Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the opening of the 61st academic year of the College of Europe in Bruges on November 2, 2010, in Bruges:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

2 November 2010 · Opening of the 61st academic year of the College of Europe · College of Europe, Bruges, Belgium

Context
Merkel addressed students and dignitaries at the College of Europe in Bruges, inaugurating the 61st academic year during the Belgian EU Council presidency on November 2, 2010.
Main themes
European integration, German reunification, College of Europe opening, freedom and democracy, Albert Einstein and scientific worldview, Cold War and Eastern Europe, Solidarity movement, German responsibility in Europe, generational change, borders and nation-states
Duration
~37 min
88th percentile
Words
4,437
88th percentile
Sentences
218
91st percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.01
48th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 45%44%
  • Economic 19%18%
  • Geopolitical 13%13%
  • Environmental 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 2%

218 sentences in 56 paragraphs

Dear Prime Minister, dear Yves Leterme,

dear Governor Breyne,

dear Mayor Moenaert,

dear Member of Parliament Mendéz de Vigo,

dear Rector Demaret,

Excellencies,

ladies and gentlemen,

and especially you, the students of the "Albert Einstein" class!

I would like to sincerely thank you for the long-standing invitation and for the kind words of welcome! I believe that, after the timing for a visit was already postponed, it is now a very good time to be here due to the Belgian presidency of the Council.

It is a special honor for me to open the 61st academic year of the world-renowned College of Europe in Bruges together with you. I am particularly pleased to inaugurate a class that has Albert Einstein as its patron. Not only because I am trained as a physicist, but also because you have chosen one of the great scientists who has profoundly changed our view of the world – as has just been made clear in the words of the President – and our understanding of space and time, our understanding of mass and energy. Even if you are studying something else, it is worth taking a moment to immerse yourself in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. At that time, radioactivity was discovered by Marie Curie, then came Albert Einstein with his theory of relativity, and later the entire field of quantum physics – I mention Niels Bohr, for example – which completely transformed our deterministic thinking.

It is very interesting that such a great scientist as Albert Einstein struggled throughout his life to understand another great world, namely that of quantum mechanics, despite the fact that many figures are closely interconnected. From this, one can learn how difficult it is to transition from a known worldview to a new one that has been gained through scientific knowledge. This highlights boundaries – the limits of one’s own understanding and the limits of a particular time, which are repeatedly pushed by great individuals. When one then thinks, acts, and researches in the new space, everything suddenly seems very simple; one can hardly understand why such things remained closed to earlier generations.

This is also how we feel when we talk about Europe. For in the member states of the European Union, we are experiencing a process in which borders have less and less of a separating nature. We can hardly imagine how a Europe of nation-states could exist, which waged wars against each other for centuries. Therefore, I must say to you, dear students: No other generation before you has been able to utilize the opportunities of Europe as you can today – you here in Bruges, certainly.

Because we know how invaluable freedom and democracy are, we also see how the upheavals of 1989/90 have expanded our possibilities. For 20 years, however, we have felt that some of the freedom and democracy that a part of Europe longed for now seems almost taken for granted. I must tell you that my generation – my life was shaped by unfreedom, by state arbitrariness, and by dictatorship until I was 35 years old – underwent a massive change around 1989/90. Because suddenly there was the possibility to live under free conditions. This was an experience not only made by a part of the Germans, namely the East Germans, but it was also a European experience. The German reunification is inconceivable without European unification. Helmut Kohl, who shaped the unity on the Federal Republic side as Chancellor at the time, repeatedly said over the years and decades: German unity and European unification are two sides of the same coin. He was in the fortunate position to be able to shape this unity himself after having spoken of this dream for many years.

