Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the memorial event for the victims of right-wing extremist violence on February 23, 2012, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

23 February 2012 · Memorial event for the victims of right-wing extremist violence · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed a state memorial event in Berlin on February 23, 2012, honoring victims of the NSU right-wing extremist murder series committed across Germany from 2000 to 2006.
Main themes
Victims of right-wing extremist violence, National Socialist Underground (NSU) terrorist group, remembrance and memorialization, indifference and societal responsibility, German government accountability, xenophobia and racism, loss and grief of bereaved families, preventing extremism, bomb attacks in Cologne, solidarity with victims
Duration
~20 min
65th percentile
Words
2,391
65th percentile
Sentences
176
86th percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
8.4
7th percentile
Syntax
2.57
6th percentile
Vocabulary
2.42
92nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 73%73%
  • Institutional 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

176 sentences in 46 paragraphs

Dear Mr. President of the Federal Council,

dear Mr. President of the Bundestag,

dear Mr. President of the Federal Constitutional Court,

Excellencies,

ladies and gentlemen,

but especially: dear families who have lost a loved one or have experienced an attack themselves,

I thank you for coming to this memorial event today.

On the podium to my left, candles are burning. They are candles for people – for people whose lives were extinguished, extinguished by cold-blooded murder.

Enver Şimşek. He was 38 years old and had fulfilled the dream of owning his own flower shop in Nuremberg for himself, his wife, and his two children.

Abdurrahim Özüdoğru. He often helped out in a tailor shop in Nuremberg. There, he was struck by the fatal shots. He was 49 years old and leaves behind a daughter.

Süleyman Taşköprü. He ran a vegetable market in Hamburg. When he died at the age of 31, his daughter was only three years old.

Habil Kılıç. A few months before his violent death at the age of 38, he had opened a grocery store in Munich with his wife. They have a daughter.

Mehmet Turgut. The 25-year-old had just come to Rostock from Anatolia. Hopes and dreams accompanied him. He had no chance to realize them.

İsmail Yaşar. Especially the schoolchildren in the Nuremberg neighborhood often came to the snack bar of this family man. He was 50 years old and leaves behind three children.

Theodoros Boulgarides. The 41-year-old father of two lived in Munich and believed in his future in Germany as a businessman.

Mehmet Kubaşik. He came to Germany with his wife, opened a kiosk in Dortmund with her, and built a livelihood for his daughter and two younger sons. He was 39 years old.

Halit Yozgat. The 21-year-old ran an internet café in his hometown of Kassel – until the murderers extinguished his young life.

Michèle Kiesewetter. The police officer moved from Thuringia to Baden-Württemberg for her police training. She was only 22 years old when she was murdered in Heilbronn in her patrol car. Her colleague sitting next to her survived the attackers' shots severely injured.

Ten burning candles – ten extinguished lives. We remember them today. Ten candles – they stand for a series of murders in Germany from 2000 to 2006, whose perpetrators remained undetected until 2011, thus for more than ten years, right among us; unprecedented for our country.

Before we answer the all-important questions "How could this happen?", "Why did we not become aware earlier?", "Why could we not prevent this?", I ask for a moment of silence. Silence, just as employees across the country will observe a moment of silence today at 12 o'clock. This has been agreed upon by trade unions and employers.

Thank you.

With this silence, we honor the victims of the murder series of a terrorist group that had its core in Thuringia since the late 1990s and called itself the "National Socialist Underground." We honor the victims of this terrorist group; and we also remember the victims of other terrible acts. Let us think of the bomb attacks in Cologne on January 19, 2001, and June 9, 2004. Many people were injured in these attacks. Some of them are here with us today. I thank them. Many of them bear external scars from this. How much the emotional wounds hurt, we can only guess.

Sometimes reports about ruthless right-wing extremist perpetrators shake us. For a few days, they dominate the headlines. Sometimes the name of a city remains in our memory as a crime scene. But often enough, we perceive such incidents only as footnotes. We forget too quickly – far too quickly. We suppress what happens right among us; perhaps because we are too busy with other things; perhaps also because we feel powerless against what is happening around us.

