Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the European Banking Congress on November 17, 2006, in Frankfurt/Main:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

18 November 2006 · European Banking Congress · Alte Oper, Frankfurt am Main, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the European Banking Congress in Frankfurt on November 17, 2006, speaking on European financial market integration and the challenges of globalization.
Main themes
European financial market integration, Lisbon Strategy, globalization challenges, Frankfurt as financial center, Basel II implementation, EU financial regulation, European champions, stock exchange mergers, financial services action plan, competitive financial systems, growth and employment
Duration
~44 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,280
92nd percentile
Sentences
269
94th percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
3.08
58th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 39%38%
  • Institutional 36%35%
  • Geopolitical 17%16%
  • Ceremonial 5%4%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

269 sentences in 57 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Ackermann,

Excellencies,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am pleased to be able to speak at your conference today: Trade Centre Europe. I apologize for speaking in German, but German chancellors have to speak in German, at least as long as the French President speaks French.

I am happy to be here with you today, here in the Alte Oper in Frankfurt am Main. Twenty-five years ago, this house was splendidly reopened after it had been left as a ruin following the Second World War. Similarly, the financial center of Frankfurt has developed from very modest beginnings after the Second World War into a significant global financial center.

This did not happen by chance, as Frankfurt was able to build on old traditions. When one considers that the Frankfurt Stock Exchange has a history of over 400 years, we can say: There is tradition here. Therefore, Frankfurt can also face the challenges of globalization with courage. But we also know that competition has become tougher. We are therefore very pleased that many international institutions are based here in Frankfurt, including the European Central Bank. We are somewhat proud of that as well.

We all know that growth and employment can only succeed if we also have an efficient and internationally competitive financial system. This means that what we call the Lisbon Strategy in Europe, namely the very ambitious goal of being the continent with the highest growth by the end of the decade – we may not fully achieve this, but we at least aspire to it – cannot be successful at all if we do not have efficient and integrated financial markets in Europe. Of course, stock exchanges are a part of this. Therefore, let me also say, in light of current or almost current events, that I very much regret that the intended merger between Deutsche Börse AG and Euronext did not materialize, as this would have improved the integration of European financial markets and the associated infrastructure. Not everyone shares this view, but we would have liked to see it happen nonetheless.

At this point, I also want to say a word about what is needed in Europe. If the Lisbon Strategy is to be successful, if we want to meet the challenges of globalization, then we must, of course, also commit to European champions. We must not remain stuck in national thinking. There is currently a discussion in Europe about this: Do we perceive this Europe with its internal market as a size in which we are then also willing to accept European companies? Or are we, when it comes to companies and employment, ultimately still bound to national thinking?

Of course, we need modern answers in Europe – the financial institutions know this as well – to what financing is necessary today. The classic bank loan is no longer in demand as a one-size-fits-all solution for external financing. Instead, what is needed are individual, tailored financing solutions, with banks acting as both capital providers and advisors – and this in an increasingly competitive environment. Therefore, Frankfurt knows, and all of Europe knows: It cannot rest on past successes. Therefore, we also need a variety of new regulatory frameworks – frameworks that fit international developments and frameworks that promote growth.

Today, many international developments are initiated or driven by international bodies. This corresponds to global thinking. I would like to remind you of Basel II. However, I do not want to hide the fact that I see with great unease that Basel II is being implemented within the European Union, while at the same time, across the Atlantic, there is hesitation at the last moment. That was not the intention of Basel II. In this respect, we certainly need to discuss this with our American partners again.

Similarly, much is being passed at the EU level. I think of the extensive action plan for financial services from 1999, which has already significantly advanced the integration of financial markets in Europe with its many individual measures. Now, all of this must be implemented quickly and consistently in all member states, as far as it has not yet been done – and preferably one-to-one, so that we do not create individual hurdles through national implementation while others may have fewer hurdles.

I believe it was also right for the European Commission to outline the guidelines of its financial market policy until 2010 with its white paper in December 2005. This was not a new ambitious catalog of measures. I believe the market participants are not particularly upset about this. Instead, it is about a so-called dynamic consolidation. This means we look at how the measures unfold their effects and realize the integration of financial markets as unbureaucratically as possible.

If this white paper does not contain any new major regulatory measures, does that mean there is no longer a need for action in financial market issues in Europe? I do not believe so. For example, we need a fair and transparent solution for the procedure regarding cross-border acquisitions of significant stakes in financial institutions. And we certainly need a deepening of financial market integration in retail banking. I believe it is right that the Commission places a special emphasis on this. From the German side, we certainly want a deepened integration here as well.

