Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the General Assembly of the German Association of Cities on May 4, 2011, in Stuttgart:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

4 May 2011 · General Assembly of the German Association of Cities · Stuttgart, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the General Assembly of the German Association of Cities on May 4, 2011, in Stuttgart, discussing federal-municipal collaboration and fiscal sustainability.
Main themes
Municipal politics and local governance, federal-city collaboration, sustainability and demographic change, debt brake and fiscal consolidation, solidarity and future of cities, economic and financial crisis recovery, urban planning and redevelopment, tax revenues and municipal finances, voluntary civic engagement, German Association of Cities annual assembly
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,035
86th percentile
Sentences
213
90th percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
2.92
36th percentile
Vocabulary
1.96
6th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 33%31%
  • Economic 28%27%
  • Institutional 22%21%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Environmental 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

213 sentences in 54 paragraphs

Dear Madam President, dear Ms. Roth,

dear Mr. Mayor, dear Mr. Schuster,

dear former Mayor, dear Mr. Rommel,

dear Mr. Articus,

dear mayors,

dear ladies and gentlemen,

dear Mr. Rommel, I am also very pleased that you can be here today. I would also like to extend warm greetings to Karlheinz Böhm, whom I was just able to shake hands with. I am glad to be here once again, and through my presence, we can continue the dialogue between the cities and the federal government to some extent.

A narrow majority of Germans live in cities. This means that the future of our country also depends significantly on the development of our cities. You express this with your motto this year, "Solidarity and Future – only with strong cities!" Solidarity in our society is always at stake when the federal government, the state governments, and the cities talk to each other. The future requires responsibility. Responsibility is lived out in our country primarily at the local level, that is, in municipal politics and in the individual German cities. Thus, the German Association of Cities also reflects part of the scope for shaping the future of our entire country. This means that the mood, attitudes, and opinions of the citizens are reflected in your work. Where things are going well and where there are difficulties, one learns best in politics close to the people, that is, in municipal politics.

I say this very often: You cannot flee from place to place in municipal politics like a federal chancellor. Whenever you go to the baker or have a beer in the evening, you can be reminded of what you said yesterday or the day before. This is what gives charm, but also the difficulty of municipal politics. The escape options are really limited.

In this respect, I am deeply convinced: If you want to inspire people locally for politics – also for voluntary engagement in municipal parliaments – then municipal politics must offer sufficient scope for design, then decisions must be possible, then it must be possible to take action. It is about all our futures. That is why, for us in the federal government, it is also about the cohesion of our country how the federal government collaborates with the cities in the country.

I think we theoretically agree that we must not consume the future, but that we must preserve the living conditions for people in the long term. This means that the principle of sustainability should run through our politics, especially since Germany is a country undergoing demographic change. More and more of you will feel what is changing locally in the cities. Urban planning, urban redevelopment, and urban design will be vehemently oriented towards this demographic change in the coming years.

It is all the more important for us – I often explain this abroad – that we do not continue to live at the expense of our future. The fact is that particularly due to the economic and financial crisis, a debt crisis has arisen in many European countries and many countries around the world, and Germany has not been spared from this. Our debts have thus significantly increased to over two trillion euros due to the effects of the economic and financial crisis. Therefore, we have done well – at least I am convinced of this – to enshrine the debt brake in the Basic Law, with all the consequences that this entails in the coming years.

We must not consume even more future. This naturally sets certain limits to our scope for action. That is why the applause was also so hesitant. But consuming the future – we are now seeing in some European countries what that means, what cuts it entails when one gets into financial difficulties – would be the wrong answer.

Nevertheless, we acted correctly when we initiated future investments during the economic crisis that have also benefited the municipalities, especially. This has made many things possible in the municipalities and created room for maneuver. It is all the more difficult when these additional investment opportunities are now somewhat restricted again. Managing the crisis was also difficult, but it also carries the tendency that one becomes somewhat accustomed to the crisis measures. I am also experiencing in our budget discussions that it is not entirely easy to return to normal mode.

Nevertheless, you also feel that the economy is on the rise. The situation in the labor market is very encouraging. This is also reflected in the municipal situation. Tax revenues are improving. We had drastic shortfalls in revenue during the crisis. You experienced this in the area of trade tax as well. This is now being somewhat compensated.

