Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the event marking the end of the mandate of the National Regulatory Control Council on September 20, 2011, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

21 September 2011 · Event marking the end of the mandate of the National Regulatory Control Council · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the closing event of the National Regulatory Control Council's mandate in Berlin on September 20, 2011, reflecting on five years of bureaucracy reduction efforts.
Main themes
Bureaucratic reduction, National Regulatory Control Council, information obligations, rule of law, regulatory quantification, legislative scrutiny, German federal governance, international best practices, compliance targets, democratic accountability
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,543
68th percentile
Sentences
119
71st percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
3.00
48th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 76%76%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Economic 8%8%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

119 sentences in 32 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

"Five years of reducing bureaucracy – the way forward" is the motto of your event today. Five years of the National Regulatory Control Council – or simply: NKR – is a good opportunity to take stock.

What motivated us back then, five years ago? The philosopher Karl Jaspers wrote as early as the beginning of the 20th century: "Bureaucracy tends to make itself an end in itself." Knowing this, we asked ourselves: What can be done about it? We looked internationally, in the Netherlands and in Great Britain, and then indeed took a bold step.

We all know: We need rules; without rules, it doesn't work. Legislation has also been referred to here as a necessary thing. The rule of law in Germany is a great asset, even if some were somewhat disappointed after the peaceful revolution in the GDR that the rule of law alone does not bring justice. However, it seems to me impossible to create justice without the rule of law.

But as it is: Highly complex legal systems like that of the Federal Republic of Germany tend to treat all conceivable realities of life comprehensively. The judiciary does the rest, and at some point, a person feels restricted in their initiatives, in their ideas, in their creativity. The interesting point here is – this is something we learned especially from experiences in the Netherlands and Great Britain – that bureaucracy in the form of information obligations can be made measurable. This then opens up the possibility of systematizing the reduction of bureaucracy.

I have spent quite a long time pondering whether it is actually right to quantify bureaucratic regulations and whether the numbers are accurate, because one can certainly make all sorts of mistakes in this regard. However, I couldn't come up with anything better, so I submitted to the method. It proved to be a good approach at least in the first approximation.

Then I was truly astonished by the boldness of the approach. I believe that the first appointment of the members of the National Regulatory Control Council took place at a time when the members themselves were not yet fully aware of the magnitude of the task; otherwise, we might have had to recruit even more members. However, the task was tackled promptly, and it was said: Now the entire acquis communautaire – as one would call it in Brussels – is to be put to the test. And then measurements were taken together with the Federal Statistical Office and the ministries.

Now, information obligations are by no means the only thing that causes bureaucracy – that is why the further development of the task is so important – but they are certainly tangible enough to move forward and make a quantification. Then, indeed, a climate developed in the federal government – both in the Grand Coalition and now in the Christian-Liberal Coalition – where we said: We must achieve the set goal. It was not only about dealing with the past, but from day one, it was said: The task must transition into a way of handling laws that will ensure that in the future it will no longer be necessary to scrutinize the entire body of legislation that will emerge over the next 20 years.

The Parliament has always lovingly engaged when the Regulatory Control Council made critical comments on the government's legislation. That is how it should be. However, it has been somewhat more reserved regarding the question of whether the Regulatory Control Council should have as much access to draft laws from Parliament. We have kept ourselves out of that because we believed we were on a morally good path. In any case, we allowed everything that we legally set in motion to be scrutinized. This then becomes somewhat of a self-runner because one already knows what kind of criticism one will face afterwards. Overall, it was a very meaningful, very important process that now continues automatically into the future.

In light of the fact that we have almost reached the 25 percent target regarding the abolition of information and reporting obligations, it is a pity that a great jolt does not automatically occur throughout society, and that one does not say: We feel it – 25 percent more air, 25 percent more possibilities.

