Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the opening of the European-Israeli Dialogue on March 10, 2007, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

10 March 2007 · Opening of the European-Israeli Dialogue · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the European-Israeli Dialogue conference in Berlin on March 10, 2007, reaffirming Germany's commitment to Israel and outlining international responses to Iran.
Main themes
Israel's right to exist, Iran nuclear threat, European-Israeli dialogue, German foreign policy, Holocaust denial, international sanctions against Iran, Middle East conflict, EU Council Presidency, German-Israeli relations, peaceful diplomacy, UN Security Council
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,670
83rd percentile
Sentences
168
84th percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.02
50th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 82%79%
  • Economic 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Institutional 4%4%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

168 sentences in 56 paragraphs

Mr. Minister Herzog,

Madam Commissioner,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am pleased to be here once again at this conference, which is held in a good tradition by Axel Springer Verlag and was just opened by you, Mr. Döpfner. The framework has also been described. We may say it every year, but it is true again this year: The European-Israeli dialogue is of utmost importance.

From this point, I would like to send my warmest greetings to Lord Weidenfeld, who unfortunately cannot be with us today, but who has enriched this forum, this dialogue, with so many pieces of advice and experiences and is an important constant in our international relations.

This year, as the Federal Republic of Germany, beyond the German-Israeli relationship – as has already been mentioned – we have the opportunity to be more internationally active and collaborative with the EU Commission and the Council due to the fact that we hold the EU Council Presidency and the G8 Presidency. This naturally also brings with it a bit more responsibility. But when I say this, I want to emphasize that it is indeed a huge opportunity for Germany.

I want to make it clear once again, although it is often said at events of this kind: The resolute commitment to Israel's right to exist is and remains a firm constant of German foreign policy. This applies to all federal governments.

One would have hoped that one would not have to repeat this today. But the situation as it presents itself internationally requires us to name this as a starting point again and again, to make it clear: For historical reasons, but also for current reasons, it is essential to point out that any statements that call into question Israel's right to exist must be firmly rejected and that measures must be taken with all clarity to make this clear.

When I say this, it also means that we must act very clearly, especially regarding what is happening in Iran. We must make it clear that the statements of the Iranian president – up to and including the denial of the Holocaust, up to and including conferences that take place on such topics – not only do not find our approval, but we also oppose them with all determination.

However, this also means that corresponding actions must follow. We see here again in dealing with Iran that actions worldwide are not as easy to organize as the words that express Israel's right to exist. Therefore, I would like to begin by stating that the international community has undertaken some actions regarding Iran.

I want to make it clear at this point that I say this from my conviction: What we undertake with the international community in dealing with Iran must be under the clear message that we want to use peaceful means.

Dealing with Iran is difficult in that we are essentially faced with a decision question at every step: Do we do this because we are convinced of it – largely together with partners like the United States of America or the European Union – or do we also strive to gain legitimacy in the UN by involving important countries that have a significant influence on Iran's economic development? Are we trying to bring them to the table?

I say clearly: In my firm conviction, it was right to continually strive for this commonality with Russia and China in the various steps in dealing with Iran, particularly with the permanent members of the UN Security Council. I hope that we will succeed in this with further steps as well. At the moment, discussions are again taking place in the UN Security Council regarding a new sanctions resolution against Iran. I am optimistic that we will be able to take the next step here as well.

But it is, of course, partly the case that the speed of action is not increased by this. However, I believe that the overall effectiveness is indeed increased, and through the commonality of the international community, significant pressure potential is developed on Iran.

We have always tried to make it very clear in dealing with Iran that the Iranian people must have a chance for reasonable development. Iran is a great cultural nation. There are many reasons to make it clear: This is about dealing with a regime that makes unbearable statements. But it is also about showing: This country has a chance for development if it adapts to and complies with the principles of the international community.

Last year, we made an offer. We have repeatedly made it clear to Iran that the door to negotiations remains open, but not at any price; rather, the resolutions and assessments of the International Atomic Energy Agency must be accepted. It must be completely clear that all activities that raise even doubts and certain indications that work is being done on the development of an atomic bomb must be firmly prevented.

