Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the event of Deutsche Börse AG on the future of the financial center Germany in Europe on September 4, 2018, in Frankfurt am ...

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

4 September 2018 · Event of Deutsche Börse AG on the future of the financial center Germany in Europe · Frankfurt, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed a Deutsche Börse AG event on the future of Germany as a financial center in Europe, held in Frankfurt on September 4, 2018.
Main themes
Frankfurt as financial center, European integration and prosperity, Germany's economic performance, social market economy, international financial crisis response, skilled worker shortage, innovation and international competition, federal-state financial relations, short-time work policy, corporate investment and employment
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,504
81st percentile
Sentences
190
88th percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
2.89
33rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
11th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 46%46%
  • Geopolitical 20%20%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Technological 7%7%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

190 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Weimer,

dear Mr. Minister-President, dear Volker Bouffier,

esteemed members of the Hessian state government,

dear Mr. State Secretary,

ladies and gentlemen,

I could start jokingly and say to Volker Bouffier: Sustainable commitment, even with Eintracht, pays off. I have seen Hessian ministers-president who had difficult times with Eintracht. I am happy with Frankfurt that things are going better now.

I would like to sincerely thank you, dear Mr. Weimer, for the invitation. The fact that this is a historic place that radiates European strength today also has symbolic character. Indeed, 70 years ago, the very courageous decision was made to combat scarcity with freedom in order to create prosperity from it. I enjoy reading the history of how perplexed the Allies were back then; however, we do not want to delve deeper into that now. When you see what has become of that decision, it is encouraging. However, we must not overly romanticize things 70 years later, as there were also quite large demonstrations in between. Not everyone in the German people was convinced that the path taken was the right one. However, politics showed perseverance back then because it was convinced of the right ideas; and that paid off.

The fact that the spirit of Europe can be felt here in Frankfurt is also related to Frankfurt as a financial center and to the Deutsche Börse, which is part of this financial center. Frankfurt has repeatedly experienced that with European integration, the attractiveness for investors from all over the world has also grown. Frankfurt is truly an international metropolis. And all of Germany benefits from that; I want to state that explicitly. Therefore, dear Volker Bouffier: No worries, we in Berlin know that this is not all there is; and we also know that a lot of value creation – not to say: a great deal of value creation – takes place outside of Berlin. After long discussions, we are also quite familiar with the federal-state financial equalization. In this respect, we know that a lot of the German gross national product is generated in Hesse and that this is also in the international context.

We cannot – and I completely agree with the Minister-President on this – decouple our situation in Germany from the situation in Europe. I am deeply convinced: Germany will only do well in the long run if Europe does well too. In this respect, European prosperity is in Germany's own interest. Of course, Europe also benefits from a prosperous Germany. This is mutually dependent. Therefore, at the moment – I emphasize: at the moment – we are quite satisfied that all EU member states are on a growth path. In Germany, we will have our ninth consecutive year of growth in 2018. There are many indications that the upswing will continue similarly next year.

If we think back to the international financial crisis ten years ago, to the budget preparations in 2008/2009, and to our fear of having to enter the next legislative period with 80 billion euros in new debt, we see that we acted correctly back then. And we also see that the social market economy proved itself in a difficult hour. We did one thing back then – the current finance minister was the labor minister at that time –: We took the regulatory function of the state very interventionistically. We asked ourselves: What is our greatest asset? We said: Those are the jobs for the people in our country. By deciding to expand short-time work and also the opportunities for further training, we essentially saved our treasure through a difficult situation. That has proven to be effective.

Today, companies are increasingly investing in the future. In 2017, corporate insolvencies were at their lowest level since 1999. The upswing is reflected not only in the order books but also, above all, in the labor market. This autumn, we have the chance to have over 45 million employed people for the first time. We have the highest number of social security-contributing employment relationships to date. And in many parts of Germany – not everywhere – we have what is called full employment. However, we currently also have the complaint that we are lacking skilled workers in many areas. This could be the biggest bottleneck, so to speak. We have had times when we constantly discussed tax reforms. We are still doing that today; but the question of where the skilled workers will come from is very dominant.

