Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Newspaper Congress of the Federal Association of German Newspaper Publishers e.V. on September 19, 2011, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

19 September 2011 · Newspaper Congress of the Federal Association of German Newspaper Publishers (BDZV Congress) · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Federal Association of German Newspaper Publishers Congress in Berlin on September 19, 2011, speaking on press freedom and digital transformation.
Main themes
Digitalization and newspaper industry, freedom of the press, internet and media transformation, public participation and democracy, globalization and interconnectedness, print journalism challenges, online communities and news dissemination, freedom of expression in authoritarian states, media landscape change, local newspapers and identity
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,778
72nd percentile
Sentences
189
88th percentile
Readability
42
40th percentile
Grade
11.1
33rd percentile
Syntax
2.66
10th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
30th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 47%41%
  • Economic 23%20%
  • Institutional 13%11%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Technological 5%4%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 13%

189 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Dear President Heinen,

dear colleagues from the parliaments,

ladies and gentlemen, dear participants of the BDZV Congress,

Newspapers inform, they contextualize news, they promote opinion formation and thus also participation in social life – this is precisely what is fundamentally important in a functioning state. Newspapers are cultural assets. They create identity. This is especially true for local newspapers. They connect global events with the concrete living environment of the readers. A free, independent, and opinionated press therefore deserves every support. And I demonstrate this through my presence. I am happy to be here.

49 million people over the age of 14 – that is almost 70 percent of our population over 14 – read a daily newspaper regularly. This gives Germany a newspaper density that few countries in Europe can match. Other industrialized countries, such as the USA or Canada, show significantly lower figures. This finding supports what I said to you two years ago: Newspapers will continue to be an integral part of the media landscape in the future.

Nevertheless – we need not beat around the bush – newspapers are undergoing profound change, as three-quarters of Germans now use the internet. They also inform themselves through this medium. The latest news is hardly learned from newspapers anymore. This has been the case since the breakthrough of radio and then television. But even broadcasting can be overshadowed by the internet in terms of speed. We all know: News spreads across the globe in seconds today.

The World Wide Web allows for news dissemination that does not follow a one-way street. Internet users can respond directly to news, act as multipliers, and publish their own comments. Through this form of exchange, like-minded individuals can be found at a rapid pace, forming so-called communities.

This also presents a great opportunity; I want to emphasize this point. Because the internet enables more participation. Those who may lack the time and means for traditional forms of engagement, who hardly engage through parties, associations, clubs, or similar networks, or who cannot do so for health reasons, are also included in the exchange and dialogue over the internet. Today, many people come together who would hardly ever meet in person. The internet collapses great spatial distances. I see this as an opportunity for the medium.

Due to increasing globalization, people are more dependent on each other than ever. For example, it also affects us in Germany when a major bank in the USA goes bankrupt. We have all experienced this. We also feel the effects of a rapidly growing population at home. Every one of the seven billion world citizens has the same right to lead a dignified life, preferably in prosperity, as we do. We are also confronted with the consequences of the economic rise of countries like China, India, or Brazil. The examples of our global interconnectedness could go on endlessly: climate change, access to resources, energy consumption – all of this affects us closely and globally and in every single country. A country alone cannot tackle the associated challenges. Global tasks require global solutions.

What does this mean for us here at your newspaper congress? Not only life itself, but also the dissemination, mediation, and processing of information on all these topics happens globally, it happens rapidly, and in part so rapidly that it seems to overwhelm the individual. But like everything, this has two sides, because it is undoubtedly true: Information is much more accessible today than it was 20 or 30 years ago.

Especially in states where the press lacks independence, the internet gains enormous significance. It serves as an important source of news where totalitarian regimes attempt to suppress freedom of expression. It enables the opposition to disseminate information – both within and outside the country. In this way, the internet can promote processes of freedom. The developments in North Africa particularly illustrate this. Think of the many blogs that accompany the events. Also think of the images and videos from Syria that are spread via mobile phones and that we see on the internet and eventually in television news.

Thanks to the internet, injustices, inequities, and violence by despots can increasingly no longer be swept under the rug. The concept of openness to the world has gained new dimensions through the internet. Thus, the internet has long since secured a firm place in our media landscape. All of this concerns you, of course, because it brings changes for traditional formats like newspapers.

For many years now, you have been addressing this change at your congresses. The questions are obvious: How does digitalization affect print journalism and the publishing business? How is the readership changing, or their media usage behavior? For you as newspaper publishers, it is crucial to be in tune with the times. In this context, the important question arises for you time and again: Is your industry driven by change or is it a driver of change?

