Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the German Employers' Day on November 22, 2018, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

24 November 2018 · German Employers' Day · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 20th German Employers' Day in Berlin on November 22, 2018, marking 100 years of social partnership and the Stinnes-Legien Agreement.
Main themes
Collective bargaining autonomy, Social Market Economy, Stinnes-Legien Agreement centenary, digitalization challenges, employer-trade union social partnership, wage distribution and inequality, collective agreement coverage decline, industrial vs. service sector divide, German economic growth, post-reunification labor developments
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,675
90th percentile
Sentences
249
93rd percentile
Readability
55
78th percentile
Grade
10.0
20th percentile
Syntax
2.96
43rd percentile
Vocabulary
1.94
5th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 36%35%
  • Institutional 19%18%
  • Technological 15%15%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 7%7%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

249 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Kramer,

dear Mr. Honorary President, dear Mr. Hundt,

dear, esteemed Steffen Kampeter,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am very pleased to be with you again today. You are essentially celebrating two anniversaries. The German Employers' Day is taking place for the 20th time. It has become one of the most important economic and social policy events in this country. As for the other anniversary, we can all congratulate ourselves – as you have already hinted –: One hundred years ago, not only was the Republic proclaimed; shortly thereafter, social partnership was also established – just a few days after the end of the First World War in a very uncertain economic situation – when employers and trade unions agreed on the Stinnes-Legien Agreement on November 15, 1918.

That was a milestone; and I agree with you: a milestone on the path to the Social Market Economy. It prevented the socialization of private means of production at that time; the November Revolution was initially comparatively left-leaning. Therefore, it was important to recognize trade unions as equal negotiating partners of employers. Mediation procedures were introduced to resolve collective bargaining disputes. Collective bargaining autonomy was agreed upon. It was later enshrined in the Basic Law of the Federal Republic of Germany. It allowed social partners to independently agree on working conditions without state intervention. This means that the Stinnes-Legien Agreement created a completely new partnership that had not been known before.

I personally believe that collective bargaining autonomy is also one of the core elements of the Social Market Economy in the long term. But this also means that this core element must remain visible. If today only about 30 percent of companies are directly bound to a collective agreement, then that is a declining and, as I see it, already a threatening situation. You, Mr. Kramer, spoke about the reasons for this and who contributes to it; and I can tell you a lot about that as well. Especially in the time after the reunification of Germany, there have been developments in the metal industry that have certainly accelerated this process. The fact is, however: If this percentage does not rise again but continues to fall – and if collective bargaining autonomy were guaranteed a hundred times in the Basic Law; and if we say as often as we want that it is a core element of the Social Market Economy – then this will lead to increasing pressure on politics in real life. This is essentially a pressure that is no longer bundled by associations, but rather an individual pressure, where the danger exists that only the stronger will prevail and that the overall societal good cannot be kept in view.

That is why I am pleased that you said: We want to initiate discussions to explore together with the trade unions how we can make collective bargaining more attractive again – through whatever instruments. Both you and I, Mr. Kramer, have already talked a lot about this. I believe that, given the challenges of digitalization, which I will return to later, and also many company foundations with partly completely new structures, it will not be trivial to increase collective bargaining again.

What is also important is that one keeps all parts of trade union existence in mind. Because the classic German industry has partly maintained its collective bargaining by outsourcing everything that was not directly related to the industrial value creation process to other areas. When you are a union leader responsible for services, you see that there are indeed very different living situations in Germany – on the one hand in the automotive industry, in mechanical engineering, or in traditional chemical companies, and on the other hand, when you look at how the cafeteria operations, cleaning services, and many other services are evaluated.

That, dear Mr. Kramer, is also one of the reasons that there is a certain tendency to distribute more social wealth than economic growth allows, which I fundamentally consider worrying if this is done for too long, because the gap between the service sector and the area of industrial value creation, in my feeling, is becoming larger, and in distribution struggles, some say "We have to catch up" and others say "We also have to let our employees share in the wealth." Then what is available is essentially distributed twice. That is the problem, regarding which I ask you to bring this back together, to think holistically in your companies and not to think "Yes, if I only deal with a works council that is concerned with the core business, I do not need to care about everything around it," but to also see the surroundings. Otherwise, this leads to a deep sense of injustice, becomes a political issue, and then ends up with us.

