Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the German Employers' Day of the Confederation of German Employers' Associations on November 23, 2010, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

27 November 2010 · German Employers' Day of the Confederation of German Employers' Associations · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Employers' Day of the Confederation of German Employers' Associations on November 23, 2010, in Berlin, reviewing Germany's economic recovery and key policy priorities.
Main themes
German economic recovery, employment and labor market, energy policy and renewable energies, industrial location competitiveness, infrastructure investment, nuclear energy as bridge technology, demographic change, international competition from Asia, legal certainty for investors, Stuttgart 21 and planning reliability, citizen engagement and digital networking
Duration
~42 min
91st percentile
Words
5,017
91st percentile
Sentences
251
93rd percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
11.0
32nd percentile
Syntax
2.95
40th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 50%49%
  • Social 23%23%
  • Institutional 16%16%
  • Environmental 4%4%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

251 sentences in 50 paragraphs

Dear Professor Hundt,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am very pleased to accept your invitation to the Employer Day again this year, and in fact even more gladly than last year. Because the situation today, in terms of the economy and employment in Germany, is extraordinarily positive compared to what our expectations were a year ago. While last year we could only glimpse a certain silver lining on the horizon, the overall situation this year proves to be relatively robust. This nourishes the hope that we can achieve reasonable growth rates not only this year but also next year and perhaps beyond.

Nevertheless, after the 4.9 percent drop in gross domestic product during the economic crisis last year, growth rates of 3.4 or 3.5 percent this year are still not sufficient to return to pre-crisis levels. One must not forget that a certain basic growth is necessary for securing employment. This means that we cannot rest on our laurels in the current situation; rather, we must do everything we can to leverage the relatively positive development and momentum to make the right decisions for the future.

It is true that we currently rank among the leading countries and growth engines in the European Union. However, on the other hand, we have also experienced the reality of what I said quite early in the crisis, namely that in such a crisis, the cards are reshuffled worldwide. When looking at Asia, one sees an incredible dynamism and that part of our recovery is indeed due to the growth rates in the Asian region, for example, China. Given the increased international competition with a growing influence from Asia on one side and the demographic change we have to manage on the other, it remains correct and important that we make appropriate decisions for our country.

Before I address the points that particularly interest the BDA, I want to emphasize that it is about securing the Federal Republic of Germany as an industrial location for the coming years. There will certainly be an increasing service sector. However, it would be completely wrong to believe that we could maintain our prosperity without an industrial foundation.

An industrial location requires a sensible energy concept. A broad societal discussion has now erupted about this. That is not a bad thing. We have set in motion the things we consider necessary, always under the premise that we want to reach the age of renewable energies as quickly as possible, but in a way that jobs are secured here and not driven out of Germany. Electricity must remain affordable. This applies to citizens and to industry. Therefore, while all necessary environmental compatibility must be considered, the security of supply and the price of electricity must also be kept in mind. It is important that we realistically assess the timeframes in which we want to reach the age of renewable energies. Moreover, our goals are truly ambitious.

We must ensure that the necessary infrastructure is in place to implement this profound change in energy supply. We say that we need nuclear energy as a bridge technology for longer. When we talk about a bridge technology, it means that one day we will phase out nuclear energy. As long as energy from renewable sources cannot be produced in sufficient quantities in regions of Germany where industry is located, it makes no sense to force a transition when the necessary infrastructure is not yet in place.

We will not tire of making it clear: There is a certain degree of hypocrisy when one advocates for renewable energies but repeatedly demonstrates at the forefront of every protest movement against the construction of high-voltage lines that are needed. We need hundreds of kilometers of high-voltage lines. Therefore, this must be discussed.

We have made a clear commitment to infrastructure projects. You mentioned the example of "Stuttgart 21." It indeed touches on a profound question regarding the reliability of planning in our country. One cannot say that the planning periods are too short here. Generally, they are not. Now they are again so long that many things can change in the meantime. However, this cannot be the case, as otherwise investors – and this is not just about a train station – will no longer be able to rely on Germany. That would be the most serious thing that could happen. Because one of the great qualities of the location Germany is that even investors from outside believe they can rely on us. Therefore, legal certainty is very important in this regard.

This does not mean that we should not repeatedly discuss new forms of communication with the responsible municipalities regarding how to engage with citizens. The world has changed massively due to the existence of the internet and a much faster networking of groups with similar interests. You notice this in your associations, and we notice it in the parties. This must be responded to. But that cannot replace legal certainty.