The former president of your association, Wilhelm Sandmann, advocated early on for an offensive approach to the opportunities of new media. He saw the publishers as having a duty to help shape the development of digital information culture, otherwise, competitors from outside the industry would take over the field. And that is why the motto for publishers back then – in the early to mid-90s – was: occupy positions, develop know-how.

In the meantime, German newspapers provide around 660 editorial online offerings. More than half of German internet users visit these regularly. Because those who want to inform themselves reliably on the internet often end up on the pages of print media. More and more newspaper houses are also offering apps for smartphones and tablet PCs. They are utilizing new technological possibilities to reach more people, especially younger ones.

Publishers are competing with other providers. This is initially a positive aspect, as competition invigorates business. But, Mr. President Heinen, I agree with you: It must be fair. This also applies to fee-funded offerings from public broadcasting institutions.

It is clear: We need a strong public broadcasting service. The coexistence of public and private providers has proven itself in my view. In Germany, we enjoy a particularly versatile and diverse program landscape. A strong public broadcasting service must also utilize the opportunities of the digital world. However, a balanced relationship with private offerings must be maintained.

Private media companies and publishers need enough room to maneuver. Their investments must pay off. If the offerings of public broadcasters restrict the space of private providers too much, our proven dual system will be jeopardized. No one wants that. Therefore, public broadcasting institutions are called upon to carefully examine their internet offerings: Do they really correspond to their legal mandate? This must also be weighed repeatedly with their smartphone applications.

Economic success, of course, depends on the quality of the offerings. This applies to online offerings just as much as to print copies. Here, it is primarily the newspapers that readers have high expectations of. This inevitably leads to the question of how newspapers can assert themselves in the context of the internet and increasingly image- and video-oriented media. They face the challenge of satisfying both old and new reading habits.

The newspaper is more than ever a place of deceleration, reflection, explanation, and of major themes and debates. Recently, the publisher Hermann Neusser pointed out how important this is for credible journalism during the awarding of this year's Theodor Wolff Prize – I quote: "The globalized, complex world cries out for translators and mediators."

I cite as an example the financial and economic crisis and also the debt crisis in Europe. The web of finance, markets, and trade relations is extremely complicated. Accordingly, it is correspondingly difficult to convey macroeconomic changes and the necessary responses to them.

Of course, politics is primarily responsible here – to avoid any misunderstanding and to ensure that no one thinks I want to pass on my responsibilities. But newspaper publishers and journalists also bear responsibility to the public. Rumors must be carefully distinguished from news. Facts and sources must be verified. Time is not everything. What good is it to be the fastest if that undermines reliability and thus credibility? You must never forget: The trust built up over decades between the newspaper and the reader must not be disappointed, for otherwise, the most important capital of the publishers and the editorial offices would be at stake.

Newspapers assert their existence as a paid medium against electronic and mostly still free offerings only through thorough research and intelligent analysis, in short: through their intellectual added value for readers. If, on the other hand, the quality of a newspaper declines because it enters into a speed competition with digital media that it can only lose, then in the end there are two losers:

first

the reader and second the newspaper itself. In such a speed competition, the newspaper would question its own existence. Quality is not a sufficient condition on its own, but it is a necessary condition for the lasting success of a newspaper.

I know: The temptations of a fast-paced media world to make compromises in journalistic diligence are great. But it remains true: Critical vigilance and the courage to be diligent are the virtues that will make a newspaper worth reading in the future. If some publishers have only been able to reach profitability in recent years by cutting back on editorial and author work, then this is bad news for many. Naturally, readers then wonder why they should still pay for these products.

Quality journalism cannot be replaced by bloggers and reader reporters, but only complemented. That is why I also believe that investments in qualified personnel are good investments, also for the next generation. The profession of journalist must remain attractive. Many talents can be discovered and developed at a young age. School or university newspapers contribute their own part to this. Young people today grow up with an unprecedented variety of media. The internet or apps on mobile phones exert a high fascination. In handling new media, children often surpass their parents early on.

If newspapers want to assert themselves in this situation among the information offerings in the long term, they must also inspire the youngest for themselves. That is why it is good that many newspapers offer extra pages or supplements for young readers. They target the interests and experiences of children and adolescents. This creates an early bond with the medium of newspapers.