Or perhaps out of indifference? Indifference – it has a creeping but devastating effect. It drives cracks right through our society. Indifference also leaves the victims without names, without faces, without stories.

That is why we are setting a sign here. With an eleventh candle on the podium. We have lit it for all known and unknown victims of right-wing extremist violence. This memorial event is also dedicated to them. Each of these people has a family, friends, and acquaintances. Their suffering, their worries are hardly imaginable.

The contempt for humanity shown by the right-wing extremist murderers is ultimately incomprehensible. And yet we must try to understand how and by whom they became who they are. We must do everything to ensure that no other young men and women grow up to such contempt for humanity. We owe this to the victims, we owe it to their relatives, we owe it to all of us.

Many bereaved are here with us today. I know how difficult this has been for them. They told me earlier about their great pain. They told me how abandoned they felt. I am all the more grateful that we can be here together today. I also thank the relatives who will later address us: Mr. Ismail Yozgat, Semiya Şimşek, and Gamze Kubaşik.

Most of them were left alone in their distress. Because the backgrounds of the acts remained in the dark – for far too long. That is the bitter truth. Only a few people here believed it was possible that right-wing extremist terrorists could be behind the murders, as there were no previously typical behavioral patterns of terrorists, such as claims of responsibility. Instead, this led to the search for traces in the mafia and drug milieu or even in the victims' family circles. Some relatives were unjustly suspected for years. That is particularly distressing. For this, I ask for your forgiveness.

Not only did years pass without at least making progress in clarifying the acts. No, these years must have been an endless nightmare for you, dear relatives. In one of the conversations that former Federal President Wulff had with bereaved families, the phrase was uttered – I quote: "We just wanted to be treated like normal people." Like normal people – these three words express their entire despair. How terrible must it be to be subjected to false suspicions for years instead of being able to mourn?! What agony it is when neighbors and friends turn away, when even close relatives doubt?! And how does one cope with the skepticism about whether the security authorities are really doing everything possible to clarify the murder of the next person?!

Dear bereaved, no one can bring back your husband, father, son, or daughter. No one can erase the years of mourning and abandonment. No one can undo the pain, the anger, and the doubts. But we can all show you today: You are no longer alone with your grief. We feel for you. We mourn with you.

As Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany, I promise you: We will do everything to clarify the murders and uncover the accomplices and masterminds and bring all perpetrators to justice. All responsible authorities at the federal and state levels are working hard on this. That is important enough, but it would not be enough. Because it is also about doing everything within the possibilities of our rule of law to ensure that such a thing can never happen again.

In the meantime, a federal-state commission has been established to address right-wing terrorism. In addition, investigative committees have begun their work in the Thuringian state parliament and in the German Bundestag. The first steps have been taken for better cooperation between the Office for the Protection of the Constitution and the police, as well as between state and federal authorities.

We do this because we will not accept that people are exposed to hatred, contempt, and violence. We do this because we are taking a firm stand against those who persecute others because of their origin, skin color, or religion. Wherever the foundations of humanity are shaken, tolerance is out of place. Tolerance destroys itself if it does not protect itself against intolerance.

"The dignity of man is inviolable. To respect and protect it is the duty of all state authority." – Thus begins our Basic Law. This was the answer to twelve years of National Socialism in Germany, to unspeakable contempt for humanity and barbarism, to the civilizational break caused by the Holocaust. "The dignity of man is inviolable." – This is the foundation of coexistence in our country, the free democratic basic order of the Federal Republic of Germany.

Whenever people in our country are marginalized, threatened, or persecuted, it violates the foundations of this free democratic order, it violates the values of our Basic Law. That is why the murders of the Thuringian terrorist cell were also an attack on our country. They are a disgrace to our country.