Nevertheless, we are now experiencing economic success for the ninth consecutive year. This is the longest growth period since the 1950s. But as it is with success: It drives fantasies about what else could be done. That is precisely the difficulty. Theoretically, these good times should be used to set the course for the future. Politically, however, the temptation to distribute something from what is available is naturally greater. Reforms tend to fare better in economically bad times, although the price to be paid then is greater. That is what we have to grapple with. But we can be proud that we have as many employees today as we have ever had.

We also have the development – which I believe is said too rarely – that poverty and social exclusion have decreased and that the fact that so many people have social insurance-covered employment is, of course, a factor that contributes to combating poverty and gives hope for the education of children who grow up in families where people are not unemployed. I mean: When I became Chancellor, we had five million unemployed. I still remember how in March 2006, the newspaper that always has particularly large headlines titled: "Mrs. Merkel, these are now your unemployed." There were more than five million at that time. Today, we can already be satisfied that we have 2.4 million or 2.3 million unemployed.

We have also committed to keeping wage-related costs below 40 percent. Dear Mr. Kramer, I remember my early years in the German Bundestag. At that time, they often exceeded 40 percent. That was the top topic. But I also understand that you look with some concern at certain developments. Even there – I should also speak a little about social cohesion today – there are, of course, certain things that worry politicians. The entire area of care – this will become even more significant in a society that is changing demographically like ours – is associated with questions that deeply unsettle people. If you look at the employment situations there, you see that the working hours are sometimes dramatically uncertain. Often there are long stretches without a day off. The collective bargaining coverage is not particularly good. Trainees still pay school fees today – a circumstance that has not been recognized at the federal level for many years because it is actually a matter for the states; a paradox. If you want to inspire young people for these professions today in an environment where you are looking for skilled workers everywhere, it is clear that you need to change something in this training.

We need to take care of these things. And in shaping the German social system, we face the question: How do we do this to offer better care services and make such professions more attractive while keeping wage-related costs below 40 percent? As an alternative, only tax funds come into question; and a lot of that already flows, for example, into pensions. Therefore, we are already under pressure here, which will certainly not decrease in the coming years.

When we talk about social cohesion: As a federal government, we have set up one of the most complicated commissions – the Commission on "Equivalent Living Conditions." Just take a look at how different the living conditions and the concerns of people in Germany have become. In Munich, for example, there are not enough apartments or the rents are so high that skilled workers can hardly afford them. In fact, companies and the state must build apartments for themselves and their employees. On the one hand, we are missing far more than a million apartments, and on the other hand, more than a million apartments are vacant. There are people in rural areas, where I also have my constituency, who have worked their whole lives for their little house, who then have to experience that their children move to Stuttgart, to Munich, or elsewhere, that they are left sitting on their property, which is certainly not as mobile as their children, and that their life's work is losing value. If today, as an older person, you go into a nursing home and own a property in Freiburg and a property in Höxter, then what you can get from the property of your old house in Höxter – even though you have done the same in your life, invested, and worked – may only be enough for one-fifth of what is generated in value in Freiburg. People perceive this as unfair. That is not surprising. But we do not have a complete answer to that.

Therefore, it is very important that we work together to ensure that economic development takes place sensibly in all parts of Germany. For example, in Bavaria, this works because they have a good core. But in all the new federal states, not a single DAX company has its headquarters. Convincing DAX companies that they should also engage in the new states, which are essentially deindustrializing, is not helped even by super transport connections. This means that young people leave. And at the moment young people leave, the older ones are totally unsettled. Because the fact that they do not see their grandchildren grow up, that the children live far away in Munich and in a tiny apartment where they roll their eyes three times when grandma is still visiting on the second day – yes, the guest room is not included in the rent – that drives people. This has nothing to do with the fact that 45 million people have a job, but it does concern them. And we have to deal with that.

