Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the German Consumer Day 2013 on June 3, 2013, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

3 June 2013 · German Consumer Day 2013 · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Consumer Day 2013 in Berlin on June 3, 2013, outlining government priorities for consumer protection and regulation.
Main themes
Consumer protection, consumer rights and regulations, information transparency, trust in markets, food safety and labeling, consumer education, digital information overload, product seals and certification, federal-state cooperation, election year consumer choice, smartphone consumer tools, competition and fraud prevention
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,331
88th percentile
Sentences
268
94th percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
10.2
23rd percentile
Syntax
2.78
20th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
15th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 32%32%
  • Institutional 24%24%
  • Social 17%17%
  • Technological 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Environmental 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Not in focus 1%

268 sentences in 69 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Billen,

dear Ilse Aigner,

dear ministers from the states,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am pleased to be here today. Mr. Billen has just pointed out once again that the time of the "cat's table" for consumer protection is over, because we also meet once a year to discuss matters; and not because Ilse Aigner does not have a permanent good contact, but because we have understood: consumer protection is a cross-cutting task. For this very reason, we hold regular discussions and also evaluate what has succeeded and what has not.

It is true that I go shopping from time to time. Thank God I am not caught by a reader-reporter every time. One thing I always do in the supermarket is to decline to take a photo when someone asks if we can take a picture together, because then I get everything mixed up. Once it happened to me that while I was giving autographs, I took the wrong package home – and another consumer probably did too. To prevent this, I now practice not multitasking, but rather limit myself to normal shopping.

"Consumers have a choice" – you have already noticed in your speeches that this motto can be understood in many ways. Because you know that consumers always have a choice. But in an election year, consumers also have a special choice. And since we are all consumers, the motto is almost a call for high voter turnout, which I of course welcome.

The consumer centers also know how important it is to gather information. Life in the 21st century is not getting any easier, to put it mildly. Various options make the selection ever larger. As a result, the demands on consumers are also increasing. It is becoming more complicated to navigate through the jungle of offerings. That is why it is of utmost value to discuss how to provide information that is both factually correct and understandable. Although I may seem to be on safe ground with a possibly complicated legal terminology, in the end, this is coupled with an almost nonexistent comprehensibility of the announcement. Finding the right balance here is not always an easy task.

Knowledge is multiplying. Today, anyone who wants to buy something or take out insurance can find answers to almost all questions on the Internet. But we neither have the desire nor the time or the ability to sift through all the thousands of search results. Can we even properly assess and categorize the information according to our customers' needs? And what if the answers differ and I have no overview of who is the more credible informant? That is why it is so important that we try – and especially you as consumer protectors, as consumer centers – to provide people with clarity, orientation, security, and support, because – the keyword has already been mentioned – trust has diminished in many areas.

Now we also know that customers and consumers do not have just one wish, not just one idea; we want quality, but also variety. That is why the study you just presented to us, "How do consumers actually react to what they find?", was quite interesting.

We must ensure stronger rights and regulations in the interest of consumers. This is a political task. We need to set guidelines so that reliable and transparent information is provided. I also want to mention some things that Ilse Aigner has just initiated, who is an everlasting fighter for more consumer protection in the federal government.

The consumer ministry's telephone hotline and consumer apps for smartphones can be great aids. The independent advice of the consumer centers is of utmost importance. The importance of consumer education will continue to grow in the coming years. There are therefore various starting points to strengthen consumer competence. This also includes offerings such as seals, for example, a state-controlled one like the organic seal. Seals can also be organized privately. Seals can be useful. But since I was just asked what sometimes annoys me, I add: It is, when one does not deal with it every day, quite difficult to distinguish between all the seals: Which are really valid and which might mislead you? At this point, we must try to have fewer, but as memorable as possible seals that the customer can really rely on. Because label deception can be very quickly overlooked when reading quickly – there are many hooks and eyes to overcome.

What is the core task of consumer policy?

First

: Protection against inadequate competition and excessive prices.

Second

: Protection against deception and fraud.

Third

: Protection against health hazards.

These are classic fields of consumer policy. I want to mention the topic of food monitoring, which has been raised by many customers. We have put the cooperation between the federal and state governments in crisis situations on a completely new basis. The federal states have taken up our suggestion for interregional control teams to monitor companies operating across regions. The first states have already established such teams. If we do this right, we can say: The federal division of labor has proven itself. But I also want to make it clear that it also repeatedly reaches its limits. Ilse Aigner has had to experience this in many places.

That is why we want to further expand the coordinating role of the federal government in the next legislative period. One cannot be satisfied with what has been achieved so far. Many state ministers are here; they are always a bit annoyed when the federal government allegedly interferes too much in their affairs. But when something happens, the inquiry directed at the federal government is immediately: What have you done? It is then very, very difficult – if one cannot explain down to the last detail that all gears are indeed interlocking – to convince the citizens that federalism is a good thing. And because we are politically convinced that it is a good thing, it must also work.

