Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the German Employers' Day on October 16, 2012, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

16 October 2012 · German Employers' Day · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Employers' Day in Berlin on October 16, 2012, discussing economic policy, wages, and pension reform with employer representatives.
Main themes
Infrastructure investment, pension system reform, wage floors and minimum wage, additional wage costs, social security sustainability, domestic demand stimulation, pension contribution reduction, demographic challenges, collective bargaining, social justice and regional equality, private retirement provision, German employment situation
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,113
77th percentile
Sentences
148
80th percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
10.8
30th percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
7th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 38%36%
  • Social 20%19%
  • Institutional 19%18%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Geopolitical 7%7%
  • Environmental 4%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

148 sentences in 30 paragraphs

important point, we must also consider the issue of investment in infrastructure. We know that our infrastructure is in need of modernization and expansion. This is not just about roads and bridges, but also about digital infrastructure, which is becoming increasingly important in our interconnected world. We need to ensure that our businesses can operate efficiently and that our citizens have access to the services they need.

Investing in infrastructure is not just a matter of economic necessity; it is also a matter of social justice. We must ensure that all regions in Germany have equal access to opportunities and that no one is left behind. This is particularly important in rural areas, where access to services can be limited.

In conclusion, I would like to emphasize that we are at a crucial juncture. The decisions we make today will shape the future of our economy and our society. We must work together, across party lines and with all stakeholders, to create a prosperous future for all. Thank you for your attention.

The point is about the additional wage costs. For many years, we have discussed additional wage costs with the BDA because they were comparatively high in Germany compared to other countries. I believe that today, due to the good employment situation, we can jointly say that the additional wage costs are at an acceptable level. However, we have also decided, as Mr. Hundt has demanded, to lower the pension insurance contribution now that it is legally possible, because we believe that especially at this moment, domestic demand should be stimulated by all possible means.

The reduction of the pension insurance contribution has, of course, the advantage, in contrast to tax reductions, that it benefits employees from the very first euro they earn. This is a difference from tax progression. Since we have a sort of flat rate in our social systems, because the full social insurance contribution rate is applied to incomes, it would be important to relieve those who earn very little in a special way.

Since I am already on the topic of social security systems, I also want to address the question of the future of the pension system. I believe, Mr. Hundt, that I, with all due respect, do not need to protect Ms. von der Leyen from anything, nor you from Ms. von der Leyen, because she is fulfilling her duty when she thinks about a topic that, in my view, will be of particular importance in the coming years. We do not feel this at the moment, as the employment situation is good, which is why the pension level is not currently declining as it would if we had fewer employees today. But we know that, given the demographic structure of our population, there will be a decline in the pension level by the year 2030. We say: not lower than 43 percent, but we must expect a level significantly below 50 percent.

Now the BDA says, for example: We do not want a uniform statutory minimum wage. I understand that. However, I say: In the Federal Republic of Germany, the situation is that not all employees have a collective agreement anymore. Therefore, the Union has at least decided to introduce wage floors – sector-specific and regionally different, but at least for all areas without collective agreements – because we believe that there are currently employment relationships that are not fairly compensated. Now one might say: There are few or many. At least today, it is no longer a situation as the BDA might have found it 30 years ago, where most socially insured employment relationships were also bound by collective agreements. We no longer have that situation; especially in the service sector, this is no longer the case today. Therefore, we believe that we need wage floors.

But regardless of whether it is a minimum wage or a wage floor: hourly wages of under ten euros will, with a pension level significantly below 50 percent, certainly lead to a situation in the future where one does not receive a pension at the level of basic security, even after many years of employment. How do you actually want to maintain the acceptance of a system when you have to tell people the following: For the so-called benchmark pension, you need to earn about 15.65 euros an hour today and be insured for 45 years; you would have to work for 33 years at a pension level of 43 percent to reach the basic security level? Then you can calculate how many years someone earning nine euros an hour would have to work to receive a pension at the level of basic security. Do we seriously want to tell people who have been insured for 45 years, who earn a wage that is not among the average wages but below it, that after 45 years of contributions, they will receive exactly the same basic security as someone who has not contributed a single day? That is politically untenable. Therefore, we must change that.

I absolutely agree with Mr. Hundt: In the future, private provision will also be part of pension provision. The statutory pension alone will not be sufficient. Until now, I have only spoken about long-term insured individuals who should at least receive their pension from the pension insurance above the level of basic security. Therefore, we should also ensure for long-term insured individuals that the supplementary provision, for which they have contributed over many years, is not completely offset against basic security, but that a certain portion can be retained, so that those who engage in private provision can say in old age: After long-term insurance, I have something from it and I differ from those who have never contributed.

