Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the General Assembly of the German Association of Cities on April 24, 2013, in Frankfurt am Main:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

27 April 2013 · General Assembly of the German Association of Cities · Frankfurt am Main, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the General Assembly of the German Association of Cities on April 24, 2013, in Frankfurt am Main, emphasizing European unity and the role of cities.
Main themes
European unity and integration, municipal governance and cities, peace and freedom in Europe, economic competitiveness and debt reduction, globalization and emerging economies, German-French partnership, democratic values and press freedom, city partnerships, Nobel Peace Prize for EU, Iron Curtain and historical memory, Warsaw Ghetto uprising commemoration
Duration
~41 min
91st percentile
Words
4,929
91st percentile
Sentences
271
94th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
10.0
20th percentile
Syntax
2.89
33rd percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
7th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 36%36%
  • Social 23%23%
  • Institutional 17%17%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 9%8%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

271 sentences in 53 paragraphs

Dear Mr. President, dear Mr. Mayor Ude,

dear Mr. Mayor Feldmann,

dear Petra Roth, if I may say this in reminiscence,

dear Mr. Articus,

dear Mayors,

dear Mr. Governing Mayor,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am very pleased to be here again this year at your assembly of German cities – and I do so with the firm conviction that dialogue with the municipal level is of crucial importance. It does not only take place on the occasion of conferences of this magnitude, but actually all the time. It does not only happen through the media, but often also directly. However, it is particularly important to me, on the occasion of the General Assembly of the German Association of Cities, to make it clear: We are not only dependent on each other and to some extent reliant on one another, but real life takes place in the cities and communities.

The German cities are, of course, a significant part of a proud Federal Republic of Germany. That is why it is good to be with you. You represent – as I have already said to you elsewhere and am happy to repeat – the politicians who stand their ground locally, who cannot run away, who are not somewhere else, but who must face the questions and concerns of the citizens every day. Therefore, dear Mr. Ude, even if there may be disagreements in this or that form, it is good to always listen to the mayors to learn something from real life.

I am pleased that you have chosen the motto this year: "Strengthening Europe – for its citizens, for its cities." Because this motto has substance. It encompasses more than a mere claim to democratic political design; it also raises the question of why Europe exists. Why do we support Eurozone countries that are struggling with self-inflicted difficulties? Why do we spend weeks and months wrestling over binding guidelines for debt reduction and a common path to greater competitiveness? Why do we rely on European cohesion, even though each state could also pursue its own path?

My answer, summarized in a few words, is: Because the European unification of the past decades has brought us peace, freedom, and prosperity – over such a long time and to an extent never seen before in history. Last week, we commemorated in the German Bundestag the uprising in the Warsaw Ghetto 70 years ago. It was not so long ago that things were very different in Europe. Amid all the problems we face today and must solve, we should never forget that these problems are solvable and of a completely different quality than what occurred in earlier years in Europe.

I am convinced that in times of increasing globalization and in the face of new global challenges, we can only succeed together and with united efforts in Europe. Seven billion people in the world, a number that is rising – people who all want to live in prosperity, who have their demands. We only need to look at the emerging countries. Many German cities also maintain city partnerships on other continents. They know the dynamics of the catch-up processes that are underway there.

We argue about many things in Europe. We often debate for ages, whole nights long. But – this must also be said from time to time – we do not argue about whether we have democratic elections, whether we have press freedom, whether we have freedom of opinion, whether we have freedom of religion, whether we have freedom of movement. The fact that we generally do not have to argue about these things – with a few small exceptions – is the great advantage of Europe. That we are 500 million people who stand up for these common values, wherever we appear in the world, makes us much, much stronger in many questions that existentially concern our citizens.

Recently, I was asked at a book presentation: The freedom you always talk about is abstract. I replied: Excuse me, I experienced large parts of freedom only abstractly for 35 years of my life, namely behind the Iron Curtain. Today, freedom is a reality for me. That is something wonderful. It may sometimes be difficult, it may sometimes be complicated, we sometimes clash. But we have freedom. We should defend it and try to spread it further in the world.

