Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the German Employers' Day 2011 of the Confederation of German Employers' Associations on November 22, 2011, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

26 November 2011 · German Employers' Day 2011 of the Confederation of German Employers' Associations · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Employers' Confederation annual day in Berlin on November 22, 2011, discussing Germany's economic recovery and the Eurozone debt crisis.
Main themes
Eurozone sovereign debt crisis, Germany's economic recovery, social market economy, short-time work scheme, European competitiveness, fiscal responsibility, employer-government cooperation, Euro trust crisis, Greece debt restructuring, domestic demand growth, crisis management policy
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,604
89th percentile
Sentences
210
90th percentile
Readability
51
66th percentile
Grade
11.4
37th percentile
Syntax
3.09
60th percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
7th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 45%42%
  • Institutional 26%24%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Social 8%7%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Environmental 6%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

210 sentences in 52 paragraphs

Dear Professor Hundt,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am once again pleased to be with you. This is almost a tradition. First, I would like to sincerely congratulate you, Professor Hundt, on your re-election, which is also a tradition – a tradition that is older than my visit to the Employers' Day. I wish us continued constructive, sometimes harmonious, sometimes somewhat controversial, but always respectful collaboration.

This year's Employers' Day of the BDA takes place in a very exciting and indeed very serious situation. We have been grappling with the consequences of an international financial and economic crisis for some time now. I believe we can proudly say that Germany has emerged from this crisis stronger than it entered it, as everyone has taken on their responsibility. This is partly due to a truly well-functioning social market economy.

When my colleague Steinbrück is here, we remember our joint actions back in the Grand Coalition. They meant important and forward-looking decisions. I think, symbolically for what we did back then in terms of building bridges over the valley of crisis, the topic of short-time work is significant. Some say: We need to extend it. I simply say at this point: Let us not talk ourselves into the next crisis. But I do say: The federal government will, if the situation should show similarities – we are working together to prevent that from happening – immediately take up special regulations and reintroduce them in the shortest possible time; that is clear. Because that was one of the most important bridges we could build.

We have also experienced – and this has truly meant responsibility in collective bargaining – that the offers from the state, the government, and the parliament were accepted. No one can be ordered to, for example, utilize the options of short-time work. From large companies to smaller ones, everyone has tried to make use of these bridges. This has done Germany a lot of good, just as the utilization of municipal investment programs and many other regulations have led to more investments through state financing at a time when the economy was struggling in some areas.

This has led to the fortunate situation that many people did not even notice that we had an economic downturn of an unprecedented magnitude of over five percent in 2009, until we fortunately had a growth of 3.7 percent in 2010. With this, Germany has also proven to be a growth locomotive for the entire European area.

Interestingly, after we had the most difficult discussions in the international arena, we have also succeeded in that, after our growth was predominantly based on export strength and domestic demand contributed little, now about two-thirds of the growth is fueled by increased domestic demand. This shows us that the results of crisis management are also reaching the employees and the companies to some extent. This is an important message.

It would be nice if that meant the crisis was over. But due to very large economic stimulus programs that were necessary, and due to a changed perception of many countries by the markets, we are now facing difficulties, particularly in the Eurozone, which are fundamentally based on a sovereign debt crisis, but which also have to do with differing competitiveness within the Eurozone and the resulting tensions.

I believe that, after nearly nine years of the Euro's existence, the situation was such that the markets completely underestimated the differences in competitiveness, but now the markets are rather overestimating the difficulties and differences, leading to a completely different perspective. For over nine years, there were practically almost the same interest rates across the Eurozone. As a result, the tensions did not become visible at all. These were misjudgments by the markets. Greece's competitiveness was not much better three years ago than it is today. Be that as it may; there were of course also misdevelopments in politics.

This has led to a crisis of trust, to which we now have to respond and have been responding for 18 months. These responses are clearly still not sufficient to this day. Time and again, there is a search for the one answer that will bring a quick and immediate end to the entire trust crisis in the Euro. I say once again: That will not happen, because we a) have serious structural flaws in the Eurozone that do not include enough elements of a political union, and because b) the difficulties we are facing today have developed over years and decades and therefore cannot be eliminated with a bang.

