Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the conference series "When I Think of Germany" on the topic "How Do We Want to Live?" on September 28, 2012, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

1 October 2012 · "When I Think of Germany" conference series, session on "How Do We Want to Live?" · Alfred Herrhausen Society, Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Alfred Herrhausen Society conference in Berlin on September 28, 2012, speaking on how Germans want to live in the future.
Main themes
Future of German society, quality of life, democratic participation, citizens' dialogue, social consensus, social market economy, education system, federalism, intergenerational values, civic engagement, Germany's post-war legacy
Duration
~45 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,416
93rd percentile
Sentences
213
90th percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.23
76th percentile
Vocabulary
1.89
2nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 36%35%
  • Social 20%20%
  • Institutional 20%19%
  • Geopolitical 13%12%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

213 sentences in 53 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Nowak,

Mr. Steltzner,

Professor D'Inka,

Mr. Fitschen

and all other distinguished personalities,

I am pleased to be here today at the Alfred Herrhausen Society. I would like to sincerely thank Mr. Nowak and the Alfred Herrhausen Society, as well as the "Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung," for taking the citizens' dialogue as an opportunity to revisit the topic of how we want to live in Germany in the future and in what kind of world we want to live.

I believe you have already had a very exciting day today. When I looked at the booklet that was included with last week's "Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung," I wasn't quite sure if the whole thing might take a somewhat pessimistic turn. However, I hope that today has indeed provided reasons for optimism.

Fundamental directional questions of societies are, by their nature, not easy to answer; at least not if one believes that people are different – if one adheres to the Christian faith, one would say: created differently by God – and naturally have different ideas about what life should look like. Therefore, the questions of how we want to live, how we want to make decisions about that, and how we want to come to these decisions together can, of course, only be clarified in a process of constant discussion and constant weighing of opinions from groups or individuals.

When we began our citizens' dialogue, we naturally wished for as many people as possible to participate in such a process. This is a great art: How do I reach as many people as possible in a system like democracy, where everyone has an equal role in the electoral system, where every citizen has the same rights in the decision-making system, so that as many as possible take care of their own future? I would say: A democracy is at its best when as many people as possible are engaged.

This raises the question: Can one actually assume that there is a basic consensus in such a discussion about the future of our country? We have repeatedly learned that we – for example, politicians – live off assumptions that we cannot create ourselves. I believe that the basic consensus is something that also changes. Therefore, the basic consensus of our society should actually be discussed even more intensively from generation to generation. After all, after the Second World War, when we established a basic law and built the country – very successfully – it was thought that the awareness of a common basic consensus would automatically be passed down from generation to generation. Today, there are also many self-evident truths on various issues. But I fear that if you ask people to write a short essay on questions like "Why is our pension system organized the way it is; why do we have a social partnership; how does the decision-making mechanism in the social market economy actually work when it comes to collective bargaining?", these essays would not turn out well.

For me, having looked at the Federal Republic of Germany from the perspective of the former GDR for many years, it has been a very interesting process to continually grapple with the question: What is actually better? I was fundamentally of the opinion that in democracy, common sense prevails. In principle, I still hold this opinion today. However, in light of the fundamental principles of the social market economy, I must say that the explanations that have developed over the decades often make things more complicated rather than simpler. That is why, for example, there is such a fundamental longing for a simple, comprehensible tax system. But this longing is then called into question when certain groups realize that they might have a temporary disadvantage. This means that I believe societies that want to clarify their basic consensus should also have an order that can be explained to others and, above all, can be explained repeatedly to future generations.

I noticed in this citizens' dialogue that the placement of the education system in the states – for example, regarding universities – is hardly accepted today. Representatives of adult education centers, who had also thought about the question "How do we want to live tomorrow?", expressed themselves in the discussion with great anger and said: "What are you actually the Chancellor for if you can't even ensure that we have a uniform school system and can move more easily within Germany?" Since then, I have also spoken again with the state premiers and said: The ministers of education must create a system that meets the demands of the mobility of workers today in such a way that people say, "Yes, it is good that we have differences in the education system," but still the standards of this education system are designed in such a way that I can easily move from one federal state to another. However, I have learned that this is sometimes not easy even from city to city, as the types of schools in the states have become very diversified.

