Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the event for the interim report of the National Regulatory Control Council on May 11, 2009, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

12 May 2009 · Event for the interim report of the National Regulatory Control Council · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the National Regulatory Control Council's interim report event in Berlin on May 11, 2009, reviewing the Council's work and progress on reducing bureaucratic burdens.
Main themes
Bureaucracy reduction, regulatory control, standard cost model, better regulation, legislative scrutiny, reporting obligations, National Regulatory Control Council, government oversight, balance between regulation and freedom, measurability of regulatory burden
Duration
~18 min
61st percentile
Words
2,180
61st percentile
Sentences
113
69th percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
10.7
28th percentile
Syntax
2.97
43rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
16th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 75%75%
  • Economic 12%12%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

113 sentences in 26 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Ludewig,

dear members of the National Regulatory Control Council,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag,

esteemed guests,

I believe it is a good idea to take stock today in front of a somewhat larger forum of the work of the Regulatory Control Council, the experiences, and what has changed since the beginning of this work.

I have been commended for the good idea. I have, I believe, always accompanied the Regulatory Control Council with joy and helped it when it faced difficulties. But the original idea was one developed by Norbert Röttgen and Olaf Scholz for the coalition agreement. At that time, the standard cost model and the quite good experiences that had been made in the Netherlands and in Great Britain were mentioned for the first time. It seemed plausible to me – I believe just as it did to Mr. Müntefering – that we should try to quantitatively track the reduction of regulations and thereby bring a piece of rationality into the whole matter.

That is why we turned to this issue. A legislative process has been initiated. There is the Federal President, who oversees the whole process and can intervene as the highest authority in case of disputes within the government. So far, it has not been necessary to resort to such extraordinary actions. We have always advanced the whole matter quite peacefully.

It has been the case that the first broad awareness of the work of the Regulatory Control Council, I believe, related to the fact that the newly drafted laws were scrutinized by the Regulatory Control Council. This was a process that sometimes kept us quite busy. In the meantime, people are already thinking a bit about the Regulatory Control Council in advance. You know what you think about certain formulations. In this respect, adjustments have been made. It has also been the case that Parliament has sometimes called upon the Regulatory Control Council to implement changes – I believe, in the case of corporate tax reform. The Regulatory Control Council is thus known. It is used wherever it seems appropriate, and I believe, mostly for good and right purposes.

Now, it is the case that there is almost no one who does not believe that state regulations should correspond to common sense. Thus, the statistical and reporting obligations – which is what the Regulatory Control Council is about – have of course always been designed to correspond to common sense. But one experiences, given the diversity of humanity, that not everyone finds everything equally understandable and useful, and that over time, in light of changing lifestyles, things that once seemed useful and understandable may no longer be so self-evident after 20 or 25 years.

We certainly agree that without regulations, no state can function. That is correct. When I look at the last six months, we have talked more about where we need regulations in the future, where we did not have any so far, while the abolition of regulations has been less at the forefront of the discussion. But as always, it is actually about the dosage, about the balance between what needs to be regulated and what does not. Of course, new fields are constantly emerging. From stem cell research to genetic technology, there are areas today where we also need to find a balance again. Lord Dahrendorf once said: "We need bureaucracy to solve our problems. But once we have it, it hinders us from doing what we need it for." I believe that is the right expression for this balance that we need to seek.

Reducing bureaucracy and better regulation – both are, so to speak, necessities in the room – are your topics. You have approached the matter according to the tried and tested standard cost model. It is also good that you have always maintained an exchange with Dutch experts.

Regarding measurability: There is already a fierce debate about whether everything can be measured precisely and whether it really needs to take so long. But efforts have also been made to reduce emotionality by choosing institutions that are simply assumed to be able to do this correctly. For example, the Federal Statistical Office has played an important role in this context.

Through the standard cost model, the costs of information and reporting obligations are determined. This allows for a systematic, transparent, and comprehensible approach to reducing bureaucracy. It is quite interesting to see how frequently the individual measures that were scrutinized had to be multiplied. Some things that seem to be a high burden for small groups are not as costly for society as some things we have already gotten used to, but in the multitude of processes, their financial impact is much more extensive. Thus, one must always find a balance regarding how the reduction should take place.

The requirements for regulations are changing. Therefore, a law for the Regulatory Control Council is one that deals with the past and one that deals with the future. Regarding the past, we first had to overcome some departmental resistance, in the sense that some, when they heard the word bureaucracy, felt directly addressed. Others have followed the whole matter with relatively good conscience. An environment minister – I was one myself once – often thinks that one is about to attack him, and then it is said for safety's sake: Everything we have comes from Europe anyway, so we cannot do anything because we are only implementing directives. But that has settled down.

A staggering 9,500 information obligations of the economy have been measured – a truly remarkable number. This was only possible because all ministries participated and many employees collaborated with the staff of the Federal Statistical Office. I would like to take this opportunity to express my heartfelt thanks for that.