The question of how the threatening potential from Iran develops in the region of the Middle East and Near East is, in my view, closely linked to other conflicts and fundamentally to the conflict between Israel and the Palestinians.

For me, it is completely clear that the resolution of the conflict depends crucially on whether we succeed in advancing a two-state solution. This includes that Israel's right to exist is not called into question, that violence is not a means to resolve conflicts in this region, and that the previous negotiation steps of the international community are accepted by the Palestinian side, namely by all Palestinians. These are the prerequisites for us to reach a two-state solution.

The question is: What does the current situation look like? – You will discuss this.

What perhaps distinguishes the attempts at resolution in the past – and many problems have unfortunately remained the same for a long time – is that we do feel that the Arab states are now willing to engage in greater activities in light of the changed power dynamics in the region. I believe we are all in agreement here in this room: Without regional efforts, it will be very difficult to resolve the conflict between the Palestinians and Israel from afar. Therefore, I see this as a sign of hope.

Now, when I was in the region – in Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, and Kuwait – I was repeatedly asked: Where do you get your optimism that things could move forward? I can only say: I draw my optimism from the fact that the current situation cannot remain as it is, and we must hold ourselves accountable if we do not do everything we can to try again and again to resolve one of the most complicated conflicts in the world.

I would like to say at this point: If someone like Axel Springer had not been a visionary, if he had not always believed that freedom could be possible just a few meters from this house and that a wall could be brought down, then much of what I have experienced, what you all have experienced with German unity and the unification of the European Union, would not have been possible.

After the Second World War, there were visionaries who believed that war could be overcome, that a centuries-long history of Europe could be surmountable, in which Europeans inflicted so much suffering on each other. By addressing the interests of others, it became better for them, and thus the European Union was created. If we did not take this as encouragement to use this experience outside our own continent and transform it into a commitment to peace in this region, then, in my view, we would not have drawn the right conclusion from history.

Therefore, Europe is obliged to pass on what it has experienced as fortune in the second half of the 20th century, to at least try to do so. But this will only succeed if all forces in the region are strengthened to want this themselves. Because against the united will, for example, of the Arab states, this will not succeed.

That is why I am very pleased that something like an Arab Quartet has been formed from Jordan, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, and Egypt. I am very glad about this, even if we can express criticism about the results. I am very pleased that the King of Saudi Arabia has decided to take action against the current bloodshed in the Palestinian territories.

Of course, the agreement from Mecca is not yet what meets our demands regarding the three conditions. But it can be a beginning if we continue in the right direction. That is why we have also said: We encourage further steps. That is why we have also worked hard to ensure that there are as many contacts as possible between the Arab countries that are developing their own activities and the Middle East Quartet.

There was also again the question here – similar to the issue of how we deal with Iran – whether to reactivate the Middle East Quartet, which had been relatively passive for a while. The Federal Republic of Germany has strongly advocated this. We Europeans can, of course, play an active role in the entire Middle East peace process through this Middle East Quartet. It is undisputed that it is impossible to achieve peace in this region without the United States of America. Therefore, we must not overestimate our role. But we can play an important role.

What always applies also applies here: No country can solve all conflicts alone today; rather, it requires the cooperation of various countries. Therefore, I consider the transatlantic relationship to be extraordinarily important, especially concerning the Middle East region. We have now moved this Quartet back to meetings. The next meeting will take place in the region. I also consider this to be extraordinarily important.

This year, during the European-Israeli dialogue, we find ourselves in a very exciting phase, the outcome of which we do not yet know. There are again meetings between the Israeli Prime Minister and the Palestinian President. I welcome this. Because if there is no dialogue, it is incredibly difficult to make progress. The formation of a national unity government is in question, about which we cannot yet make any assessment because it has not been formed. But there are also many points where we say: Action must be taken here.

