Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the "Economic Discussion 2010" of the Ministry of Economic Affairs, Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises, and Energy of the State of North Rhine-Westphalia on January 18, 2010 ...

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

18 January 2010 · Economic Discussion 2010

Context
Merkel addressed the annual Economic Discussion 2010 hosted by North Rhine-Westphalia's Ministry of Economic Affairs in January 2010, reviewing Germany's crisis response and outlining economic priorities.
Main themes
Economic recovery from 2009 crisis, Germany's export strength, short-time work and employment policy, federal-state coordination, innovation and industrial competitiveness, North Rhine-Westphalia's economic role, medium-sized businesses, social cohesion, demographic change, fiscal policy uncertainty
Duration
~40 min
91st percentile
Words
4,858
91st percentile
Sentences
222
91st percentile
Readability
55
75th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
3.07
57th percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
7th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 55%53%
  • Institutional 17%16%
  • Social 12%11%
  • Environmental 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 6%5%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

222 sentences in 47 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Minister-President, dear Jürgen Rüttgers,

dear Madam Minister of Economics, dear Christa Thoben,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am very pleased to have accepted the invitation to this traditional economic discussion and would like to first wish you a successful and healthy new year; not only personal success but also success in the responsibilities you hold for other people – which applies to most of you here in the room – whether on the employer side, the employee side, in science, or in the technology sector.

The year 2010, the beginning of a new decade, is an exciting year because it follows 2009, a year in which so much unusual happened that one cannot simply predict how 2010 will unfold. There are a number of people who act as if nothing has happened. Economic forecasts are being made, tax estimates are being made, but error margins are not provided. One knows this in politics, but as a physicist, one is somehow shocked. However, if one had to provide error margins in these times, they would have to be quite high because there are actually no empirical values on how an economic structure, how a social state, how the Federal Republic of Germany reacts to an economic downturn of five percent in 2009 – a situation that the Federal Republic of Germany has never experienced before.

The only thing one can say is that last year went better than many expected; through very harmoniously coordinated actions on the international stage and – I believe I can say this, even though I am happily leading a new federal government as Chancellor today – through the wise actions of the previous federal government, which were carried out in close coordination with the federal states regarding issues of economic stimulus and financial aid.

If we saw anything last year, it was this: Germany is capable of action when it comes to a difficult situation. Germany is capable of action with its political actors and also regarding the assumption of responsibility in the employer and employee sectors. There has been a level of societal cohesion that I have always wished for, although I was not sure if it existed. For that, I would like to sincerely thank everyone who contributed to it.

The star singers who came to me this year said that they went to the most powerful woman in Germany to ask for help and to collect proper funds, and that they were therefore happy to be at the Federal Chancellery. I said: I can move some things and I am not completely powerless, but of course, I cannot move anything if others do not also participate. This sentence has been thrown back at me several times, but it is true.

It is indeed the case: We could have created the most beautiful economic stimulus programs, but things like short-time work could only function because they were accepted, because people took risks. I have met so many managers, so many company heads, so many medium-sized and family business owners who told me: Mrs. Merkel, if we were to pool our business knowledge now, we would have to act completely differently; but we do not do it that way out of responsibility for Germany, but we are betting on the future. 2010 must be the year in which this commitment to the future made in 2009 proves to be an opportunity for our entire country. That is my goal. And that is the goal of the new federal government.

Today, the annual economic report for North Rhine-Westphalia has been presented. It is very impressive for me to be in the state that generates more than one-fifth of Germany's gross domestic product and where over 20 percent of the companies and employees in the manufacturing sector in Germany are based. Therefore, it is of course right that the state of North Rhine-Westphalia holds a key position for the further development of the entire Federal Republic of Germany. Therefore, much depends on how politics can be shaped in this country. It also depends a lot, dear Jürgen Rüttgers, on how we can create sensible policies for Germany in coordination between the federal and state levels.

