Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the meeting with representatives of the digital economy on August 25, 2016, in Tallinn:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

26 August 2016 · Meeting with representatives of the digital economy · Tallinn, Estonia

Context
Merkel addressed Estonian digital economy representatives and Prime Minister Rõivas in Tallinn on August 25, 2016, celebrating Estonian digitalization and bilateral cooperation.
Main themes
Digitalization and e-governance, Estonia as digital pioneer, Germany-Estonia cooperation, Industry 4.0 and Internet of Things, cybersecurity and NATO Cyber Defence, NATO solidarity and Baltic security, Baltic States' independence anniversary, Singing Revolution and freedom, Bundeswehr commitment to Baltic Air Policing, digital economy and growth, e-voting and e-learning, historical memory and reunification
Duration
~15 min
52nd percentile
Words
1,787
52nd percentile
Sentences
106
66th percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
10.1
22nd percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 43%42%
  • Social 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Economic 10%10%
  • Institutional 10%9%
  • Technological 9%8%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

106 sentences in 33 paragraphs

Dear Prime Minister, dear Taavi Rõivas,

dear colleagues from the cabinet,

ladies and gentlemen,

I would like to sincerely thank you for the warm and friendly welcome in your country, which can be said to cultivate both tradition and progress.

As we took a stroll through the old town of Tallinn yesterday, which is part of the UNESCO World Heritage, one could feel the wonderful atmosphere of an ancient Hanseatic metropolis. One could also sense that Tallinn is a city rich in tradition, but also historically aware, modern and progressive. In the Estonian government's showroom, I was able to catch a glimpse of what is everyday action here.

This is based on the fact that Estonia recognized the opportunities of digitalization very early on, and one can rightly say that Estonia is one of the most innovative countries in the world. This is particularly true because not only are digital options available in everyday life in principle, but they are also widely embedded in the entire population and therefore part of daily life. E-government, e-learning, or e-voting – these are taken for granted, while in other parts of Europe we are just beginning to create the prerequisites for them.

I say quite openly: Germany looks with great interest at this already existing situation here. That was also the reason why we invited the Prime Minister – you, dear Taavi – to the retreat of the Federal Government. The one hour we originally had in mind quickly passed. There were many, many questions. I hope that many actions will arise from this.

As I mentioned, we were just at the presentation of so-called e-Estonia. This confirmed to me once again the innovative power that lies within it. The consistent application of digital technologies saves a lot of time, a lot of money, and is growth-promoting. We often talk about growth in the European Union. Here, one can practically see how that is achievable.

Now Estonia has also discovered the topic of Industry 4.0 or the Internet of Things for itself. Together with Estonian partners, the German embassy is committed – for which I would like to sincerely thank the ambassador – to ensuring that there are stronger cooperations here. The industrial country Germany, with still a very high industrial value creation of over 20 percent, and the digital pioneer Estonia could and can do many things together.

What is interesting is – this coincides with the discussions we are having in Germany regarding digital value creation in the industrial sector – that Estonia recognized the dangers to which an IT-based society is exposed very early on through broad application. Therefore, the issue of security is of utmost importance here. Corresponding solutions are also being found.

That is why it is no coincidence that since 2008 the NATO Cyber Cooperative Defence Center of Excellence has existed in Estonia. That we were able to visit it yesterday was a great joy for me.

As heads of state and government, we reaffirmed at the NATO summit in Warsaw that we take the threats to our IT systems, to our infrastructure as a whole, very seriously. I want to quote again from the NATO resolution. We have decided to ensure that "our nations can defend themselves in the virtual space as well as in the air, on land, and at sea." This is a high demand, but we want to meet it.

This also makes it clear once again that we stand closely together in every danger situation. That was the decisive signal that characterized the Warsaw summit. It was a commitment to solidarity, as enshrined in Article Five of the NATO treaty. Especially for Estonia, this is a very important sign in its exposed geographical location, namely the security of feeling that the alliance cannot be divided.

Germany makes a substantial contribution to the reassurance of the Baltic States. In Baltic Air Policing in Estonia, the Bundeswehr is once again taking on leadership responsibility for four months. We continue to work together with our partners for the security of Estonia. This commitment to solidarity is very important to me personally.

I know that my visit coincides with a significant anniversary in your country. In these days, Estonia is commemorating its great historical success, the renewed attainment of its freedom and independence 25 years ago. We rejoiced with you 25 years ago. Two years earlier, the people in East Germany had the fortune to experience freedom. I am one of those who received completely new opportunities for life at that time. It was the same for the people here in Estonia.

