Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the congress "Yes to TTIP! Seize Opportunities, Safeguard Interests, Shape the Future" of the CDU/CSU parliamentary group in the German Bundestag on the 21st ...

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

22 September 2015 · Congress "Yes to TTIP! Seize Opportunities, Safeguard Interests, Shape the Future" of the CDU/CSU parliamentary group in the German Bundestag

Context
Merkel addressed a CDU/CSU parliamentary group congress on TTIP in Berlin on 21 September 2015, advocating for the EU-US free trade agreement.
Main themes
TTIP negotiations, transatlantic trade and investment partnership, free trade agreements, parliamentary involvement and democratic legitimacy, export success and economic growth, EU-US trade relations, transparency in trade negotiations, German industry competitiveness, public skepticism and debate, EU trade policy
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,700
83rd percentile
Sentences
197
89th percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
2.90
34th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
11th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 52%51%
  • Institutional 19%18%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 3%

197 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Dear Volker Kauder,

dear Gerda Hasselfeldt,

dear Michael Fuchs,

dear colleagues from the various parliaments,

esteemed guests who are participating in the discussion here,

ladies and gentlemen,

never before has a free trade agreement of the European Union received as much public attention as the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership of the European Union with the United States of America. Never before have the parliaments in Europe been so closely involved in the negotiations of a free trade agreement as in this case. The European Parliament adopted a comprehensive resolution on this agreement in July. This resolution was preceded by months of discussions in all committees of the European Parliament. The free trade agreement has also been repeatedly on the agenda in the Bundestag's committees and in the plenary since the negotiations began two years ago.

I am very pleased that our parliamentary group in the Bundestag is so engaged in the parliamentary debate on this agreement. The work of the working group led by Michael Fuchs is particularly important in this regard. A heartfelt thank you for accompanying this process so well from a parliamentary perspective. I believe this commitment must and should continue. Today's congress is an expression of this lively and committed support. I would like to extend my heartfelt thanks to all who have contributed to this.

For one thing is clear: Parliamentary work – whether in the European Parliament or here in the German Bundestag, whether in the factions or in the committees or in the plenary – makes a very important contribution to the success of the negotiations. And one thing is also clear: In the end, the parliaments must decide. If there has been an engaged accompaniment of the negotiations, then this decision can be made much better.

The involvement of the parliaments also illustrates the democratic legitimacy of the negotiation process. It strengthens the transparency of the negotiations, and – I also say this – it leads to new ideas. In the end, we want a good agreement that is supported not only by the governments and member states but also by the parliaments. Therefore, I encourage you – the really intense phase of the negotiations is still to come – to continue this kind of support. This is necessary. Because even in our constituencies, there is very intense discussion about this free trade agreement. There is a lot of skepticism and a clear rejection among many. Therefore, it is necessary that we can argue. I believe we have very good arguments.

We must first focus on what this agreement is really about and what it is not about. From my perspective, the success of our companies in international markets is too often overlooked in the discussion, even though this success is of great importance for growth and employment. We should think about our interests in this context, about the question of where our prosperity comes from and how it is generated. As a major exporting nation, we depend on good export conditions when it comes to creating new jobs.

A number of supposed contents and consequences of the free trade agreement are often discussed, even though both negotiating partners in Europe and America have long agreed that these topics should not be part of the agreement at all. This means we are discussing a lot about things that are not going to happen, but which have long been excluded and about which it has already been said: that does not matter.

This means we need to clarify even more, time and again, what this agreement actually means for companies, employees, and consumers. The contribution that an ambitious trade policy of the European Union can make to the success of our companies in global markets can be very well seen in existing free trade agreements. I want to cite the example of the agreement with South Korea. It was also hotly debated, especially in industrial circles. I still remember exactly how I discussed with Matthias Wissmann what the agreement meant for the German automotive industry and for the suppliers. I just want to say: In the first half of 2015, German exports to South Korea were over 50 percent higher than the level before the agreement came into force in July 2011. German total exports increased by only 13 percent during the same period. With South Korea, it was 50 percent, overall on average 13 percent – I do not know how one can claim that this has nothing to do with each other. I think it is a pretty strong indication that a free trade agreement can intensify trade.