In addition, we must also find reasonable regulatory answers. I am not one of those who believe that more apartments will be created through the fifth rent brake, but I believe that housing shortages can only be combated with housing construction; that is part of it. However, I must also say at this point, even though I do not want to address anyone personally: If you live in a neighborhood where there is still a piece of green space, the interest in having new apartments built there is very limited locally. Today, you can win election districts in Munich more easily by saying "No new development." I believe the General Secretary of the CSU will come later. He won in Trudering because he said "No new development." I understand that, because the density in the city is already high. But we are also faced with the question: Where do we get building land from? How do we build systematically so that it goes faster and not everyone has to reinvent everything? These are also questions we are facing.

By the way, regarding the question of DAX companies and their engagement in the new federal states, I would also like to say thank you, because I see Mr. Kaeser sitting here in the front row, for example. Görlitz is one such case where people are asking what will become of them. Hopeful answers have also been found there.

Now there is also uncertainty regarding the hardly tangible challenges of digitalization. I think it is very good that you have invited the chairwoman of the Digital Council, Ms. Suder, today. Thank you very much for that. This Digital Council really gives us as the federal government a push, if I may say so, because it introduces us to the challenges of digitalization in a very compressed manner. The first point, which we talk about a lot in Germany, is infrastructure. Okay, its expansion needs to go faster. But I believe we are now on a good path. By the end of 2019, we will have connected 98 percent of households to broadband. By the end of 2021, we will have connected 99 percent. The rest we will have to connect, so to speak, with state aid. We already need to use state aid now, but to connect the very last household, we will almost have to do it entirely with state support.

By the way, we have the following situation: Now we are expanding broadband on a large scale, but we have a bottleneck with construction companies that are still available. Prices are naturally rising. Now the connections are there. Now, if you go to a village in Vorpommern or a village in the Eifel and ask the question: Who actually wants to benefit from this beautiful fiber optic cable? People are sitting at home with DSL; many are quite happy with it, especially the older ones. Then the big question arises: How do we achieve the refinancing of the investments? Because there is no obligation to connect like there is for water and sewage. If you were to ask people if they want a sewage connection obligation, many would say no. We are in a situation due to the private design of this future public service where perhaps only 50 percent or 60 percent in rural areas will actually make use of the great new offers – of course in commercial areas, of course the medium-sized businesses, of course the schools and hospitals; that’s clear. But there are many others. And how we deal with that will one day become a very exciting question.

Secondly, we are concerned with comprehensive internet access. This is also one of the tasks of the "Equal Living Conditions" commission. Because people do not just want to have internet access at home, but they may also want to exchange short videos with their family while sitting in the meadow and resting. This means we need comprehensive coverage. This poses a somewhat larger problem. For this, we need at least 10,000 new radio masts. The supply does not necessarily have to be at the level of 5G, but everyone here knows that, and one would already be happy to have permanent 3G. This will be a major challenge.

But it is also about 5G applications – I see Mr. Lutz – along the railway lines, along the federal highways, along the motorways, along the country roads. There we will have the possibility of real-time data transmission, at least nearly. There will be minimal latency times. So, 5G applications are still to come. However, they are not yet available in a comprehensive manner today. This means we do not need to expand the entire country to 5G immediately; we still have a bit of time for that. This means that five years is not a drama. But those who need real-time applications must have access to these connections. And we want to move in that direction as well.

However, there is also a part of digitalization that will change our lives so profoundly that I do not know if we all already know what is coming, or I know that we do not know. How does one deal with such a situation when one wants to give people security? One must not promise them anything false, but must try to take them along on a path. You are doing this in companies. I have visited companies where the possibilities of digitalization are being excellently utilized through continuous further education. But this is still not happening in all areas. I believe we have not fully grasped the disruptiveness of our work processes.