This means that there should not be maximum harmonization without regard to national peculiarities. But if we want to have deep, manageable, and simple relationships between the various countries, then we must also be more willing to accept harmonization.

I believe that the principle that has now spread in the European Commission under the motto "Better Regulation" is a correct one. "Better Regulation" is the fine way of saying that one wants to reduce bureaucracy. This is not an easy step in Europe, but it is a necessary one.

When we celebrate the 50th anniversary of the signing of the Treaty of Rome next year, we can look back on a significant body of European Union directives. The idea that in the European Union, in the sense of the acquis communautaire, only directives can be added but never disappear is certainly not a productive idea. Therefore, we support – and we will particularly emphasize this in our presidency – that the topic of "Better Regulation" – incidentally also with ambitious timelines – is advanced.

If one looks at the regulatory density that the new member states of the European Union are confronted with at the moment of their accession, and considers whether one could have built the European Union as well in the 50s, 60s, and 70s, then I believe one begins to hesitate. We are placing a considerable burden on ourselves.

We need uniform payment instruments. I think that the representatives of the banking sector also wish for a stronger integration here, just as with the issue of financial market supervision. We now have 70 different supervisory institutions for financial markets among the many member states. For banks and insurance companies that are active in several member states – with the thought of European champions becoming more common – this certainly represents a significant burden.

Now there is always the question: Do we want a fully Europeanized financial market supervision? We are politically of the opinion that the time for that has not yet come. However, that is an idea we should discuss more intensively. But we must also see that the market structures in the member states are still significantly different. At least from the German perspective, there must not be any deterioration in competitive conditions. We must carefully consider whether we transfer competencies to the Commission or not.

But we need a harmonization of supervisory law and also a deepened cooperation of supervisory authorities. Here, too, it will be the case: The better we manage to bring the individual institutions together and find our own solutions, the more practical the solutions will be. Because there is always the danger that if those who do not carry out the work decide how 70 different supervisory authorities should cooperate, the supervisory authorities may not be pleased. That might still be bearable. But if customers or those who deal with the supervisory authorities are also dissatisfied, then it becomes problematic.

The federal government has always been very active in shaping the framework conditions for the financial sector. We will continue to do so in the future. Next year, during the first half of our EU presidency and also in the context of the G8 presidency throughout 2007, we will of course have a special responsibility. Many expectations will be placed on us. But I would also like to say at this point: Expectations often go in very different directions. Therefore, we may not be able to meet some expectations.

At the very least, we must have the discussion: Where should Europe actually develop? At the moment, there is skepticism among citizens in the member states towards the European Union because concrete problems, such as unemployment, weak growth, and demographic challenges, are not always addressed and solved by the European Union in the way that people envision.

This means that it is very important for us that citizens in Europe regain their trust in this European Union. By the way, when one thinks of retail banking and what one can do as a citizen in Europe, sometimes even small things, if I may say so, are not entirely unimportant. Because when one wants to carry out very simple transfer orders between neighboring countries in Europe, one is surprised at what the internal market has not yet achieved. The fees are not insignificant, if I may say so from personal experience. If you want people to believe, for example, in a European financial market, then start with the very simple things. You will be surprised at how that works.

We need a growth-friendly policy. At the moment, we have a good basis for this, as the European Commission forecasts that we will have 2.7 percent growth, the strongest community-wide growth in Europe since 2000. This can please us, but it must not in any way satisfy us. I believe we can also say that the positive development in Germany has contributed to this – simply because Germany is the largest economy in the European Union. Even in our case, economic growth will be as strong as it has not been for six years. Fortunately, this is also reflected in our labor market, as we can say that we have 470,000 fewer unemployed than a year ago. What I find particularly important: We have 250,000 more social insurance-contributing jobs, which is of incredible significance for all social security systems.

We also know that we can only be strong in Europe and in our G8 presidency if we, as a national government, also do our homework. This is interconnected. Some may think that now that we have the international presidencies, we will no longer take care of our policies at home. That will not happen at all, because the question of how well Germany is doing is crucial to how much influence and how many opportunities we will have to advance political decisions. This means we will not let up at home either.

I believe that now, a year after the new federal government took office, some contours are emerging that clearly show that we are taking and have taken important steps. I will only mention the reform of corporate tax law, for which the key points are available, the reform of inheritance tax law, and the question of REITs – a topic where at least I would have wished that residential properties would also be included. However, we decided to at least tackle the whole thing and not let it lie again. I believe that was also the right decision.