Now, it is of course nice to be able to manage and distribute prosperity, but – and I say this is a clear "but" – we must continually earn prosperity anew. What is reality today is, of course, not guaranteed for tomorrow. I am deeply convinced that we have the opportunity to do so, but we must keep pace with the international speed of innovations. If we look at how quickly the United States reacts to many things and how things are being done in Asia, especially in China today, we know that the competitors are increasing, not decreasing.

International competition does not sleep. And especially our export-oriented economy needs modern, regional, and international financial services; that goes hand in hand. Therefore, Frankfurt is also of great importance. I will put it this way: Our ability to provide financial services in a comprehensive sense can certainly still grow, so that it represents a good balance and a good commonality with the real economy. Financial services not only help companies but also benefit all citizens. Whether in retirement provision, saving, or any kind of investment – the financial sector always plays a role.

What functioning banks and financial institutions are worth, we experienced particularly ten years ago. We have learned from that. In the course of the international financial crisis, not only was the G20 format established at the level of heads of state and government. At that time, extensive regulation was also initiated because we wanted taxpayers not to bear the risks of this sector anymore. By the way, I believe that the financial markets have gone through the first wave of global digitalization. We have learned a lot about how to set up global regulation. However, we also repeatedly have concerns about whether the so-called "level playing field" will hold in the long run or whether someone in the world will always try to escape, which, as we know, brings disadvantages for everyone else. However, we agree: Risk and liability must go hand in hand. This may not be sufficient for the long-term stability of the financial markets, but it is certainly necessary.

We must, of course, continually develop regulatory measures. We must also ask in some places whether all, both small and large, are treated with the same regulation, as we make distinctions there. In any case, we have learned: Without a regulatory framework, the financial market will certainly not function.

How the financial center Germany develops depends on many factors. I would like to focus on two that have already been mentioned today. One is the decision of Great Britain to leave the European Union – a regrettable decision that we must deal with. On the other hand, the financial market sector, like every other economic sector, must also – and perhaps even more than any other economic sector – utilize digitalization for its benefit.

First, regarding Brexit. We aim to reach an understanding with Great Britain. The British government has submitted specific proposals. Discussions are currently underway. However, it is important that this goal is achieved under the premise that a non-member of the European Union cannot have the same rights and obligations as a member of the European Union. The process of integration within the European Union is sometimes not entirely easy. But now it is clear: The separation process is even more difficult. One realizes what has already been regulated, including what concerns everyday life, and what we must rethink anew. For example, it is often said that cooperation among security authorities is absolutely necessary, even constitutive. We work very closely with the British and the European Union. But a withdrawal also means a withdrawal from Europol. And then one must first see: What do we do regarding British data? One can then piece everything back together, but one must establish completely new regulations. And there are thousands and thousands of such issues.

If we assume that we want a close partnership, but with a third country, it is of course very important that the British tell us how they envision that. The Chequers proposal is the basis for the current discussions. If you had asked me earlier, I might have suspected that a proposal would come from the area of financial services to stay very closely connected; but that is now a different proposal. This, of course, also has implications for Frankfurt as a financial center.

We do not want the negotiations to fail. However, we cannot completely rule that out either. We do not have a result yet. But I assure you: We will work with all our strength and creativity towards a result. Nevertheless, we must assume that Great Britain will be a third country, so that something like a comprehensive free trade agreement can be the basis of our future relations. In terms of process, it will now be the case that we must not only conclude the question "How will the separation be legally structured?" this autumn – I will leave that deliberately open – but we must also answer the question "What will the future relations look like?" as clearly as possible, because investors and the economy want to prepare for that. Our interest should be to achieve as much clarity as possible in the political principles of future relations, because if these are formulated too generally, it will create less investment security for both sides, for both the British and the remaining member states of the European Union, than would be possible.