We know: Without the contribution of the liberation movements in Central and Eastern Europe, German unity in peace and freedom would not have been conceivable at all. Therefore, it is of no small symbolic significance that there is not only the College of Europe here in Bruges, but also one near Warsaw, in Natolin. For we know that without the solidarity and the development of Solidarnosc, such a development in the then Eastern Bloc would not have been possible; just as this development would not have been possible if the thoughts of the Eastern and Central Europeans had been abandoned in the western, free parts of Europe, instead of being convinced that one day the Cold War would come to an end.

Now we Germans know that an incredible amount of trust was placed in us during the time of German reunification. It was not only the courage of the East Germans and the foresight of Helmut Kohl, but it was also a fact that the Chancellor of German unity was primarily a person who was trusted in the world – in Europe, but also in the United States of America. We know how much trust was placed in us. Therefore, as a reunified Germany, we want to continually justify this trust.

It is therefore obvious that Germany, as the largest economy in Europe, has a special responsibility for our continent. I believe we have particularly felt this in the last two years – during the time of the massive international financial and economic crisis. In the spring of this year – just a few months ago – we as the European Union looked into the abyss. Only through a joint effort was it possible to avert damage from the monetary union as a whole.

At that time, I acted as the German Chancellor, but also as a convinced European for Germany. Because I believe in Europe, I proposed to my Parliament, the German Bundestag, to take unusual and previously unthought-of paths to help Greece and thus secure the stability of the Eurozone as a whole. My motivation was the European project. Only for this reason did I decide to implement a time-limited solution for the Euro rescue fund and for ambitious reforms and tough austerity programs for Greece and other countries. I was strongly criticized for this: some thought it was too slow, others thought it was too fast. However, I believe it was right to insist on the one hand that the countries that caused such a crisis must act for themselves in the future, and on the other hand to make it clear that we stand in a common European responsibility. I believe that today we are all in Europe of the opinion that this was overall the right way to save Europe from an abyss. A lot was at stake. I said in the spring in the German Bundestag, in our Parliament: "If the Euro fails, Europe fails." That is why it is incredibly important that the stability of the monetary union is secured in the long term so that we can further develop our visions of a united Europe.

What are these visions? It is the vision of a union that is successful with its model of life and social responsibility, which combines competitiveness, that is, economic strength and social responsibility. We experienced in the international financial crisis: When the excesses of the markets dictate life, we do not have a just social model and ruin the economy. Therefore, the balance of economic strength and social responsibility is so important. That is why we also anchored the topic of social market economy in the Lisbon Treaty.

The vision of Europe is the vision of a union that decisively, unitedly, and convincingly represents its interests and values in the world. This European Union is founded on values: freedom, responsibility, dignity of the individual. Our task is to advocate for these values in a world where not everyone is committed to them – as a group of 500 million people who represent these values together. It is the vision of a union that boldly addresses the great challenges of our century – whether it is about the protection of human rights and the securing of peace and stability or about climate protection and sustainable energy supply. This means we need the credibility of our lived values and must equally contribute our economic strength.

A crisis like the one we had in the spring was not foreseen by the architects of the economic and monetary union. However, we know today: A strong European Union can only exist if we understand this crisis as an obligation and an opportunity. Therefore, in recent weeks, I have advocated that we do not simply leave this crisis behind us, but rather take convincing precautions to ensure that such a crisis does not happen again.

Of course, there is always a great public discussion when a proper path is being fought for in Europe. Personally, I believe: One must not sweep the problems under the rug. Harmony alone is not a value in itself for Europe. Rather, it is about building Europe on strong foundations. Therefore, we need a culture of stability and we need common values. That is why we agreed on essential new paths at the European Council on Friday, which also include sanctions in dealing with the stability pact, which will coordinate economic policy much more strongly and which will require member states not simply to incur debts, but to strive for economic strength and financial stability.

As important as all this is: We must still have a mechanism that ensures we do not find ourselves in emergency situations again. Therefore, we have said: In the event that the Euro and the monetary union as a whole are once again in danger, we need a mechanism that can manage crises and that will be anchored in the treaty. Therefore, we have decided on a limited treaty amendment that we want to discuss in December.

