Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the opening of the International Bertelsmann Forum "The Future of the European Union" on September 22, 2006, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

24 September 2006 · International Bertelsmann Forum "The Future of the European Union" · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the International Bertelsmann Forum in Berlin on September 22, 2006, outlining guiding principles for the future of the European Union.
Main themes
Future of the European Union, European integration, EU values and democracy, EU constitutional treaty, economic competition and prosperity, European enlargement, intercultural and interreligious dialogue, public enthusiasm for Europe, common currency, Treaty of Rome anniversary, European identity, peace and security
Duration
~27 min
79th percentile
Words
3,255
79th percentile
Sentences
166
84th percentile
Readability
44
47th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
15th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 44%41%
  • Geopolitical 32%30%
  • Economic 11%10%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

166 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Mr. Weidenfeld,

ladies and gentlemen!

I would like to express my heartfelt thanks to the Bertelsmann Foundation, Ms. Mohn and Mr. Thielen, as well as many others, for convening this conference, for addressing the topic of Europe, and for creating a framework that opens up new perspectives for us beyond councils and purely political events. In this respect, I and we, who represent the Federal Government here, will listen very attentively to see if we can gain some inspiration. I can also promise you that in return.

Given the many individual issues in the political day-to-day business, it is always worthwhile to take a look at the fundamental aspects. You have already done that by providing us with some impressions of the people in Europe. I believe it is undisputed that, from an outside perspective, Europe is an incredible success story for many in the world. Since this has become somewhat self-evident for us, it is still worth emphasizing it from time to time. When we look at conflict regions elsewhere in the world, what Europe has achieved after the Second World War is something that not only can be shown off but has also led to freedom and prosperity.

Since the founding of the European Coal and Steel Community, European integration has steadily progressed. We discussed this over lunch with the Hungarian Prime Minister, that the new member states have now taken a step into a deeply integrated Europe, which the older member states had years and decades to achieve, which of course also raises some friction and some questions. However, the overall degree of integration is now very high. It includes a common currency for soon 13 member countries, stemming from the fundamental idea of people and personalities after the Second World War who said: Those who share the same currency will never again wage war against each other. It was therefore not only a monetary decision but also a value-based decision.

The members drew closer together. Spain, Portugal, and Greece have transformed into flourishing democracies during this time; not to mention the Central and Eastern European countries. A country like Ireland is now among the wealthiest within the European Union. This means that Europe is associated with many opportunities for security, prosperity, and peace. We need this Europe – we are clear about that. But in public, the awareness, the enthusiasm in many places – one must say this soberly – has somewhat diminished. Europe is currently not a topic that immediately sparks enthusiasm when mentioned.

This is related to the fact that a whole series of questions remain unresolved: Where should Europe develop? What is the goal of the unification process? And it is also related to the fact that we find ourselves in a very tough competitive situation. This means that job competition, crime are keywords that could foster a protectionist tendency – we must certainly keep an eye on that. At the same time, there is a fear of a bureaucratic superstate that cannot properly define its own borders.

Therefore, we have received a "no" in France and the Netherlands for very different reasons, which are not only related to the constitution – Mr. Weidenfeld, I can only emphasize this. That is why it was also right to say that we will not immediately return to the constitutional treaty, but first address a few points that otherwise disturb people about Europe. This will certainly help the constitutional process.

At the moment, we have talked a lot about the Europe of projects to make it tangible, and this must continue.

I would like to clarify in five guiding principles what, as I believe, we must achieve. For we must re-establish Europe for the people of today, especially for the younger generation, without discarding the historical justification. But it must be supplemented.

My

first

guiding principle for such a new justification is: Europe must become clear about what its values are. These are not only shared historical experiences that we have, but we are based on common values that we all share: freedom, democracy, the rule of law, respect for human rights. Therefore, our politics must also be value-based. In our relations with other states that are not members of the European Union, this must be discussed; it must be reflected. I believe that this value-based approach with contemporary justification must be an important topic in view of the 50th anniversary of the signing of the Treaty of Rome. We will also prepare a political declaration here, and I ask that we keep the process as simple as possible and the wording as rich in content as possible. It is not always the case that the most perfect participation procedure leads to the most concise result. In this respect, we must find ways and means to truly address the questions that concern us.

Regarding the question of values, it is also about conducting an intercultural dialogue and an interreligious dialogue on the part of the European Union. In Germany, we have started to establish an Islamic conference with Federal Minister of the Interior Wolfgang Schäuble and to conduct this dialogue. I think we should also make it clear on the part of the European Union that we are ready for such a dialogue. It is not easy; for two reasons: Because we sometimes do not easily agree on a common platform and because our knowledge about other cultures and religions is inadequate.

I believe the necessity to be knowledgeable not only about our own home in a global world but also to engage with other cultures in a way that allows for respect and tolerance while still enabling genuine intellectual engagement requires much broader knowledge. There are very educated people – I certainly do not want to alarm anyone here – but the overall knowledge about those with whom we speak is not sufficient to conduct a truly in-depth dialogue.