Having said that and once again pointing out our investments in research and education, which are increasing despite all budget consolidations, we can turn to what is particularly important to you, namely the situation in the labor market.

One of the most encouraging things we have seen during the crisis was that the political offers, such as short-time work, were accepted and implemented in companies by both employers and employees. In this respect, one can say that this was a piece of lived social market economy in a difficult situation, which certainly relied heavily on the fact that we have collective bargaining autonomy and collective bargaining partnership in our country. We could rely on that. Therefore, I would like to express my heartfelt thanks for the acceptance of these measures, whether from small and medium-sized enterprises or large companies. There was an awareness that the great treasure of our economy is well-trained people. The fact that we were able to quickly return to an upswing after the crisis is related to this.

There are now almost 41 million employment relationships. We have fewer than three million unemployed. When the question of justice arises – the budget week is currently taking place in the German Bundestag – I can only say: The fairest thing is to give as many people as possible the chance to participate in social life through their own employment. That is the goal to which we remain committed.

We can truly be proud of what we have achieved together. It is also true that politics has a certain share in this. I am the last to deny that important decisions were made during the government of my predecessor with the "Agenda 2010," which we have always supported. But it will soon be the case that I will be the only one defending the whole thing while the authors will only look for ways to distance themselves from it. But I will stand by it. Because, of course, the measures from back then, plus other reasonable decisions, have contributed to this development, just as intelligent collective agreements have provided the breathing space and flexibility, as well as working time accounts and much more.

Part of this success is also due to temporary work. Therefore, the flexibility instrument of temporary work must also remain in place. We are continually discussing this with the trade unions, especially regarding how to achieve the greatest possible coherence with permanent employment. Here, collective bargaining autonomy is significantly required. I find that the collective agreements recently concluded in the steel industry are very intelligent collective agreements.

In everything we discuss here – even when we talk about minimum wages – our intention is to strengthen collective bargaining autonomy and not to relieve the collective bargaining partners of their responsibility. However, I have also said at this point and repeat it: It is regrettable that there are still significant white spots today – especially in the service sector – where collective bargaining autonomy does not function as it does in the classic industrial sectors. I can only encourage all of you to uphold collective bargaining autonomy, maintain collective bargaining partnerships, and continually strive for new collective agreements.

However, we must also recognize abuse in temporary work. These cases of abuse cause a lot of damage. Therefore, I ask you, in the spirit of good cooperation in the social market economy, to pay attention to what is being done with the instrument of temporary work, because otherwise this instrument will be discredited to such an extent that it will be politically difficult to maintain it as a flexibility instrument – which I would like to do.

In the spring of next year, we will certainly take another look at the freedom of movement for workers. We will seek to discuss this topic with you again.

Mr. Hundt, you rightly addressed the issue of collective bargaining unity. Now we are fortunate: You are an engineer and I am a physicist; therefore, we cannot conduct a constitutional dispute here. Regarding the issue of collective bargaining unity, a change has occurred due to the latest supreme court rulings. The DGB and BDA have reacted to this and made proposals to us. The federal government is also very intensively examining these proposals and finding the right responses. I cannot tell you today: We will adopt your proposals one-to-one. Personally, I am convinced that there is a need for regulation. I am also convinced that we should not wait until the collective bargaining landscape is properly fragmented to then say: Well, we have conducted the experiment, and now we must see how we can manage the damage. The Federal Minister of Economics and the Federal Minister of Labor are on it.

You, Mr. Hundt, spoke of an overwhelming majority of constitutional lawyers who said that there are no constitutional concerns regarding your proposal. However, there are also people who have studied law and have concerns. I cannot simply brush these concerns aside. But in the end, a political decision will be required; that is completely clear. Therefore, I tell you that we will provide you – I would say, within the next two months; because I do not want to announce anything here that I cannot fulfill – with an answer regarding what we believe we can do.

However, we have also received an expert council report. Reinhard Göhner just told me that they only consulted one labor lawyer; but that does not matter, it is still the expert council of the federal government. It has told us that we should not regulate anything and first take a look. There are people who say: We have already learned to live with sectoral unions – whether it is the Marburger Bund, Cockpit, or the train drivers' union. The existence of all of them has certainly not made collective bargaining life easier. Personally, I believe that we should do something because otherwise, in my firm opinion, it will become cherry-picking, and those who have the lowest qualifications and wages will be the victims of this development. Therefore, this is not only a question of operational collective bargaining unity, which is very, very important, but it is also a question of social justice. Because the one who can establish a monopoly or power position in the company will receive the large wage increases, while all those who can be easily replaced will suffer because the total amount of the pie available for distribution will, of course, not increase.

