Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the "Leadership Meeting on Economy" of the Süddeutsche Zeitung on November 21, 2013, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

21 November 2013 · Leadership Meeting on Economy of the Süddeutsche Zeitung · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Süddeutsche Zeitung Leadership Meeting on Economy in Berlin on November 21, 2013, discussing Europe's economic union and Germany's fiscal policy.
Main themes
European economic and monetary union, Maastricht Treaty anniversary, euro currency benefits, Stability and Growth Pact compliance, sovereign debt crisis, German export trade, fiscal consolidation, European integration, Germany-Italy economic ties, internal market, coalition agreement formation
Duration
~43 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,118
92nd percentile
Sentences
287
95th percentile
Readability
52
67th percentile
Grade
10.5
26th percentile
Syntax
2.89
33rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 59%59%
  • Institutional 20%20%
  • Social 12%12%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

287 sentences in 52 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

I am pleased to be here again today. To tell you what the final coalition agreement looks like, your meeting is taking place a week too early. Therefore, I must remain somewhat vague in certain areas. Nevertheless, I am very happy to have come here today. I appreciate that you are organizing your economic conference in a very international manner and that you attach great importance to the topic of Europe. I am also pleased that Italy will be one of the focal points. There are very close ties between the German and Italian economies, which continually encourage us to deepen our political cooperation further.

Twenty years ago, on November 1, 1993, the Maastricht Treaty came into force. It changed Europe. It laid the foundations for us to have an economic and monetary union in Europe. While we had the opportunity to get used to the euro, in recent years we have also had to navigate the euro through difficult waters. It can be rightly said: We have a monetary union, but whether we already have an economic union to a sufficient degree – I will return to that – remains to be seen. In any case, we have free movement of people, goods, services, and capital. The internal market is the cornerstone of the European Union.

With the introduction of a common currency, transaction and currency hedging costs have been eliminated. The removal of exchange rate risk has brought more planning and calculation security. I believe we all agree in this room that the financial crisis of 2008 and 2009 would have been far more dangerous for us in Germany if we had not had a common currency. We did not experience massive exchange rate fluctuations, as would have been the case otherwise. This means I am convinced that without the euro, we would not have emerged from the valley of crisis as smoothly and quickly as we have with the euro. The internal market and the euro are therefore invaluable for the German economy and thus for jobs and prosperity in our country. That is why I also refer to the Maastricht Treaty. Because it ultimately brought us growth opportunities that Germany has repeatedly utilized.

In recent years, nearly 40 percent of our total goods exports have flowed to the euro countries. Almost 40 percent of our goods imports also came from the euro countries. Our trade surplus in the euro area has, by the way, decreased significantly in recent years. Looking at the entire European Union, our export and import shares amount to approximately 56 to 57 percent each. So you can see: Even when we talk about emerging markets, intra-European trade is still the core of German exports. What follows from this? It follows that Germany can only thrive in the long term if Europe thrives. This means we have a national interest in getting back on our feet across Europe and seeing more growth.

We know that the European crisis, the sovereign debt crisis, did not arise overnight, but has built up over years. One of the reasons we have faced significant difficulties today and in recent years is that Europe has repeatedly failed to adhere to its agreements. The Stability and Growth Pact is actually very clear. It specifies, among other things, how high the inflation rate, new borrowing, and total debt can be. But many countries have not adhered to it. Germany now has a debt level of about 80 percent of GDP. 60 percent is allowed. Therefore, for the federal government, reducing total debt is a central project in the next four years. The prerequisite for this, of course, is that we first have no new borrowing.

This means: When we are sometimes accused of consolidating too much, we are actually doing nothing more than working towards complying with what we are obligated to do under the treaty in about ten years. Sometimes one wonders what discussions are being held. I also advise that all the tightening measures we have now initiated and established in connection with fiscal pacts and similar agreements should not be treated in such a way after two years that one is merely looking for creative interpretations. It is sometimes the case in Europe – if I may say so freely – that the one who reminds others of the rules appears to be a penny-pincher or a petty trader or someone who lacks emotional enthusiasm for Europe. Europe's problem, also in relation to the citizens, is that we have kept very little of what we promised. That must change.

I know that Germany has also set bad examples. About ten years ago, we also contributed to weakening the Stability and Growth Pact. But we have learned the lessons from that. Now it is about adhering to it. We have – I recently spoke with the President of the Commission and the President of the Council about this – about 95 target indicators in Europe – parameters that probably none of the acting politicians can fully enumerate. My favorite indicator is the one established in 2000, when it was aimed to become the most competitive continent in the world, that each country should spend three percent of its GDP on research and development. Germany is now close to that. One of my goals is to maintain this three percent target in the next legislative period, despite economic growth, thus also increasing research investments.