We have made a contribution to Europe in the triad of "Renovating, Reforming, Investing," also in terms of the budget balance. It was Germany that once demanded the Growth and Stability Pact. It is always particularly unpleasant when, as the initiator of something, you end up being among those who fulfill it the least. We are glad that this year we will once again meet the Maastricht deficit criterion and that next year we will have a federal budget where we can say again after years: More investments than new debt. The new debt will, as far as we can foresee now, be the lowest since reunification. These are figures that, I believe, make us look a bit better – also with regard to the future and the leeway. Because if you look at the current composition of our budget, then interest expenditures and fixed expenditures are simply so overpowering that there is too little room left for investments. We need to enlarge this investment leeway again.

So we know: Germany can certainly make better use of its presidencies if it leads by good example. In our presidency, we will of course pay particular attention to deepening the internal market. I am deeply convinced that the European internal market offers the opportunity to create a size that is truly competitive worldwide for the more than 400 million people living in Europe, and can thus set accents, in a way also set standards. Therefore, the further development of the internal market is of utmost importance. Jacques Delors once said: "No one falls in love with an internal market." – That may be true. But it is, of course, the case: Without the internal market, Europe will not be able to unleash its economic performance.

I want to draw your attention to a topic for which I do not have a conclusive solution, but which will occupy us in the coming years. The delineation of the internal market, which today is largely regulated by the European Commission, from social policy, which remains under national jurisdiction, will become increasingly difficult in the future. Where does competition begin, and where is a size primarily to be considered economically and where more from a social perspective? We must succeed in delineating this as precisely as possible, otherwise we will constantly have procedures before the European Commission. If, for example, a simple sports club in Germany has to compete with a gym and eventually finds itself before the European Court of Justice, people will not understand that. In this respect, we still have many delineation tasks ahead of us.

This was, by the way, one of the reasons why the Federal Republic of Germany advocated so intensively for a constitutional treaty – a treaty that is supposed to clearly delineate at which level the jurisdiction lies, and that is supposed to make it clear that when the jurisdiction lies with the European Commission, it is of course also given the powers to act, and that when there are national jurisdictions, the European Commission cannot regain jurisdiction through backdoor coordination.

The constitutional treaty is therefore a step in the right direction. This is also one of the reasons why we are very strongly advocating that we make progress with this constitutional treaty. But it is certainly not yet the ideal solution we envisioned. However, the allocation of competencies will be one of the essential questions for the acceptance of Europe among the citizens. Because nothing is worse than being unable to tell people who is responsible for what in a political system. There are a multitude of boundary questions where one can use Europe as an excuse, where nation-states try to assert their interests through Europe. This unsettles citizens and does not provide a basis for acceptance.

We need a deepening of the internal market. And we must continually make it clear, also in connection with EU enlargement, that we have gained at least 2.5 million new jobs through the creation of the internal market, so this is not something that destroys jobs, but that through this openness the opportunity arises to create more jobs.

Of course, when I talk about deepening the internal market, we still need a multitude of measures. I believe you in this room are not entirely satisfied with the Services Directive. We believe that it is at least a step in the right direction, that it will simplify approval procedures. But certainly, we will have to discuss this further in a few years. It is quite interesting: Actually, the free movement of services has been a requirement since the establishment of the European Union. However, if you look at how practice looks in the individual member states, such a directive is urgently needed. This means that we are still far from the claim we set for ourselves in many areas.

We know that half of the goods traffic still takes place in the non-harmonized area today. This means that the freedom of goods movement can still be hindered by member states. Therefore, the principle of mutual recognition must be effectively enforced. We want to primarily promote the opening of markets. This applies, in addition to financial services, especially to the areas of postal services and telecommunications. It is also very important that we achieve parallelism in Europe. It makes no sense if Germany leads by good example in this regard – for example, our letter monopoly will be abolished by the end of next year. But of course, we can only do all this if it is not being slowed down in other countries and handled very differently, because otherwise we will face competitive disadvantages. Therefore, we say: We will advocate very intensively for the complete opening of the European postal markets by 2009; that is very, very important.

We need to revise the legal framework for electronic communications. We also support the Commission's proposal to focus more on the market in frequency policy. Therefore, the presidency will leave many tasks for us in this regard. We will also be able to pass on tasks to future presidencies. By the way, we will have to deal with the energy market. The Commission will make a number of communications on energy policy at the beginning of next year – both on external energy policy and on the free market for energy in the European Union. As seen in the discussions about E.ON and Endesa, we are also far from a liberalized, barrier-free market here.

And, as I have already indicated, we will deal with the topic of simplifying bureaucracy and reducing bureaucracy. The European Commission will do what the Dutch have done, what the British have done, what we are now doing in Germany, namely also establish a so-called Regulatory Control Council and set the goal of abolishing 25 percent of control and reporting obligations. I believe this is also a very important target. This will start in the spring. The German presidency will accompany this with a lot of energy.