Nevertheless, I tell you – you know this too: We are entering absolutely uncharted territory here. When one says that for 60 years no one has raised constitutional concerns regarding the issue of collective bargaining unity in the workplace, that is true – where there is no plaintiff, there is no judge – but we have also had a development of certain sectoral unions that has accelerated and led to this case law. There has not been a comparable case in 60 years. So we cannot just ignore that. A problem has arisen that we did not have before.

The point I would like to mention here, alongside temporary work and the question of tariff unity, is the standard rates for unemployment benefit II, which of course have a lot to do with the attractiveness of accepting work, that is, the question of whether work is worthwhile. Here we have proceeded as the Federal Constitutional Court has instructed us. However, we have also said: Hartz IV, unemployment benefit II – this is not a state of life, but a bridge over a difficult time, during which everything must be done to create incentives to return to work. That is why, for example, we have waived the accounting of cigarettes and alcohol, to say: Those who want a slightly higher standard of living should have an incentive to take up employment again. I believe this is also in your interest.

We have also made it clear that we want to take another look at the regulations for additional earnings. You may not be entirely satisfied with the circumstances and might have envisioned more. But when you delve into the details, you see that very quickly a lot of taxpayer money would be needed to really achieve that. We must, of course, be careful not to set completely wrong incentives here. Thus, we have opted for a rather minimal solution.

We have rightly placed a stronger emphasis on the issue of education for children. In doing so, we have deviated from the cash principle and said: Here, benefits in kind should be provided, so that educational offerings actually reach the children. Especially in light of the demographic development in our country, it is very, very important that we emerge from the situation where dependence on state transfer payments is practically passed down from one generation to the next. Therefore, the opportunity for participation must be strengthened from an early age. That is why it is right that the Minister of Labor has proposed providing an educational benefit in kind to those affected. Of course, this will need to be implemented over time. However, I believe that the basic direction is correct.

Now, for the attractiveness of the labor market, it is certainly not only the question of work incentives, flexibility in terms of temporary work, and tariff unity that is important, but particularly in light of our demographic situation, the question of wage-related additional costs is also crucial. Here we are approaching a point where we have differing opinions year after year. I will come to the topic of health shortly, but first I would like to address the situation of social security contributions. In 2004, we had parity wage-related additional costs at a level of 42 percent. In 2006, we had wage-related additional costs of around 41 percent. For years, we promised that we would reduce the parity wage-related additional costs to below 40 percent. When we finally achieved that, we were all very happy. In the first half of 2009, we had 39.25 percent, and on January 1, 2011, we will have 39.45 percent. That is the truth.

I believe that after such an economic crisis as we have just experienced, after such a situation in which we have done a lot for unemployment insurance, especially for short-time work, which we are now shouldering through taxpayer money and in the future again through loans from the Federal Employment Agency, it is a great achievement to remain at parity wage-related additional costs below 40 percent. The situation that we are raising health contributions back to the level before the economic stimulus programs is also related to our exit strategy. We now have the situation in all areas that we are scaling back the economic stimulus programs. At the beginning of the crisis, we consciously said: We are going from a 15.5 percent health contribution to 14.9 percent. And now we are going back to 15.5 percent. – The Minister of Economics is just stepping in and will confirm this for me.

I mean this very seriously, because we are getting public criticism for it. And when we are criticized from two sides, that is always very bad. Winning battles on two fronts is not easy. We are not discouraged, but it is not easy. We have now established that we want to achieve a decoupling of labor costs from health costs for the foreseeable future. This is a huge step given the dynamic system of social insurance. However, this is generally described by employees, trade unions, and a certain side of the German Bundestag as a disintegration of solidarity. That those for whom we are doing this out of great conviction – because we say that the cost dynamics of the health system must not be transferred one-to-one to the parity wage-related additional costs – are among the harshest critics of this health reform, I cannot understand. I still think that they are not all specialists in the field of health insurance, as that could explain a lot. Not everyone has to be.