When we ask ourselves "How do we want to live in the future?", this is a question that assumes we fundamentally view our basic law, our fundamental rights, and our state structure as correct. I find that fundamentally correct and say that we want to further develop it. But from my perspective, there is also a very urgent question: What is happening in the world? For many years and decades, we believed that Europe and Germany were very much involved in the innovations of this earth. I believe we have succeeded very well in this, for example, with the end of the Cold War, with the reunification of Germany, and with the expansion of the European Union. After this phase, in which we gained more freedom in Europe, we suddenly realized that more freedoms had also emerged elsewhere, that modern technologies give others much more opportunities to improve their prosperity, and that others are, of course, also very ambitious.

We find that – for example, when we talk about the sovereign debt crisis in Europe today – we still represent about seven to eight percent of the world population in the European Union. When Konrad Adenauer was Chancellor, it was still around 20 percent. But it is not my fault that we are so few; it is rather because much more has happened elsewhere. With these seven to eight percent of the world population, we still produce about 25 percent of the world's gross domestic product, but we also have about 50 percent of the world's social spending – seven to eight percent of the people account for 50 percent of social spending.

When we ask ourselves how we want to live tomorrow, we must also address the question: What do we actually want to do to ensure that we can still live as well or better tomorrow, how do we remain competitive, or how do we remain the countries that produce what the world is interested in, how can we provide work for our people, and how do we learn to make do with what we earn?

In emerging countries, the question arises: Is the order of democracy one in which one can only win elections by promising more than one can keep or generate? It would be a great threat to democracy if we could not show that we can also live with what we generate, and if we do not, through debt, essentially fall into the clutches of forces – for example, the financial markets; Mr. Fitschen is here, so I must now speak properly about the financial markets – that then decide how we can still live. Paul Kirchhof recently described in a very interesting article in a Sunday newspaper how freedom can be lost if, in the end, I am dependent on others lending me money for my debt repayment and can thus dictate conditions to me.

This means that in considering the question "How do we want to live tomorrow?", we must primarily strive to ensure that we still have the ability and the opportunity to freely decide how we want to live. This will be one of the most difficult tasks in the near future. Because, unlike in the United States of America – which I often discuss with the American president – we have, for example, in Germany and tendentially also in many other European countries a demographic change – I do not want to immediately call it a "problem" –: People are living longer on average, we have more older people and fewer younger people – this means that we, on average, as a society are getting older – we are becoming more diverse and we will also, in total, be fewer. We must keep all of this in mind.

In addition, our borders are becoming much more permeable due to advancing globalization. When national measures were taken in the past – for example, introducing wealth taxes – one could assume that the cultural constitution of the individual wealthy was such that they did not have a hard time perhaps investing their wealth outside of Germany. Our neighboring country, Switzerland, has always been a good candidate for that; at least one did not always go straight to Singapore. Today, with increasing globalization, distances are shorter, and transfers are made much easier through the internet. This means I must constantly deal much more with neighboring locations and ask myself: What advantages do I offer, what disadvantages do I have; and how can I attract interesting people who create prosperity for my country?

These questions will occupy us even more in the future. That is why I am also someone who, in Europe – for which I am sometimes criticized – insists that we carry out necessary reforms. We can have as many beautiful ideas as we want, we can discuss whether we want more qualitative or more quantitative growth in the future, but all of this will be of no use to us if we ultimately are not more competitive in relation to the countries that currently have very high growth rates.

We do have enormous advantages: We have an experienced society that can resolve conflicts peacefully – that is precisely the wonderful aspect of the social market economy – we have framework conditions in which the development of the individual – despite all obstacles – works wonderfully compared to other regions of the world, in my opinion. We have freedom of expression, we have freedom of religion, we have freedom of the press, we have freedom of movement. All of this is anything but self-evident. When one sees these days how radical Islamist forces are emerging in some countries, one suddenly realizes again what one has in European life and what a great degree of community we have.

But if we isolate ourselves and say: We do not care about what is happening outside of Europe, then we will not be able to maintain our prosperity. That is why labor costs or unit labor costs are not some evil figure with which one tries to coerce other countries, but that is why the question of whether we are competitive in this regard is of crucial importance for whether we will have growth.

In some growth discussions, it sometimes seems as if growth were a quantity that we could force through legal means. But we cannot do that. Growth requires certain conditions. If in a society no one is willing to engage, to start a business, to hire people, to produce something interesting, to take risks, and to submit to economic cycles, then we can talk a lot about growth, and we can expand the state apparatus as much as we want, but there will certainly not be the growth we need for a solidary balance. Therefore, it is of utmost importance that we treat carefully those people who have ideas, who want to undertake something, who want to provide work for others. We must not disturb them, but rather encourage them to find a place in our country where they can realize themselves.