The German automotive industry – which I have already mentioned – as a sector that has rightly negotiated its interests very intensively, has benefited just as much as the electrical engineering and chemical, pharmaceutical, and metal industries. This success of our trade policy should motivate us to conclude the negotiations with the USA, our most important trading partner, quickly.

I also want to remind you that not only we, the European Union, are negotiating free trade agreements, but that a multitude of bilateral trade agreements are being negotiated worldwide. Listen and be amazed: China, for example, has already concluded a free trade agreement with Switzerland. Switzerland is not exactly known as a country that lacks certain consumer protection standards and certain quality standards. This is very interesting. China has also negotiated a free trade agreement with Iceland and is telling us other Europeans, of course: You have not even properly considered the topic.

Back to exports to the United States of America. In the first six months, German exports to the USA increased by almost a quarter to around 55 billion euros. The United States thus became the most important export destination for our companies worldwide for the first time. At the same time, German imports from America increased by 19 percent to 29 billion euros. Therefore, it should be a matter of course for two such large partners – I have already said what exports to America mean for Germany; they are significantly higher at 55 billion euros than the 29 billion euros of German imports from the United States – to consider what unnecessary trade barriers can still be removed between these two partners. Because what reasons are there not to talk about barriers with the largest trading partner when I am talking about barriers with everyone else in the world?

This applies, on the one hand, to the reduction of tariffs. It is already becoming clear that we will agree on a very far-reaching reduction of tariffs in the agreement. So far, so good. Most international free trade agreements are also agreements on the reduction of tariffs. The German automotive industry alone pays about one billion US dollars a year in tariffs to the USA. This money can be invested much better through a reasonable agreement, for example, in the development of new drive technologies or other products.

On the other hand, the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership aims at much more than just the reduction of tariffs. This is probably the point why the discussions are so intense. We do not only want to reduce tariffs, but we want to set a new standard for free trade agreements of the European Union as a whole with this agreement. It is about creating the foundations for the European Union and the United States of America to gradually grow together into a common economic area in the medium term. This is the reason why we are negotiating not only about tariffs but also about a multitude of non-tariff trade barriers. These non-tariff trade barriers are obviously the area where the discomfort and skepticism of many are located.

What is a non-tariff trade barrier? You, who are sitting here, of course know that. But I will say it again. These are trade barriers that exist, for example, in different safety approvals. We certainly do not have the situation in the USA with auto parts, whether it is brake lights or other parts, that traffic safety does not play a role. In Germany, traffic safety is also highly regarded. But whether a light should be orange or rather yellowish is a topic that can be debated when it comes to the question of what is safer.

Now, the result of reducing non-tariff trade barriers will not necessarily be: Everyone must apply the American solution or everyone must apply the European solution. Instead, a first step could also be the mutual recognition of the respective safety tests. This means that there are then different possibilities to say about different parts: These are safe; and those are also safe.

With regard to areas of consumer protection, there is great concern about what it means if the United States of America has a different consumer protection system than we do.

In this regard, I want to say as

First

that I cannot share the implicit assumption that all regulations in the United States of America are worse than in Europe. It is true that the Americans have a completely different legal system. But whether it is stricter or less strict is difficult to assess. Consumer protection and consumer safety also play a significant role in the United States of America.

Now it is about how we can bring these things together. The really important thing here is that we clearly state: European law, that is, our standards, are not up for negotiation. I could understand it if one were to say that we are starting to reduce European standards. But we are not doing that. The clear promise is on the table that what we have agreed upon in Europe will not be up for debate but will be the basis of the negotiations and will be adhered to. Conversely, the same applies to the United States of America. This means it is about the alignment of standards or the mutual acceptance of standards.

Now something is being negotiated – it is admittedly really new – that has not been a topic in classical trade negotiations so far. Classical trade negotiators in the WTO or at the European Union's trade commissioner are people who are familiar with tariffs. But – here comes the point – of course, one must also involve a broader spectrum of experts – people who have knowledge of consumer protection, environmental protection, and also social standards.