Therefore, my request to you is also: Allow yourselves to engage in completely new thinking – also to think less in hierarchical systems. Ms. Suder can explain this to you better than I can. Let us assume that our great state challenge is to create the so-called citizen portal based on the Online Access Act. This means we need to open more than 500 functions that citizens deal with their state – applying for parental allowance, applying for child benefit, reporting a move, registering a vehicle, and so on – with a single access for the citizen and give them the opportunity to handle all these things digitally. This first leads to the fact that we must think completely differently. We must first put ourselves in the citizen's shoes and not first build the entire system and then see if it is practical. Today, when we plan something, we do not necessarily think from the citizen's perspective. Rather, we think: 575 functions – you have to somehow plan all of them; and when you have finished them, then you look at how the citizen takes advantage of them. The new way of working should proceed in such a way that I take one function and first work on it and try out whether it is useful in the sense of the citizen. Then I take a second function. And this is how I build it up piece by piece. Perhaps you are already doing all this in your companies. But the Berlin airport would have been better if this form of processing had been applied from the start; that much is certain.

Then I come to the topic of Artificial Intelligence – a point where we are clearly not leading. We have, so to speak, islands that can make good contributions, but the entire breadth is not adequately represented. Our advantage is that we have a strong industrial pillar. With Industry 4.0, we will succeed in getting good applications.

However, we are in an incredible battle for the best skilled workers in the world with very flexible pay options everywhere. Therefore, one will certainly have to think a lot in Germany about Max Planck Institutes and non-university research institutions.

We want to establish 100 new professorships. We have identified twelve centers that will be networked with each other and also connected with France. We will have our agency for disruptive innovations, which we have at both the German and European levels, engage very strongly in the field of Artificial Intelligence. We will tell our Federal Court of Auditors: Be calm, because we will inevitably waste more money before a major innovation comes out. All of this requires a complete rethinking.

At the moment, we are experiencing in our administration – I do not know how it is with you – that when we want to get digital projects on track, it takes us a very long time to get through. However, if we bring in 50 young people from some university and ask them to work on two topics, we have an answer after two months. This means we will also have to outsource more, bring in more young people. But of course, these are also people who do not think first about a collective agreement – to return to our starting point. Bringing that together is, of course, difficult.

Regarding skilled workers: Yes, we now have a Skilled Worker Immigration Act. I ask you, now that we as CDU members are using the word "immigration," not to call the law "immigration law" again. It is an immigration law. I do not know if you can follow the depths and nuances of such discussions precisely; but anyway. In any case, we have set important course and are trying to make it as unbureaucratic as possible. In the implementation, we will not be able to manage this alone in the foreign representations, but we need the support of the economy. I thank you for the willingness that is present. We will also have to rely on the comparability of qualifications to work with you in the form of a clearing house or similar to try to proceed unbureaucratically. Ultimately, it is about the skills and abilities and not about the formal qualifications.

From your perspective, we are sometimes too hesitant because we say: The worker used today is, after one year, at the latest after one and a half years, someone who has a permanent claim to social benefits in Germany; at least that applies to many of them. That is our problem; and that is why we are so cautious. Because we know: We are facing disruptive upheavals. No one can predict exactly how needs will develop in the coming years. This year we have 1.24 million open positions that we need to fill. For that, we need skilled workers. But if we are completely honest, we need very different skilled workers. In one area, we need the specialist for digitalization and artificial intelligence, and in another area, if I look at my constituency, we also need a hundred bakers and a hundred cooks in the hotels. The question is: How will this develop and what does that mean? We cannot manage this challenge in such a way that when someone becomes unemployed, we then receive critical remarks from you again about why wage additional costs are constantly rising. Therefore, we simply keep that in mind.

We must also pay particular attention to ensuring that our own workforce is trained in a reasonable manner. This is also one of the major topics that the federal government has committed to. Here we are dependent on you. We must not make too much of a theoretical further education that is solely selected by the Federal Employment Agency, but we must, wherever possible, provide further education in the workplace. However, I believe that the possibility of receiving subsidies from the Federal Employment Agency when a company offers further training for reasons of digitalization could be particularly beneficial for medium-sized companies. We do not interfere in the content but provide subsidies for it. I believe that is a reasonable thing.