When I spoke in my citizen dialogue about the question "What do we actually want to live from?", it turned out that this was the most difficult question to answer. Especially the younger people almost always had ideas about where to raise taxes, where to make things fairer, and where to do more for environmental protection. But when I asked them, "Are you really sure that we will still have an automotive industry in 20 years, that BASF will still be the largest chemical company in the world, and that we might once again be able to produce memory chips or computer programs in large quantities?", I got the impression that they had not really engaged with these questions. It is also nice that our children are currently growing up in a world where the concern "Will there still be jobs for us?" is not one. Fortunately, it is not as urgent at the moment as it has been in many years before. Right now, we are facing a shortage of skilled workers; it is not that we have too many skilled workers.

In any case, one can state that something is changing massively in the world. It may well be that in 20 years the Chinese will also be able to build good cars. One can certainly be concerned that while we happily welcome every new generation of iPhones and iPads, we have nothing to do with their production, and that when it comes to the genetic modification of plants, we say: We want nothing to do with that. These are things that, in my view, are not discussed enough when one asks: "How do we want to live?" Because I believe one must also ask: "What do we want to live from?"

When we talk about the question "How do we want to live?", there are, at least from my experience in the discussions we had in the citizen dialogue, very clear and, I think, very beautiful ideas in Germany. There is the idea that we want to be a country where togetherness plays a big role, where the forces should not fall too far apart, and where it is accepted that there are richer and less wealthy people. Overall, there is certainly a deep feeling that it is actually better to have a certain cohesion, a rooting, and also a togetherness of generations – although there are certainly concerns in this regard.

I believe this feeling comes first from the imprint of the social market economy, which has made our country strong and has shown that employees and employers are positively dependent on each other and make decisions together. I think the experience of the great financial crisis of 2008/09 has reaffirmed our belief that we should strengthen social partnership.

I believe it comes second from the fact that the middle class in Germany plays a very large role, which, as we always say, is the backbone of our economy and can react very flexibly.

The

third

point is that there are many family businesses in this middle class that think in very long time frames and are not focused on short-term profit, as is the case in other places. These are, in my view, important strengths of our society that we must also utilize. We must also be careful that society does not drift apart. Among the medium-sized businesses, among the family businesses, there are not only small companies but also world market leaders that have achieved great success outside Germany and have long made their way into globalization.

If we look at the state of the financial world, which has experienced massive growth in recent years, I say: I am pleased that Mr. Fitschen is here today. But I also say: We certainly do not have too many financial institutions in continental Europe and in Germany. We have a very robust savings bank and cooperative bank system – I do not want to say anything against that. But if you look at which parts of the gross domestic product are generated in the financial industry in other countries, you have to say that this share in Germany is relatively small. It is, so to speak, unbalanced compared to our real economic strength. We actually need to strive for a balance because our companies need financing and liquidity. Those who provide liquidity must also feel somewhat committed to our fundamental ideas. These are again prerequisites that cannot be forced. I cannot force a hedge fund manager to adhere to the philosophy of the social market economy – I know that; I am not a dreamer. However, I believe that a strong banking landscape in continental Europe would make us stronger overall.

Therefore, it is now very important that we in Europe, together with the City of London, try to find regulations. Because if we were only dependent on financing institutions outside our own countries, we would not have the opportunity to live the social market economy as we envision it. During the financial crisis, we painfully became aware that there is hardly an international newspaper – with the exception of the "Frankfurter Allgemeine" – of world renown. It is mostly Anglo-Saxon newspapers that shape opinions about economic processes. There is also no rating agency in continental Europe. This means that many institutions that are of utmost importance for the question of how we live come from a sphere that does not necessarily share our way of living immediately. This also constitutes part of the debates.

One could now say: Where is the difference – these are also democracies, these are free countries where all the values that are important to us also apply. However, there is a difference: I believe that in our case, thinking in longer time frames is more pronounced and the sense of security is more deeply rooted. While in America one says, "I will just try it now and am also willing to take a higher risk," this willingness to take risks is less pronounced in our case.

But if we want to live the way we want to live, then we must ensure that we generate this as independently as possible. Therefore, I keep returning to the question: How do we manage to remain an innovative, a creative society – a society in which sufficiently many people are engaged in the fields of engineering, natural sciences, and technical professions? Because we must also advocate politically very strongly for these areas. We now have more students in all these fields again, but we also have a huge shortage of skilled workers, which means that the best German companies may have to establish foreign branches because they cannot find enough trained people here.

