Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the groundbreaking ceremony for Blocks D and E of the Westfalen Power Plant on August 29, 2008, in Hamm:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

29 August 2008 · Groundbreaking ceremony for Blocks D and E of the Westfalen Power Plant · Westfalen Power Plant, Hamm, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed guests at the groundbreaking ceremony for two new blocks of the Westfalen Power Plant in Hamm, Germany, on August 29, 2008.
Main themes
Coal-fired power plant construction, energy supply security, industrial competitiveness, modernization of energy infrastructure, climate policy and efficiency, German energy policy, job creation and regional economy, electricity export, innovation in power generation technology, North Rhine-Westphalia industrial location
Duration
~22 min
70th percentile
Words
2,615
70th percentile
Sentences
135
77th percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
11.4
37th percentile
Syntax
2.94
40th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
22nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 35%33%
  • Environmental 18%18%
  • Institutional 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 14%13%
  • Social 8%7%
  • Technological 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 5%4%
  • Not in focus 4%

135 sentences in 36 paragraphs

Dear Prime Minister, dear Jürgen Rüttgers,

dear Mayor Hunsteger-Petermann,

dear Mr. Großmann,

dear Minister of Economic Affairs, dear Christa Thoben,

dear Members of Parliament, on behalf of all the locally responsible Member of Parliament Laurenz Meyer, ladies and gentlemen,

I am pleased to be here today with you for the groundbreaking ceremony for two new blocks of the Westfalen power plant. I have consciously decided to be here: on the one hand, because I am convinced of the industrial location of North Rhine-Westphalia, and on the other hand, because I want to strongly support the modernization of coal-fired power plants in a discussion that is often very heated.

We know that such new investments come at a price – two billion euros are being invested here. But I am convinced that innovation and investment in the future will pay off in the coming years and decades – because energy policy is a very long-term policy. This project will, of course, create jobs during the construction phase, but it will also secure competitive jobs in the region in the long term. One could hardly wish for a better commitment to the traditional power plant location of Hamm and to this region.

Therefore, I want to make it clear once again: Two blocks with a capacity of 800 megawatts each will show every investor – I am not just talking about energy investors, but others as well – that a reliable energy supply is guaranteed here, and for a very, very long time. You are contributing today to a fundamental pillar of energy policy, namely supply security. Supply security is the prerequisite for Germany to remain an industrial location and for any economic engagement. I believe that these connections are sometimes not fully recognized today.

In the federal government, we have dealt extensively with the structures of German energy supply over the past two years – despite the differences regarding nuclear energy. We now have very clear scenarios regarding energy consumption and the need for renewal programs. We have incorporated the expertise of politics, business, science, and consumers into our programming.

The result is – despite the controversies – partly very clear: If we want to maintain our self-sufficiency in electricity as an industrial location, we need new, efficient power plants in Germany. This includes efficient, modern coal-fired power plants. Those who prevent the construction of new power plants – for various reasons – ultimately take on enormous risks for jobs, prices, and the future of Germany.

I want to make it clear: I do not want an industrial location like Germany to become dependent on foreign electricity supplies. Of course, we will develop a European network. But I also tell you: If we are the country with the best plant builders and the best experience regarding the most effective power plants, then there is no reason not to export a little electricity from time to time. Exporting electricity is not a sin – it is sometimes portrayed today as if one must apologize for every kilowatt-hour transported elsewhere. Energy generation is a strength of the industrial location Germany.

We must not walk a path that leads to a shortage of electricity, as that would mean rising electricity prices. Ultimately, this would also mean that old plants would have to remain online longer than would be justifiable in terms of sensible climate policy. Therefore, the rejection of new power plant constructions is not only economically counterproductive, but it is also environmentally and climate-wise counterproductive.

We should keep in mind that one of the most modern power plants is being built here. It has already been said by Mr. Großmann and Jürgen Rüttgers: The efficiency of the power plant is 46 percent. The efficiency of coal-fired power plants currently operating in China averages 22 percent.