There are very few member states of the European Union that spend this three percent. However, this is not a major topic of discussion for us; rather, we look at it once a year, nod, and then continue as we have always thought was good. We have countries like Finland and Sweden that spend more than three percent, and countries that have expenditures of 0.9 percent. At some point, we wonder why a proper unified economic area does not emerge from this.

Therefore, my intention and that of the entire German federal government – I hope also of the future federal government – has always been aimed at bringing more reliability back into European action. Of course, it is important to show solidarity, but solidarity and national responsibility must always be seen as two sides of the same coin.

We have successes to show: The budget deficits in the euro area have decreased significantly. Labor costs in the countries affected by the crisis have also fallen. This has improved competitiveness. Current account deficits have decreased. We have recently seen: Ireland will exit the euro rescue program. Spain has restructured its banks so that the Spanish program can come to an end. Portugal is on a tough but very good path. You will also have the Greek Prime Minister as a guest here. Greece – often viewed very skeptically from the German perspective – has achieved an incredible amount. I am not saying that the work is done. But many things have changed in many areas. Greece now has a primary surplus, which was not expected of the country, and thus fulfills one of the prerequisites to one day stand on its own feet again.

Although we still have a lot of work ahead of us, investor confidence has gradually returned. I hope that this will continue. You will certainly discuss this with more knowledgeable individuals at this event. I believe the return of this confidence is also related to the fact that we have made a number of institutional advancements in the European Union and particularly in the euro area. This includes the fiscal pact. It also includes the establishment of a banking union – a very ambitious process.

If I may remind you: When we concluded the Lisbon Treaty, the general opinion was that we would never want to change the treaties again. Behind this was the thought that we had already reached the maximum in the institutional structure. However, it has now become clear that we need to work much more closely together in the eurozone. We are currently doing this very often on an intergovernmental basis, as with the fiscal pact. Also on the way to a banking union, certain steps cannot be taken without a treaty change. Wolfgang Schäuble will certainly elaborate on this here. But I want to make it clear: Germany is ready for the further development of the treaties. At the very least, we must be prepared to improve the euro protocol that exists in the Lisbon Treaty, which therefore only applies to the euro states, in order to enable institutional cooperation within the framework of the so-called community method and not always act only intergovernmentally.

That we are advancing both supervision and restructuring measures regarding a banking union and, in a third step, also possibilities for direct recapitalization – at least for the systemically relevant banks in Europe – is a huge step. I also want to make it very clear: It is a step that has not been easy for Germany. However, I have learned during the discussions that investor confidence in Europe will only truly return if a transparent supervision of at least the systemically relevant banks is established in all member states of the euro area. However, I say: We politicians have the duty to now give the European Central Bank the opportunity to install a truly independent supervision. Because we have already learned from the first stress tests conducted by the European Banking Authority, the EBA, how attempts are made from all sides to exert political influence. The politicians now have the power to create a truly credible supervision. I want to contribute to ensuring that the European Central Bank maintains its high reputation in the financial markets in this area and can thus help us all.

My words have already shown that many questions revolve around the competitiveness of Europe. I therefore believe that institutional advancement cannot end with the so-called banking union. Rather, we must think back to the beginning of the economic and monetary union. Jacques Delors pointed out back then, before the introduction of the euro, in a report that closer economic policy coordination within a common currency area is necessary. This is what we are talking about now; it is a very deep concern for me.

Today, we have a mechanism for macroeconomic monitoring of the member states by the Commission. The Commission gives us country-specific recommendations. However, we have zero bindingness on whether these recommendations are adhered to or not. Germany – I say this quite frankly – has not always adhered to all recommendations. However, we do not always consider some of the recommendations to be appropriate. For example, one of the recommendations that we receive directly or indirectly every year is that we should abolish the splitting of spouses in our tax system. We will not do that – I say this quite frankly. We will not enshrine that in the new coalition agreement either. We also do not see why this particular feature of the German tax system should be such a heavy burden for Europe, as we meet the indicators for female employment; we meet the indicators for overall employment.