Against this background, the question also arises: Are we actually ready to accept immigration? We have struggled with this and have discussed it a lot – my party often struggles with it as well. But we have now decided to allow skilled workers into the country. Without immigration of well-educated people, we will not succeed.

Connected to this is also a point that I believe we need to overcome much more strongly. Whether we want it or not: The English language will play an increasingly important role worldwide and, I believe, also when we talk about Europe. We have been arguing for 25 years about the European patent because all countries believe their language must be represented in the European patent. We have somehow managed to get this sorted out in the spirit of enhanced cooperation. But when we talk about how we can achieve more mobility in the European labor market with 25 percent unemployment in Spain and our shortage of skilled workers in Germany, I honestly cannot think of much else than to tell all skilled workers: You must learn a foreign language – and that will be English – so that we can communicate more easily and gain more mobility. Because it is certainly better to work in Germany, the Netherlands, or Sweden than to remain unemployed for a long time somewhere in Spain or Portugal.

I believe that with seven billion people in the world and in light of the great dynamics in various regions of the world, no single country in Europe will be able to realize its vision of how it wants to live unless a European dimension unites us. We can achieve little as individual countries in the world regarding future design, the handling of natural resources, or sustainability. Germany, with 80 million inhabitants, is still the largest among the European countries, but will soon make up less than one percent of the world’s population.

This means that Europe, in my view, takes on a whole new significance for the question of how we want to live. When the European Union was founded, Europe was the insurance that there would never be war again. Nevertheless, one should always be aware – one only needs to look at the western Balkans – that it can happen very quickly that disputes flare up again. However, I believe that we have internalized this "never again war"; we have achieved that. Security is present to a degree we have not known before. Given seven billion people on Earth and various social forms and ways of life, I firmly believe that we can only bring our values into the world community and assert them, or at least part of them, within a European framework.

Therefore, we will have to ask ourselves the question – even if we Europeans are very different –: Is it worth it to engage for this Europe, or is it not worth it? I spoke at the beginning about the need for Europe to be competitive. But currently, we have problems with that. Who do we support and how? How do we manage to create reasonable economic conditions together? We must work against mistakes that did not arise yesterday or two or three years ago. These misdevelopments have rather emerged at the latest ten years ago, many already 20 or 30 years ago.

Now one could say: If everything has gone wrong for so long, then it makes no sense to continue with it. But I say: That is the absolutely wrong answer. Once we have jointly recognized what has gone wrong, the first answer must be that Europe needs to gain more credibility. I certainly rely on the European Union; and of course, especially on the area where we have a common currency. This means in a good sense: More Europe – not by giving up diversity, not by giving up nation-states, but by providing a common proof of credibility.

Because on the financial markets, where one certainly does not form a concrete picture of every single city in Europe and its traditions, it has been recognized that we Europeans have promised a lot but have not kept much. Therefore, our greatest task in the coming years is to regain credibility. Even in the year 2000, the heads of state and government of the European Union declared that they wanted to have the most dynamic continent by 2010. No one currently says that Europe is that. However, the goal itself was right. Back then, it was said: Each country must spend three percent of its gross domestic product on research and development. Today, you can find everything possible in the European Union between 0.7 and 3.5 percent, but you do not get the impression that anyone has cared about the guideline that it should be at least three percent.

This means that the most important thing we need for Europe, which I believe is our guarantee for the preservation of democracy, prosperity, and freedom in the future, is credibility. This naturally means that one feels committed to the European institutions to the extent that one actually implements the promises made. That is what the current discussion is about, no more and no less. It is not about someone giving up their nation-state. It is not about someone committing to something additional, but it is simply about actually implementing everything that has already been promised.

When we ask how we want to live, when we want to be credible in the world, when we want to show that living in democracies does not mean constantly breaking promises, then we currently have one of the more difficult tests to pass. But if we pass it and endure it, if we are successful, then we really have a good chance for the future.

Now I believe that there is a large number of people in our country who say: We are actually living at a very high material standard; we have many of the things we need, and we do not always need more of everything material, but we need more cohesion, perhaps more investment in health, more culture, more education – in other words, what can be referred to as qualitative growth factors. In this regard, I believe we can again be an example of a highly developed society. In the history of humanity, there have actually been few societies in which all members of society had a good right to education, fair treatment in the healthcare system, and equal participation in elections. Such societies did exist – we see this when we look at the last millennia – perhaps for sub-societies, for the upper classes; but that this applied to everyone has not proven to be a centuries-old successful model so easily. In this respect, we have the chance to show that we can do this. However, we do not have this chance if we spend more every year than we take in, thus robbing future generations of any leeway.