Because we have achieved what I just mentioned, for this very reason the Nobel Committee awarded the Peace Prize to the European Union in 2012. Many said: What is this about; an institution – and then Europe in one of its most difficult hours? I can honestly tell you: I was touched that the path taken by Germany and France was highlighted once again. Thanks to all of you who live the German-French city partnerships every day. So one can say: We have achieved something in Europe. Europe is more than its institutions, even if the institutions received the prize. Europe – that is all of us, the citizens, who, as far as the Federal Republic is concerned, are particularly represented by the German cities.

We face the task of creating prosperity in the future as well. If we want to be heard in the world, we must do this together. We are determined to do so – especially in the common currency area, in the area of the Euro. The European Central Bank is located here in Frankfurt am Main. It is located here also because the Euro is supposed to be a currency that is stable – as stable as the Deutsche Mark was for many years. I want to point out again: In the more than ten years that the Euro has existed, the inflation rate has been lower than in the last ten years of the Deutsche Mark. This shows that a stable currency has emerged.

We are now discussing in Europe: What path should we take going forward? Therefore, I want to make it very clear at this point: It is important that we shape our further development in Europe sustainably. We have not always managed sustainably. We in the Federal Republic of Germany have a debt level of over 80 percent of gross domestic product. Given the demographic developments in the coming years, which you know at least as well as I do, this is a challenge. Others are also dealing with the question: How do we achieve sustainable budgets? This has now been assigned to us as a long-term task based on the Fiscal Compact. This will not be solved quickly.

But it is not about saving for its own sake. We have now frequently used the term "austerity" in Europe, a term I did not even know until two years ago. Three or four years ago, I also did not know the term "real economy." One always learns. At its core, it is about whether we will one day manage to live only from what we earn. This is, by the way, much more binding for you than for other levels of government. In any case, this is an important long-term goal. It is fundamentally about whether we are competitive, whether we can sell our products. And that, in turn, means whether we have jobs for the people in our countries.

At the moment, a situation has arisen in Europe that we certainly cannot be satisfied with. Six million young people under 25 are unemployed; that is a catastrophic number. Therefore, we have also decided to place a special emphasis in the medium-term financial forecast and to say: We must change this. This is best achieved through a truly competitive economy with jobs that are not state-subsidized but can sustain themselves economically as much as possible.

At the moment, we are in a transitional phase in Europe. We have achieved quite a bit after the international financial and economic crisis. This includes soon having a common banking supervision in Europe, it includes common solidarity mechanisms like the ESM, it also includes the Fiscal Pact. But I also want to make it very clear: We will not be able to live together in a common currency area in the long run if we do not also have a certain coordination of our national economic policies. This does not mean that everything must be transferred as a competence to Brussels, but it means that, similar to state treaties that we know in the countries, we must also coordinate with each other: What framework data do we set, how much do we invest in research, how much do we invest in infrastructure?

How do we envision life in our countries? We want to build a Europe in which the personal responsibility of the nation-states is, of course, important and solidarity can be provided when personal responsibility is actually taken. The Federal Republic of Germany always acts from the understanding that Germany can only thrive in the long run if all of Europe thrives. That is our maxim.

The new financial framework that we have negotiated for the period from 2014 to the end of the decade, which now needs to be discussed and adopted together with Parliament, is a financial framework that is also of great importance for the municipal level. We have agreed on central key values. We now have a basis. And I believe it is also in your interest to adopt this basis as quickly as possible. Our aim is to achieve this by the end of the Irish presidency of the Council – that is, by the end of June – so that the municipalities also have planning security. When I think of the ESF funds and other matters, this is indeed of utmost importance.

I am, of course, pleased that the German cities have made progress in many questions regarding their budgetary situation. A few years ago, due to the international financial and economic crisis, the situation was much more threatening. Now Mr. Ude has beautifully said: Average values are not interesting; if you touch a hot stove with one hand and the refrigerator with the other, the average temperature is still not a particularly interesting reference point. – That is correct. I can agree with that as a former theoretical physicist. But there were years when there was not even a stove, only refrigerators. In this respect, the existence of certain stoves is already quite good. One could say that the German cities ensure a balanced average temperature among themselves. However, I did not come here today to suggest that to you; rather, I wanted to point out, as is appropriate for my function, what the task of the federal government is and what contribution we make to it.