Coal currently accounts for about 25 percent of global energy consumption. We can therefore expect that coal-fired power plants will continue to be built worldwide in the coming decades. This can also be an export success. Similar to our concerns regarding nuclear energy, the same applies to coal-fired power plants: If you no longer use your own great technology at home, you make only half the impression when exporting plants compared to when you are proud of your products in your own country.

Coal is available worldwide, easy to store, and relatively price-stable. This also makes the long-term investments manageable. Therefore, we should stand by this, but of course also do everything we can to promote innovations. By the way, we also know: If there are no new orders for new coal-fired power plants, then the innovative capacity of the plant builders will naturally stagnate, and we will not remain on the development path of modern technologies, as it has already been presented, but the development would stagnate.

In this respect, RWE has also taken an interesting new step with its plan to develop a power plant in Hürth, which is also to use CO2 capture technology (CCS). We will need to develop the framework conditions for CCS technology. The European Union is currently developing a directive – the outlines of which are known and are not as controversially debated as some other issues. Then the corresponding German legislation must follow. This will certainly be a challenging path. But here, too, I can congratulate RWE: If you are among the first with a practical project, then you have the best chances – without this being a commitment, Mr. Großmann; I want to make that explicitly clear for the record – to receive funding.

Overall, the capture of CO2 with storage somewhere underground may not yet have reached its final technical state. Someone who has once worked in the field of physical chemistry always thinks that something chemical can still be done with it. I know that a lot of research is being conducted internationally in this regard. Therefore, it is worth investing in the future here as well. So, thank you very much for that.

We know and must learn that in energy policy, not just one form of energy generation is correct, but that we need a diversified energy policy. We have always done well in Germany with an energy mix. This will also be the case in the 21st century. First and foremost is, of course, energy conservation. This will be advanced through various programs and also through more conscious consumption behavior of citizens. We need fossil energy sources, and we need the expansion of renewable energies.

Basically, we have overcome many controversies in energy policy by now. Therefore, I would like to join the plea that Jürgen Rüttgers has made here. We know the long discussions. Even in the Christian Democratic Union, in my party, it has not been the case that we have been open-hearted towards renewable energies from the very beginning. There were individual pioneers from the north who said: Wind energy has a chance. Today, wind turbines have developed into an export success – that must also be said.

However, I believe we need an initiative of reason – I say this now as a party politician and not on behalf of the federal government – and we must design the operating times of nuclear power plants in such a way that we achieve reasonable price formations and can also apply our new technologies. Here, too, it applies: We have at least co-developed the latest reactors. This is now situated in a German-French cooperation project. But we must ensure that we still retain shares. We also need future policy here.

As key points for steps of the federal government in terms of further development of energy policy, I would like to mention the Renewable Energy Sources Act – we have debated this extensively; Laurenz Meyer knows what I am talking about – and the new regulations on combined heat and power generation.

Mr. Großmann, I want to say here explicitly: I am aware of the concerns of the energy-intensive industry regarding the future of the certificate trading system. I have also had very tough discussions about this in the European Union – especially with the Commission – and said that it is unacceptable if we pass a climate package in the autumn without clarity on how the certificate trading system will proceed for the energy-intensive industry. I will not agree to that. We know that special attention must be paid to this.

We have now – it must be said openly – among the 27 member states of the European Union, no longer have a large number of countries that have energy-intensive industries at home. Therefore, it is incredibly important that we continuously raise awareness of this issue through European industry associations. Because many decisions in the European Union are no longer made unanimously, but by majority decision. We have also advocated that the slowest should not always set the pace. However, regarding certificates, we see today – both in the automotive industry and in the chemical and steel industries – that we need allies. We find these primarily through the work of European associations.

We must mention that you are of course already taking the free allocation of certificates into account in your finances. You are also called upon to have clarity and truth. I just want to say: The step is not so bad when 20 euros booked become real 20 euros. But we will still talk about that – since we are also talking about elephants today, I just want to say: We are not greenhorns in politics either.

Nevertheless, it is a difficult matter, especially for the areas that are not yet subject to certification today. What must not happen under any circumstances is that there is double certification, meaning that first the energy producers and then the energy-intensive industry are burdened with everything. There is much to consider here.