I want to emphasize explicitly: I categorically reject all discussions about us now bidding farewell to our traditional strengths and having to consider whether it is right that we are an export nation. Germany's prosperity, the prosperity of the Federal Republic of Germany cannot be maintained without a strong position in the export sector. This does not mean that we cannot also develop service sectors. This does not mean that we will not have more employment in the social sector in the face of the significant challenge of demographic change. But if we believe that we no longer need to be an innovation engine in the world, if we believe that we can do without registering as many patents as possible, or if we believe that we can simply take our inventions somewhere else and have production take place elsewhere, then we will not be able to maintain the standard of living in Germany. Therefore, for me, the export strength of the Federal Republic of Germany is one of the essential keys to prosperity in Germany. We must, of course, change because the world is changing and because we are more dependent on innovations than others.

Now we are in a crisis situation; I say: we are in it. We may have passed the low point; I hope so. The global economic recovery is fragile; everyone tells us that. Whether the toxic assets have already been written off everywhere, no one can say for sure. The recovery, the global economic growth, if it exists, is currently being driven to a large extent by the Asian region. But let us assume that we have left the low point behind us and that the economic forecasts for this year of plus 1.5 percent are correct, then that does not mean at all that we have already overcome the crisis.

I do not say this because I want to spread pessimism; not at all. I just believe that in order to look optimistically into the future, it is very important to conduct a complete analysis. Let us assume that we have three consecutive years of 1.5 percent growth. Then by the end of 2012/beginning of 2013, we would only be back at the level of 2008. Anyone who understands the relationship between growth and employment knows what that means and what a demanding task lies ahead of us, especially regarding employment.

Many do not feel the crisis personally – that is good, that is what we wanted – because we have managed to keep unemployment relatively under control and to maintain employment, especially through short-time work. To what extent we will succeed in this year is still unclear. Therefore, we must – I agree with Jürgen Rüttgers – always keep an eye on how our instruments are working. We must also look at the individual sectors. We must ensure that our skilled workers, our masters, our engineers – the true raw material and treasure of Germany – do not come into great danger in the long run. I do not see that danger as yet eliminated; I say that very clearly.

The second point is: We are now always talking about the debt of our public budgets as if this debt had nothing to do with the fact that we had an economic downturn of five percent. These two things are closely related. The fact that we have fought the economic crisis as we have has something to do with the debts of 2010. Last year, the Federal Employment Agency essentially depleted its cushion of 15 billion euros for short-time work, and this year the federal government – I find this right – is providing the Federal Employment Agency with a grant of 16 billion euros and additionally a grant of four billion euros for the healthcare system because we said: It would not be fair to let only the contributors to unemployment insurance and health insurance bear the consequences of the crisis and not the general public in the form of taxpayers. Moreover, we are doing the economically right thing by strengthening the automatic stabilizers to do something against the crisis. This, of course, results in debts. Therefore, I say that we must view both things in connection. If we were out of the crisis, the budget would not look as it does now. But it is a budget that reflects the crisis.

However, the Federal Republic of Germany has done something that I am not aware of any other country in the world doing. Last year, in the midst of the crisis, we amended our Basic Law and included a debt brake in this Basic Law. Because we know that sustainability, especially in times of demographic change, will only succeed in the long run if we finally achieve balanced budgets. Because since the last Grand Coalition in the 1960s, we have tried to achieve this but have never succeeded, we have now enshrined in our Basic Law that the federal government may not incur new debts of more than 0.35 percent of gross domestic product from 2016 onwards – that is between six and ten billion euros – and that the states may not incur any new debts at all in economically normal times from the year 2020 onwards.

Since this is firmly established in the Basic Law, no one needs to fear that we can simply violate it. This is the framework within which we must conduct everything we do financially in the coming years. We have bound ourselves. And I cannot imagine that there will ever again be a two-thirds majority in Germany that would change this in the foreseeable future; it would also be wrong. Now this means for us that, for example, at the federal level, we must already work towards the year 2016 starting in 2011; the states, by the way, must do the same. Therefore, it is right what was written in the Düsseldorf Guidelines in 1949: that tax cuts and finances are interconnected.

But now we are facing perhaps the most complicated situation one can imagine. We have incurred debt, we are in a crisis, we must focus on sustainability in the long term, but at the same time, we must set growth impulses because everyone knows that if we do not do this, we will have to deal with saving for a long time and must touch the substance of what goes into education, research, and investments. That must not happen. I also say: What I do not want is to put the social peace of this country to the test so that it can no longer be maintained. This is also a strength of the social market economy. Perhaps we have never seen as clearly as last year how helpful corporate co-determination is when much was discussed together.