It took years for us to adopt the Lisbon Treaty. I myself – the Federal Republic of Germany held the presidency at that time – dealt a lot with this topic. None of us will carelessly reopen treaties again. However, I believe that a European Union must be a capable union that can respond to the demands of the times. We cannot say: Because we spent ten years dealing with a treaty amendment and it was so laborious, we must exclude for the future that it ever happens again. Such a Europe will not be regarded as capable of action either in the markets of the world or in the countries of the world. Therefore, we need a crisis mechanism and therefore we also want to involve private capital providers so that they can make their contribution. Because it is about a political understanding in which it is not the economy that drives politics or pulls it along, but in which politics has the claim to shape our common life. Because we need a legal basis for such a mechanism, we also need a limited treaty amendment.

Jean Monnet, the first honorary citizen of Europe, already knew: "Nothing is possible without people, nothing lasts without institutions." This means we must, on the one hand, take care of the people and ensure that they like this Europe. On the other hand, this Europe needs institutions to be capable of action. With the Lisbon Treaty, the institutional framework has been placed on a new foundation. Now, about a year after the Lisbon Treaty came into force, the question arises: How can we better shape the interaction of the institutions?

The economic and financial crisis has once again made it clear how closely intertwined our economies and societies are today in Europe. It has also shown: The division of labor between the Union and the member states has essentially worked. However, an argumentative pattern has returned to the debate that we have known for many years, which refers to the so-called "community method." If you delve into the history of the European Union, you will see that this is a term that many know; although it is a cumbersome German word, "community method" is also repeatedly mentioned in many other languages. I suspect you know the term from your studies. It describes the exclusive right of initiative of the Commission and the role of the European Parliament and the Council in European legislation.

Today, as a representative of a member state, I may say: Sometimes it seems to me that the representatives in the European Parliament and in the European Commission see themselves as the only true defenders of the community method. They sometimes see themselves in opposition to the proponents of the so-called intergovernmental method, that is, the purely inter-state method of cooperation. For them, this includes the Council, the European Council, and the member states. These are, so to speak, the intergovernmentalists, while on the other side are the guardians and preservers of the community method.

I must tell you that I listen to this argumentation with a certain skepticism, and therefore I often feel a contradiction rising within me, because I believe it does not do justice to the European way of cooperation. The community method is, of course, a method of European legislation – as I said: the Commission takes the initiative.

First,

not only the Parliament discusses this, but also the Council. The Council is part of European legislation and consists of representatives of the member states; representatives of the Commission participate in the discussions.

Second,

one should not overlook that the European Council is also part of the European Union; it is an institution of the European Union. The member states are constitutive parts of the European Union and not its adversaries. I really want to use this speech to say: Let us understand ourselves as Europe together – the member states just as much as the representatives of the European Parliament, who, by the way, also come from the member states, and those who represent the Commission. Because only together can we form the Europe of the citizens.

Third:

A solution is not automatically and solely better because it is brought about or executed by EU institutions, but from the very beginning of the European Union, the principle of subsidiarity has always played a very important role. What does that mean? It means that I should always solve a problem politically as close to the people as possible. What can be better solved at the municipal level, at the local level, does not need to go to Europe. Rather, Europe must deal with the problems that we can solve better together, and the member states must take care of the problems that they can solve better on their own. Otherwise, we will get a policy that is very distant from the people.

Fourth:

The community method can, of course, only be applied where the European Union also has competencies. The Lisbon Treaty states: The member states are the masters of the treaties. This means that the member states decide that something falls within European competence when they believe that a problem can be better solved at the European level. The community method is therefore not intended to transfer competencies to Europe, but it is a method to effectively, sensibly, and efficiently implement transferred competencies. Where there is no community competence, the community method cannot be applied either.