These are the two elements we are working on, and I fully support the Federal Minister of Labor. The topic she has raised is an important one. It is also not only being discussed by us in the government.

Another major task for the future competitiveness of our economy is the issue of securing skilled workers. Although we have fewer than three million unemployed, we still have almost three million unemployed. This means that a primary focus remains on getting the unemployed into work. I would like to extend a heartfelt thank you to all those in the room who are doing something for the training of young people who are initially declared unfit for training after school, who are guided through courses, internships, and one-year training phases to vocational training. Because young people who enter the workforce at the ages of 16, 17, or 18 have a chance. For young people who have never had a stable job beyond the age of 30, it will be much, much more difficult to achieve a continuous work biography. Therefore, it is worth fighting early for each individual. Thank you to those who do that.

But we also know: It is not enough, given the demographic development, to rely solely on those who are already in our country. We must also seek skilled workers from abroad.

In this regard, I would like to mention three things.

First, the federal government has introduced a recognition law for people who have obtained a professional qualification abroad. This should already be implemented in the federal states, so that the professional qualifications of those who have had to work underqualified in Germany because their foreign qualifications were not recognized will be easier to recognize in the future.

There are real paradoxes: For example, if you, as a former citizen of the GDR, obtained a professional qualification in Russia or Bulgaria and fell under the regulations of the unification treaty, the qualification as a mathematician, physicist, or engineer was of course recognized because it was regulated in the treaty. However, if you came to the Federal Republic of Germany after German reunification with a Russian qualification, this recognition was not granted. Therefore, it is high time that we do something about this.

The second point concerns the skilled workers we allow to immigrate. We have implemented the EU directive, the so-called Blue Card directive, and reduced the income thresholds. We believe that this provides a better opportunity to actually bring the skilled workers we need to Germany.

The third point, which is very important to me, is a European point. We have a single market in the European Union. This has become quite natural for us. However, what we do not have is a unified labor market. If we really want to live the single market, it also includes the possibility of finding a job much more easily anywhere in the European Union. Today, we have many Spanish, Portuguese, and other young people who are unemployed. At the same time, we have a shortage of labor, for example, in Germany. What we must achieve in the coming years is that it becomes a matter of course to not only be able to study in another European country – that has become relatively self-evident – but also to be able to learn a profession, for example. For this, we also need more portability of our social security systems – a major topic; I am thinking, for example, of company pensions. Where there is a will, there must also be a way. On the other hand, we need better language training for young people – including skilled workers. In ten or twenty years, it must be taken for granted that every young person speaks a second language with which they can communicate abroad. This is a task for our young people in Germany and also for our entrepreneurs in Germany, just as it is a task for young people in other countries.

I would like to mention a topic in connection with the competitiveness of our country that Mr. Hundt has also mentioned, namely the issue of collective bargaining unity. I am also aware of all public statements on this. Perhaps, Mr. Hundt, we should sit down together with all the sources you have quoted; then it should be possible to come up with a law on collective bargaining unity within an evening. I do not want to say that some speak differently to me than to you. We should just try it. I want us to come to a solution on this. Therefore, we should tackle this. I would then invite Mr. Sommer to complete the discussion, so we have a nice roundtable. Because in this matter, there is a rare harmony between the BDA and the DGB that we want to fully exploit.

Another topic you mentioned, which I would also like to address because it is of extreme importance for the industrial location of Germany, is the issue of energy prices, energy supply, and the future of energy supply in the Federal Republic of Germany. It has not even been a year and a half since we made a cross-party decision to phase out nuclear energy by 2022. I have no intention of revising this decision, and I do not know anyone in the political arena who wants that. This means we must hurry – you said it yourself.

Now it may seem that not much has happened this year. I would disagree with that. We have achieved quite a bit, but we are far from where we need to be. What has not yet been sufficiently accomplished but must succeed in the coming months is that we coordinate our ideas for the expansion of renewable energies and the necessary infrastructure we need for that. This task is not trivial, because on the one hand, we have a Renewable Energy Act that cannot be changed by decree, but for which majorities are needed for amendments. We experienced this firsthand with the revision of the Renewable Energy Act in connection with photovoltaics last summer or spring. It does not help if individuals are brave and suggest how to quickly make the funding rates degressive. Because this courage from one group immediately provokes the counter-courage of the other group, which says that this must not be done.