What follows from this? It follows that we need a cooperation between the Commission and the member states in which we negotiate the country-specific recommendations together, that we make decisions on this in our national parliaments, and that this also creates a so-called "ownership," as it is said today, meaning a responsibility of the member state to truly implement the necessary changes. This is what I personally understand by economic policy coordination. When we talk about labor costs or other issues, it often concerns matters of national responsibility. Therefore, closer economic policy coordination can only occur if one works together with the nation-states. Because we do not want a pooling of pension insurance or a pooling of health insurance in Europe for the foreseeable future. Therefore, a mechanism of cooperation with the member states must be found.

This is all a matter of drilling thick planks – if I may say so cautiously – because many say: Actually, we have already experienced enough changes in Europe. I believe we should not stand still, but we should make our house of the euro weatherproof now, so that we can better withstand new shocks that may one day come from outside than the last global economic shock, which the euro area has not yet sufficiently coped with.

Now I come to Germany. Germany has been able to recover quite quickly from the international financial crisis, in which we experienced a remarkable economic downturn. We have achieved this also through export successes. The subject of in-depth investigation in Brussels is now our export surplus. This is surrounded by many discussions.

Here, we can start with two questions.

On the one hand, we can ask: What is the situation with supply?

And on the other hand, we can ask: What is the situation with demand?

When we look at the supply side, I note: It would be absurd if we were to start from the premise that German companies should reduce their production or make cuts in product quality. That cannot be the purpose of a successful Europe. It is also a myth that those working in export-oriented industries are poorly paid. Our skilled workforce is well paid; the issue of low pay does not arise in this area at all. This is evident these days when discussions about minimum wages take place, as certain union sectors have no problem with it at all. Therefore, it cannot and must not be the case that one tries in one way or another to artificially diminish Germany's competitiveness.

We must be careful that we do not only look at ourselves in Europe as a point of reference, but that we also look beyond our own borders. The question of a strong Europe is determined by competitiveness against the most effective and efficient worldwide. And these are often not found in Europe, but somewhere else in the world. If we do not take this perspective and continue to orient ourselves inward, we will not recognize the signs of the times correctly. I have already said: In terms of the situation in the Eurozone, we do not have a very high trade surplus. Rather, our trade surplus results from exports to emerging markets. Therefore, it is also questionable whether we can exert much influence on this at the moment.

We can also look at the demand side. One can ask: Is there enough consumption in Germany? The recommendations at the moment are contrary to what we are discussing in the coalition negotiations. This means that tax cuts are recommended rather than tax increases to strengthen domestic demand. We reject – I am speaking now as the chair of the CDU – tax increases. We have experienced in the last four years that no tax increases or even slight tax reductions in the corporate and inheritance tax areas have led to increased tax revenues. Tax rates and tax revenues are by no means proportional. One can raise tax rates in such a way that one ends up with lower tax revenues. The only thing that counts for the finance minister is the revenue and not the rates. Therefore, we believe that those who have contributed to creating such a good employment situation in Germany, namely the self-employed, the medium-sized businesses, which are often partnerships, must not be burdened more heavily. Otherwise, we could find ourselves back in a situation where the number of employed persons and those subject to social insurance decreases.

So we have had rising tax revenues. The meager growth we currently have is largely driven by domestic demand. Therefore, the task in connection with the discussion about a minimum wage is also to do everything possible to prevent job losses.

I want to say a word about this. Mr. Kister has already spoken about the complications that arise when an election campaign is over and those who have campaigned against each other must then govern together. But it is part of democracy that the voter casts their vote and that politicians have the duty to make something reasonable out of that vote. What distinguishes Germany is that we, as parties, are highly capable of dialogue with each other. When I look around Europe, this is comparatively a very, very positive fact.

Nevertheless, we do not make it easy for ourselves. You can observe or marvel at this every day in the coalition negotiations – "marvel" is even more preferable to me than "observe." However, I ask you to always keep in mind that the Grand Coalition, as it is likely to be formed now, is not the heartfelt wish of the politicians, but the result of the voting behavior of your newspaper readers. What one learns first in politics is that one must take the vote of voters seriously. The voters did not give an absolute majority to either the economic wing of the CDU or the left wing of the SPD. Only in the sum of both parties do we achieve governability. The Greens, to whom we made overtures, have graciously declined. In this respect, everything is very clear.

If one finds that something not so good comes out of this, then I tell you: From the perspective of the economy, something even worse could come out of other constellations. Yes, it is simply the case. Therefore, I too will have to agree to things that I did not originally consider to be right. This includes, for example, the question of a nationwide statutory minimum wage. I and the Union will do everything to avoid job losses. But a realistic assessment of the situation quickly explains that the Social Democrats will not leave the negotiations without obtaining a nationwide statutory minimum wage. Therefore, there is no need to beat around the bush. I believe that the formation of a government should take place in a responsible manner for Germany. This is not happening too quickly; and it will take a while longer. This is now my sober analysis.