Therefore, it holds true: One is not more European than the other – depending on where one is sitting – but we are all Europe. Our Council President Herman Van Rompuy recently said: "Often it is not about the choice between the community method and intergovernmental action, but about the choice between a coordinated European position and nothing." This means that I find a coordinated European position not only by applying the community method, but I sometimes also find a common European position by applying the intergovernmental method. What is important is that we have common positions on important issues.

Therefore, I would like to take up this thought and turn it into something positive: If all important actors – the institutions of the Union, the member states, and their parliaments – act in a coordinated and complementary manner in their responsibilities, then we will succeed in addressing the great challenges of Europe successfully. The distribution of competencies for this is very clearly regulated. We wanted a confident European Parliament that, in the Lisbon Treaty, has become an equal co-legislator alongside the Council. We wanted an imaginative European Commission that retains the monopoly on initiating proposals. It remains the guardian of the treaties; that is absolutely correct. And we wanted the European Council to become an institution with a permanent president. This means that the heads of state and government of the 27 member states and the president of the European Commission, together with the president of the European Council, set guidelines for the development of the European Union.

Therefore, I believe: We must overcome the camp mentality in light of this newly distributed responsibility, we must set common goals and establish common strategies. Perhaps we can describe it together like this: Coordinated solidarity action – each in their own responsibility, all for the same goal. That is, for me, the new "Union method." I believe that is what matters. I would like to explain this to you with an example.

One area that has gained significance again recently is energy policy. For example, we will have a special Council of heads of state and government on energy policy at the beginning of February. I believe that especially in this field we can achieve new and better results through the Union method, as I have just presented it. A look back at the history of the European Union shows: The European Union began with the question of energy. Back then, it was about coal and steel in the European Coal and Steel Community. In the meantime, the significance of coal and steel in European work has somewhat diminished. But just as the topic of energy was a founding motive of the European Community back then, it is again at the top of the agenda today.

We all still remember the gas supply crises in recent years. The resulting supply shortages in some European countries have clearly shown us the value of a secure supply and the disadvantages of our dependence on energy imports. In recent years, we have experienced considerable price fluctuations in energy markets. They have caused significant difficulties for the European economy and millions of people. Finally, we have the issue of climate change and environmental damage. This results in enormous costs and a massive threat to our livelihoods.

This means: A reliable, affordable, and environmentally friendly energy supply is an important cornerstone of our lives. Therefore, we are well advised in Europe to pursue new paths in energy policy. The member states have explicitly anchored energy policy in the Treaty of Lisbon for good reason. Energy policy is thus a shared competence between the Union and the member states. There are therefore competencies of the Commission and competencies of the member states.

In my view, the contribution of the European Union should primarily extend to the following areas: a functioning internal energy market – we still do not have a functioning internal energy market today – a connection of European energy networks, supply security, energy efficiency, and new and renewable energy sources.

To meet the goals that we must always consider in energy policy – namely environmental compatibility, economic efficiency, and supply security – we must not only better coordinate national actions, but also do more at the European level.

I want to make this clear with two points.

First:

We must implement jointly agreed European goals nationally. The member states are responsible for deciding how they shape their energy policy – whether they want to extend the operating time of nuclear power plants, as we do in Germany, whether they want to phase out nuclear energy or re-enter it – they are responsible for that themselves. However, we already set ambitious European goals for 2020 under the German EU Council Presidency in 2007, namely a 20 percent reduction in climate-damaging greenhouse gas emissions compared to 1990, a reduction in energy consumption by 20 percent, and an increase in the share of renewable energies in total energy consumption by 20 percent. Each country has to make its contribution – that is clearly defined. If we all focus on achieving these goals in our national energy policies, then we can also achieve the European goal together.

Commissioner Oettinger, who represents the energy issue in the European Commission, has my support to analyze the challenges we face in the new so-called "Energy Strategy 2020" and to develop ambitious proposals. Because the most beautiful European goals are of no use if we do not act nationally in this sense, but they are only useful if they are implemented nationally. However, the member states must also show – that is exactly the Union method now – that they are seriously pursuing these goals. This means that there must first be a European agreement and then the goals will be implemented.