However, when one asks, "Do you not notice anything from the reduction of bureaucracy?", it is rather the case that people first look at you in disbelief. And when you then say, "Well, this and that has already happened," the response is: Yes, but there is still a lot left. This, in turn, shows that it was right to go beyond information and reporting obligations and to try to look at the task as a whole.

Edmund Stoiber would have one less task if there had not been the National Regulatory Control Council in Germany. Because we dared, with our good experience in hand, to put the discussion back on the agenda in Brussels about whether Brussels legislation could also tolerate similar procedures. Two observations were to be made in this regard.

One observation was that the self-understanding of the Commission differs somewhat from that of a government accustomed to daily parliamentary control, as we are in a nation-state, particularly in the Federal Republic of Germany.

Moreover, the approach with expert committees that provide the Commission in Brussels with advice is very underdeveloped. We in Germany, on the other hand, are used to having economic experts and other advisory councils that constantly and several times a year explain to us that many more suggestions could be taken into account in our work. In this respect, we do not have an inherent rejection feeling; rather, we take up suggestions and try to make the best of what we can. In the European Commission, this process has not yet progressed as far. All the more important was it that José Manuel Barroso then stated that, in a certain way, the bureaucracy of the European Union's legislation could also be scrutinized.

And now comes the point that made success in Germany possible at all: The initiative originally came from Norbert Röttgen as the first parliamentary manager; it thus came from Parliament. It would not have been possible without the German Bundestag. In contrast, the opinion in the European Parliament regarding the question of whether one should even do something like this, whether one should investigate bureaucracy, is very divided.

We started this back in the Grand Coalition. I would say: That was a bold step, especially for the Social Democrats. I must add right away that I still enjoy leading the Christian-Liberal Coalition, otherwise it will be immediately explained that I have once again reported with dreamy eyes from the old days. No, that is not the case – but I know that this was not something that the Social Democrats were born into, so to speak. In this respect, it was good that we began the systematic reduction of bureaucracy in the Grand Coalition, while, for example, the socialist faction in the European Parliament quickly equates this task with a lowering of standards, with social weakening, and so on and so forth.

We must unlearn this; it is very important. This way of thinking has never played a role in the work of the Regulatory Control Council anyway. And for that, I would like to thank the members very, very warmly. The work of the Regulatory Control Council was not ideologically charged, but was questioned in a very rational way: How can I achieve the same goal with the same legal certainty perhaps in a better way? This is a new, important way of thinking that can still be further developed in Europe.

The second observation is as follows. In a nation-state, where we do not believe that our identity is simply derived from the sum of our laws, it is easier to say: If I change or even abolish a law, nothing bad will happen. We have already had several governments in which there were also laws with a finite duration, where one simply checked whether they were still needed. Such thinking has now become very inherent to us; we no longer have major difficulties with it, while the depth of integration in Europe is often perceived in terms of the question "Is our acquis communautaire growing?" – the larger and more extensive it is, the more Europe we have. I am deeply convinced that this way of thinking must change.

That is why it is also so important that initiatives like ours regarding the Regulatory Control Council come from the nation-states, and from as many nation-states as possible, to inject this way of thinking: Europe is not better when it has more laws; rather, Europe must do what belongs to Europe; and if, after 20 or 30 years, it turns out that some regulation or responsibility no longer belongs to Europe, then Europe can also give something back.

The OECD has also greatly appreciated the efforts we have made, especially that there are clear and binding goals and that a uniform methodology is applied. This uniform methodology is precisely what ensures impartiality. It will certainly be a difficult task again when transitioning from information and reporting obligations to legislation as a whole and to the impacts of regulations. Care must be taken to develop adequate methods but not to adapt them arbitrarily. Because if the measuring instrument is different each time, acceptance will decrease.

So we can say: We have achieved quite a bit that is also very concrete. For example, delivery and sales vehicles weighing between 2.8 and 3.5 tons no longer need to record driving and rest times. This brings a savings of 36 million euros per year.