We can observe a very interesting case with this example: If sufficiently many people benefit from a regulation, it will always become more difficult to abolish this regulation by democratic means. As soon as a majority benefits and is no longer willing to give it up, that is how it is. Now one must honestly say: It is not only the Greens and perhaps a few SPD members who would like to have photovoltaic systems on their roofs; this extends far into the middle class and the economy – at least I suspect so – and far into the use of municipal properties, if one still has a municipal conversion area. The yield from photovoltaic systems can make airports profitable, can pay off household debts, can do many wonderful things, because there is nothing more secure than a guaranteed return for 20 years. Since we also do not have to expect incredible losses in sunlight, measured against the current sunlight in Germany, because smog has largely been fought, this is one of the safest and most predictable sources of income. However, finding reasonable changes for this requires at least a majority in the German Bundestag plus a majority in the Bundesrat.

The increase in electricity costs that we are currently experiencing due to the rise in the EEG surcharge is relatively complicated. Photovoltaics is one element of this. However, of the 1.7 cents increase, it accounts for only 0.35 cents. The use of biomass, which has much smaller installed capacities, contributes 0.2 cents; likewise, wind power, although the capacity we have available today is similar to that of photovoltaics. In any case, we have a cost increase; and we need to talk about this. The Greens are now talking less about the cost increases from photovoltaics, wind power, and so on; they simply leave that out and do not discuss the legislative processes either. I understand that, as it is not particularly necessary at the moment. However, as Federal Chancellor, I must also address this.

There is also a component that accounts for 0.5 cents, which results from the fact that, at the request of the economy, we have removed more businesses from the EEG surcharge. Now, one cannot demand one thing on one hand and then say on the other hand: I want nothing to do with this matter. We need to take another look at this part as well. We must therefore examine whether it was actually correct to remove so many companies, as there are now more than those that are in international competition. If the effect is that all those for whom no exemption applies have a high electricity price, while others, who are also not in international competition but just barely fall under the exemption regulation, pay a lower electricity price, then that is problematic.

Furthermore, one must also see the following: Part of the increase in the EEG surcharge is based – listen and be amazed – on the fact that electricity has become cheaper on the stock market. Since the funding costs for renewable energies are of course always the same, but electricity has become cheaper, the differential costs are higher. This means that this also constitutes part of the EEG surcharge. However, this cannot contribute to the increase in electricity prices, but only to the fact that the electricity price does not decrease. I ask you to consider this as well. I see an urgent need for reform in the EEG, but I also see the necessity to coordinate between Northern and Southern Germany regarding who is expanding which renewable energies. Because this determines what infrastructure we need. If every federal state wants to become self-sufficient in its energy supply, regardless of whether it has mountains or sea air, then we will not succeed in Germany.

The good news is that we have found a working rhythm with all the state premiers. The federal government normally meets with the state premiers twice a year. Now we have two additional meetings each year to take on exactly these coordination tasks. I rely on everyone's willingness to find a reasonable way to guarantee environmental friendliness, supply security, and affordability of electricity at the same time. I am passionately engaged in this task; however, it is a very ambitious task. If we navigate this new territory well and if we get through all the difficult situations, then Germany will serve as an example for many countries around the world on how to create a modern, future-proof energy supply. Therefore, I believe that the effort is worthwhile and that we can develop an export hit from this one day. With this optimism, Mr. Hundt, I am happy to engage in the discussion again.

Overall, it is firstly important that we – as good as the situation is in which Germany currently finds itself – do not forget to set the course for the future.

Secondly

, we should devote ourselves with all our passion to solving the problems in Europe. Germany can only thrive if Europe thrives as well. Just as we could say that Germany emerged from the 2008/2009 crisis stronger than it entered it, one day it must also be true for Europe that Europe emerges from the crisis stronger than it entered it.

Today, we have seven billion people living in the world. As the largest European country with 80 million people, we are hardly able to determine any relevant size in the international concert alone that corresponds to our ideas of life. Therefore, 500 million Europeans who share their fundamental values, who stand for democracy, for freedom of expression, for tolerance, for freedom of religion, for freedom of the press, for freedom of assembly, are, so to speak, an insurance for us that we can continue our way of life in the future. Therefore, this effort is worthwhile; and therefore, what we invest in this task is certainly well invested. In this respect, we must, on the one hand, of course, be strict in many areas and say: Ultimately, the conditions in each country are always very concrete conditions. On the other hand, we must sometimes also remember how difficult we find some reforms, which is why we have no reason to constantly point fingers at others who are slower in some respects. The quality of Europe also arises from European diversity. Through this diversity, we are enriched.

We still have a lot to do. I thank you for allowing me to present my thoughts to you today. I wish you all the best for your conference.