We must bring these things together: maintain social peace, create a solid budget policy, and set growth impulses. That is now the art. There are growth elements that can be obtained for free, such as reducing bureaucracy. The new federal government is focusing on that. What we started with the Normenkontrollrat, we want to continue intensively. There are growth elements that go into the innovation and education sector. The federal government has set itself the goal for this legislative period – parallel to what North Rhine-Westphalia is doing – to invest twelve billion euros more in the education and research sector. We want to ensure together with the states that by 2015, we spend ten percent of gross domestic product on education and research in Germany.

The research part is extremely important for our country, but the education part is of course the prerequisite for us to be able to excel in research, implementation, skilled work, and technology. Therefore, what the state of North Rhine-Westphalia has done is of great importance, namely that it has taken the lead in engineering and natural sciences and has established universities of applied sciences that have strengthened training and promotion for pursuing such professions.

My heartfelt request to all of you is: Give young engineers, give young scientists a chance now. If they come from the university or from the university of applied sciences and have gone through a rather difficult course of study in the eyes of their peers, but then they are precisely the ones who cannot find work, then in the next 15 years we can again say: "STEM subjects are so great – mathematics, engineering, natural sciences, even a little physics study. Were you unemployed afterwards? Too bad, you had a bit of bad luck, but try again in the next generation. Maybe you will find a place in the business cycle somewhere else." – That cannot and must not be the lesson for a future-oriented Germany.

Another growth impulse is that we are also offering tax relief. I must say that the discussion sometimes confuses me a little. For almost 20 years, since the reunification of Germany, I have heard in my faction how colleagues with shining eyes recount how it was back then when Gerhard Stoltenberg implemented the tax reform and how the economy grew and how everything worked. And had German unity not come about, we would have had balanced budgets because a wise tax policy was pursued.

Now we find ourselves in a situation at least as difficult as in the early 1980s. It cannot be that tax policy has no growth effect at all. It has been somewhat smugly said here regarding the Growth Acceleration Act: Let’s see if it is a debt-increasing law or if it brings growth. Of course, tax cuts initially also lead to lower revenues, but subsequently, growth arises from that. We believe, of course, that this will be compensated in the medium term.

Now I would like to mention three elements from this Growth Acceleration Act. Throughout the entire election campaign, I have heard how terrible this corporate tax reform is, what pro-cyclical effects it has, and what needs to be changed. We have quietly fulfilled all these wishes – regarding the interest barrier, the acquisition of companies, and others – probably still not 100 percent, but as much as is manageable. Therefore, I also tell the representatives of the municipalities – the mayor is also here: You can certainly calculate statically what lower revenues will arise from this; however, if businesses go bankrupt and you only have insolvent companies left and no trade tax revenues at all, then you need not worry about the losses at all. This means that what we have done is a loss prevention law.

The Growth Acceleration Act also touches a bit on social policy. When you consider who supports this society, it is, of course, everyone in their own way, but it remains true that something must first be earned in order to distribute something afterward, because we do not want to incur so much debt in the future. It is also true that family businesses, the medium-sized companies in Germany, are one of the central pillars of our prosperity. It has become clear during the crisis that those who think in the long term should be strengthened, while those who think only from day to day or hour to hour should be observed a bit more closely.

In this respect, it may not be entirely wrong to not scrutinize the transition of a business from one generation to the next with such eagle eyes, as if we consider everyone who takes over a business to be a potential fraudster. We had agreed with the Social Democrats on wage sum regulations, where I felt that as a medium-sized business, one had to say: There is only suspicion. We have now relaxed that a bit.

We have also taken it upon ourselves to improve inheritance law for siblings, which I find absolutely right if one has a certain notion of family. At least one cannot wage battles against it that would be somehow relevant.

Furthermore, we have said – and I believe this should become a fundamental element of our tax system: We want children and parents to be treated equally in tax law one day. This is about more than just an 8,004 euro basic tax allowance. It is a principled consideration of the family and the question: How do I view children, how do I view the decision for children? Therefore, we have now increased the basic tax allowance and, in the process, also the child benefit.