We have abolished the obligation for medium-sized retailers to keep accounts, conduct year-end inventories, and prepare balance sheets. This alone relieves the economy by more than two billion euros per year. – When I think of small businesses and accounting obligations and see Edmund Stoiber, a lot comes to mind. We still have a lot to do in Europe.

Associations no longer need to confirm donations in paper form but can also confirm them electronically.

These are three small examples among many, many others that show what has been achieved. That is why I also believe that we should tell the story of the work of the Regulatory Control Council and explain to every member of the Bundestag what it actually means. Otherwise, we will also find it difficult to make ourselves understood when it comes to changes in regulations.

Another point is that it is also about the question of compliance costs. The compliance costs could also become an interesting field at the Federal Employment Agency and with Hartz IV – this is not directed against Mr. Weise, but simply against what has been imposed on him. – I could certainly imagine that one could take a closer look at compliance costs in this area.

Another example: A project was launched to take a closer look at the application procedures for statutory benefits for those in need of care and chronically ill individuals. What all needs to be documented? We are currently collecting simplification proposals that can then be incorporated into the upcoming care reform. I believe this is something that can truly benefit many people.

Who does all this serve? Essentially, our goal is to improve the relationship between the state and citizens, to avoid unnecessary loops and capers, to allow people to go about their daily work with common sense, and still feel a sufficient degree of legal certainty. In legislation, the question will always remain a topic: How much risk do we accept in individual cases, how high should the density of regulations be? This balancing act will not be taken from us by anyone. But if one has quantifiable methods, one can much better imagine what one is doing, so to speak. Therefore, the issue of compliance costs of certain laws beyond reporting and information obligations is certainly one of the most exciting topics that awaits us in the future. If we can perhaps make proposals in the near future and in the coming years, especially in the area of care or also in the area of the employment agency, that show that the implementation of regulations works a little closer to the people and a little more straightforward, then I believe the work will carry on even further.

The constellation of the Normenkontrollrat is indeed interesting: The Federal President stands, so to speak, above everything. If the Normenkontrollrat had had many grievances with the government, it would always have had an instance to which it could have turned in desperation. However, I believe that would not have been necessary anyway, because just the threat that this could happen has enabled us as a government to handle cooperation properly. At the same time, Parliament has been very attentive to the matters at hand. I have already said: Whenever you have made a critical remark, Parliament has welcomed it gladly – if not the governing factions, then at least the opposition; but most often, it was already the governing factions.

In this respect, I would say: The first stage has been completed in such a way that a second can be set up. Tomorrow, the new members of the Normenkontrollrat will be appointed. I would like to express my heartfelt thanks. I have already hinted at it: It was a lot of work. The task was so charming that one could hardly run away from it, but it also demanded a lot of strength and time from you. You have, if I may say so, not allowed yourselves to be instrumentalized by anyone at any point. You have quietly followed your own paths. The discussions were not the subject of public scrutiny. If there were disputes or discussions, they were certainly conducted in such a way that they always served the one goal of reducing bureaucracy and improving legislation. And for that, I would like to express my heartfelt thanks. Time is the most precious commodity in the 21st century. You have taken it. Therefore, thank you very much, and I look forward to good further cooperation with many of you.

To all those listening today, I recommend reading the reports. Feel free to continue telling that something is happening. We have also received a lot of feedback from the chambers, from business associations, from municipalities, and from representatives from various sectors who were willing to conduct pilot projects. This has certainly contributed to the fact that the federal government, states, and municipalities have come a bit closer together with regard to the same goal of shaping politics for the people, without constantly strangling and tormenting them. In this sense, it has been a pleasure to work with you during this first period.

My thanks also include Eckart von Klaeden and former state ministers, of course, who have always maintained very intensive cooperation. To the parliamentarians among us, I say: Keep an eye on it. If you find that the government is faltering, then let us know – preferably first in person and then through the newspaper.

Thank you very much.