When we talk about Europe and the structures, I believe we need to think very intensively again about the question: Where do we want to go? There are still very, very large differences between the views of the individual member states. I want to illustrate this with the example of the relationship between the Parliament, the Commission, and the Council. From my point of view, the Commission is responsible for managing the shared competencies. It is allowed to issue the necessary directives for this. The European Parliament, in my opinion, must increasingly develop into a proper parliament, as we know it from national parliaments. This means that the composition of the Commission – we illustrate this with the example of the Commission President – must have something to do with the outcome of European elections. After such elections, there is a new Parliament. Then there is a new Commission, which is composed by the heads of state and government in the Council and has nothing to do with the election result. People do not understand that. Therefore, we have also managed in the constitutional treaty to say: Whoever is the strongest as a party group in the European election should also have the opportunity to determine the president, so that at least at the top of the Commission it is seen that voting makes sense. However, not all member states are of the opinion that this is the right way.

Secondly, the question arises: How does the legislation of the Commission relate to the tasks of the European Parliament? I have set myself the goal – we will now slowly push this forward, and we will also gradually gain allies for it – that what we know from national parliaments, namely the principle of discontinuity, is also introduced in Europe. What does that mean? It means: If a law in Germany is not fully debated in Parliament before the legislative period ends, then the law does not survive the legislative period, but the new Parliament must put this law back on the agenda. In Europe, a directive survives everything: the change of the Commission, the change of Parliament. The directive remains in place.

I believe it would also be very, very important for the self-understanding to anchor the principle of discontinuity in the European Union. I know that I still have many battles to fight here. But to make the legitimacy of the European Union clear, we need this. If you had invited me to a panel discussion on this topic with the Czech or Polish president, we would certainly have come to very different opinions – with the French one, by the way, as well. But that does not matter. One has had to drill many thick boards in Europe. But there are also a few allies.

So we want to put the topics of energy policy, bureaucracy reduction, institutions, and the relationship of the institutions on the agenda. We will also advance the relationships of the European Union with important other partners through the respective summits in two areas.

On one side, during our presidency, there is the EU-Russia summit. A new cooperation agreement must be negotiated with Russia. One of our goals is to set up a negotiating mandate in which we define energy cooperation in certain chapters – and this, if possible, in an analogous manner to the Energy Charter, with whose ratification Russia is still struggling a bit. We need good relations with Russia. We need strategic relations with Russia. Russia is a large neighbor of the European Union. Nevertheless, we must also establish the relations on a reliable basis.

On the other side, we have another summit: the EU-America summit. There, we want to advance something during our presidency that is personally very important to me and that was initiated by the Austrian presidency under the heading "Common Market." We will certainly not come to the point of creating a free trade zone between the European Union and the United States in the foreseeable future. I believe it would not be particularly wise at the moment to always discuss agricultural tariffs. But we must ask ourselves: On what basis are the European rules based, on what basis are the American ones? If we look at the underlying understanding of values, they are indeed very comparable values: freedom, respect for the individual, respect for human dignity, democracy. I believe that in light of the development of global markets, it is worth the sweat of the actors to consider where we could develop common positions and common rules from this shared understanding of values, for example, when it comes to the protection of intellectual property.

For we, as developed Western countries, will, despite all the creativity and willingness to innovate that we need, of course only have a chance if certain principles, over which we have argued for centuries in Europe, gain worldwide validity – for me, these include the protection of intellectual property, the acceptance of patents, and certain rules. If, in one part of the world, it is not a problem to steal or copy something, then there will be distortions in competitiveness. Therefore, in my view, we must pool our strengths. We will, in our G8 presidency, particularly pool our strengths to take common positions towards third parties.

When I talk about this common market of America/Europe, I am not talking about isolated activities. That would be completely wrong. We must dispel the concerns that protectionist tendencies could gain ground again, which both the U.S. President and some in Europe have. We only have a chance through openness. You can react to globalization with fear, but then people will experience that playing with that fear does not solve a single problem. The approach can only be openness and strengthening our own strengths while overcoming our own weaknesses.

In this sense, I firmly believe that everything must be done once again to kick-start and bring success to the World Trade Round. I must not and do not want to raise exaggerated expectations here, as this does not solely depend on Europe. Whether the outcome of the U.S. mid-term elections has improved the conditions for this is still not entirely clear to me. Therefore, we should still try to make use of the remaining window of opportunity, as the multitude of bilateral agreements that would arise if this Doha Round fails is not an adequate alternative to a multilateral trading system.