I must say that I no longer understand the discussion about this. I am very much in favor of treating everyone who receives "Hartz IV" fairly, but I am also in favor of ensuring that parents who work at the threshold of entering the Hartz IV area do not find themselves in a worse position, even if they have many children. If the gap between child benefit and the Hartz IV rates – and no one wants to lower the Hartz IV rates for children – is too large and you have three or four children, then you first have to earn 200 to 300 euros to have the same available. This is precisely about the question: Is it worth it to perform? Therefore, the increase in child benefit cannot be wrong. That parents who earn a bit more but do not yet receive a tax benefit can make use of an additional 20 euros in child benefit, I do not doubt that either. Therefore, I believe that a social policy dimension is emerging here again.

At the beginning of the year, we added other tax relief measures that had already been decided by the previous coalition. We have already implemented all of this. I believe this provides a growth impulse. Now we will have to decide how to proceed. But I tell you: As things stand, we also need growth impulses for the year 2011. Otherwise, we will only be dealing with saving and not setting the necessary incentives. That is my conviction. Anyone who begins to say that all those who pay taxes in this country are a clientele, I say to them: I am happy to engage with this clientele.

Think of skilled workers and masters who work overtime. Just look at the fairness of our tax system. There is an area where the rate rises steeply. It is not about high incomes, but about those with low and medium incomes who pay taxes and who are hindered in their performance by the progression, by the so-called "Mittelstandsbauch," in a way that is not fair. If we no longer talk about these people in our country, then we should not be surprised if we later have no solidarity left in the social sphere.

And now I tell you: With purely deterministic thinking, you cannot put all of this together. If you do not have a bit of dialectical ability, if you do not have a bit of courage for the future, if you act as if you already know the tax estimates from May of this year, from May of next year, and the year after that, and could add it all up, then, I would say, you should stay away from politics. Then one can become a prognosticator or agnostic or depressed or whatever – I will not be any of that; I am a politician and want to ensure the prosperity of this country.

What has happened in this crisis? Twenty years ago, in 1989/90, there was this incredible victory of freedom over planned economy, the victory of the social market economy over planned economy, the decline of dictatorships, and the victory of democracies. At the end of the first decade of the 21st century, we have essentially reached the limits of freedom – where freedom has little to do with responsibility. It has become clear that the system of freedom is one that only works when responsibility is firmly anchored in this system. What the banks have done, namely bringing the world to the brink through constant excessive attempts to make profits at any cost and without any real foundation, must not happen again. Because everyone pays the price, only those who won are somewhere on beautiful yachts on the world’s oceans or over all seven mountains, as one might symbolically say. Or they are starting to do the same thing again today.

Therefore, politics is under obligation. And you, especially the representatives of the real economy, must help us establish rules. These rules can be national and European. Jürgen Rüttgers has said: If necessary, it must be done that way. But they are only truly effective if they are made internationally. That is also the realization. This began with the Rio process, with the topics of climate and biodiversity, because it was understood: We can no longer solve the problem as a country, as a continent alone. This continues today towards the financial markets and free trade with global rules. Much cannot be done alone. I do not say "nothing." I just spoke about some things we can do alone, but certain crises can only be fought globally.

There is a very thick board in front of us that we have to work on. Because the willingness to delegate responsibility to international institutions and to be evaluated is, of course, still not sufficiently present. We in Germany are practiced in this due to our membership in the European Union. Just imagine if Brussels and the competition commission had not existed during this crisis. I do not want to calculate how much protectionism would have prevailed in Europe then. I know that we sometimes get angry with the competition commission; I have experienced that myself. But overall, it has ensured that free trade and the internal market in Europe could function reasonably well.

If we do not grant the WTO similar powers, if we do not ensure that there is as free trade as possible in the world, then the world will fall back into a crisis or at least we will not be able to achieve what we actually want and what corresponds to our capabilities with our good innovative abilities. It is therefore very important to establish common rules. We are now trying to do this in the financial markets. It is extremely laborious, but it is not as hopeless as it is sometimes described. We have achieved some things regarding rating agencies, regarding bonuses, also regarding the question: "Too big to fail"? But we must continue to discuss what happens when a bank is too big to bear its own risks. We do not yet have a conclusive answer to this question. This must be a topic at the next G20 meeting.