As part of my work as Chancellor, I sometimes personally watch videos of perpetrators, for example, in hostage situations. I also watched the video that was discovered in the course of the investigations against the Thuringian terrorist cell. It is designed with elements of the well-known cartoon series featuring the Pink Panther. In this video, its creators boast of the murders and mock the victims. I have not seen anything more contemptuous, more insidious, more infamous – if such degrees even exist – in my work.

I have asked myself: How do people come to think and do such things? Who or what shapes extremist perpetrators? How can it be that such perpetrators repeatedly find accomplices and supporters? How do we best protect people from hostility and threats?

We must admit that we are partly failing in this. We must admit that sometimes, especially where unemployment is high and emigration is strong, the familiar structures of youth work are often lost, recreational opportunities dwindle – and the enemies of our democracy know how to exploit this. It has reached a terrible state when neo-Nazis can capture young people with camaraderie evenings because no one else cares for these youths. We must not rest when a party that is hostile to the constitution and right-wing extremist can lure young families with games and festivals because others do not offer that.

The state is called upon here with all its strength. But state resources alone can hardly defeat hatred and violence. The security authorities need partners: citizens who do not look away but look closely – a strong civil society. This cannot be mandated. It is based on everyone feeling co-responsible for the whole, that everyone makes their personal contribution to peaceful coexistence. Civil society grows in families. Children learn the basics of responsible coexistence at an early age. It grows in circles of friends and acquaintances. It grows in schools, clubs, and in the workplace.

I also see many encouraging signs, many people who are committed to peaceful coexistence – for example, in Dresden, where just a few days ago thousands of citizens commemorated the anniversary of the bombing of the city and reached out to each other. With this gesture, they stood up to the neo-Nazis who wanted to misuse this commemoration. Day by day, numerous small and larger initiatives in our country set signs against hatred and violence. They have been initiated by courageous, brave people. Some of them are sitting here among us. I thank you on behalf of many others in our country. I thank the foundations, the media, the teachers and clergy, the entrepreneurs, the representatives of associations and clubs, all of whom advocate for a thriving coexistence and stand against hatred and violence.

The fight against prejudice, contempt, and exclusion must be waged daily – in homes, in neighborhoods, in schools, cultural and recreational facilities, in religious communities, in businesses. Everywhere we should develop a fine ear and sensitivity for the small remarks, the careless comments. Some remarks are quickly taken lightly – with the motto: He or she does not mean it seriously.

But intolerance and racism do not only manifest themselves in violence. Not only extremists are dangerous. Those who stir up prejudices, who create a climate of contempt, are also dangerous. How important, therefore, are sensitivity and a keen awareness of when exclusion and devaluation begin. Indifference and inattentiveness often stand at the beginning of a process of creeping brutalization of the spirit. Words can become actions.

The Irish thinker Edmund Burke once said – I quote: "All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing." Yes, democracy lives from looking, from participating. It lives from all of us standing up for it, day by day and each in our place. Living democracy requires us to take responsibility for coexistence in freedom – and thus for a life in diversity. If this succeeds, diversity can unfold its richness for the benefit of all.

Germany has repeatedly experienced this in its history. For it is also a history of emigration and immigration. Bridges have been built to all parts of the world. Germany owes a good part of its prosperity to its openness to the world and its curiosity about others. We live here in this country from diversity, from the most varied life paths. Germany – that is all of us; all of us who live in this country; no matter where we come from, how we look, what we believe in, whether we are strong or weak, healthy or sick, with or without disabilities, old or young.

We are one country, one society. Those who come to us from many countries around the world are not simply immigrants. They too are diverse and different. Together, we all shape the face of Germany, our identity in the globalized world of the 21st century – supported by our Basic Law and its values, our free and democratic basic order, articulated in our language. Together, we all defend the inviolable dignity of man, as enshrined at the beginning of our constitution, for all of us who adhere to these values.

This is the message of the twelfth candle on the pedestal. It is the symbol of our shared hope and confidence for a good future. Let us all together, each in our place and according to our abilities, live for this hope and this confidence – for the good of our country and its people.