Therefore, I see the task in the question of how we want to live primarily as proving that we are capable of thinking beyond our own generation. This is not so easy in the current phase of the Federal Republic of Germany, because, as I said, we will have more older people, and it is naturally in the nature of older individuals to consider their own life perspective for a shorter time compared to younger ones. Furthermore, as fewer and fewer people have children and grandchildren, we must find a way to strengthen social cohesion through education, through community, through new forms of living together – we have talked about community centers, we have intergenerational houses, we have sponsorships between older and younger people. Various forms of participation, togetherness, and networking within society will play a much stronger role if society develops as is absolutely foreseeable today.

If we can show that we can manage demographic change and move away from debt – that writing the debt brake into the Basic Law was a significant effort – then we will have achieved something truly great in a civilizational and cultural sense. However, that has not yet been accomplished. Today, there is more willingness to think about it.

When the television channel suddenly went silent in Brussels while the Chinese Prime Minister was speaking, someone in my constituency came up to me and said: Mrs. Merkel, is it already that bad, are we so indebted that they can just turn off the camera? I replied: No, I do not think it is that bad; and I do not even know how that happened. However, I notice: People are worried. This means: If we want to live self-determined lives, if we want to have control over our way of living – and I am convinced that we want that; you all spoke about it today – then we still have a lot of work to do on the foundations for that.

I believe there is another aspect of why our lives will change significantly – although I cannot predict it exactly, as I am a "digital migrant"; young people will know better – namely the Internet. In any case, for me, the opportunities of the Internet far outweigh the questions we need to address. I can imagine that the possibilities of the Internet, the possibilities of communication can serve us very well on the way to answering the question of how we want to live together and how we want to maintain the cohesion of society in all areas of society. Of course, there are always dangers associated with it, but we will also have opportunities that we have never had before. We will be much better informed about other countries. We will grow into a world where it may be completely natural for children to know very early on what Chinese culture and Indian culture look like, how things work elsewhere, what others can do, where our products come from – all of that which used to take much longer.

One last plea: We will, above all, have many more children with a migration background, and many of these children, if they are well educated, will already inherently know about two or three cultures. Today, we often see this as a huge integration task; and in many respects, it is indeed a huge task. However, in discussions, for example, with young footballers with a migration background or with musicians or other groups of people with different cultural backgrounds who have a common task, it becomes clear that a different cultural background can also be an incredible enrichment. There are potentials in this that we really need to utilize in our society. Therefore, we must address everyone and say: We really need everyone in this country to keep it livable and to fully retain our self-determination.

When I was recently in Indonesia, the Indonesian President told me: "When I took office in 2004, we also had a debt like yours, namely at 83 percent. We are now at 24 percent. You cannot imagine how good I feel again because I have the impression: I can decide again what I want to decide." When we talk about reducing the debt ratio in Europe, which is over 60 percent of GDP, by one-twentieth each year in the coming years, and if we will have the greatest difficulty doing so, then you can see the task we are facing.

Therefore, I simply invite you to advocate for sustainable living and for as many people as possible to engage in public discussion and be willing to accept different opinions and form a common consensus from them. Because one must note – especially in light of the great media diversity – that every peaceful discussion with different starting positions – which can then lead to a compromise only after several steps – is immediately labeled as a dispute. A society that discusses problems as if there were only conflict or peace will not be able to solve the problems. Therefore, we also need a good culture of discussion to solve the tasks at hand. That is why I wish for engaged citizens, but civilized disputes – a really good culture of debate, if I may say so. The Alfred Herrhausen Society proves to be an organization that continually initiates this and continually attracts people. Thank you very much for that.

We were pleased with how many participated in our dialogue about the future of Germany. We received over 11,000 proposals on the topics "How do we want to live together?", "How do we want to learn?", and "What do we want to live from?" We are now trying to assess these proposals for their feasibility. In almost all proposals, there was no concern about who is responsible for what in this country. Instead, it was said: Please find mechanisms for how to cooperate between the federal government, states, and municipalities to solve the problems of the people. This is also what many mean when they say that the person should be at the center of the whole question and not the institution that just fits or does not fit and then sends the person on to the next institution.

I really enjoyed this citizen dialogue. I hope you enjoyed this day very much. Let us fight for our future. We have all the chances, but it is not legally anchored that it will continue as it has between 1949 and now. Therefore – because many others in the world also want to make progress – let us show that we can do that too.