Then we have, of course, the point of flexibility in labor law. Personally, I would go further in some areas. My struggle – even though I have been in office for 13 years now – to implement the European Working Time Directive one-to-one in Germany and at least to exploit the flexibilities contained therein has so far been largely unsuccessful. Where there are collective agreements and agreements with the works council, we have opening possibilities within the experimental clauses. Use that so that we can gather good experiences there. But we have a working time law that is very unsuitable for start-ups and for young companies that live in the digitalization sector. Therefore, we need flexibility instruments such as temporary work; that is very important. I know that we will also demand a lot from you when we first tackle the fixed-term employment without cause. Ms. Nahles is coming today; she can perhaps report on that.

But I must tell you: There are also incredible things. When one reads that in the public service, in some cases, contracts are limited 17 times and then people are laid off again, one wonders. Such things also exist in the service sector; do not have any illusions about that. Therefore, I can only repeatedly ask: The more responsibly you handle your freedom, the less we as a state have to interfere in things.

Finally, a few words about Europe. Thank you for your clear commitment to Europe. Europe is a source of our prosperity; that is completely clear. Anyone who wants to preserve such a source must also contribute something to it. However, we cannot assume that the perspective of looking at the world is the same in all member states of the European Union. Therefore, we need a certain degree of rules; that is also completely clear. However, we must also be willing to engage with the wishes and ideas of others to some extent. For us, a strong France is constitutive for advancing Europe. Therefore, I and the entire federal government have a maximum interest in the success of French President Emmanuel Macron with his reforms, which, by the way, are partly very courageous and partly also benefit greatly from German experiences, especially in the area of vocational training. We really want to support this success.

We are aware of the challenges, especially in trade matters. Let me say this: If one imagines that Germany were solely exposed to the considerations of the United States of America in trade matters, particularly in customs matters, we would be in a much worse position. The fact that Jean-Claude Juncker and the Commission handle trade issues for all of us in the European Union is, of course, sometimes tedious, as one always needs a mandate from 28 – in the future 27 – states. However, it also means that we are more protected, because it is always about the entire European Union. This has been a very important aspect in recent months for conducting discussions with the United States of America on trade issues.

As a large economy, as an economy with a high trade surplus, we are, of course, particularly in focus, and we want to speak bilaterally with the United States of America to make it clear that we – especially for American medium-sized companies – are a country with open markets. No one is turned away if they want to export to us. Perhaps some things are still not sufficiently known. In this regard, we are striving to show maximum transparency and to make that clear, as we have an interest in ensuring that there is no uncertainty. We feel that the trade conflicts between America and China are causing a lot of uncertainty for German companies as well. Everything we can do to protect and make an open order practicable again is of great importance.

Another source of uncertainty is, of course, the question of Britain's exit from the European Union. Britain should remain a partner, should remain a friend, and should have the closest economic relations with us. Britain decides that for itself. We fundamentally agree that at the end of the road there will be a very comprehensive free trade agreement, although we must honestly say that we do not have much experience with international agreements in the services sector. However, we want to see that as a future relationship.

Britain's exit is proving to be more difficult than a hypothetical exit of any other member state, due to the internal British situation regarding Ireland. The fact that, through the Good Friday Agreement, Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland are essentially connected like a single market, and that these two entities are now to be separated while still ensuring that no border is created, presents us with significant – let’s say, intellectual – challenges, because it raises the question: How can one ensure that where there is to be no border, the single market still ends? This is essentially the entire discussion we are having. If there were no such problem, we would have already accomplished the exit agreement.

I must tell you: I will do everything I can to ensure that we reach an agreement. A disorderly exit is the worst possible path for both the economy and the mental situation of our future relationship. We have already made some progress, but certainly many discussions are still needed, especially in Britain. As 27 member states, we can only do two things:

First, we can engage with Britain in a partnership and friendly manner, and

Second, we can stand together as 27 member states and not allow unrest to arise among ourselves. Both have been successful so far. And we will continue in this manner.

Thank you very much for your attention.