However, it should be noted in the reporting that the comparison to the previous year, even if it sounds good, does not say anything at all about how the situation compares to the situation five years ago, and certainly does not say anything about how the situation looks when considering existing obligations. There are always also segmented data that should not let us fall into euphoria. This means that even if you hear something about the May tax estimate now, it does not mean that unexpected blessings await you that the federal government and the states have left over. – I look at Mr. Wowereit, who has a good overview of the situation of the states. – There is probably not as much to be had as some might think.

Nevertheless, we have set some important priorities in our politics, such as in the area of education, which is also significant for you in the cities. Here, the training pact should be mentioned first. The training situation in Germany is extraordinarily encouraging. If you take a look at our European neighboring countries, you can sense how favorable our situation is. We must be so, given the decreasing number of young people, so that we can truly give everyone a chance to receive a decent education and training. The figures we have in some areas – the host city is really a good example of this, dear Mr. Schuster – are figures that others can only dream of. I think, for example, of Spain and other countries. We can be somewhat proud of this together.

We have very consciously allocated much of the additional education spending to the higher education pact. After we decided on a cooperation ban in the education sector, we made an exception, so to speak, as the first step. This is also good so that we do not become too principled. It is well and rightly invested money that ensures more quality in our universities and training. The tasks arising from the shortening of school times can also be better addressed.

We have long struggled for the education package for children from families receiving basic security. In the end, something has come out that is commendable. Although there are some initial difficulties, I am honestly not surprised. We have decided by a large majority to provide in-kind benefits rather than cash benefits. This implies that the support is not simple but rather complicated. However, I believe that if we now promote this together, bringing it closer to the parents, we can achieve an effect in the medium term that truly reaches the children.

It was also right for the federal government to say that the municipalities should take this into their own hands, that it should run through the municipalities. I do not want to say much more about this; I just want to point out that through this education package, at least your financial framework has not worsened. I say: If you should free up funds in certain areas as a result, please reinvest them in the area of children and youth work, because – you know as well as I do – there are many people who have an income just above the basic security threshold and for whom it is also not easy to provide their children with the opportunities necessary for education and participation. So if a bit of room for maneuver should arise, it would definitely be right and good to use it for the children.

We face enormous challenges in the area of integration – this task lies primarily with the large cities. Of course, support in the form of in-kind benefits is sometimes even more difficult to implement here because parents must first be introduced to certain possibilities. But you know, if you look at the enrollment numbers in your cities: The proportion of migrants among the youth is increasing. If we do not achieve better participation on average in the future, then not only the affected children and families have a problem, but all of Germany faces an existential problem. Therefore, every effort here is very important.

We have made a truly important step by saying: We will take over basic security as a federal benefit. Anyone who is familiar with the subject – and you all are – knows that applause for this step should actually grow stronger every year because the real dynamics in this matter will only come into play later. I tell you this so that you know that we knew what we were doing. This was a very conscious decision. I am convinced it is systematically correct because it reunites old-age security, which has traditionally always been at the federal level, and because it offers a way to readjust municipal finances in such a way that the funds actually flow to the municipalities that need them most. You cannot achieve this with every kind of redistribution.

There is now also no reason to give as many additional funds as possible to the few cities that are doing quite well, but rather to balance out the structural burdens to some extent. For example, the costs for basic security in your case, Mr. Mayor Schuster, amounted to around 37 million euros last year. But the costs will continue to grow in most cases. Therefore, the decision was correct.

It was a very special step that was not easy for us because we do not yet know whether there will be any further results in connection with the municipal financial reform. It is also a small anticipation of a project that is not yet fully completed, in which we have made your life easier in that we said: We are not doing this against the municipalities. We will continue to adhere to this – either out of insight or out of an understanding of the power dynamics. In any case, we will do it.

I would say: Your connections to all parts of the German Bundestag are still so good that one does not take off into any heights. But I tell you: Let us continue to think about whether there are ways to put the revenue situation of the municipalities on a more stable foundation. I do not currently see the solution either. I just say: We should stay in conversation; and we should especially stay in conversation regarding the second task area of the Commission on Municipal Finances, which deals with simplifications and questions of standards. This is a very important point.

Due to various meetings, I have repeatedly dealt with the expenditure situation of the municipalities. It has become very clear to me that, for example, the share of social spending in their budgets is rising much more sharply than the share of revenues, and that this always carries the risk of living off the substance locally. This is a difficult situation. Therefore, with the takeover of basic security, we have made a point. The education package should also not be forgotten in this context.