I would like to address three areas that I believe are currently in the focus of consumer protection and are also very close to my heart. Before that, however, Mr. Siebenkotten, a remark about rent. We have legally regulated a case, namely that for existing rents, price increases can be limited. The states have the authority to do this for certain areas. The Bavarian state government has now enabled this, for example, in the area of Munich. Others will follow.

The

second

point that the debate is currently revolving around is the question of new rentals. We in the Union have indeed reconsidered this topic. I was at the German Association of Cities and was very impressed that all mayors, across party lines, were convinced that a limit must also be introduced in this area. For this very reason, we have also decided to include this in our election program. However, we must be very careful that new apartments are also built. If we end up in a situation where no new apartments are being built in urban areas where rental prices are already very high, then no form of limitation will ultimately help us out of the dilemma. But I explicitly advocate regulations that go beyond the current legal situation.

And I must honestly tell you: If the SPD had a good idea first, then I am the last one to not label it under "consumer protection patenting." Yes, it was an SPD idea; it was taken up by CDU mayors, then by CDU and CSU; and then we just have to implement it. Then I just have to convince the FDP of it. But I am working on that.

But now to the three areas.

First

: Investments. How secure are our investments today?

My

second

topic: What will the energy supply of tomorrow look like?

And

third

: How can we navigate the Internet?

These are

three

core topics to which I would like to make some remarks.

Investment is a matter of trust. And this trust has been profoundly disturbed by the international financial crisis. Lost trust has not yet been regained. In my conversations with bank representatives – I want to explicitly say, we need banks to have a functioning economy – I repeatedly say that this trust can only be regained through a lot of work. This will not happen quickly.

Since we have also fallen into a sovereign debt crisis in the euro area after the international financial crisis, from which we are not yet completely out, the basis of trust has been further shaken. Investors had temporarily turned away from some European countries. One has seen how difficult the situation is when suddenly no investor wants to buy government bonds from certain countries. We are now in the process of regaining trust. It can only be regained if investors who invest in government bonds are convinced that states can also repay their debts.

This task must essentially be solved by the affected countries. We can help, help in solidarity, give them time to carry out the necessary structural reforms and to rehabilitate the banks. We can provide guarantees. But the problem itself can only be solved by the countries. Therefore, some controversial discussions have had to be held at this point. But I believe they were necessary to put our euro on a stable foundation. We all know: If trust in one's own currency were not sufficiently present, we would have a huge problem. That is why solid budgets are one of the basic prerequisites for long-term trust.

But that alone is not enough; we also need, above all, sustainable regulation of the financial markets, the absence of which was the cause of the financial crisis. We have issued the mandate that still applies: Every financial product, every financial location, and every financial market actor must be regulated; and not just in Germany – we have largely achieved that – but worldwide. That is why the G20 conference will again address this issue in September of this year.

We have made progress. We have more capital provision at banks through the so-called Basel III regulations. We have internationally agreed that all systemically relevant banks must be equipped with enough capital so that they do not become a burden on taxpayers in an emergency. The banks are, by the way, anything but happy about this. But it makes no sense; it must not happen that one can say "too big to fail" – too big to go bankrupt – and then put oneself in the hands of the taxpayer. For the large, systemically relevant banks, it has now been agreed worldwide that this must no longer happen.

Banks must present a resolution plan. They must show how they can extricate themselves from risky situations in the event of risks. In addition, we have created a fund in Germany – which we also want to achieve for other countries in the world – to which banks must contribute, so that in case of need, there is still a cushion so that taxpayers do not have to step in. This is the so-called bank levy. However, we have experienced that the establishment of such a fund takes a very long time in the German banking landscape, because many – the savings banks, the cooperative banks – have rightly said: We have not taken on large risks, so we do not want to pay large contributions for such a fund. Therefore, the relevant banks must be determined that will contribute to this. The establishment of the fund will therefore take a while.

We have introduced a multitude of regulations. We now know how we can restructure banks, how we can wind them down. We have banned high-frequency trading in Germany. And by the way, it has turned out that Germany has often taken the lead, passing the first law in the European area; then we were criticized – even when we, for example, were the only ones to ban short selling – and after a few weeks had passed, Europe decided to adopt corresponding regulations at the European level.

This also means that if we want global regulations, we need national pioneers. Then Europe must act; and when Europe has acted, we have a good chance of perhaps enforcing regulations worldwide as well. One certainly cannot retreat behind the position that not everyone is in agreement yet, but must also take a step forward.