Your association is also actively promoting the future readership with a variety of projects. We stand by your side in this. Print media have always had an important function as political leading media in our free democratic order. Introducing children and young people to them, winning them as informed media users in and for our democracy, is therefore also in the interest of our community.

Our National Initiative for Print Media aims to raise awareness of the value of newspapers and magazines. It provides a platform for all those who advocate for a competent, critical approach to media nationwide. All actors share a common goal: Children and young people should be able to distinguish, recognize, and experience the qualities of texts. The involvement of your association as a partner in our initiative is worthwhile. I would like to thank you very much for that.

According to a nationwide survey, around two-thirds of students continue to pick up daily newspapers after participating in a project. They are convinced that print media have a future. And the older the young people get, the more firmly this assessment solidifies. Such results should encourage us to continue and perhaps even intensify our commitment to young readers.

Media education is therefore a societal task that, once again, extends beyond the realm of print media. Children and young people must also learn to find age-appropriate and high-quality offerings online and to use them sensibly. The initiative "A Network for Children" serves this purpose. It is supported jointly by politics, business, and institutions for youth media protection. Children are provided with a safe surfing space where they can learn to use the Internet meaningfully. The federal government is funding innovative, child-friendly online offerings with 1.5 million euros per year as part of this initiative. The focus is primarily on cultural, socio-political, and scientific websites.

For your economically successful combination of print and online offerings, it is essential that data is transmitted free from discrimination. This applies both to transmission speed and transmission quality. To better protect this net neutrality, we have initiated corresponding regulations. These include transparency requirements. In addition, the Federal Network Agency should be able to set minimum quality standards. We will closely monitor further developments to take additional steps to ensure net neutrality if necessary.

When I speak of reasonable framework conditions to be competitive, the term advertising business must of course also be mentioned. The advertising business is and remains indispensable for the refinancing of media offerings. Accordingly, your interest in advertising regulation is significant. It cannot be done without state regulations. However, the principle of separating editorial content from advertisements is also important in the age of the Internet. Especially in sensitive areas, such as online advertising aimed at children, all responsible parties are called upon to actually apply the existing fundamental principles. The self-regulatory bodies of the media must prove themselves in this regard.

I can assure you: The federal government is still against further advertising bans. However, this presupposes responsible handling of advertising by all market participants. Many rules are now being established at the European level. Therefore, we continue to oppose new, not necessarily justified advertising restrictions in dialogue with our partners in the European Union.

In other areas, however, stronger regulation is in the interest of publishers. This particularly concerns the protection of intellectual property, which you, Mr. President, have also mentioned here. Services known as news aggregators, which partially build on the work of other publishers without compensating them, are problematic.

Publishing services cost time and money. Therefore, I can understand well that a neighboring right for publishers is being demanded. That is why the federal government is currently working on a draft law that aims to further adapt copyright to the requirements of a modern information society. We have not forgotten it; it is being advanced. We strive for a balanced regulation that takes into account the legitimate interests of all parties involved. Furthermore, we will also promote this debate on the protection of the rights of publishers and journalists regarding the use of their works at the European level, as a solution in Germany alone is not sufficient.

Whatever a future neighboring right for publishers may look like, I am convinced it will not be a panacea. Nevertheless, we will not shy away from the task. Moreover, we have often experienced that when we introduced a regulation in Germany, it could also be implemented at the European level. However, we must and cannot respond to new possibilities of digital technologies solely with legal adjustments; primarily, innovative press publishers are also needed, who continually seek new paths.

You have raised the issue of press merger law. We would be incredibly grateful if you could present us with a proposal on this, which we would then address promptly. Of course, we would then immediately see whether it is a general and jointly developed proposal or whether objections are already on the table the next day. So, we will stay on this topic. It has been clear to me for a long time that we need to do something here, as it is in all our interests and, above all, in your interest.

This congress certainly offers many opportunities to discuss current developments in the media world and new business models. This is important for you and your success as publishers. But I also say: This is important for our entire country. You bear a great responsibility for our community. You fulfill this responsibility every day. I ask you to continue to do so in the future.

You enjoy making newspapers. You are all rooted in this genre. And therefore, no one is better than you to prepare the newspaper for the future. Where we can help with guidelines and regulations, we want to continue the constructive dialogue, but the desire and joy of shaping the newspaper landscape come from you. I also say personally: I always enjoy reading the newspaper. I am not always satisfied with what is in it, but I am a tolerant person and love freedom and democracy. Press freedom is and remains a constitutive part of our democracy.

All the best and further fruitful discussions.