We keep hearing messages that say: One just needs to implement a debt cut for Greece, and then things will get better. We have now experienced that even with a voluntary debt cut, significant difficulties arise. Then one says: If only you had done it right and brought about a full default. – I must tell you: I tend to be able to manage the next step somewhat before I take it.

The talks about debt cuts have quieted down somewhat. Then there is the proposal for a mutualization of liability in the form of Eurobonds, which has recently come back into fashion; you had a representative here today for that. Then there is the proposal for a European Central Bank as a so-called bazooka, as they say in the Anglo-Saxon world, which supposedly solves the problems.

I believe that we as politicians are particularly called upon. We have lost political trust in the area of the Euro by giving ourselves rules that we have not adhered to. We have not only failed to adhere to them once, but there have been about 60 violations of the Stability and Growth Pact. None has been sanctioned to the extent that anything sustainable has emerged from it. Therefore, I deeply believe that we cannot restore this trust purely financially, but that this trust can only be restored through a coherent political response. A coherent political response naturally includes elements of more Europe. It includes elements of more precision regarding the consequences of misconduct. It certainly also includes elements of solidarity, which we also demonstrate through the various funds.

A current argument is: As a political entity, one needs a "lender of last resort," otherwise one cannot survive in the world. The European Central Bank is not this by treaty. Therefore, it must be made so immediately. To this, I say that I believe this will not work at all – at least not for a longer time – because after a massive bond purchase by the European Central Bank as a political solution to this crisis, it would of course soon be found that what is on the books of the European Central Bank must be recapitalized by someone. Then one will look back to the member states and ask: Who can still afford this? Then we will be back at the same point.

This means we need to change the construction of the Eurozone. Therefore, the questions of a liability community belong at the end, if they are still necessary at all. If a political union works, if all provisions are adhered to, then it will result that the interest rates, as an expression of differing competitiveness, will converge much more closely again. If at all, then this discussion fits at the end. Therefore, I do not find it particularly appropriate that we are having it again in the middle of the crisis, as if it were the answer to this crisis. It is not a lasting answer.

Therefore, there will be no way around giving up national responsibilities to the extent that they no longer apply comprehensively for those who do not adhere to the agreements in the Eurozone. In other words: Those who do not adhere to the agreements in the Eurozone must expect that there will then be an automatic intervention right, as I call it. The automatic consequence is that a national budget is no longer valid because the respective member state has not adhered to the agreements made collectively. This can be achieved, for example, through a treaty amendment.

When the Lisbon Treaty or the Constitutional Treaty was being created, the question was considered: Should there be a right to sue against states that do not comply with the Stability and Growth Pact? At that time, the national governments repeatedly said: No, we do not want that, because that concerns our national budget. Therefore, it has a different quality than a directive adopted by the European Commission, to which the nation-states have adhered.

Over the course of these ten years, it has become clear that the national budget affects every other partner in the Eurozone just as much as it does its own country. Therefore, we are conducting a higher degree of domestic policy in the Eurozone than we otherwise do in the European Union. Therefore, the question of "How do I comply with the requirements?" has immediate implications for each of us.

By the way, this is also the case in the Schengen area. We have committed ourselves to only controlling the external borders, while we forgo the internal protection of our own national borders, and we rely heavily on the fact that everyone who has an external border in the European Union is willing to take on this border protection for the others. We have repeatedly transferred responsibility to others and assume that this agreement will also be adhered to.

Therefore, for me, treaty amendments are not something that can be viewed as a special German matter, because we love treaties or because we are so precise, but treaty amendments are for me an immediate part of crisis management, and indeed as a political response to a politically induced crisis of trust. This must be pursued from my perspective if one wants to convince the markets that things really work.