As a former Minister of the Environment, I have had long discussions about what justice in the sense of international trade means at the World Trade Organization. We know that if our agriculture, if our farmers here in Germany operate livestock farming and crop production according to the principles of good professional practice, and if elsewhere in the world such environmental standards, consumer standards, and the best professional practices are not adhered to, we ultimately have little chance of achieving fair conditions in world trade because our standards are so much higher and therefore production is many times more expensive.

This means it is in line with our philosophy and our sense of justice when we, who have high standards, say: We cannot just negotiate the price and tariff for beef, but we also ask how much environmental protection and how much proper, sustainable agriculture is behind it? Because it is illogical to give money to countries that have ruined their soils or deforested their forests just because we have only standardized tariffs but not the production conditions.

Now I also know that we cannot achieve this overnight. But our consumers will increasingly be interested in questions such as whether child labor is excluded and what the social standards are. In this context, we are now placing special emphasis on international supply chains within the framework of the G7 process. This means it is in our interest to try out with a country that also has relatively high standards how far we can agree on common standards in order to then discuss sustainable conditions of doing business with other countries in the commonality of these two large economic areas. That we are now fighting against this, although we have never fought against trade agreements that were only about tariffs, does not make sense to me. Of course, this is now much more complex and much more complicated. In addition to the classical trade experts, others must also be involved. But I believe it is important and right that we face this process.

Now comes another point. Let us think about the future. There are entire areas in which we are constantly creating new regulations – whether it concerns data protection, nanotechnology, or new products in other fields. We have committed to working closely with the United States from the very beginning to prevent double regulations from arising, but rather to establish common regulations that prevent the need to reinvent everything. Therefore, the legislative scope in Germany, in the EU, or in the USA is not restricted. Everyone can make their own regulations. But where possible, we should try to coordinate regulations from the outset. This is done voluntarily; it is not mandatory.

That is why I believe that the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership offers us many new opportunities. It also gives us the chance to provide the regulations we have on investment protection with a new international standard. To this end, the Commission has now made a proposal. Investment protection, I would say, has not really interested anyone in the German public for many years. We have negotiated investment protection agreements for decades, about which there was never any public debate. Now there is a public debate. These agreements were, by the way, of great importance to many companies in Germany because they protected companies from arbitrariness in certain countries to which they would otherwise have been exposed.

For example, there was a very interesting discussion: When Ukraine felt it was treated unfairly regarding Russian gas prices, it went to such an international arbitration court and said: Resolve this. Because one could not immediately assume that one would get justice in Russia on this issue.

There are many such cases – even within the European Union. I know solar companies that were affected by a retroactive reduction of subsidies in Spain and then tried to obtain justice before an international arbitration court regarding whether subsidies can simply be withdrawn retroactively, which of course undermines economic planning. Such cases occur repeatedly. That is why such courts have actually proven their worth.

Now, however, one still wants to arrive at a modern, transparent rule-of-law procedure. Even the provisions in the trade agreement with Canada regarding investment protection procedures are much more modern and transparent than ever before. Interestingly, the discussion arose at the moment when investment protection issues were no longer negotiated bilaterally between countries, but became part of the European treaties with the Lisbon Treaty. Now Europe is taking care of it. This has now led to a Europe-wide discussion. The Commission has now made an interesting proposal regarding the establishment of an international arbitration court that could function bilaterally between the United States and Europe for the first time. We explicitly welcome this proposal and will bring it into the negotiations.

In addition to the many advantages we can point to, it is also important to make clear what is not to be agreed upon. The Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership will neither impose requirements for the promotion of culture and media nor affect the German fixed book price law. It will also not impair the existing structures of public services. There is a joint declaration from the European Union and the United States on this. It will not weaken the high standards of labor protection in Germany. Food standards will not be lowered – neither regarding the import of the much-discussed "chlorinated chickens" nor of hormone-treated meat and genetically modified organisms. I think this has become widely known by now. But it does no harm to repeat it.

