Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Digital Summit on December 4, 2018, in Nuremberg:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

4 December 2018 · Digital Summit · Nuremberg, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Digital Summit on December 4, 2018, in Nuremberg, delivering remarks on Germany's digital transformation strategy and economic future.
Main themes
Digitization and digital economy, artificial intelligence, social market economy, Industry 4.0, 5G infrastructure and connectivity, medium-sized enterprises, digital transformation of manufacturing, technological disruption and social cohesion, digital infrastructure gaps, standardization of digital processes, prosperity and inclusion in the digital age
Duration
~19 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,222
62nd percentile
Sentences
112
68th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
2.90
34th percentile
Vocabulary
1.95
6th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 38%37%
  • Social 27%26%
  • Economic 12%12%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

112 sentences in 24 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

dear Mr. Berg,

dear colleagues from the cabinet,

and especially dear Minister-President Markus Söder, our host here,

I am pleased to be able to participate in the Digital Summit again this year and that you are all here. We just had a lunch where we reflected on what has been achieved between two Digital Summits and what kind of work has taken place.

First of all, I would like to report to you that in the 70th year of the Social Market Economy, we are firmly convinced that the digital economy and the age of digitization must serve humanity and not the other way around. This is not an end in itself.

Today, we posted a small piece on our BPA Twitter account or, better said, on the Seibert Twitter account, that of the government spokesperson – I am now doing a little promotional block – which also deals with artificial intelligence. In it, the member of the Digital Council, Mr. Boos, states that we primarily save life time through artificial intelligence, namely time spent on stupid or repetitive algorithms, and that this gives us more time for creativity; so it is good news, at least for all those who are not intellectually lazy.

The question of how we shape society in the age of digitization is a comprehensive concern for us. This is also reflected in the platforms that work throughout the year – always in a mix of industry representatives, business representatives, and political representatives. In recent years, we have also developed a working and learning method for ourselves in politics, where it has become very clear that we are all, so to speak, in a sphere where we are not yet very familiar. I once referred to this as "new territory." That earned me a significant backlash. Therefore, I do not want to simply repeat that now. In any case, it is still, in a way, uncharted territory.

This is essentially a revolutionary phase. We have all gotten used to casually using the word "disruptive." This disruptive phase naturally means upheavals. I completely agree with you, Mr. Berg, that much of what we are experiencing today in terms of social phenomena, discussion culture, and also concerns and fears is indirectly related to the rapid technological change, and that, in order not to let this devolve into a discussion where one part of society is labeled as elite and another as left behind, we must ensure that this becomes a success story, just as the Social Market Economy is. Prosperity for all – that must also be the future melody in the age of digitization.

This means that we first need the infrastructural prerequisites to be able to utilize new technological possibilities. This is about digital networks. I have also followed the lively discussion about 5G with some astonishment. Perhaps it is so lively because, for the very first time, it is widely understood by the people that we have frequency ranges and that access to this technology will only be possible through auctions. I dare to say: If we no longer had dead zones, the interest in 5G would not be so great. Essentially, we are having a substitute discussion. 5G is stepping in for all the wishes of people who today can hardly make a phone call, let alone see moving images when they are sitting on some meadow or at some beach. Just a few years ago, we thought we had won the battle when we connected every household. But expectations are growing at a rapid pace, which is why it will be important to say: Not everywhere do you need the sound quality of the Berlin Philharmonic, but everywhere you should be able to hear some sounds. That is essentially what needs to be achieved in the infrastructure discussion. Then people will also be satisfied.

Regarding the economic sector. What is happening now – this is a crucial point for an industrial country like Germany, where a large part of value creation still takes place through industrial manufacturing – is the digitization of manufacturing processes and the digitization of processes between companies and customers. Here, I think we are very, very good in some areas. We have global champions. But we may not have advanced the penetration into the mass of medium-sized enterprises as far as it should be. Since we are a country that has proudly stated time and again that the medium-sized sector is the backbone of our industrial value creation, we really need to see that the large frontrunners take the others along with them. This is also a task for chambers of crafts, for chambers of industry and commerce. It is essentially an educational task that we must fulfill. I think the federal government is also ready to contribute to this.

For this economic value creation, we coined the term Industry 4.0. It may have been mentioned at one of the IT summits and has spread quite well worldwide. We talked again today about how we are very, very well positioned regarding the standardization of processes. You can even hear about Industry 4.0 in Asia and elsewhere. So we are indeed trendsetters here.

Now we are also thinking – fortunately, as I see it; for this, I would like to thank the trade unions, especially IG Metall – about what this means for our world of work and how our world of work will change. Mr. Hofmann made it very clear today that, in terms of job profiles and qualifications, we need to look much more into the future to provide the right qualifications, especially for younger people, but also to initiate retraining and further qualification initiatives.