Of course, we need a permanent crisis management mechanism, in which we exercise solidarity, as the ESM will become. But the starting question must be: I must be willing to give up a bit more sovereignty for a common European currency – at least when I violate the rules. I must – that is why I have also advocated very much for the Euro Plus Pact – gradually introduce minimal requirements for commonalities in areas of labor law, social rights, investment quotas, and much more. We will not be able to avoid this. – Even if country A and country B do not incur new debt, the question will remain: If country A puts everything into consumption and country B invests everything in extreme cases, there will still be no coherence in the Eurozone, and the currency will not be sustainably protected in the long run.

We stand before this step. We must decide on this step, because – I believe we are all in agreement here in this room – the Euro is a good, stable currency that has existed for ten years, from which Germany, but also all other European countries have benefited. I repeat the sentence that I am deeply convinced of: If the Euro fails, then Europe fails – at least as we know it. Of course, a continent will remain, but its further integration will fail.

This is the great task we face, and it is not too far off. Decisions must be made very quickly now. If it is said that treaty amendments are so complicated, then I must tell you: Either we have the will to do so – I know of no country that is not currently a member of the Eurozone that would say that the Eurozone does not need to integrate more strongly; therefore, we must also find a way to carry out treaty amendments for Euro member states – or we are not capable of it. Then we will present a picture to the world that says we are not willing to defend what we have created for our own benefit. I see no more alternatives at this time. One can no longer muddle through.

But even then, we still have enough to do to work off the sins of the past, so to speak. For the Eurozone, one must say: Yes, it is true that living on credit will not work. – This is not a German attitude. – Therefore, the debt brake that we have written into our constitution is a reasonable response to the challenges of our time – especially to the challenges we also have to face demographically. With the international financial and economic crisis, "living on credit" has come to an end. If we do not manage the transition, it will cost us a lot of prosperity.

For this reason, I say: We are called upon to act very quickly and to find political solutions. Then I also see good chances that we will gradually regain trust. But that will not happen overnight. Therefore, from my point of view, the European Council, which we will hold on December 8 and 9, is of great importance. I also believe that the message to the world would be condemnable if we were to say that Europe is a construct that, with the Lisbon Treaty, has set a legal framework with its last strength and for the last time, and if we were to explain to the international community that we would never again be able to amend this treaty; come what may in the world. Even if we say that it would always take us ten years to negotiate an international treaty, we would never have concluded the Two Plus Four Agreement. We would not have German reunification today. Therefore, I say: In exceptional situations, one must also be ready to take exceptionally swift steps.

As Europeans, we are almost dependent on our common internal market and a common currency. When we look at population development, when we look at our share of global gross domestic product, one can only say: This will all tend to decrease. If we want to assert ourselves, if we want to enforce our interests, if we want to promote our sustainability ideas and our values in the world, we must be a strong, economically cooperative union.

A lot has happened in the last 18 months, by the way. It is often mentioned today what has not worked. I can only tell you: The thinking about debt, about competitiveness, about innovation has fundamentally changed in the member states. By the way, Germany is not outside of this orbit. Sometimes the impression is created that there is Germany on one side and on the other side many countries that have not done much right. We have a lot to do and are fully occupied with making our financial policy sustainable. We have a lot to do with making our social systems sustainable. We have a lot to do to ensure that our innovative capacity does not continue to decline. A country that engages in so many discussions about building a train station risks not making a significant impact internationally. So we have many, many homework assignments to complete.

However, we can be pleased that in Germany there are 41 million employed persons, the highest number in a long time, that unemployment has decreased, that there are fewer than three million unemployed, and that youth unemployment has been halved. All of this is good, even if demographic effects certainly play a certain role. But when I look at the structure of our federal budget and see that it amounts to about 300 billion euros, of which 80 billion euros are spent on pensions for non-insurance-related benefits and 40 billion euros for long-term unemployment, one can hardly imagine how nice it would be if we could halve long-term unemployment and have 20 billion euros more available for debt repayment or for investments in the future. It will now be about working very energetically in the area of long-term unemployment.