I want to make it clear through my somewhat lengthy remarks that I am very, very aware of the topic and that it will also be one of the most difficult discussions in the autumn when we discuss the climate package under the French presidency. Because the industrial location France is, of course, hardly affected by these questions due to its very high supply of nuclear energy – that must also be seen. Among the industrialized countries that could still be our allies, there are also those that have a completely different problem situation.

Another point I want to address is: The most beautiful energy generation is of no use if the lines are not right. Therefore, we must ensure that we fully integrate renewable energies into the grid. If we take a look at what is happening today, we find that ultimately a huge energy shift is taking place. Renewable energies, especially wind energy, are primarily generated in the north today. Bavaria currently has over 60 percent of its supply from nuclear energy. If the plans are implemented as they are, then this is not just a question for Germany, but you will ultimately have to bring all the replacement energy from the north to the south within twelve years. This is an almost impossible undertaking, and it would only culminate in having to buy nuclear energy in Temelín and elsewhere in our neighboring countries. I really cannot see any advantage for us as Germans in that.

This means: Power lines must be built. We have also improved the legal regulations for this, in the form of the "Law to Accelerate the Expansion of High-Voltage Networks." There will still be a number of questions regarding this, especially concerning the underground cables that play a role in this context. Who pays for the fact that others do not want a cable above their heads? Will this be distributed nationwide? And how will all this be done? Perhaps it can all be laid together with pipelines – once dug up and many things put in. But that was more of a joking remark; I really do not know much about spatial planning issues.

The energy supply is therefore one of the central issues for the industrial location of Germany. In this regard, we have actually made good progress in recent years. Companies have restructured, and employees have achieved a lot in modernization together with company management. It would be a shame if we were to jeopardize this in the coming years. For the unemployment figures from yesterday prove that we can move forward if we plan for the long term, if we do not close ourselves off to further reforms, and if we proceed with prudence and reason.

That is why, especially now, in light of the economic downturn, it is less about launching short-term economic programs. Rather, it is about increasing trust in the location of Germany through long-term sound decisions. In this context, Jürgen Rüttgers has mentioned important points with his anti-recession program that can create such long-term trust.

We know that the question of how we proceed with major projects is ultimately also a question of cooperation – the cooperation between politics and business and also the cooperation on the ground. Therefore, I want to mention that this project is also a wonderful project of collaboration between RWE Power and a total of 23 municipal utilities. The municipal component at RWE is significant. It is highly commendable that one can also commit to new investments.

I suspect that the city of Hamm has played a not insignificant role in this whole matter. I think it is great that you have made your landmark, the elephant, available for energy generation. The wonderful energy elephants that you see here stand for that. That you have engaged the youth in this is also a symbolic gesture.

Last Friday, I was on an educational trip with Jürgen Rüttgers. We looked at what has been done for the young people in this country in recent years – investments in the future. Here, the circle actually closes: If we have a population whose distance from technology, innovation, and creativity has become so great that from their perspective electricity only comes from the socket and no one thinks about how everything is interconnected, then we will also have difficulties in establishing long-term acceptance for new technologies in our country.

That is why the topic of education – especially scientific and technical education – is so important. For what has made Germany strong are the spirit of invention, the skills of tinkers, and the abilities of skilled workers and engineers. This must be preserved and further developed. In this sense, the elephant is certainly a very suitable symbol: it stands for openness, curiosity, and sensitivity.

We still need to inform ourselves a bit about enthusiasm for technology, and it must also grow into the 21st century. The education and enlightenment of the population as a whole, the enthusiasm for technology – that is our common task. The foundation for this is being laid for young people in North Rhine-Westphalia. We are trying to help with the higher education pact and with training initiatives from the federal side. The more the economy collaborates with the municipalities and the more each individual is proud that something new is being created here, the more people will be interested in these projects.

Therefore, I would like to conclude by saying: I suspect that with this groundbreaking ceremony, you have not only made me happy and that I am not the only one who has come here with pleasure, but that this is also a good, appropriate, and forward-looking contribution to the 62nd birthday of the state of North Rhine-Westphalia. Perhaps this contribution will even be mentioned today on North Rhine-Westphalia Day in Wuppertal.