Nevertheless, regarding "strategies for more growth," we have tasks to fulfill in these coalition negotiations. One of the conditions of the Union is: No tax increases – and no new debt from 2015, in order to achieve a reduction of total debt. This serves not just for the pleasure of the finance minister. Given the ongoing change in the age structure of our population, the fact that we must come to a point where we do not incur new debts is also something that is very closely linked to intergenerational justice. Moreover, the trust of financial investors, given the high debt burden in Germany and the interest payments, is of course absolutely important to have any room for investment in the future.

The

second

major point, alongside budget and tax issues, will be the amendment of the Renewable Energy Sources Act. The industrial location of Germany is already under pressure because we have a very high share of renewable energies, which makes energy prices in Germany relatively high in international comparison. This pressure has been exacerbated by the fact that energy prices in the United States are significantly lower. Regardless of the expansion of renewable energies, the gas price in America is currently only about half as high as in Europe; and this, of course, has a strong impact on investments. This applies not only to Germany but to all of Europe, so we are well advised to develop a coherent European energy policy. Energy suppliers are currently facing difficulties not only in Germany but also in other European countries.

What can we do? We can slow down or halt the increase of the renewable energy surcharge. We have seen that some of the renewable energies, such as photovoltaics, are becoming marketable much faster than we thought. But this requires a significant effort, which I hope the Grand Coalition will be able to undertake. There are now a high number of beneficiaries of renewable energy subsidies in Germany. As it is in democracy: If more than half benefit – and certainly more benefit than one thinks – then it is not easy to find a majority for the abolition of such subsidies. Therefore, any kind of change is very difficult to implement. But it must happen.

We must also make progress with the expansion of the grid. We now have a double problem: Every subsidy in the area of renewable energies – currently, about 25 percent of our electricity generation comes from renewable energies – leads to the need for more base load to be maintained, which in turn means that – I mention the lovely term "capacity mechanisms" – additional funds must be made available to ensure that sufficient capacities are available, so we have price pressure from two sides. It must be attempted to contain it.

In addition, the expansion of the grid in Germany is still challenging. What does that mean? It means that for wind, one must focus on attractive locations and cannot continue to expand wind power plants as extensively as before. For offshore wind energy, capacities must certainly be limited, so expansion corridors must be defined, because offshore wind energy is still very expensive and because the wind blows longer at sea than on land. If the subsidy is also twice as expensive, then you can imagine what that means for price development. Even today, it is said: A whole industry depends on this. That is correct. About 10,000 jobs are at stake. Nevertheless, the expansion corridor must be clearly defined.

This means that we will emerge from the coalition negotiations with clear goals for expansion corridors for the coming years. We will gradually move to a tendering model with quantity tenders – first certainly in the offshore area and then also in other areas. We will concentrate funding on favorable locations, especially in the wind sector. For solar energy, the upper limits for funding have already been set. In addition, we must develop capacity markets that are cost-effective and not created solely from the perspective of which owner of power plants would prefer to place their power plants in strategic reserves or in the capacity market. This will also be a significant effort.

Our discussions also revolve around the entire area of the labor market. It will be important to find a balance between the flexibility in the labor market, which has brought us many additional jobs, and a certain security for employees on the other side. The discussions between the Union and the Social Democrats are among the most difficult; there is no need to beat around the bush about that. Nevertheless, we will try to agree on something that does not destroy our good employment situation but enables further progress.

We will also have changes in the social security systems, which are being watched closely by many. For us in the Union, it is important to continue to decouple employer and employee contributions in health insurance. This means that we will keep the employer's share constant. This will be significant in the next legislative period.

In the area of pensions, we in the Union have made considerations that are not only met with approval in the economy. Under the keyword "mother's pension," we want to close a justice gap for women who had their children before 1992. Closing this justice gap is not just a backward-looking question because these women raised children who will still pay pension contributions in the coming years and decades. Therefore, we consider this justified.

We have, of course, also had discussions with the Social Democrats about other pension issues. What happens, for example, to people who have worked and paid contributions for 45 years? In this context, there is a strong push for people to be able to retire without deductions at the age of 63. I say very explicitly: This is humanly understandable when one sees individual fates. But I also say: I will ensure that the pension at 67, as a truly important decision of the first Grand Coalition in this century, is not undermined, but that we make a clear commitment to the pension at 67, which must be introduced gradually. Anything else would be unacceptable to the younger generation. Fortunately, we have already seen an increase in employment among those over 60. Therefore, we must be very careful not to send any false signals now.