Of course, we will also talk to you about other topics. There have been city days where the topic of savings banks was at the center. I would like to make the gentle suggestion that we have dealt very kindly with the savings banks in the entire context of the financial crisis. The state banks are, after all, sometimes places of certain concerns. Sometimes one had the impression that the savings banks and the state banks are separated by the greatest distance one can imagine in Germany, and not that there are, for example, shares of savings banks in state banks.

From the federal government, we have repeatedly said: We are aware of the value of the savings bank structure; we know that the savings banks are of utmost importance for our country. Accordingly, we have also proceeded in a very specific way here – the state governments, by the way, as well. I believe we do not need to keep repeating what we want – that was done for a few years – as it has become clear that we want to protect and support this structure.

Now there is indeed a new field where collaboration will also be necessary, in which much exciting development is taking place. The keyword energy generation and the question of municipal utilities has already been thrown into the debate by Mayor Roth. The events in Fukushima have created a situation in which we are once again discussing energy policy in Germany, in which we will accelerate the phase-out of nuclear energy compared to the extension decisions we had made, and in which we may also succeed in reducing some societal divides to some extent and coming together for a joint effort towards a sustainable energy supply.

However, the intention to shut down nuclear power plants more quickly has raised several questions that are also of great importance to you in the cities. One of the questions is: What will the kilowatt-hour of electricity cost?

This question arises firstly for the citizens. Our electricity prices are already not among the lowest in Europe, but rather on the higher side. We naturally want energy to remain affordable. This is always one of the points we have to consider. It is about economic efficiency and affordability on one side and supply security and environmental friendliness on the other side.

Secondly

this question arises for the energy-intensive industry. We will also have to hold discussions with the European Commission on this matter. Because it makes no sense and must be prevented that we pursue a sustainable path of energy supply in Germany only at the cost of energy-intensive industries relocating to regions where the sustainability of energy generation is not guaranteed. Therefore, we will also have to discuss to what extent industrial electricity tariffs are a subsidy in the classical sense or whether they are a necessity to create a reasonable competitive field with others around the world.

How can we achieve the transformation of our energy generation? This is, of course, also linked to a transformation of the infrastructure. Anyone can talk about this – but I believe the mayors the least, because once the power line has reached the outskirts of the city, most problems are solved. This is therefore more of a problem for those who work in rural areas.

A few days ago, I inaugurated the first commercial wind farm of EnBW in the Baltic Sea. Without new line construction, it will not be possible to create an energy transition and to establish a completely new generation structure for energy.

When talking about affordability, one cannot overlook that the installation of an underground cable is at least five times more expensive than the installation of a high-voltage line and that the lifespan of the underground cable is likely only half that of a high-voltage line, which means a price ratio of one to ten. Therefore, the network fees must also be included in the consideration of the electricity price. Now there are also those who say that the network fees should not only be distributed where the network is built but should be spread out overall. This will also need to be discussed.

We will now talk with the large energy suppliers, but also with the municipal utilities. We will say: A regional energy supply can be expanded in many places. In Germany, we consume about 660 terawatt-hours of electricity per year. Of that, about 40 percent is industrial electricity, the rest is electricity for trade, commerce, and households. I think industrial electricity is a specific volume.

But especially in the area of household electricity and electricity for trade and commerce, many interesting models can be developed regarding local supply, especially since our Renewable Energy Sources Act provides a return-secure structure when one establishes a facility in the area of renewable energies. Many people have already understood this. The question is whether this could not be spread even better among the people in the spirit of the Raiffeisen banks by creating opportunities for energy generation together in municipalities.

In this respect, we still have room for maneuver locally and could also create a certain enthusiasm for new forms of energy generation if people are personally involved in this transformation. I do not want to say: Everyone should have their own wind turbine. But if every municipality has a pilot project, then understanding of the problems will grow, and insight into what we can achieve will also be present.

You can count on me and the entire federal government that we want to tackle the energy transition, the goal of quickly reaching the age of renewable energies, with passion and joy, but that we also cannot sweep all problems under the rug, but must see: Enormous changes and infrastructure projects are necessary, including the creation of storage capacities. Renewable energies will be able to be deployed more quickly the more we can invest in storage capacities.