In any case, we have decided: health contribution rate of 15.5 percent and decoupling of the employer's contribution from the additional costs, capping at two percent of income, and subsequent solidarity-based refinancing through tax revenue and no longer just through the contributions of socially insured employees. We have decided this in a way that is also financially viable, and not set up some unrealistic calculations as are now being made in the form of citizens' insurance by the Greens, SPD, and others. These are the two alternatives for the health system in Germany.

I can only sincerely ask employers again and again, when they have to make a decision – they will not get anything else. Take what we have done; it is truly employer- and employee-friendly and financially viable in the long run. Moreover, it is ultimately the answer that a welfare state must provide, namely that there is no two-tier medicine. Because if we maintain the complete coupling to labor costs, then that is not only bad for you and for the number of jobs, but it also puts pressure on the financial volume available for health systems. And that automatically leads you into a two-tier medicine. Just as the health discussion is difficult in every industrial country, it is of course difficult for us as well. However, I am deeply convinced that we have made a good further development of the previously not very popular health fund.

I believe we are all in agreement in this circle that the pension at 67 is a necessary response to demographic change and that it makes no sense to suspend it now or to beat around the bush about it. In 1950, we had an average of six employees working for one retiree who received ten years of pension. Today, we have a situation where three employees work for one retiree who receives an average of 18 years of pension. As this development will continue to intensify, there can only be one answer: there must be a longer working life. This also means, of course, that the employment opportunities for older employees must be improved. That is why I am grateful to all those who are strengthening the already existing trend and saying at this point: We are giving older people more opportunities and have taken operational measures that enable a longer working life. I also tell you: It is not only the speed of youth that counts in our society, but also the experience of the elderly. Therefore, we must make further progress in this area. Otherwise, the pension at 67 will not find acceptance.

Another major area – I thank you for your support, Mr. Hundt – is, of course, the question of solid state finances. It was important and right that we introduced the debt brake into the Basic Law. With this, we have essentially committed ourselves. Under the premise of this debt brake, we are currently conducting discussions about the 2011 budget. This budget sets priorities in the areas of education and research. But this budget also adheres to the requirements of the debt brake. This means that the state must make significant contributions, which means that we have certain cuts in the social sector, and it also means – one must not beat around the bush about this – that we have certain burdens on the economy. We will continue on this path. I, for my part, see no reasonable alternative to this path.

Now, the German consolidation policy has not only an internal component – it is a response in terms of generational justice – but it has also shown that it has a European and global dimension. We are in an extraordinarily serious situation regarding the Euro. I do not want to paint dramatic pictures here; I just want to say: None of us could have imagined a year ago what discussions we would have to lead here in the spring and what measures we would have to take. I am referring both to the Greece aid package and to the Euro shield.

I am already surprised – one of my predecessors is supposed to have brought this up again today – that some criticize Germany again and again for not having unconditionally pledged support at the first call for help from Greece, but for having said: We stand in solidarity for the Euro, but only on the condition that the causes of the weaknesses in Greece are actually eliminated. If it is based on the premise that the best European is the one who helps first, then I can only say: That is not good for Europe. What we have learned and agreed upon in the phase between February and today is the result of hard bargaining in Europe. In this process, Germany was not on the side of the refusers, but on the side of those who said: If the Euro is to be a permanently strong currency, then the Stability and Growth Pact must be comprehensively adhered to by all Euro members, and then the necessary measures must be taken. We will not be deterred from this.

It was right to involve the IMF. It was right to have the Commission, the IMF, and the ECB monitor the measures in Greece. These are not only budget consolidation measures, but also structural measures that must be taken there. This has led to other Euro countries also introducing structural measures and budget consolidation measures. And that is why we have also made many steps forward.

Now we have difficulties in Ireland. These are to be classified differently than those in Greece, but they are nevertheless very concerning. Here, it is basically the banks that are causing the state deficits. Ireland has a deficit of around 30 percent this year. That is, of course, a dramatic figure. These are – I want to point this out again – basically still effects from the time before the economic crisis and not new effects. This shows that the financial and economic crisis as such is not yet over.

Now we will have to negotiate conditions with Ireland so that the causes can be eliminated again. But it is right and good that we have a shield that clearly demonstrates solidarity and commitment to a common currency. Because the other side of the coin is, of course, that Germany, as a large exporting country, has benefited in many ways from the existence of the Euro. I do not want to imagine the financial and economic crisis with all the exchange rate fluctuations that would have occurred if we had not had a single currency. Then Germany would also have had to take responsibility because, as an exporting country, we have no interest in completely unstable conditions in our neighboring countries.