A topic that is gaining increasing importance, especially when it comes to securing the skilled workforce in Germany, is the issue of reconciling work and family life. We have made significant progress in expanding childcare facilities for children under three years old. There is now a legal entitlement for them as well. A lot has happened in recent years; and much more will need to happen in the future. I ask you from the business community to continue to support this positively, as it is of utmost importance for the employment of today's parents.

There is a development that nearly every young person today receives an apprenticeship position if they want one. However, there is now also a trend in Germany towards an increasing number of students at universities. When I became Chancellor, about 37 percent of a year group began studying at a university. Currently, it is over 50 percent. We must be careful that dual vocational training does not weaken, as dual vocational training has also strengthened Germany as an equal pillar of the education system. At the moment, we are providing a lot of support to ensure that dual vocational training also takes place across Europe. We must be cautious that one day we do not wake up in Germany with student rates that correspond to those of other European countries while neglecting dual vocational training.

Therefore, we will also relaunch the training pact. Above all, we need to create more permeability in the education system, which has not yet been at the center of the discussion. We have significantly strengthened the permeability for those who have vocational training towards universities. Following this path is now possible in various forms, even while working. However, we have numbers of new students that do not match the numbers of graduates, meaning the completion rates. We actually have no organized way to guide someone who realizes in the middle of their studies that it is not for them back into vocational training. We will now focus more on this path because there are young people who may have studied for one, two, three, or four semesters and therefore already have certain qualifications, but they must also have the opportunity to enter a shortened vocational training program and obtain a professional qualification—at least if they wish to do so.

With the implementation of the so-called "Blue Card" of the European Union, we have improved our immigration conditions. Germany is now a very open country for immigration when it comes to skilled workers. However, Germany's international reputation in this regard is still extremely poor. We need to work on this because we will need immigration in the skilled labor sector in the coming years. This is foreseeable in light of demographic change.

In this legislative period, we will invest more in transport infrastructure than in the previous legislative period. This is also urgently needed, as we are a classic transit country always at the center of European connections. We need to ensure that we live less off our existing resources—I say this very cautiously—than we currently do.

We will take another important investment step, namely to advance digitalization; that is, the expansion of broadband. It cannot only be about using state funds, but we also need to create framework conditions—also at the European level—that facilitate investment in the telecommunications market. If you look at Asia, Europe, and America, you know that in recent years the volume of data transmission has increased about tenfold, but the revenues of European communication companies have decreased by ten percent. In contrast, the revenues of American and Asian companies have grown by about 30 to 40 percent. This shows: The entire regulation in Europe is too focused on fragmentation and low end-user tariffs and far too little on investments. I believe that this must primarily be addressed at the European level; in some areas, we can also do something in Germany. We will not be able to be a modern economic continent if we do not better organize our telecommunications issues.

In some countries, such as Austria, there are five to seven providers. In China, there are three major providers. The entire European competition law is aimed at competition among the players, but with such an investment necessity as exists in the digital sector, we are struggling with it. Therefore, there is still much work ahead of us. In Germany, we have the opportunity, with the second auction of the frequencies of the digital dividend, to connect suitable framework conditions that may also allow for better expansion in rural areas. Such steps must be taken because we cannot achieve this solely with state funding.

We have set ourselves the goal of reviewing the very complicated funding conditions once again. We recently discussed this within the framework of the heads of state and government. If a mayor has to meet 19 criteria according to the competition rules in Europe to receive a grant, it regularly leads to the situation where you cannot find an employee in a small town in Germany who can oversee all of this. Bavaria has had the size to establish a central contact point so that it can access almost all German funding. But it cannot be in the spirit of the inventor that Europe has money that cannot be accessed because everything is so complicated.

The infrastructure issues regarding transport and digital expansion will therefore be focal points. The energy transition will be a focus of our work. I have spoken about the three percent target for research and development, which we want to maintain and thus stimulate investments in the future, in good, competitive products. That must be our credo.

I have now made the beginning for your conference. Mario Draghi is still not here. Because you just said so smugly that two of the three gentlemen from the financial sector have worked near me, I just want to note: Mario Draghi is one of those who supports me very much when it comes to economic policy coordination and the issue of competitiveness in Europe. There is a great consensus on these issues.

Thank you very much, and I wish you a good conference.