our country must commit to the values of our Basic Law.

Fourth:

Educational work has the task of always placing today's anti-Semitic attacks and riots in a historical context. For this, historical knowledge and a critical historical consciousness are indispensable. I quote historian Professor Norbert Frei: "For one does not have this, but one must continually work to achieve it anew. In this sense, every generation must strive anew for a critically enlightened relationship with our past. Where this happens, historical remembrance will not be an empty ritual. Rather, history remains meaningful, and new questions and perspectives can even arise."

Fifth:

In this context, remembrance work has fundamental significance. At the awarding of this year's Peace Prize of the German Book Trade, the awarded research couple Jan and Aleida Assmann pointed to the importance of our cultural, our national memory. Our nation is described by them as "a community of people who also remember the shameful episodes of their history and take responsibility for the enormous crimes committed in their name."

Taking a moment today to pause and remember together is therefore important. It is equally important that remembrance needs places that tell of what happened and places that commemorate the victims and clearly name the perpetrators – for example, the Memorial to the Murdered Jews of Europe in the center of our capital. The underground information center attempts to make the dimension of the Holocaust clear. That is why many individual names are mentioned there, in order to "dissolve the incomprehensible number of six million murdered Jews in its abstraction and free the victims from their anonymity."

For it is about people. Each one of them had a name, a unique dignity and identity. Remembering this identity and dignity helps to not remain in loss. It helps to not disconnect memory from present life, but to continually establish the connection to the past in our present life and, based on that, to shape the future – a future in which we recognize a human in every person and meet each other from one human to another.

Today we once again live in a time of profound changes. Rapid technological upheavals cause concern among people. Due to the acceleration of globalization and digital progress, many feel left behind. In such times, the danger is always particularly great that those who respond to the difficulties and consequences of upheavals with seemingly simple answers gain followers – simple answers that too often also come with a coarsening of language on the streets as well as online. This is the beginning that we must resolutely confront.

That is why we commemorate today with the promise that we will resolutely oppose attacks on our open and plural society. We commemorate with the knowledge that watching transgressions and crimes ultimately means complicity. We commemorate in the conviction that the democratic majority must remain vigilant. Normative boundaries are needed. The rule of law must show no tolerance when people are attacked because of their faith or skin color.

Drawing these conclusions is our task not just on such a commemorative day. We should think about this every day. Let us all work every day with the understanding of today to ensure that something like what happened 80 years ago never happens again. That is the message and the essence of our commemoration today. Thank you very much.