When I met with Palestinian President Abu Mazen a few days ago, I pointed this out to him again, and we also agreed on this: As a sign of confidence-building, at least the release of soldier Shalit is necessary. – Unfortunately, nothing has happened in this regard so far, although I know that many are working on it. But that would be an important signal to say: We want to move forward here.

We also do not yet know how the national unity government will engage if it comes to act as a government. We also know that there are significant differences between Fatah and Hamas. It is encouraging that Fatah today recognizes the principles, namely that it rejects violence, acknowledges Israel's right to exist, and accepts the international negotiation process.

But, of course, it is a worrying question in the truest sense of the word: What if one force in the government does not accept this and the other force has completely different opinions, and how will life then develop in these Palestinian territories?

Nevertheless, we must proceed step by step at this point. We must not squander opportunities because certain steps have been overlooked. Therefore, I advocate proceeding with care but also with clear principles.

In this context, I do not want to speak of hope yet. I merely want to point out: A lot has been set in motion in recent months – this, however, after the terrible events of last summer, which brought the entire region to the brink of a real catastrophe.

Therefore, one cannot speak about the Israeli-Palestinian issue at the moment without also saying a word about Lebanon. Because in Lebanon, we also have an extremely fragile situation. The Siniora government has our full support. But the constellation of the government and the questions of how the work with the parliament functions and how it will proceed are, of course, not clarified in many areas.

I believe it was important that the major Lebanon conference took place in Paris. It has strengthened Prime Minister Siniora. We must make every effort, including the work of UN troops under the UNIFIL mandate, to strengthen Lebanon's sovereignty. This includes our commitment to ensure that the tribunal addressing the assassination of former Prime Minister Hariri is established. This is indeed the reason for the current instabilities, at least the superficial reason. This, in turn, is of course also very closely related to the handling of Syria. I believe we must make and support every effort, including through the United Nations – this is also what Prime Minister Siniora himself strongly desires – to truly establish this tribunal.

This tribunal – the word is indeed very harsh – means, of course, that one must also proceed honestly. Here we come to the point that Syria's role is on the agenda. The European Union has repeatedly stated: We are ready to talk to Syria. There is no superficial rejection here. We are also trying to strengthen forces in Syria that could perhaps bring about a change.

But I must state that all the trips that have taken place so far have not yielded what we would wish for in terms of a concession from Syria. There is no cooperation regarding the strengthening of Lebanon's sovereignty. It would be very easy for Syria to at least diplomatically recognize Lebanon. There are also opportunities to cooperate in the area of border security on the Lebanese side and also on the Syrian side. But even here, there are no signs of willingness to do so. Everything indicates that Syria is currently neither able nor willing – I do not want to assess that – to take a step towards the great majority of the international community. I regret that.

Here, too, what we have said about Iran applies: The door is open. We, as Europeans, are always interested in dialogue. But certain results must, of course, be achieved, and certain conditions must be met. Small signs of cooperation must be recognizable. Unfortunately, they are not at the moment.

When we talk about the region, we cannot overlook Iraq. This means that the fact that there is dramatic instability in Iraq is a significant characteristic of the situation description. I find it right that a dialogue with partners in the region is beginning these days. I also find it right that the United States of America is participating in this. We, as the European Union and within the framework of the G8, are of course ready to take responsibility in this dialogue.

I also very much welcome that this initiative is coming from the Iraqi government. Because I believe our thinking – at least it is my conviction – must be very much focused on encouraging all willing forces in the region and not giving the impression that solutions are being imposed from above that ultimately have no broad acceptance throughout the region.

This is anything but simple. But the situation is so complicated that, in my view, everything must be tried to move things forward – not at the expense of principles, but by exploring all conceivable options. Because we know that history is not predictable. We can make very few statements about certain internal power dynamics in specific areas.

If we – this is my personal experience – had conducted surveys in the old Federal Republic about when the instability in the GDR – and these were still manageable areas – would lead to a collapse, then very few would have been able to make a precise statement.

Therefore, I believe it is always worthwhile to exert pressure and also to be able to live with the fact that one does not know exactly which pressure will generate which internal movement. What is crucial is that one still hopes for the overall development.