Now I do not want to mention any examples here. When you are in Stuttgart, it is best not to talk too long about infrastructures so that it does not become too controversial. My opinion is known. We will also have to do a bit in our generation to set the course for future generations. We benefit today from the tracks and rails, the roads and high-voltage lines that our ancestors built. In this respect, every generation has the responsibility to contribute to the future again. That is simply the way it is.

Now, a faster exit from nuclear energy, if it is not to be compensated by the import of nuclear energy, will be associated with the need to somewhat expand fossil energy sources as a bridging technology – whether gas or coal, we will see. This, in turn, means: If we want to meet our CO2 reduction targets, our climate protection goals, we must invest more in energy efficiency and lower consumption. In this context, the area of households, buildings, so to speak, the entire heating sector, is still relatively uncharted territory for us. Therefore, we will have to discuss stronger investments in the building sector in this context. We will also need to talk a lot with you about this.

It was, for example, very good that the German Tenants' Association was already present at the hearing of the Ethics Commission. Because the question of an aging population and the question of investment readiness in the buildings of the future are associated with tasks that require a certain creativity to set the right incentives, especially for those who own housing and are already somewhat older and naturally ask themselves: Is it worth it for me, what does the demographic development in my region look like, do I have a chance to sell my apartment, my house at a low cost? All these questions must be taken seriously, otherwise, progress in efficiency will not be possible. I explicitly state: We are also dependent on your advice and your suggestions. This is of great importance.

I think that we should work very closely together in the entire urban development policy. The cooperation platform "National Urban Development Policy" already exists. I believe it is also the place where demographic changes can be discussed well. Some other points certainly also play a role in this context.

We have now extended the program for multi-generational houses. But you know: The federal government cannot finance this indefinitely. However, if you could also think about your multi-generational house locally and its future after 2014, keeping in mind the role of the federal government and the federal government as a whole regarding basic security and the education package, that would be nice. You sometimes express wishes to me. Now I will express one to you. Because the matter is fundamentally right.

Then there is the entire area of expanding daycare places to mention. The federal government has made a significant push for this for children under three years old. You will also receive permanent financing. We will see how the questions develop now. We should not sound alarm bells – that has not happened at all – but continue to work on the project. I think that good successes can already be reported. We naturally wish for high birth rates in general. The birth rates of recent years have been lower than we had set.

On the other hand, it seems that many parents are indeed considering the compatibility of work and family, especially with younger children. This means that the demand will certainly be high, especially in the cities. But at this point, we should first work through our joint program.

I believe we are working well together in the area of integration. Integration is a topic that must occupy us daily and not just at certain times when someone lists all the deficiencies, which I still consider unhelpful if one does not also name the successes. It is not about not talking about the problems that exist and that are sometimes tangible. But it is also about encouraging, showcasing good examples, and making it clear how things can be achieved.

We will also try to make things much more concrete through integration agreements. I think that language courses have overall proven to be very helpful, although one must be very careful – I have seen such projects in Hamburg – that after such a language course, an environment is available in which especially women can find a point of contact to use all that they have learned. This is, of course, something that can only be regulated locally and is one of the great, but certainly not always simple tasks of the cities.

This year we are celebrating the Year of Volunteering. It is all the more important that we promote and advance volunteering. It is good that there are now volunteer agencies in many cities that also provide a certain degree of management services for the entire volunteer sector. I have already invited various volunteer representatives to my office at the Federal Chancellery. We will also see how the volunteer service will develop. The minister is quite optimistic and says she believes there will be a great demand. With the suspension of compulsory military service, we are also taking a new path here, where especially you will see how we progress.

This means that in the future, we will not run out of joint projects, and the common connection will remain existent.

You have all voluntarily become mayors and city councilors, so you have a dream job, a desired profession like I do. You are doing something with your work that requires a lot of strength in times of constant change. You constantly face parliamentary scrutiny in your work. You have to fulfill many wishes and meet expectations. As I said, you are also representatives of your cities. Therefore, I want to conclude with a heartfelt thank you.

I believe that being a mayor and city councilor is a great profession, working for cities is a wonderful thing, but it is not a given that people are willing to take on this role. Therefore, it is in all our interests that we work well together and that you have reasonable and good working conditions. As far as the federal government can make a small contribution to this, it will do so, including the partial criticism that we are also happy to listen to.

Thank you very much.