The financial market sector is, of course, also affected by the changes, and this in a situation where a large part of financial services in the EU has so far been provided in London. Some actors – this has already been mentioned here – have already decided to relocate their business, for example, to Frankfurt. There is an intra-European competition in this regard; we are not surprised by that. But, dear Volker Bouffier, dear Mr. Weimer, dear people of Frankfurt, I believe we are up to the challenge. Our methods within Europe differ, but we understand a bit about the subject matter.

We will do everything to support Hesse in creating attractive framework conditions for the financial center Germany. For this, we need certain fundamental statements, for example, to exclude tax increases and to further strengthen digital infrastructure. A very interesting issue is the question of job protection for a certain group of people who want less, not more, job protection. We will also comply with that – to avoid any misunderstandings: in this partial area. Work is already being done on this regulation.

For us, the project of the capital market union is gaining even more significance. We want to advance the integration of national capital markets because we believe that it has a stabilizing effect. I believe that this is sometimes underestimated.

I have heard the words about Euro clearing. I have asked the State Secretary from the Federal Ministry of Finance just to be sure. I will say this: We are thinking constructively. We need to look again at the costs. But overall, the statement makes sense that clearing for the euro area should not take place somewhere else. Therefore, one would say: The logic does not speak against it; and the rest is up to the experts. However, I can politically explain to everyone that Euro clearing should take place in the eurozone. And then Frankfurt is, of course, the outstanding place for this.

I want to say something more about Great Britain and the EU. If we look at how the world currently looks, how things that seemed self-evident to us – such as multilateralism and the belief in win-win situations – are in danger or under pressure, we can see that the exit of Great Britain, a country that has always committed itself to free world trade and to multilateral institutions, is indeed a blow for us. Therefore, it is in the European interest, in the interest of the remaining European Union, to build really good relations with Great Britain; I am deeply convinced of that.

When I think, for example, of security policy cooperation, I realize that the United Kingdom faces similar challenges. Much of what makes the world unsafe today is happening right at Europe's doorstep. One could certainly say: Those who are an island are in a different strategic position. But in light of what is happening in Syria, what is happening in Iraq, what is going on in parts of Africa, we see ourselves united in our challenges and our responsibilities. Theresa May has said time and again: The United Kingdom is leaving the European Union, but it remains part of Europe.

It is, of course, completely clear: European responsibility in a comprehensive sense for what will happen at our doorstep in the coming years and decades will certainly increase. Because we cannot simply assume that others will stand by us in this regard. We have had this discussion in NATO or wherever else. When one looks at the challenges in the Pacific region and the rise of China, one does not say anything wrong when one says: America will focus heavily on the Pacific region. This has, by the way, already begun under President Obama; this is not a new orientation. Against this backdrop, we must therefore pool our forces in Europe. And I am incredibly keen that we manage this atmospherically and substantively well with the United Kingdom, because we need each other.

Of course, we will also miss the "native speaker" in the European Council, even though we still have the Irish, whom we do not want to forget. In any case, the question of phrasing nuances is always very important to the native speakers; and in the future, we will have to call Downing Street for that.

As a second topic, I mentioned digitalization. Our future prosperity is very much related to how Germany is positioned here. We are experiencing something that has long been unknown to us Germans and Europeans, namely that quite a few products come from elsewhere and not from the European Union. In the past, at least we had Nokia phones; today they either come from Asia or from the American region. This means that the digital consumer goods sector has already moved away significantly from Europe. The necessity for us at the moment is to regain ground, at least in business-to-business relationships, namely with Industry 4.0 and the possibilities of establishing platforms.