Of course, it also depends a lot on whether everyone implements what is decided. One of the biggest annoyances for all those who need loans is that we in Germany and Europe have implemented "Basel II" very well, but our American friends, who were originally the idea generators for it, have said after 15 years that they will not implement it. Now we have forced them, within the framework of the G20 negotiation processes, to say that they want to implement it starting in 2011. However, this requires a decision in both American parliamentary chambers. Now we will wait and see if that really happens.

If every medium-sized business here in the room has to adhere to all the criteria of Basel II, then you know what that means for lending. If others in the world do not do this, the danger that crises will arise from this again and that we will ultimately have to bear the costs without having been able to make profits from it beforehand, is very high. Therefore, as German Chancellor, I will do everything in my power to ensure that what we agree upon is truly implemented worldwide, so that we do not face competitive disadvantages.

The same applies, of course, to climate protection. The Copenhagen conference was a great disappointment. I do not even want to talk about the fact that we did not achieve many quantitative goals there. Although countries like China and India have said for the first time – this is actually a step forward – that they are also willing to take on commitments – now one can discuss whether to a sufficient extent or not; but at least it was about commitments. But the crux of the disappointment was that they are not willing to make commitments binding in an international forum.

If binding commitments at the international level are fundamentally rejected by international actors, then we find ourselves in a very difficult situation. If it is also rejected that uniform standards for climate protection measures are applied internationally, then we find ourselves in an even more difficult situation. We need to talk about this in Europe. I do not want to give up our commitments – Germany will maintain them – but I do want us to push internationally for a fair competitive situation. I do not think much of restoring this by imposing import taxes on countries that do not feel committed to climate protection. That would bring about such a huge bureaucratic mess that this cannot be the way forward.

But I also say: A decade lies ahead of us in which we must learn global cooperation and in which, in my firm conviction, the fundamental principles of the social market economy must be anchored worldwide so that we have a fair chance to assert ourselves with our way of doing business and living. This is necessary, even if it sounds utopian.

Therefore, it will depend on us as a country to go through this crisis with optimism, to reflect on our strengths, and to become stronger where we are weak. One example has been mentioned today: energy policy. The federal government has set itself the goal of presenting a coherent energy concept for our country by autumn of this year. This has not been achieved for years.

I tell you that we are firmly committed: we want to enter the era of renewable energies as quickly as possible. A lot needs to be done for this, investments must be made, and the laws must also be appropriately designed. One must also be able to lay a high-voltage line from the North Sea towards the south. We cannot struggle for years in disputes over underground cables and overhead lines. Everything must be done for innovations and investments.

But to believe that one can automatically transition from the current state to the state of the renewable energy era without reconsidering the construction of a modern coal-fired power plant, without acknowledging that nuclear energy is necessary as a bridging technology, will cost us so dearly that we will lose industrial production and jobs elsewhere. And I do not want that.

Therefore, we must resolve the contradiction that supposedly exists between the environment and the economy and say: We are working towards a sustainable energy supply, we are working towards sustainable mobility. But all of this must be done with moderation and reason. I cannot see what is gained when German energy companies buy old Polish coal-fired power plants or operate the old ones here longer because it is no longer possible in Germany to obtain a permit for a new one. Therefore, I also thank the North Rhine-Westphalian state government for doing everything to prevent this situation from arising. It is so important that we are innovative while also paying attention to economic viability, to economic reason, as Jürgen Rüttgers would say.

Germany must become more innovative in the coming years. We are on a good path, but it can and should get even better. Germany must assert its interests internationally to establish fair rules for economic activity. Germany must continually connect to what has made us strong: the diversity of companies, the enthusiasm of employees, the courage and willingness to take risks of entrepreneurs. Politics must support exactly this courage, this willingness to take risks, and the commitment of employees. Then we will also succeed in being a social country in the long term.

I am deeply convinced: the quality of life in a country will increasingly depend in the coming years on how much culture one can afford there, how safe I feel living there, how I fare when I am ill and dependent on healthcare or the health system. We can only maintain quality of life if we rely on our economy, if we rely on our employees, if we rely on those who want to innovate and therefore must have a home here. That is why it is so important that performance is rewarded, so that life in this country remains humane overall. That is what I want. And I know that you all want that too. Therefore, I wish us all a productive, but joyful and good year 2010.