I believe that when it comes to the question of how the region will develop – especially regarding the question of what significance or weight Iran has in this region – it is very important to pay attention to countries like India, China, and Russia. Because they are the major trading partners of Iran.

Of course, sanctions against Iran in certain areas also have implications for European-Iranian economic relations. In the case of American-Iranian relations, it is somewhat simpler. But the real questions, including Iran's prosperity, also depend on the behavior of other actors. One must not forget: The way OPEC engages, how oil production levels are determined, has a significant impact on the oil price. And this, in turn, has a significant impact on the question: What does the internal situation of Iran look like?

This means that many variables must be considered. Therefore, we Europeans do well, in my view, to continually include emerging countries in our considerations. That is why we must maintain a very open dialogue with China. I have often done this in my contacts with China. China is beginning to pursue a very independent foreign policy when we look at the entire African continent. They are now also becoming much more engaged in the Gulf region.

We will also – I say this for us Europeans – have to be somewhat quicker in certain areas when it comes to economic cooperation. I have now worked very hard to ensure that we at least get the agreement with the EU and the Gulf Cooperation Council. The Commissioner nods. We have been negotiating for a full 17 years – one must consider that – and the world has changed significantly in these 17 years. I hope that we will make a step forward in April and truly make progress.

This also has something to do – this must be seen from a European perspective – with the fact that this region has not always been seen as economically significant to us. This is also partly due to the fact that we, as Europe of 15 and now 27, are not always very easy negotiating partners until we reach a result. But I believe that economic, diplomatic, and scientific cooperation as well as military collaboration in certain areas today are closely linked to the question of who engages where and how.

Therefore, I would like to conclude at this point with a remark that again refers to our relationship and friendship with Israel. We must pay attention to the fact that German-Israeli relations are not only relations that continually strive for conflict resolution, but that they take place on a broad level – in the scientific field, in the economic field, in the area of youth exchange and delegations of all kinds in very close cooperation. Therefore, I would like to thank everyone who does this beyond the political sphere.

Because what was taken for granted for generations before us after the Second World War, a very intense effort for good relations with Israel, must also be continually exhausted and lived by today’s younger generations.

We know from incidents of anti-Semitism – just recently there was an attack on a Jewish kindergarten in Berlin – that the German-Israeli and German-Jewish relationship must be continually reworked and that there are always attacks and new questions.

With Ambassador Stein – he is also present – we have sometimes discussed how little historical awareness many people in Germany and in Europe as a whole have, how much life takes place in the present time and how what happened 60 or 70 years ago is in danger of being forgotten, and what a challenge it is for my generation – I say this very deliberately – and what responsibility weighs on us when the generation that experienced the Holocaust, the Shoah, and National Socialism is no longer alive. We must see all of this clearly. In my view, this can best be addressed by having the most intensive relationships in all breadth.

The European Union has done this in various ways. However, if we are honest, there are many discussions in the European Union that deal more with what is to be criticized than with the question of Israel's right to exist. Here, too, one must always ensure that this takes place on a common platform with the necessary prioritization. I believe that we therefore have a great responsibility here.

When you discuss the German-Israeli relationship this evening and tomorrow, also about the possibilities of political progress, I have one final request: Do it not in a spirit of despair – but that is not the case in this circle anyway – but in a spirit of creativity. Discuss where we can find further points of approach to finally solve a long-standing problem. Because if we ourselves lose faith and only deal with what has already failed, then that is the surest prerequisite for no further steps to be taken.

In this sense, I believe you will support everything that is being done to move forward. To those who recognize a bit too much leniency or too little adherence to principles in the presentation of all the efforts that may still bring hope to resolve the conflict, I would simply like to say: There is a consensus in Germany that extends far beyond party lines that there are inalienable constants that cannot be put up for negotiation for the sake of a compromise. If this is clear among us, if there is no mistrust about it, then one can also try everything to further advance the process and perhaps lead it to a solution one day in the interest of young Israelis and young Palestinians.