That is why it is also so important that work continues to pay off, that those who work have more than if they do not work, and that wages remain linked to the value creation on which they are based. Due to the Federal Constitutional Court ruling, which essentially includes an automatic increase of the subsistence minimum year after year, this will not be easy in the future – one must say this openly – because wages should rise in the same proportion as productivity to maintain the wage distance requirement.

I will now take on the role of party chair; because this is something we decided at the party congress in Leipzig, namely that on the one hand, wage determination should remain in the hands of the collective bargaining partners, but on the other hand, we cannot simply accept that there are today white spots in the collective bargaining landscape that did not exist before and where collective autonomy no longer applies automatically. Therefore, I believe it is right not to politically set wages, but to ask a commission of collective bargaining partners to find wage floors for the areas where there are currently no collectively agreed wage floors. The reference point for this should be wages that have been declared generally binding and from which wage floors result.

We have

two

problems at the same time:

On the one hand, I spoke about the 40 billion euros that we still have for long-term unemployment in our federal budget, on the other hand, a shortage of skilled workers is gradually becoming noticeable in various areas.

That is why we have now taken a step, alongside the necessary implementation of the so-called Blue Card Directive, which is the right step, namely that we accept a salary threshold of 48,000 euros annual income for permanent residency with a review after three years instead of the current 66,000 euros. I believe this is an important step in the competition for the best minds. Because we are not a country that talented people are lining up to come to; rather, we must work hard to attract interesting and good people to us.

Furthermore, we have succeeded – this was quite hard work; one could almost call it Sisyphean labor – in finally legally regulating the recognition of foreign professional qualifications. If one looks at who recognizes what in Germany, one sees that it is a vivid example of diverse federalism. The many discussions we had in this context, such as whether we should really recognize the qualifications of tax advisors, even though we already have enough, were quite interesting. We have now regulated this. It will still take some time before the professional qualifications of those affected are actually recognized. However, the legal basis for this is now in place. And the Federal Council has also approved this regulation. In this respect, this is a very good thing.

When it comes to combating unemployment and future opportunities, we must also prioritize ensuring that we reach as many young people as possible among the trainees. In this regard, I would like to thank everyone here for the collaboration in the area of the training pact. Many have complained about it and said: This will not work anyway. But anyone who claims that this training pact has not achieved anything is simply lying. The pact has brought a lot and has also sharpened awareness of what needs to be done. We have now also brought many of the young people who have been in a waiting loop for years out of this waiting loop. Therefore, I would like to thank all the companies that are making a great effort. Many tell me that it is worth it and that they have a high rate of young people to whom they can give hope and a chance. But I also know that it requires a lot of additional effort.

We are, of course, also continuing the dialogue with schools and with the states regarding schools, because overcoming the gap from school completion to employability and training places is still a topic that lies too much with the Federal Employment Agency. I believe we need to work much more closely together here. But there is already, among other things, a much better career counseling service.

We have also made progress in the area of reconciling work and family, and thus essentially in the area of employment opportunities for mothers – this mostly concerns mothers – and are on a good path, but we have not yet made sufficient progress. We must particularly ensure that we do not make mistakes in the training of educators, so that one day we may have enough or at least more childcare places, but not enough educators.

A question that always plays a role at the BDA is: How do the social insurance conditions and the state of the social systems affect the profitability of work, that is, how high are the wage-related additional costs? I have stood here before you and spoken of the noble goal that the parity wage-related additional costs should be below 40 percent, meaning those for employers should be below 20 percent. I do not need to emphasize this further today. In the meantime, you have become more demanding and are still struggling for every tenth of a percent.

Of course, it is part of the follow-up effects of the high employment rate – one can see wonderfully what a high employment rate also means – that we have additional revenues in the social security systems and therefore currently do not have to record any increase in contributions overall. In care, we will add 0.1 percentage points starting in 2013, but at the same time – although not sustainably, I must emphasize – we will have reductions in the statutory pension insurance. This is rather unexpected. I remember that when I became Chancellor in 2005, I had great concerns with Franz Müntefering and Mr. Steinbrück about what gaps would arise in the pension system. But today we have a fairly good revenue situation, and the reserves have been rebuilt. This will lead to a reduction in pension contribution rates of 0.3 percentage points as of January 1, 2012.