We are aware of the difficult financial situation of several cities, especially in regions with high unemployment, where they rely on loans that are actually intended for short-term bridging and not for long-term financing. We are aware of this. Therefore, we as the federal government have very specifically said at one point, and incidentally without any other deals: Yes, we will gradually take over basic security. Although this measure is not yet completed, it has already been well processed in your minds. But it is still worth considering, as it means savings of around 20 billion euros for the municipalities for the years 2012 to 2016.

The actual purpose of this measure lies in the dynamics of the development of basic security costs. The correctness of the takeover, also from the federal perspective, lies particularly in the fact that we can help the municipalities that have high unemployment among their ranks and are facing difficult pension situations in a targeted manner. You cannot achieve this with a tax compensation measure. Therefore, the takeover of costs for basic security is appropriate. It is also appropriate for systematic reasons. Because when we talk about the issue of old-age poverty as a whole, it is now good that all benefits in old age are in one hand, because then we can think very differently at the federal level about what needs to be done in the fight against old-age poverty when we know: We pay both the basic security and, for example, subsidies for pension insurance. Then certain problems can be managed much better. By the way, the federal government contributes to the accommodation costs for recipients of unemployment benefit II, as you know, with 31 percent.

We could imagine repeatedly considering how to strengthen municipal self-responsibility. However, in long discussions, we have not managed to reach an agreement on the redesign of the municipal tax system. I was not terribly surprised by this, although an agreement would have been a nice outcome. I do not know if we have to wait until the next crisis; we will have to see. Ultimately, it is about the fact that we essentially share the same guiding principles, namely a stabilization of municipal tax revenues, relatively independent of the economic situation. However, whenever we come to talk about more municipal options, it will be a difficult discussion. So we have not made progress here. But we have made progress elsewhere, in basic security.

We have a variety of measures through which the federal government supports municipalities. This includes economic promotion in structurally weak regions. To facilitate structural change, we have made around 1.7 billion euros available since 2010. For the current year, it is 582 million euros – 45 million euros more compared to the previous financial plan. We assist in the development of commercial areas, industrial zones, and broadband expansion. This is certainly one of the central tasks. I think that cities are challenged by this. However, I believe that rural areas need even more of our attention. The quality of life and the attractiveness of the location of Germany are, of course, also significantly related to broadband expansion.

Urban development funding is also a very important point – it amounts to 455 million euros this year, which the federal government makes available. The preservation of listed buildings is also an important issue. To assist here, there are special programs for monument protection. I do not want to list everything in detail now, but the preservation of historical building substance requires a lot of commitment. From your perspective, the situation in the housing sector is currently much more pressing. Mr. Ude, I have seen your proposals or ideas on this. We can first say positively that the federal government has agreed on a cap of 15 percent for rent increases upon re-letting. I find it interesting that you say ten percent would be better. At least that is how I read it in the newspaper. In any case, it seems to me that the basic direction is correct at this point.

I also thought it was good – I want to emphasize this – that you said: We must be careful not to introduce regulations that completely slow down new construction. Our interventions in the housing market are necessary, but they must be such that in the end we do not only have state housing construction, which we certainly also need as a supplement, but that we enable attractive housing construction in cities at affordable rents. Because only through a large supply will we return to a situation where rental prices fall. – The selective applause indicates that a hundred percent agreement has not yet been reached here.

We have a very complicated situation here. The point I would like to discuss again in a smaller circle, Mr. Articus, is: It is fundamentally about housing with low or medium rents. How do our regulations on thermal insulation and other requirements fit with what is possible in the lower rent sector? I believe we have a task ahead of us that has not yet been precisely coordinated. No one wants to oppose thermal insulation, but no one wants to oppose social housing either. If in the end they no longer fit together – similar to collective agreements in nursing homes with the care rates of the nursing funds and so on – then we need to talk about it. We are ready for that.

In light of demographic change, we have an incredibly diverse and heterogeneous situation in the housing sector in the Federal Republic of Germany. We have regions where real estate prices are falling at a breathtaking pace, which has serious consequences for the people living there, and we have regions where the value of real estate and rental prices are rising to the same extent. Therefore, we will – and I ask for your support here – certainly have to treat different situations in part differently. It makes no sense, for example, to implement certain funding instruments uniformly when we have completely different situations; rather, we need to try to proceed in a tailored manner.