So, in our G8 presidency and in our EU presidency, we will indeed engage in overlapping activities. I would like to mention one point that is very important to me at this point: Beyond all the cooperation with the great continent of Asia, we must also ensure that Africa does not become a forgotten continent. Therefore, during our G8 presidency, the topic of Africa will also play a special role.

We are now experiencing through migration movements that we cannot avoid the problems on our neighboring continent, Africa. We see that China – as we saw a few days ago at the Africa-China Summit in Beijing – is pursuing a very strategic policy here, which is also closely linked to China's raw material interests. We, as Europeans, do well to develop relationships with Africa that are also a gain for the Africans. When talking to African heads of state, the issue of time plays a significant role. It is simply said: If there is a desire for cooperation in China, it is quickly fulfilled, while in Europe, a tender is first held. This eventually ends up in a court case, and then it starts all over again. That is not what the Africans need. Time is simply a factor that currently works incredibly against Europe and in favor of African-Chinese relations.

But I believe that in dialogue with Africa, we must also pay attention to two further things:

First – this will be very important for the Africans, especially in comparison to African-Chinese relations – we must say that we want a fair treatment of your raw materials; we do not want to take advantage of you here; you have a right to reasonable contracts.

Second – this must also be possible – we must insist on "Good Governance," that is, on good, reasonable governance in Africa; otherwise, development there can only end in disappointments again and again. We have a strategic interest, but we must also engage in an honest dialogue. This honest dialogue should be conducted. For the first time, we have what is called a trio presidency. The European Union is moving from the six-month presidencies that were always lined up to longer periods. Our trio presidency includes the presidency of Germany, followed by Portugal and then Slovenia. Together with the Portuguese, we will already prepare an EU-Africa Summit for the second half of 2007, where we can discuss these topics together.

In conclusion, I come to the Constitutional Treaty. We have the opportunity to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the signing of the Treaties of Rome in Berlin on March 25. For me, it has symbolic significance that 50 years after the founding of the European Union, it is now possible to celebrate in Berlin – a symbol of division, of the Cold War – that Europe is united again.

We have all experienced in the last ten to fifteen years that there is a long way between the Sunday speeches about the brothers and sisters in the East behind the Iron Curtain and the admission of these states into the European Union. The admission of Romania and Bulgaria is now imminent. I have witnessed the discussions in Parliament. The euphoria has somewhat diminished, and doubts are increasing. Nevertheless, the admission is right; I want to state that explicitly. This European continent only has a chance to weigh in the global competition together.

On March 25, we will reaffirm the intellectual foundations of the European Union. Europe has managed, after the Second World War, through endless suffering and effort, to build bridges out of hereditary enmities. The fact that this was possible, the fact that after centuries of wars it has succeeded in firmly anchoring the value of tolerance in Europe, so that the individual actors have understood that the advantage of the other can also be their own advantage, and that a common advantage arises from this, this realization must be lived by Europe. Therefore, it is so important that we do not have a beautiful European Union on paper and think nationally again, but that we actively demonstrate this. If we could also convey this ability to others, then this Europe could also contribute to solving many conflicts beyond the European continent.

Therefore, I believe that Europe, on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of the signing of the Treaties of Rome, must come to an understanding beyond the individual regulations about what has made this Europe possible, but also about the challenges that this Europe faces. There must be a clear commitment that only openness offers us the opportunity to truly live in prosperity and security. In this sense, we will prepare for this March 25.

I hope that based on the common understanding of what holds us together in Europe, perhaps a somewhat changed discussion about the Constitutional Treaty will take place. For the Constitutional Treaty is not meant to create new bureaucracy, but to organize competencies and clarify the values, so to speak, the fundamental rights, on which we build the individual regulations.

In this sense, the German presidency will not be able to find a solution for the issue of the Constitutional Treaty. The timeframe until the end of 2008 is planned for that. I also think it is very good that the European Council has decided exactly this. It would undermine any attempt if we had to find a solution during this presidency – just think of the elections in France and in other countries. But we must make progress. And we need, above all, the common spirit that this Europe – I am certainly convinced of this – is more than a free trade zone.

We will only achieve all of this if politics has allies. That is why I am happy to be here with you today, because I believe that we need the economic elites who fight for this Europe. You all know – Germany knows it best of all – how much we have gained whenever we have opened up. This thought must take hold, transcending small individual interests. Europe has made great progress in this regard. Those who trade, who shape the financial markets, should also be the ones who are our allies on this path. At least I hope for that, even in all critical dialogue. – Thank you very much for having me here today.