Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Magazine Days 2011 of the Association of German Magazine Publishers on November 18, 2011, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

18 November 2011 · Magazine Days 2011 of the Association of German Magazine Publishers · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Association of German Magazine Publishers at their Magazine Days 2011 event in Berlin on November 18, 2011.
Main themes
Digitalization and media transformation, media regulation, integration and migration, digital natives vs digital migrants, print media circulation, internet giants and governance, reading promotion, Germany Foundation for Integration, demographic change, society and technology, G8 and global regulation
Duration
~21 min
67th percentile
Words
2,472
67th percentile
Sentences
129
75th percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
11.7
41st percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 31%30%
  • Economic 21%20%
  • Social 17%17%
  • Technological 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

129 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Dear Professor Burda,

dear Mr. Fürstner,

dear colleagues from the parliaments,

ladies and gentlemen,

You had an impressive evening event yesterday. For example, I spoke with Henry Kissinger about it. I believe you have nominated outstanding award winners.

I have been a regular guest here since 2005. The topics we discuss are not diminishing. During this time, we have accomplished something together – you have primarily done this – namely, the establishment of the Germany Foundation for Integration. Therefore, I would like to express my heartfelt thanks for that before I turn to media specifics. I believe that the topic of integration is as important for our country as the topic of reasonable media regulation. Because when we look at the demographic changes and the number of children enrolled in schools in urban areas today, we see that in many cities, more than 50 percent of children already have a migration background. We will face great difficulties if we do not place the issues of language and participation at the top of the agenda. The Germany Foundation for Integration does just that. Thank you very much for that.

Professor Burda, we have been discussing for some time: How is the advancing digitalization changing the media world? You are among the first to point out that the possibilities of information technology, especially the Internet, hold the same significance as the invention of the printing press centuries ago. Like you, I am convinced that the way media is used also changes society. We still do not see the changes clearly before us, but we sense that they have a tremendous dimension.

I want to say upfront: What you wish for, a "traffic code" for the media world, cannot be created, at least not with regard to Germany; even then, it will not satisfy you. That is also what makes it complicated; a complication we encounter everywhere – whether it concerns regulation of financial markets or regulations in the media world. Like you, I believe that we certainly cannot do without rules, but I also know – we had representatives of the internet giants of this world, such as Google and Facebook, as guests for an hour at the last G8 meeting under the French presidency: The willingness of the dominant players to submit to certain regulations is limited – that is probably a natural behavior – which, due to their value creation significance for the respective countries in which they are based, does not lead to an overwhelming eagerness for regulation. Disproportionately, the countries where value creation does not occur to such an extent are much more eager to regulate.

At the same time, we also have the issue that we have a disintegrating society. On one side, there are people who are virtually at home on the Internet, who call themselves "digital natives" and have clearly stated that on the other side, those who do not belong to them are "digital migrants" and that these "digital migrants" – we would not say this otherwise in the context of integration – do not need to be integrated, but simply do not understand what is going on. Such a moral assessment is, of course, to be questioned.

I accept that I will no longer become a "digital native," but it remains the case that society must discuss: What are the expectations of the Internet? I believe that the issue of transparency, which has now been clearly emphasized by the Pirate Party, is one that can be discussed, but a completely limitless space will not be possible. Nevertheless, those who speak of the good old GEMA and other things will not succeed in the long run with old approaches. This means that "digital migrants" must show a high degree of flexibility, but this also applies to "digital natives."

Having said that, I want to say that we are all impressed by the new possibilities that the Internet offers us, and that, as Professor Burda has already said, German magazines and newspapers are admirably making use of this new medium and seeing opportunities in it. Essentially, we have two things; one is the classic magazine, the classic newspaper. We can say: Since 1999, when not everyone was using the Internet as a matter of course, the sold circulation of consumer magazines has decreased, but only by ten percent. This, in turn, shows that one should not give up the original product too quickly, and that the forecasts made in 1999, which were in some cases much more drastic, have not turned out to be so dramatic. Still, 90 percent of 14 to 69-year-olds regularly reach for a magazine. Most people will be dual users anyway. Professor Köcher will later present detailed results of a current study from the Allensbach Institute for Demoscopy.

We in politics believe that the ability to read is indeed promoted by magazines and newspapers and that reading skills should continue to be fostered. "Magazines in schools," a very successful project, reaches 450,000 children in 17,000 schools. Ninety-six percent of children between six and thirteen enjoy looking at magazines. We are fortunately blessed with a very diverse German publishing landscape, but we know that the reading ability of many children is unfortunately not very well developed. This is again closely related to language skills. Therefore, the foundation is very well positioned with you. I would like to thank Mr. Fürstner once again for that. Education is our major focus. Therefore, we will continue to move forward together in media work.

Traditional media also have a prominent role on the Internet. With iPads and similar tablet computers, we have the opportunity to sell newspapers and magazines in a completely different way through applications, through apps. This brings us exactly to the point that Professor Burda described: These are paid media contents; and they compete with free offers of various kinds. On the one hand, readers demand quality, and on the other hand, free offers are also in demand. What can we do? First, we can try to simplify competition law, which you also mentioned. I am very grateful that we have now also received proposals from the industry. Therefore, we will also try to implement competition law in this sense.

We agree with the publishers' associations and the Federal Association of Press-Grosso: The Grosso system must be maintained. I hope that is in your interest. If legal disputes lead to the Grosso system being endangered, I assure you here that we will take the necessary actions. We will need to exchange ideas on this.

Regarding competition law in connection with press mergers, I agree with you that we have a kind of antitrust law that does not take international interconnections into account. The example of the crochet magazine was certainly a very pointed one, but it essentially gets to the point. Therefore, we will continue to discuss with you how we can act politically here.