We are currently in the process of strengthening banking supervision in Europe. This is a very important step. We are working to harmonize deposit insurance across European countries. And we are implementing a uniform resolution mechanism in Europe. Progress is also being made in this area.

Of course, we are also focusing more on customers. Therefore, all types of investment funds and their managers will be subject to financial supervision in the future. Hedge funds will no longer be allowed to be set up or sold to private investors. This primarily protects small investors from particularly risky financial products.

We have ensured that consumer issues will be given greater consideration at the Federal Financial Supervisory Authority, BaFin, in the future. We are currently in a dispute about this. You say you want a financial market watchdog. We say that consumer advocates have a seat and a voice in the new Consumer Advisory Board, which advises financial supervision. Mr. Billen says that is not enough. We say: Let's take a look at it first. In this respect, we still have a hurdle to overcome. But I believe we have taken an important step with this Consumer Advisory Board that advises BaFin. This board will be constituted on June 20. I ask you to participate there first. Then we will have made some progress on the way to a financial market watchdog. Whether that will be enough or not, we will have to decide later.

In this legislative period – particularly Ilse Aigner has done this – we have already achieved a lot in terms of consumer protection. For example, there are now product information sheets as well as a consultation protocol before concluding financial transactions. However, we have found that these consultation protocols are sometimes filled out according to the same guidelines as texts that were previously drafted for certain products: The advisor protects themselves, but the customer still cannot be completely sure. Therefore, we must continually examine: Does this really work? Are we achieving what we wanted to achieve, or do we need to make adjustments? We are also venturing into areas where we have not yet gained any experience. That is why it is also important to continue working with you. I have spoken about the regulation of the grey capital market. We will now also implement regulations for fee-based advice in financial services – another important point.

However, we still have a lot to do internationally in the area of financial markets; I do not want to question that. In particular, the so-called shadow banks will be the focus at this year's G20 meeting in St. Petersburg – that is, the question of how we can ensure that after the regulation of systemic banks, not all risks shift to the shadow banking sector, such as hedge funds, and then the same risks arise internationally as they did before with banks. There must be no displacement; every financial product must be regulated.

Mr. Billen has already pointed out the different conditions in the tax area, which also play a significant role in the digital sector. Here, too, it is a matter of tackling a tough issue when we continue to talk about tax harmonization in the EU, because we have very different tax systems that repeatedly lead to displacement effects that cannot be acceptable to us.

The second major area: energy efficiency, energy transition. Affordable energy is a huge issue that leads consumers to ask: What does the energy transition mean for me?

In this context, I would like to address two areas.

The first is building renovation. I find it regrettable that it has not been possible to establish a tax incentive program for improved building renovation in this legislative period with the socially democratic governed countries. We know that many consumers are willing to invest in renovation if they receive tax incentives. Unfortunately, such a law has not come to fruition. I would still like to thank the consumer advocates who, together with environmental associations, craft associations, and industry associations, have advocated for such a law. Perhaps we will succeed someday. However, the federal government has acted differently for now. We have launched an additional program through KfW. However, it will not be as efficient.

Furthermore, we have also initiated a revision of the Energy Consumption Labelling Ordinance. This is intended to better assess the energy efficiency of many household appliances.

Mr. Billen has mocked the question of CO2 efficiency, which is also related to weight. Now I must say: Your reference to the leopard efficiency in consumption may be nice on one hand. On the other hand, it is also interesting to consider which of the heavy cars, which will still be around for a while, is innovative and which is not. If you let the larger ones off the hook because the smallest always has the best energy efficiency label, that can also have its disadvantages. I believe that we must also give those who want to drive larger cars – if we do not want to ban them entirely; and I do not want that – the opportunity to decide: Does my car have newer technologies or not? Because many manufacturers, for example, invest in energy-efficient engines. By the way – I want to mention this here, even if it may not be popular right now – many of the technical innovations we have in Germany in small cars are only possible because research has been advanced in larger cars. The range extends from materials to engine technology. Therefore, I can also appreciate weight-related energy efficiency.

However, the central point of the energy transition at the moment is the question of electricity costs and electricity prices. It is necessary for us to achieve a better integration of the Renewable Energy Sources Act with the expansion of the grid and the power plant reserves we need to ensure a consistently reliable energy supply, because supply security is a value in itself for an industrial country like Germany. Therefore, we need supply security, environmental friendliness, and price stability. Achieving all three things while dynamically expanding renewable energies is currently the great challenge.

That is why I want to say at this point: The EEG has proven itself. The Renewable Energy Sources Act is based on the priority feed-in. We do not want to question this because it is, so to speak, the driver of the expansion of renewable energies. However, we will have to find a way in a revision of the Renewable Energy Sources Act to link the priority feed-in more closely with investments in grids, sustainable energy supply, storage technologies, and similar areas. The systems cannot exist completely decoupled from each other; they must be interconnected – even with the level we already have today in the expansion of renewable energies.