This means: We need national energy concepts. The federal government has just implemented this in recent months. It has an ambitious national energy concept that aims to increase the share of renewable energies in Germany to around 60 percent of final energy consumption by 2050 and to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by at least 80 percent by 2050. That is a very, very ambitious plan. We specify exactly what we want to achieve and how we want to achieve it – from reducing consumption to increasing competition in the electricity and gas markets.

Each of our national progress will, of course, also benefit Europe. However, we must also think about the additional contribution that can only be made through Europe. For example, we need to consider how to better coordinate the promotion of the use of renewable energies among the member states. We must work together to ensure that we are leaders in energy efficiency, power plant technologies, and renewable energies. We also need research, industry, and a good competition for the best minds and the best ideas. For this, the European level must provide incentives.

Second:

We must complete the internal energy market and expand energy infrastructure. The internal market – I believe we all agree on this – is one of the greatest success stories of Europe. Germany, in particular, has benefited enormously from the internal market. For the completion of the internal market, the expansion of electrical lines is of utmost importance. Above all, our actions here must be better coordinated and aligned across borders. Because the national and European networks will have to perform significantly more than they did ten years ago. They must not only transport large amounts of energy over long distances, as the location of energy generation changes due to the use of renewable energies. In Germany, for example, much more energy will be generated in the north through wind energy than is currently the case. The nuclear energy, which is very strongly localized in the south of Germany, will gradually phase out as a bridging technology. During this period, we must have built completely new line structures. The networks must also be able to respond flexibly to the different feed-ins, because wind strength and solar radiation are, as you know, not constantly given. We need storage technologies and smart grids throughout Europe.

This means that we must primarily advocate for citizens to tackle new infrastructure tasks. It must be clear: Without new energy networks, there will be no increase in competition; without a new energy structure, there will be no expansion of the use of renewable energies. Therefore, I find it good when Günther Oettinger says: Let us create a map of priority European energy infrastructure projects. Then each member state is responsible for implementing these projects. But if one does not do its homework, the entire system of European coordination collapses. Therefore, it is essential that on the one hand we have the will for European cooperation and that on the other hand the member states must act responsibly. It cannot be that a member state – Germany often takes a very long time here – takes 15 years or more for planning and implementation times, while another member state can perhaps do it much faster. Therefore, it is now important that we all act in a coordinated manner and also communicate this to the citizens. We must say: If you block certain projects, you are not only blocking something in Germany, but you are also jeopardizing a common European action.

It is now important that we fully implement the Third Energy Internal Market Package. This refers to a multitude of legal frameworks with which we act in a coordinated European manner, which now need to be implemented into national law.

I have tried to present to you the Union method, that is, a mixture of community method and coordinated action of the member states using the example of energy policy, and to show: Our success depends on whether we – each in our place – fulfill our responsibility for Europe. I believe that energy policy is a very modern and good example for this. However, we will, of course, also have to proceed similarly in many other cases; this is just one example that illustrates the entire approach.

Dear students of the "Albert Einstein" class, surely there are also opportunities for you during your stay in Bruges to discuss the new institutional order and the great challenges of the European Union. You will likely hear as many different opinions as we sometimes do in the European Council or indeed in the European Parliament. That is democracy. Therefore, it is wonderful that we make majority decisions from the diversity of opinions. I have experienced many years of my life differently. I cannot wish for us to long for the simple path again for any reason.

What has always made Europe strong is the fundamental feeling that this European Union is an incredible blessing for us. In the Berlin Declaration on the 50th anniversary of the Treaty of Rome, we said: We are united for our happiness. Amid all the noise, all the disputes, and all the search for the best way in detail, we must never forget this. Europe is a matter of reason, Europe is a matter of competition and the internal market, but Europe is and remains also a matter of the heart. If you experience both of these in your studies here, then it is a good program. Albert Einstein will hopefully assist you in this.