We want to achieve a good, fair, and at the same time ambitious agreement at the end of the negotiations, which has many winners. This will include large and small companies. Especially small and medium-sized enterprises depend on the reduction of tariffs and double regulations when it comes to finding an entry into a highly dynamic, growing market in America. Consumers should also be winners. They will benefit from a good free trade agreement through lower prices and a broader range of products. For example, under the umbrella of the Transatlantic Economic Council, there is already an agreement on mutual recognition of ecologically produced food. This has significantly facilitated trade in organic products while maintaining the same quality of the products.

We must also not lose sight of the dynamics with which other countries and regions are advancing the reduction of trade barriers. I would like to remind you of the Trans-Pacific Partnership and the many initiatives in the Asian region. For example, China has concluded an agreement with Indonesia and many others among themselves. It is very important for Europe and the USA not to lag behind in this regard, but rather to be at the forefront.

I would also like to remind you that the European Union has long been negotiating a free trade agreement with India in parallel with the agreement with the United States. We are in talks with Japan. Others complain that we have not yet started negotiations with them at all. This means that it is by no means only about a single free trade agreement.

Moreover, we share with the USA the conviction that we must respond to the global challenges of the 21st century primarily in a multilateral way. Therefore, we will continue to work vigorously, even though it has been a long time, for the conclusion of the Doha Round.

In addition to companies, consumers, and employees, the transatlantic relations as a whole will also gain new momentum from a free trade agreement. I am also convinced of this. The close transatlantic partnership is based not only on the diligence, innovative strength, and performance readiness of our populations but also on our shared values. Despite all the differences that will undoubtedly continue to exist between the United States and us, on both sides of the Atlantic, we should never forget that Europe and the United States could not wish for a better partner for each other. The transatlantic relations are of existential and paramount importance to us in many areas.

This also applies to the management of many current crises, foremost in the Near and Middle East, which are currently keeping us on our toes and which are becoming particularly palpable for all of us in Europe with the many, many people coming to us. For example, we have not yet managed to resolve the conflict in Syria. But to believe that Europe could do this alone, without the help of the United States, seems to me not quite realistic. Never before since World War II have so many people been on the run as today. America, Europe, and many other partners – let us think of Australia, for example – are ready and able to provide protection to many of the people who have a legitimate claim for asylum. However, we also share the common conviction that this can at best be acute emergency aid and that the highest priority must rather be the fight against the root causes of flight.

The fair distribution of refugees, better protection of Europe's external borders, direct assistance on the ground – that is, in the refugee camps in Turkey, Lebanon, and Jordan – as well as the fight against the root causes of flight will also determine the discussions of the European interior ministers and the heads of state and government tomorrow and the day after tomorrow. These discussions will be important. But they will certainly not set aside the problem we have. A solution overnight cannot and will not happen. Instead, many more councils and discussions will follow. We will need patience and perseverance. We will also have to show resolve as Europeans. This includes, for example, that in my view it is worth every effort to do everything possible to decide on important issues such as the distribution of refugees by consensus among the 28 member states rather than by qualified majority. Recent European history has shown us time and again that our efforts for consensus sometimes demand a lot from us, but that it is still very valuable to try this path again and again. In any case, Germany will focus its efforts on this this week.

At the G7 summit in Elmau, we agreed with our American partners to immediately accelerate work on all topics of the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership. Our goal is to reach an agreement on the basic outlines of the agreement by the end of the year if possible. We will still have to work hard to achieve this. But we should really not waste any time. We need to accelerate the negotiations. This is in our own interest – at least as much as in the American interest. Sometimes one gets the impression that we are only doing the United States a favor. I explicitly say: It is in our interest that we negotiate constructively – in detail, but also with regard to the great opportunities that this trade and investment partnership offers.

I would like to thank everyone in the faction who is dealing with this issue and who is conducting the negotiations, discussions, and today’s discussions in exactly this spirit. I am firmly convinced: The opportunities far outweigh the risks. It is worth discussing intensively. There is no need to worry that we could not justify anything. I have found an answer to every problem for myself so far, and if I do not find it immediately, I will ask enough questions to find it. But when one can then justify it convincingly, one should also advocate for this matter.

In this sense: Thank you very much for coming, thank you very much for listening, and thank you very much to the faction for the invitation.