We also have a reasonable buffer in the health system. We must now ensure that this buffer is not squandered by additional services. We are paying attention to this, because we know: Both care and health costs as well as pension insurance contributions will tend to not decrease in the coming years. We will repeatedly face the question: How do we achieve a decoupling from labor costs? Therefore, I would like to point out once again that the health fund is not a bureaucratic monster and that the additional contributions allow for a decoupling from labor costs. I believe this will prove to be very effective in the future; I am deeply convinced of that.

To address one last topic: The reactions in energy policy to the accident in Fukushima – this is more a topic for the BDI, but I dare to address it here at the BDA – raise the question: How can we ensure an affordable, secure energy supply for the coming years? We have gone through various phases together.

For a long time, when there was a voluntary agreement with German industry and no longer-term operating times were in sight, hardly anyone spoke about what this would mean for the year 2022. Upon closer inspection, it became clear that too little was happening – especially in network expansion and storage technologies, but also in many other areas. Ultimately, we extended the operating times, but then reacted appropriately to the reactor accident and the tsunami in Japan – at least from my personal perspective. The residual risk – as Mr. Löscher from Siemens once said – has taken on a face with this accident. It would have been wrong not to react to it.

However, the challenge we now face regarding an affordable and secure domestic energy supply has become clear once again. The federal government, together with the Bundestag, will have to pay great attention to this issue. The focal point, alongside the sensible promotion of renewable energies, is of course the questions of network expansion and the establishment of the necessary infrastructure for it. We are experiencing an incredibly far-reaching transformation in energy supply on the way to the age of renewable energies. This transformation has various consequences.

In this context, I would like to thank the constructive cooperation from many parts of the economy. I know that many are still not convinced that this will work. Therefore, the monitoring process we have initiated, which must be very transparent – also with economic underpinning – is of central importance.

Germany alone can adopt many good measures – I have discussed some of them with you today – but Germany is part of the European economy, and therefore it will not thrive if there is no growth in Europe. That is why the European measures we need to implement consist not only of restrictions but also of unleashing growth impulses. However, there is a widespread misunderstanding that growth can only be generated if a lot of money is put on the table. For some measures, money is indeed necessary. However, I want to point out that countries like Greece and Portugal have not yet made sufficient use of the financial opportunities provided by the structural funds and cohesion funds. 70 percent or just under 70 percent of the funds available until 2013 are currently unclaimed in the structural fund accounts and must first be accessed. The co-financing has been simplified to such an extent that there are no excuses left.

We must, however, ask ourselves whether the structural fund resources have always been spent on the right things. Even the Spanish Prime Minister José Zapatero has recently said: I do not know if the construction boom and the construction bubble in Spain were not also somewhat caused by the many infrastructure measures. This means that in the future, we will have to use the funds we provide for promoting growth – which amount to over 300 billion euros over six or seven years – more sensibly in order to truly create innovation and long-term, sustainable growth. This will be the subject of discussions that we need to have more intensively in the future.

We need growth in Europe, and we need competitiveness; otherwise, we will not be able to maintain our prosperity. Germany also has much to do in this regard. You as employers, who provide employment prospects for workers, have contributed significantly to our innovative capacity and our growth. I also thank you for many efforts to help other countries in Europe – whether in the area of education or in the area of investments. Ultimately, we will only be successful together. In my opinion, it is worth it for our continent, for Europe, to be successful.

A look at the global landscape shows us: We are no longer the only ones where money can be invested. The world has changed completely; there are now entirely different places with high dynamics. Therefore, we should preserve what makes us strong – the stability of our social market economy, collective bargaining autonomy, the collaboration between politics and business where it matters, and the constructive dialogue where it is needed. After the international financial and economic crisis, the social market economy has gained much more momentum worldwide than before. We should use this as our strength, as it is also an export success from Germany.