Preparations and discussions for the eighth amendment of the Act Against Restraints of Competition are still ongoing. There are no final determinations yet, but there is one central point – I can assure you of this today – that we want to include: The so-called threshold for mergers between publishers should be raised. This will expand the economic leeway and design options for publishers.

I can understand that you sometimes say the timeframes in which we act have little to do with the processes in the digital world and the changes. However, media concentration law lies within the legislative competence of the states; and the states, in turn, are well aware of how helpful it would be if they could present their proposed solutions as quickly as possible. I believe there is much to be said for the fact that the relevant provisions in the Interstate Broadcasting Treaty of the states will in the future take media cross-concentration trends into account more than before.

When I speak of competition, I cannot ignore the competition between publishers and broadcasters on the Internet. I already said something about this at the newspaper congress recently. I believe it is undisputed that we want a future-proof public broadcasting system. This also requires appropriate development opportunities. But this must not lead to a complete distortion between private and public broadcasters. Therefore, I believe: Public broadcasters should focus on moving images and audio streams in their telemedia offerings and reduce texts, which do not count as core business, for example, in television. I believe that users of these applications are primarily interested in seeing moving images. Therefore, we should continue to work in this direction.

For many publishers today, a combination of print and online offerings is virtually indispensable.

Therefore,

two

aspects that have already been mentioned here:

first, data transmission on the Internet free from discrimination and second, the protection of intellectual property.

Net neutrality is the keyword for data transmission. In the context of the ongoing amendment of the Telecommunications Act, we have initiated regulations that further expand the already existing protection of net neutrality. We are keeping an eye on developments and will ensure that this can be realized as comprehensively as possible. However, things are constantly in flux. Therefore, ongoing dialogue is necessary here.

Regarding the protection of intellectual property, the services of so-called news aggregators – everyone knows this, for example, from Google – are indeed causing you significant problems because their business models are simply based on the use of others' publishing services. There is a protection gap in the current copyright law because it could not be imagined in the past. Because copyright law does not currently provide publishers with an independent right to protect their services. In this respect, the demand for a neighboring right for press publishers is very understandable.

After my appearance at the newspaper congress, I spoke again with the Ministry of Justice about this. The neighboring right is well developed. However, there is not only pressure from so-called interest groups on the legislator, but pressure on Parliament also comes from within Parliament itself, as there are now many who are much more inclined to the interests of the Internet than to the interests of traditional copyright. This means that the line of acceptance for such a neighboring rights law does not only run somewhere outside society but now also runs right through Parliament.

There is a growing portion of people who are so committed to the Internet that they have significant concerns about any form of legislation and restrictions on freedom. Therefore, it would be all the more important that we at least reach similar possibilities at the European level, but preferably also internationally. I say, however, it is our intention to pass the neighboring right for press publishers. And I add: This will not solve all problems, because you will also – you know this as well – have to continually develop your own business models. I can only say from the last few years that you have done this repeatedly, but a minimal safeguard is indeed necessary.

In an increasingly tough journalistic and economic competition, it is, of course, essential that if you want to exist, money must be earned repeatedly. Therefore, the advertising business is also one that must continue to enable refinancing. Here, Google – you mentioned it – has indeed succeeded in tapping a significant advertising market. I believe we need, on the one hand, advertising regulation. The separation of editorial content and advertising remains indispensable even in the age of the Internet, especially in sensitive areas such as online advertising directed at children. Here, however, we want to primarily rely on the self-regulation of the media. I thank you for all efforts in this area.

It also applies what I have said several times before: We are still against advertising bans, of course always on the condition that all market participants fulfill their responsibilities. But an ever-increasing restriction of the advertising market, which does not rely on the informed citizen, is actually anachronistic, because this citizen has access to much more through the internet than ever before. In this respect, I believe that nothing can be achieved through advertising restrictions – on the contrary. Since many advertising restrictions, as you know, are now regulated at the European level, we will repeatedly oppose new, not necessarily justified advertising restrictions together with our European partners. You can count on the federal government for that.

The economic framework conditions may change, the habits of media users may change, but one thing remains unchanged: The media industry is not just any trade, but it fulfills an incredibly important, an indispensable public task in our democracy and for our democracy. You as publishers therefore have a high responsibility; you as publishers also take on this high responsibility. Therefore, I would like to express my heartfelt thanks to you for that.

Our society, as you said, Mr. Burda, will change. The more necessary it will be to maintain cohesion in this society in a certain way for the future. In this regard, your approach, the approach of your association in the magazine sector, is exemplary in my opinion: not to fight against new technologies, but to engage with them, to work with them, but of course also to demand regulations with the knowledge of this new market.

I can promise that we will do a lot nationally to improve your "traffic regulations" a bit in the future. That it will become the same "traffic regulations" internationally everywhere, I will have to work on that a little longer. But you probably did not expect anything different. I think this is part of honesty, because – here comes my request to you – you must also point this out in disputes with your international colleagues and ally yourselves so that such rules gradually emerge worldwide. Do go – I believe you do this as well – occasionally into the lion's den, to those who today benefit from very large markets because they were very quick to get in there, and advocate for it.

Those who do not engage in competition will one day no longer be flexible enough. Those who are large and dominant in the market today will one day – this is also our good German experience – not have the innovative power – it can take time – to continually adapt. We know: A diversity of actors in an economic space always has the best chance of being stable and innovative in the long run. Therefore, it was certainly one of Ludwig Erhard's greatest achievements to enforce German antitrust law against restrictions on competition against the large industrial associations, thereby enabling medium-sized, mid-sized, and many small companies to exist. This must also be our interest in the media world. Therefore, we are allies in this regard.

Thank you very much for your work.