Just to remind you: On a normal day, we need an available energy capacity of about 70 gigawatts. We are approaching 30 gigawatts in solar energy expansion. We have over 25 gigawatts in wind. This means that when the sun shines and the wind blows, we can soon supply almost our entire energy needs from renewable energies. And in the many hours when this is not the case, there must always be a base load available; and this can already lead to a very, very critical situation, which underscores the need for action regarding the grids and the efficiency of modern gas power plants, for example. Therefore, a revision of the EEG is absolutely necessary. We need a stronger expansion of the grid. We are making progress here. In the near future, it will primarily be about advancing the expansion of smart grids – that is, grids that can respond better to different conditions.

We are firmly committed to implementing the energy transition. Germany can thus offer one of the most interesting examples of sustainable energy supply worldwide and show that an industrial country can also be led on the basis of renewable energies. But we still have a long way to go. For this, we need good cooperation between the federal and state governments – and also among the states themselves. Because the northern German states with their large wind capacity have quite different interests than the southern German states. I am very pleased that we have managed to find a working structure. The prime ministers and the federal chancellor meet regularly twice a year to tackle all these tasks step by step.

Next point: digital development. Mr. Billen has spoken a lot about this. The tasks ahead of us are by no means completed. As a federal government, we adopted a cybersecurity strategy in 2011, because IT security is of utmost importance – nationally and internationally. We can make progress with German island solutions, but we cannot ensure things permanently. However, I found one thing interesting: At CeBIT – because you mentioned the topic "Who monitors my cloud?" – there were exhibitors who only offer cloud constructions located in Germany for the German medium-sized businesses, because the medium-sized companies do not have sufficient trust in cloud invoices created outside Germany and because it has been accepted that German customers want a higher level of security.

Therefore, I also want to say something about the General Data Protection Regulation, which is being debated in the European Union. Our data protection is higher than in many European countries. Therefore, we are advocating for a high level of data protection in the discussions – the interior minister is also doing this together with the consumer protection minister. We just need to be careful that we find enough like-minded people in Europe, because such regulations are adopted by qualified majority and not unanimously. If we do not have partners in the struggle for high data protection, then it is difficult. This General Data Protection Regulation would then also apply directly to Germany. This means we would lose data protection. We absolutely want to prevent that. Therefore, there are currently good reasons to delay the adoption of such a regulation because it is not yet as we want it to be given our standards; and I believe that is also in your interest.

We have made important progress in some areas. For example, we have the button solution for contract conclusion on the internet. This is an advancement. We have – this is another topic – free waiting loops for special numbers starting June 1. Putting a stop to this scam, which has existed for a long time, was also a difficult matter.

However, we still have difficulties regarding the issue of warnings and alleged violations of copyright. To this, I say: The battles over legislation today are sometimes not even between the parties, but run, including with regard to the Union, across our parties. There are also those who want a very strong author protection with regard to the protection of intellectual property and the creative economy. However, this can lead to the side effect that abuse is quickly identified, which then leads to waves of warnings or billing. Therefore, unfortunately, we have not succeeded in this legislative period in finding a new version of copyright law because we have not managed the necessary balancing. However, this will be one of the most pressing tasks in the next legislative period. But it is very, very difficult to reach agreements considering the various interests. We have certainly experienced that in recent months.

We have another point where we need to work together with consumers. Today, there is a very effective mobilization of the internet community – when I think of some legislative processes that also involved trademark protection – so that a wave of protest can be triggered via the internet, which then makes any kind of action almost impossible. I am very pleased that we have managed to withstand a wave of outrage from Google regarding the ancillary copyright and not always immediately back down, because the opinion and protection of consumers are also important compared to the supposed mass power of large internet providers. However, there will still be battles to come in the future. I must simply ask all consumers to also stand up against the seemingly modern world of the internet in case of doubt, because we cannot let everything that seems modern there pass. Behind it, there are often massive business interests.

Therefore, it is very important that consumers are continually informed about the latest possibilities. That is why the federal government has also launched a variety of initiatives in the area of media literacy. That is why we also say: Many laws that we can enact – often in response to new technological developments – are only possible in combination with the fact that there are consumer centers, that there is consumer advice. Therefore, we strongly support the strengthening of your work, so that it can proceed well, because it is extremely valuable work in our time. The wealth of experience that we gain from the work of consumer centers is often the basis for our political action, for new legislation.

Therefore, I would like to thank you for the collaboration. And I never want to hear from you, Mr. Billen, that you are at the kids' table, because you have never really been there. It is just that some have not recognized the importance of consumer protection in time. At the large table of society, consumers are seated.

Thank you very much. Thank you for your work and to good collaboration.