So it remains our task to continually advocate for tough measures and hard requirements, but on the other hand, also to express a clear commitment to the Euro. This is sometimes not easy in the discussion, but it is fundamentally important. I also say: It was right that we have now introduced tougher sanction mechanisms for the implementation of the Stability and Growth Pact – both regarding the deficit and total debt, as well as regarding macroeconomic harmonization. The actual questions of the markets often do not only concern the budget holes, the deficits, but the question of what strength a country has to overcome deficits and return to solid finances. This concerns the issue of competitiveness, which cannot be viewed based on any single indicator, but depends on a whole range of factors, as we all know. These must gradually align more and more within the Eurozone, but not at the level of the weakest, but as much as possible according to the best, because otherwise Europe will hopelessly lose competitiveness in international competition.

Therefore, at the G20 summit in South Korea, Mr. Brüderle with the finance ministers and I with the heads of state and government made it clear once again: Using only one indicator to measure a country's competitiveness or the creation of imbalances, and then telling Germany, "If you have an export surplus of more than four percent, then you are on the world's sinner list," while implicitly disregarding the factors of competitiveness – we could not allow that to happen. I am very glad that this discussion is now over.

We will ensure that the current rescue funds for the Euro, which we support and will not change, will be replaced by a permanent crisis mechanism by 2013, in which private creditors – that is, those who earn quite a bit from certain government bonds – will also be held accountable. I will not back down from this because the primacy of politics and the setting of frameworks against the economy would otherwise be completely unenforceable, and because the people in our country would not understand if banks or those who work with banks earn a lot of money, but then the taxpayer has to bear the risks. That rightly finds no acceptance. Therefore, we must also demand a degree of responsibility from the actors in the financial markets.

There is no business in the world – you mostly represent the real economy, as it is nicely put – where one can shift one's risks 100 percent onto the taxpayer and the state. Why should there be a case of such a paradise when dealing with government bonds of Euro member states? That makes no sense to me whatsoever.

Lastly, a few words on the topic of skilled workers. Demographic change means, of course, that the question of whether we have the right qualifications in our country will gain importance.

I say as

First

: The key will be integration. The proportion of migrants among school leavers will increase year by year. If the question regarding integration cannot be answered in such a way that migrants, on average, have the same school results, the same educational opportunities, and thus the same training opportunities as those without a migration background, then we will have a massive problem in Germany. Among children with a migration background, there are still about twice as many dropouts and twice as many who do not have vocational training. Thirty percent of the long-term unemployed are people with a migration background. But only ten percent of educational and support measures are taken up by people with a migration background. Therefore, systematic efforts must be made to improve this, to enhance language skills, and much more.

With the higher education pact, we have made it clear that we want to improve the quality of education. We have increased the BAföG. We are responding to the school years that are now taking the G8 Abitur by offering more study opportunities. We are grateful that the economy plays a significant role in the training pact. Above all, we must ensure that as few young people as possible coming out of school immediately move into transfer benefits. I say: That must not happen in the future. Given this labor market situation, every young person must somehow have a clear path to a reasonable education.

There are certainly still opportunities regarding the employment of women. There are also still untapped potentials among older individuals. We must recognize the professional qualifications of those who have come to us from other countries more quickly. In this regard, we are currently developing a legislative process. We certainly also need to talk about the immigration of skilled workers, although the solutions and possibilities we have today have already been significantly improved in the last legislative period. There is still a need for discussion within the coalition on this matter. Whether we will ever be 100 percent in agreement on this, I do not know. But in any case, the Federal Minister of Labor will now increasingly establish a register of skilled workers who are truly in demand. One thing you must also understand: We must not experience again that immigration leads to social security systems. The labor shortage in the early 1960s led to a development in Germany for which we still have not found conclusive answers today. Therefore, such a development must not happen again. But I also say that there is now a situation and a discussion in Germany where one can ask: What immigration is in our interest? We will, of course, continue to discuss this question in the near future.

Germany is doing well, but Germany has no reason to rest on its laurels. You know this in the companies, your employees know this, and the Christian-Liberal coalition knows this. Therefore, we will continue to work step by step. This will not always be easy, especially regarding the balance between the welfare state, demographic change, and competitiveness. Therefore, dear Mr. Hundt, we will have much to talk and discuss about in the coming months.

I thank you for a cooperative, sometimes somewhat controversial, but fundamentally committed collaboration towards the same goals, and I wish you all the best.