The federal government has dedicated itself in this legislative period not only to the questions of how we can achieve infrastructure, how we can accompany industrial processes, and how we can strengthen the scientific position, but also to the questions of qualification and further education. I consider this to be very, very important – by the way, not only in the academic field but especially in vocational education. I believe the second pillar of our education system, vocational education, can and will have a future. However, it requires a very rapid development of new job profiles or at least a renewal of existing job profiles. The factor of time is, of course, also a decisive matter. That is the crux of the matter – that we live in a world where things suddenly accelerate because there are completely new technologies. The question is: Are we in Germany fast enough to really implement all of this?

This brings me to a platform that deals with digitization in public administration. We passed the Online Access Act – still in the last legislative period. We managed to push through a constitutional amendment in a swift procedure on the part of the federal government, namely in connection with the federal-state financial negotiations, which allows us to operate a joint portal with the states and municipalities. At that time, the federal states were mainly interested in the money and said: Well, if they are going to make a constitutional amendment somehow, but pay well for it, then they should get it. This enables us to make the 575 services that the state provides to its citizens accessible through a unified citizen portal by the end of 2022.

The art now lies in – State Secretary Vitt from the Federal Ministry of the Interior, who is responsible for this, has taken on this crucial task right at the beginning – enabling citizens to access it in a way that is not so complicated that they still have to carry two devices in their pockets into which they have to plug something, but that it is easily accessible. That is my heartfelt wish regarding the citizen portal. Then we will also make it a success.

I expect from this citizen portal not only a coming together of the republic – it will be a great feeling when a citizen in Vorpommern can access their official contacts just as quickly as a citizen in the city of Munich; under the motto "equal living conditions," this is a huge step we can take with this online citizen portal – but it will also significantly increase the understanding of digitization, which we need to gain societal acceptance for all the many rules and laws that we must introduce anew.

Now there is also the question of education. Mr. Berg just spoke very disparagingly about the cultural sovereignty of the states. This challenges me as Chancellor to defend the states. You are right: If the right things are only learned in some places in Germany and less so in others, that is not good. However, if something wrong is taught, then it is sometimes quite good that it does not immediately affect all children in Germany, but only some. This is how I explain the indeed very difficult cultural sovereignty and the question of why we should not talk about schools at the federal level.

So I believe the problem does not lie so much in the fact that the Digital Pact for Schools is viewed negatively. We do not want to equip schools with computers alone; rather, we want to offer a joint teaching cloud from which each federal state and each school can take what they want. We want to take care of the further education of teachers. We want to ensure broadband connections for every school through a special tender. I believe these are all very welcome things. The question with the Digital Pact was only: Should the cost-sharing be 90 to 10 – 90 for the federal government, 10 for the states? So far, so good. But for all further additional things, the sharing should be 50 to 50; and the states do not really like that. That is where the problem lies, I believe. As far as Bavaria is concerned, it is quite different; they always have money. However, we will certainly make progress with the Digital Pact for Schools.

We have also made significant progress regarding the whole topic of cybersecurity. We have already talked about this several times. I believe the importance of this, how crucial it is for our infrastructure operations, is now largely recognized in the German economy. We will still have significant tasks ahead of us, but I think with our Federal Office for Information Security, we have a really very, very good civil institution that is there to protect our economy, but also our public infrastructure.

I have not yet mentioned two platforms. One is – Mr. Doetz pointed out to us that copyright and content are not always identical – that it is definitely important that we protect content, meaning that created content retains its value. The idea that one could create a digital world where everything is exactly the opposite of the real world will not work. Certain fundamental principles must also be enforced in the digital world. And this includes, of course, the pricing of creativity. Otherwise, we will face a terrible flattening of content that we cannot accept. We still have a lot to do in this regard.

Then we had – last but not least – the topic of data sovereignty, data protection, data security, and thus consumer protection. I return to my starting point: 70 years of Social Market Economy, 70 years of an economy in the service of humanity – this also means that people must not be exploited behind their backs by becoming a free data supplier and then having no sovereignty over this data. This ultimately means, when thought through to the end, the destruction of individuality. That cannot and must not be our goal. Therefore, we must try to find the right balance. But opportunities and risks are, of course, closely intertwined.

There is a high level of data access by private companies in the United States. There is a high level of data access by the state in China. These are two extreme positions that we do not want and that do not correspond to the essence of the Social Market Economy. The Social Market Economy is never pure capitalism or anything like that. Therefore, it is now our task to find the right path. When one sees how differently the reception of the General Data Protection Regulation is – for example, within the CDU, where one no longer knows whether one can still write to their neighboring district association because of the General Data Protection Regulation, or in the world where one says: This is the first attempt to deal sensibly with data and to give the individual back sovereignty – then we are already on the right track. And I believe that we can indeed derive great profit from this one day.

I believe it was another important digital summit – one that calls for us to continue our work. We are in the midst of that work. Normally, I would have to say where the next summit will take place. I cannot do that, as this terrain is highly contested. The Federal Minister of Economics has promised to decide as soon as possible – and then for two consecutive years. So stay tuned for what is to come.