The Singing Revolution – as it was called and is still called – stands for the indomitable will for freedom and the great courage of the people in the Baltic States. It remains associated with impressive images. The long human chain of August 23, 1989, was such a sign. Estonians, Latvians, and Lithuanians took to the streets, held each other’s hands, and thus formed a bond of hope and longing for freedom across the entire Baltic region. The event went down in history under the name "Baltic Way." It was the unmistakable signal for the quest for independence. This will also remain in the history books.

The date of the action had its reason, as August 23, 1989, was the 50th anniversary of the Hitler-Stalin Pact. A secret additional protocol of the pact provided for the Soviet Union to annex large parts of the Baltic territory. That this chapter of history only closed in 1991 with the regained independence of the Baltic States is, of course, a reminder for Germany – also for its politics in the future and in view of what we have done horrifically in the past.

Germany restored diplomatic relations with Estonia within eight days at that time. That was, one must say, quite a rapid action by the Foreign Office and the entire Federal Government. Of course, we could not undo the injustice that your country experienced from the German side. But the swift resumption of diplomatic relations was, of course, a sign: We want to be good partners.

Thus, in the last 25 years, we have supported each other. Germany has helped Estonia on its path, drawing from the experiences of history, learning lessons from the cruel chapters of the 20th century, in which infinite suffering originated from Germany, also for the people in the Baltic States.

Now we are long part of the European and transatlantic family together. We stand together like in a good family. This applies to both good and difficult times.

I believe no one claims that the situation for Europe is currently simple or easy. We are experiencing developments right at our doorstep that we could not have imagined a short time ago. I certainly could not have imagined that Russia would so blatantly disregard international law and annex Crimea. Who would have expected that separatists, with Moscow's support, would destabilize eastern Ukraine to such an extent?

With the refugees seeking protection in Europe, the crises they are fleeing from in the Middle East and North Africa are also coming closer to us. Terrible terrorist attacks, like those we have experienced in some of the member states, target the heart of our free society, our way of life.

At the same time, a new global power struggle is taking place. Emerging economies are showing what potential lies within them.

All of this poses great challenges for us in Europe. We must act decisively and united. We need a European shoulder-to-shoulder approach to tackle all the challenges.

That is why Taavi and I believe that the outcome of the British referendum is highly regrettable. It is a setback in European development, in the decades-long success story of European integration. We must, of course, respect this result. But we must ask ourselves: What does this mean for the other 27 member states? Are we strong enough to take a step towards a more successful Europe, towards a better Europe?

I am convinced that we can manage to cope with Britain's decision. But for that, we must work hard. We have initiated a so-called reflection process, a process of contemplation, to explore: Where do we need to develop further? Where do existing regulations hinder us from being successful?

We will meet as 27 member states in mid-September in Bratislava, not yet to make concrete decisions, but to define topics where we need to move forward. Because unemployment is high, and we are not living up to what the heads of state and government said in the year 2000, that Europe should be the most dynamic, the most successful, the most knowledge-based continent in the world; rather, we have a lot of catching up to do. In this spirit, we should also shape this phase of reflection together.

This is something very normal. Families also need phases where they consider: How can we do something together? How can we do it better? I hope that Europe will muster the courage, the drive, and the team spirit to be successful.

Estonia is setting a good example. It has volunteered to take over the EU Council Presidency in the second half of 2017 due to the British withdrawal. That is half a year earlier than planned. Estonia is thus demonstrating flexibility – which is an Estonian strength anyway – but also a deep European conviction.

Estonia brings many of the prerequisites for success in the 21st century: Estonia presents innovative ideas and sets a good example for others through its digital pioneering work. At the same time, it stands by the values of freedom and acts with an awareness of the importance that the European Union and the transatlantic alliance have for all of us.

These are strong connecting elements. That is why we are happy to support Estonia in preparing for the EU Council Presidency, if desired. We now need to ensure – I will pay attention to this when I am back in Germany – that what is being advanced by our embassy, namely cooperation in the field of the Internet of Things, Industry 4.0, and Estonia's digital capabilities, also takes on concrete forms.

Thus, I will encourage companies from Germany to focus more on Estonia. But I will also encourage our staff in the administration, in the federal ministries, to visit the showroom here and to engage more intensively than I was able to do now. I have looked at all of this so that we can gradually make as good use of the digital possibilities of today as Estonia is already doing. One can almost feel a bit envious.

Thank you very much for allowing me to be here with you today.