Thermal insulation and energy efficiency remain an important point. This brings me to the topic of the energy transition, which also occupies you in various ways. This concerns, on the one hand, energy prices, but also municipal investments, for example, in modern gas power plants, whose utilization is currently often very unsatisfactory. What was once a secure source of income could become significant financial risks in a few years. This indicates that we have not yet reached the point in the energy transition, which we all welcome, where we have stable framework conditions with which we can continue for the next ten years.

We have attempted to revise the Renewable Energy Sources Act. This is a Herculean task, as we already have a funding stock of about 18 billion euros. If one does not want to intervene in the existing stock – the federal and state governments believe that an intervention would destroy trust, which is why we do not want that either – then that is initially a fixed financial item. We now need to consider how to curb its dynamics in the coming years so that it leads to a reasonable further expansion of renewable energies, but we do not end up in a situation where no gas power plant can be operated profitably and every gas power plant must be subsidized to provide the necessary base load.

There are regions, for example, the United States, where energy prices are currently falling, and there are regions where they are rising. Europe is among them. We want to have a highly industrialized country with Germany, as our jobs depend on it. This means I also ask you for a factual discussion at this point. I am very much in favor of expanding renewable energies. I was the Minister for the Environment, I come from the north. The wind blows particularly well there. We are proud to have created a lot of new opportunities for the economy there. But we have a situation where large parts of relevant groups in our society are now benefiting from the EEG subsidies, if I may put it that way. Any change in this area with democratic majorities requires a significant effort, because who would willingly give up a subsidy? For the sake of the common good, we must steer this into reasonable channels. Therefore, the federal government, the states, and also the municipalities will be called upon in the coming months to find solutions for this. I am optimistic that we can achieve this. It is also about the expansion of the grid. I want to emphasize again: The cities are an important partner for us. The energy transition must succeed; it has to succeed. As a high-tech country, Germany can demonstrate this. Many countries around the world are watching us with great interest as we tackle this.

A second major challenge lies ahead of you. This is demographic change. It involves, among other things, securing skilled workers. The federal government has done a lot for this. I would like to sincerely thank you, as integration policy takes place significantly in the municipalities, in the cities. I believe that if we look at the whole thing soberly, we have both light and shadow. We have achieved a lot. Without innovative, creative, good policies in the cities – from housing construction to social facilities – we could not achieve this at all; the federal government can at best set the framework conditions.

The fact that we have already had many people in language courses, the fact that we have language proficiency tests in schools, has improved things. But in many large German cities, 50 percent of the enrolled students are now children with a migration background. If we do not succeed in bringing these children to the same educational level as children from families with a long-standing German background, we will have a huge problem in the future in light of demographic change. Therefore, I thank you for your cooperation, especially in the area of the integration summit.

I am pleased that we have a knowledgeable contribution to our demographic strategy dialogue from the former mayor of Stuttgart, Mr. Schuster, and Mr. Mayor Marcel Philipp from Aachen. Everyone is invited to contribute to this dialogue. We will have the second demographic summit on May 14.

Implementing the demographic strategy would be unthinkable without addressing the topic of families, the living situation of families; and of course the topic that concerns you all. – The perhaps future president of the German Association of Cities has already commented on what will happen in his town hall on August 1. I have read that attentively. – The federal government has agreed with the states on the legal entitlement to a daycare place starting from August 1. The federal government will spend a large sum of money outside its jurisdiction – a total of 5.4 billion euros by 2014 – for additional childcare places. We will pay 845 million euros annually from 2015 for the operation of the daycare centers.

I am aware of the magnitude of the task. Now we must deal with each other honestly, as I simply say. We do that anyway by nature; it is unfortunate that I have to emphasize it. We had said: We will ask the German Youth Institute about the childcare needs we can expect. We then identified a need; and according to this need, we provided financial resources to the states. Regarding the question of how the states then distribute this money to the individual municipalities, the federal government – I believe we agree on this – has no more intervention rights. Your patrons are the states – I am a bit of that too, but the states are constitutionally.

Now we have seen that the need is growing, and therefore, in the context of discussions about the fiscal pact, we have provided an additional sum that corresponds exactly to the places that are likely to be required additionally now. I sometimes read that perhaps this or that person may not be able to fully meet the legal entitlement on August 1. We should now be careful not to fall into mutual blame, which, firstly, does not help the parents and, secondly, cannot be directly controlled by the federal government. Therefore, we have also built many supportive offers regarding childminders and others.