We have our hands full – to put it cautiously – because we are experiencing that there are regions of the world – especially in Asia – where the curiosity to engage with new technologies is significantly stronger than in our already relatively saturated and relatively good administrative situation. Therefore, we are facing incredible challenges. What we experienced with the health card, namely that in ten years there was actually no significant progress, must not happen again with the things we have now set out to do. For us as a state, it is particularly important to create a citizen portal. We must also expand the digital infrastructure. For you here on the ground, it is also important that things progress quickly in the financial technology sector. There is a FinTech Council that advises the Federal Ministry of Finance. We want to utilize the opportunities of digitalization much more comprehensively in the new federal government. We have also made structural changes for this purpose.

Artificial intelligence is gaining importance. But it is again a bit like it often is in Germany: We have had the best experts for decades, but then there comes a moment with technologies like artificial intelligence when various things come together – better computing capacities and thus better management of large data volumes and a qualitative leap, so that suddenly entirely new products can be created. In this development, which can be described by an exponential curve, there is a danger that we will not notice the exponential increase as quickly as others do. But we must stay on it. It is similar to the actors in the financial sector. The people who develop artificial intelligence, who develop algorithms, are highly sought after all over the world today. Too rigid regulations – from remuneration to elsewhere – can quickly become a disadvantage. That is why I recently had a large hearing with actors in artificial intelligence in Germany, who are active in the field of application or in basic research. We recently established a Digital Council. And we will develop a strategy for the development of artificial intelligence.

I recently received a letter from you, dear Volker, in which you informed me of what you also shared with the audience this evening. I see this as an enrichment for us, as this will be a good testing ground. For the creation of intelligent financial products and good customer management, there is actually no natural limit with algorithms. That means: Bring the experts in, intensify the topic in your universities, create clusters – and we will support you and hopefully contribute to the glory of Frankfurt, Germany, and Europe.

But we also need to look – I wish for this discussion in a broad form at the financial center Frankfurt – at how we can achieve a reasonable balance between data protection and data freedom. I believe that with our thinking, which has developed very much from the social market economy, we have good conditions to promote value creation using data while also ensuring that there can be no arbitrary ownership or arbitrary use of data, but that there is something like sovereignty. There is still much possible in terms of intelligent approaches. This will also be a learning process.

Many of you are probably thinking right now: What is she talking about; has she just introduced the General Data Protection Regulation to us? I am also surprised when, as the chair of the CDU, I am not allowed to invite a non-member of the CDU before I have been given permission to do so. But I do not even know how to write to them and how they should give me permission if I am not allowed to know them. Such complicated things probably confront all of you as well. Nevertheless, the fundamental idea of having a common "level playing field" in the European Union has been demanded by the German economy; and I believe that is also correct. However, we will have to keep learning. And the question of whether we will remain successful in the world will depend greatly on the speed of learning. Therefore, we should also prepare ourselves for the fact that not every law is for eternity, but that one must always weigh and balance anew. This applies to financial market regulation just as it does to digital matters – and we are then also ready within the framework of legislation.

The topic of IT security will still pose great challenges for us. We are also working on this; we are developing cybersecurity strategies. We have established two agencies for disruptive innovations, both for the civilian sector and for the security sector. However, there are also great challenges for the Federal Court of Auditors when one tells it: You can assume right away that 95 percent of the money will be sunk, but something really great can come from the remaining five percent; you may have to wait five or ten years for that to become evident. But if we do not approach this, then we will simply not be successful; that is how it is.

Frankfurt has all the possibilities to present itself as a modern, innovative, fast location. I trust Frankfurt to do this, because the location advantages are already unmistakable today: one of the leading stock exchanges, important supervisory authorities such as BaFin – the Federal Financial Supervisory Authority – the Deutsche Bundesbank, the European Central Bank, the European Insurance Authority EIOPA – we would have liked to have had a bit more, but never mind; we will overlook that now – scientific institutions, and not least an agile financial community that is very committed to the further development of the financial center. A lot has happened in recent years. As far as the intellectual self-confidence of the financial actors and the academic community and everything that has grown around it is concerned, a lot seems to be in motion. Therefore, I can only say: Keep it up – we will support wherever we can. Thank you very much.