We have also initiated a whole series of bureaucratic relief measures. Mr. Ludewig just mentioned three billion euros. I have even noted somewhat higher figures. We would need to reconcile that again; I do not want to create any statistical confusion here. I remembered that we had basically approached the relief effects of the corporate tax reform. I still have not given up hope – Mr. Oetker is here today – that a thank you will simply come from the economy for that. So far, that has been absent. Although a lot of measurable progress has been made in the area of reducing bureaucracy, it has not yet led to anyone feeling relieved. We need to work on that. Otherwise, one day we will have no regulations left and will still be talking about bureaucracy, which would of course be funny. In this respect, we should take a look at that.

Now there are always favorable side effects. It has been found during the systematic review of regulations that the stock of federal law could be reduced by around 16 percent through legal cleaning. So, during the systematic review, it was simply determined what could be eliminated. This has also happened relatively unobtrusively. Hardly anyone noticed, so I want to mention it here again. Furthermore – I want to emphasize this again – there is essentially a real added effect in that new draft laws are already being written differently and that efforts are also being made to create them more favorably in terms of bureaucracy and statistical obligations.

We can also say: The interim goal we set for this legislative period, namely the reduction of bureaucracy costs by 12.5 percent, that is, by half of 25 percent, has been achieved. We want to reach 25 percent by 2011. Usually, in such cases, the second half is more difficult than the first. These are not necessarily linear processes. In this respect, we hope for assistance, because – as has already been hinted – many have the opportunity to actively help in this regard. Federal, state, and municipal authorities, the carriers of self-administration, for example in the area of social insurance, and of course the affected parties themselves can pave the way for us with their suggestions based on their practical experiences.

In this context, I would like to explicitly mention positively that there are two pilot projects. Mr. Ludewig, with his long-standing experience in reducing bureaucracy, knew that the comprehensibility and experience of this rather abstract topic often fall by the wayside. He has said from the beginning: Let us first try to reduce bureaucracy in selected regions before we implement it comprehensively. The federal government, the Regulatory Control Council, and experts are jointly examining, based on the examples of parental allowance and housing benefit, what burdens the application procedures cause for both citizens and the respective authority. With the corresponding insights, means and ways to simplify and relieve will then be sought. – I do not know if the child supplement should also be included. It is so complicated that I believe it would be another field. – I believe that such projects can also serve as a model for other areas.

The resolutions of the Federalism Commission II are certainly also an expression of what we have now seen as a possible work result through the Regulatory Control Council regarding performance comparisons within administrations. Performance comparisons are effective instruments. For a long time, many resisted making one-time actions so transparent that they could perhaps be compared. I find it quite good that the federal states have now opened up to such a path. When you read the resolutions of the Federalism Commission II, I must honestly say that at first, it seems somewhat trivial, but there seems to be quite a bit of tension hidden behind it that could eventually be resolved. But we want a competitive federalism in which diversity is used to make the state and its activities appear as citizen-friendly and clear as possible to the people.

We have used our EU presidency to point out within the European Union that such an approach would be sensible, as it has already been tried in many of the member countries. This has led to very interesting effects again, because the idea that the EU Commission can be told by external experts what might not be so good was much harder for the Commission to understand than, for example, for a federal government to grasp. I was actually quite surprised by that. But in the triangle of a somewhat coherent approach of the Commission and Parliament – where Parliament said: "We oversee the Commission, so we do not need experts to interfere from the outside" – and a multitude of member states that were not keen on the Commission viewing a Regulatory Control Council as an example to question the decisions of ministers and heads of state and government, a comprehensive discussion took place, in which we made progress at the European level, but we are still not where we are at the national level.

This culminated in the appointment of an expert group led by Edmund Stoiber, who – if he were present, I would also say – has become somewhat more pro-European through this, but who was appointed by José Manuel Barroso because he was seen as a man who does not give up when a tough nut needs to be cracked. Thus, it has actually come together better than one might have thought. I would be pleased and will also say this at the European level if the mandate for this work, which will expire in 2010, should be extended. I believe that the commissioners are also slowly getting used to the idea that someone from the outside can occasionally give them a tip.

The question "Where do we need regulation and where is it, so to speak, a hindrance?" will accompany us in the coming years. Therefore, it is certainly right and good that the Regulatory Control Council focuses on statistical and reporting obligations. Otherwise, one could get lost in a too rapid advance in wide fields. One must proceed step by step. Because trust must first grow in a limited area.

I would therefore like to sincerely thank everyone who works in the Regulatory Control Council – both those who make up the Regulatory Control Council itself and the staff. Some sought to distance themselves shortly after their appointment because they had imagined the workload to be somewhat lighter. The vast majority have stayed. Therefore, I would like to express my heartfelt thanks to Mr. Ludewig, Mr. Catenhusen, Professor Färber, Professor Wittmann, Mr. Bachmaier, Mr. Barbier, Mr. Kreibohm, and Mr. Schoser.

Many hours have gone into the work of the Normenkontrollrat. The fact that it was truly about the matter can indeed be measured by the fact that even in the most critical times, little was reported in the newspapers. The threat that, if we as a government did not hurry, the public could be used as the ultimate weapon sometimes hung in the air. The weapon of the public was used today for the presentation of a good interim report. That is right and good.

Thank you very much, and here's to further good cooperation.