I see the very, very great challenge for you in the cities. It is actually not possible – institutes notwithstanding – to estimate every need precisely, let alone to estimate where which need exists. Because meeting a need interestingly always creates new needs; this is not entirely new in a market economy. So we could also find ourselves in this situation. Overall, however, we are on a really important and good path. I was the Minister for Women and Youth when the legal entitlement to a kindergarten place was introduced. At that time, there were also very defeatist reactions. In the meantime, no one talks about it anymore. It has settled in; it will also be the case one day with daycare places.

Within its possibilities, the federal government will do what it has promised and will also be creative. To avoid any ambiguities here: I cannot promise anything new, but I believe we should accept this task, which you are thankfully addressing very concretely, as an important contribution for our country. Because the compatibility of work and family will decide much – also about the socialization of many children who may not receive all the desirable stimuli at home.

I personally say very clearly, without wanting to lead any discussion about childcare benefits, that we should not completely disregard the freedom of choice in child-rearing. It is not yet decided about a child's fate if it stays at home for one and a half or two years. But a legal entitlement means that parents have the option to choose. I also say self-critically: I come from a party whose hopes have not been fulfilled in this regard. It was said that they would give women freedom of choice; and then it would turn out that no one would go to daycare. – That did not happen; rather, since the 1980s, we have known that kindergarten is well utilized; and in the future, increasingly so will be the crèche.

Long speech, short meaning: I trust you. I know that you are making an incredible effort. I also think you will manage to use the money we have made available. We need to be careful not to pass the buck too much, but rather to celebrate what has been achieved.

We have a lot of interesting projects to address demographic change, which go far beyond what I just mentioned. In some regions, the labor market situation is still very complicated, but overall it is partly responsible for the financial situation of the municipalities as it is. We must do everything we can to maintain this good labor market situation.

I know that the German Association of Cities has also pointed out problems with poverty-related immigration. For some of you, this presents significant challenges. That is why we have supplemented the national freedom of movement law. It is about being able to expel EU citizens in cases of abuse of the right to free movement or social fraud. Here, too, it is very important that we handle the situation responsibly. Mr. Maly knows – I was recently in Nuremberg – that it is also partly about the recognition of asylum claims. Every person has the right – and that is the pride of our Basic Law, our common pride – to an individual examination; there must be no generalizations based on any groups. I believe this is a very important responsibility.

But we also have – and I say this on behalf of the Federal Government – the responsibility, within our means of influence in the countries of origin – within the European Union or in countries that want to become members of the European Union in the future, this is easier than in certain African countries – to ensure that living conditions are bearable. For this, European financial resources must also be used, and efforts must be made.

We want to make Europe overall more citizen-friendly. I would like to thank all municipalities that are participating in various implementation and legislative processes. There are now "Europe direct" information centers in 55 German cities. In German, it seems one can no longer say such a thing properly. But our Federal President has said that everyone should master a second language. I also believe that this is right and important. Since one can hardly read German on Deutsche Bahn anymore, it is only logical that you do the same.

There will continue to be an intensive dialogue between you and us as the Federal Government, for which I am also standing here as a representative. We will conduct this dialogue together with the states. Germany and Europe have good chances to continue to be successful in the future, to be a truly attractive place to live for citizens. But we must not close our eyes to the fact that we must continually respond to new challenges.

I want to tell you: In the coming years, after we have made progress with basic security, two topics will be at the forefront, in my view.

The first is increased investment in infrastructure. When I consider the condition of German bridges and other infrastructure objects, I see that the lifespan of many such good structures has now come to an end and that there will be a great need for renovation. This means we must invest in infrastructure.

But there is also a second topic. Many of you will say: Well, since basic security has gone so well, we also need to turn our attention to integration assistance. I think you are systematically right about this, without me being able to make any financial commitments here. You did not seriously expect that either. Let's first take care of basic security. But one must always have a task ahead. I can already tell you that this will be a topic that will occupy us in the coming years.

I wish you good discussions and good elections tomorrow. Mr. Ude, even if you have one more day in office, may I say: Thank you for the collaboration. It has been, as always with you, lively and varied on different occasions, but always creative. What I know from those who may follow in your footsteps, from Mr. Maly and Ms. Lohse, gives me hope that the collaboration can continue to be quite good and lively.