From my perspective, Europe could also contribute something that might lead us back to a critical self-reflection. For it is not the case that everyone outside of Europe believes that we realize our values as perfectly as we think we do. The question of the role of the individual, the role of the community is being questioned in many parts of the world, and I believe it does us good to conduct this dialogue for our own reflection.

The

second

guiding thought: Europe must sharpen its contours both internally and externally, for without a clear structure regarding geographical expansion, Europe will struggle to survive in a rapidly changing world. There are – one must simply state this – very different approaches within the member states of the European Union. There are member states that prioritize deepening integration, and there are member states that strongly favor expansion. Some believe that all of this can be achieved in parallel; I do not believe that will work. Therefore, from my perspective, the statement is correct that for the foreseeable future – I will exclude the question of the Balkans for now – we cannot make any new commitments regarding memberships. This is a tough statement, one that is viewed somewhat differently by our Polish neighbor with regard to Ukraine, perhaps also by the Baltic member states. But I represent it here because I believe we must ensure that we are functional and also competitive.

For those who are conducting accession negotiations, the criteria must be met. These criteria also include the absorption capacity of the existing European Union; at least that is how we understand the Copenhagen criteria. We have initiated accession negotiations with Turkey – I want to specifically mention this here. But even there, it is necessary that all criteria are fulfilled. I do not want to elaborate on this, but we have a keyword that concerns us, which is the issue of Cyprus. A solution must be found for this question if the criteria and necessities of the European Union are to apply to all.

Because I am arguing relatively restrictively, it is all the more important that we develop a consistent and coherent neighborhood policy. We need, so to speak, a state, a community, a commonality that is more than mere neighborliness with member states of the European Union and yet does not entail full membership. Some ideas have recently been developed from the German side regarding Russia, as well as the Caucasian and other regions. This must be done. I believe this is also of great importance for the Mediterranean neighboring countries. I only mention: the Barcelona Process and others; we can still intensify and nurture many things here. This extends to a coherent Africa policy. I will come back to this shortly.

Of course, we also need better internal structuring. It is not the case that other regions of the world are waiting for us. We have rapid developments in China and India.

This brings me immediately to my third guiding principle: Economic dynamism is the prerequisite for a future-oriented European Union. If we cannot show individuals that Europe means more prosperity for them than a single nation-state, then people will not accept this European Union. Prosperity is not enough, but without prosperity, the discussion about values and many other things will be much more difficult. And therefore, it must become clear again: We are better off through Europe, and thus the implementation of a consistent completion of the internal market is one of the central topics. The daily struggles of the Commission show that this happens on paper more easily than in reality. We all often groan and sigh when it comes to vested interests to which we have become accustomed, which seem to be constitutive. But I believe there is no alternative to completing the internal market.

The Lisbon Strategy is very abstract in itself and was certainly very ambitious. Europe is probably not the most dynamic continent in the world in 2010, but we need more dynamism. And therefore, the liberalization of markets is an important point: energy, postal services, telecommunications, implementation of the action plan for financial services, a common tax base for corporate taxes – all keywords that carry a lot of potential.

And for me, the issue of reducing bureaucracy is also part of it. Generally, this is referred to in the Commission as "Better Regulation." The simple translation in German does not suggest that it is about fewer directives. I believe we have not done much important in this regard during the shaping of the internal market, but in some areas, we have done too much that is unimportant. Fortunately, directives on issues like sunshade regulations have now come into special focus in the European Parliament, because the members of the European Parliament, on the one hand, have many competencies, but on the other hand, are also asked much more at home about what they are doing in Parliament in Brussels and Strasbourg. This is also right, because a well-structured Europe needs strong parliamentary control; I am deeply convinced of that. Only in this way will the connection to the voters be possible.

As

third

, which is very important to me, we will emphasize the topic of research and development very much during our presidency alongside "Better Regulation" and the reduction of bureaucracy. The seventh framework research program is very ambitious. The goal is a very consistent approach based on excellence, not on national circumstances or distribution keys. The factor of excellence must be the standard for all evaluations in the European Union; only in this way can we move forward.

We will – this is my fourth guiding principle – only shape globalization if we throw our weight together into the scales. This means that we must appear strong, consistent, and also creative in international negotiations; I only mention the keywords Doha Round or Kyoto. There is a need for improvement, that is for sure. One can also blame others for this – other regions of the world are not particularly creative either – but Europe can also be a role model; however, we are also very attached to our vested interests.

Furthermore, it is about a common European security and defense policy. Here, it must be said that this security and defense policy – this is very important to me – must not stand against the transatlantic partnership. It must also not enter into a conflict situation with NATO. However, Europe will be increasingly challenged in terms of foreign policy, security, and defense tasks in the coming years. The last few weeks have dramatically taken us into responsibility here. If this meeting had taken place four months ago and we had said that we are represented in the Middle East with strong European forces, a mild smile would probably have crossed the faces of some. The military component that we have now deployed with UNIFIL requires a political commitment, because otherwise, the people in Europe will ask us what we are doing here, and therefore we must work creatively together with our American partners to resolve the individual conflicts and do so with great commitment.

Europe has also contributed to a process regarding Iran that has unfortunately been unsuccessful so far. Here, too, it becomes clear: throwing our weight into the balance together leads to finding more allies in the world. The situation related to the Iraq war was so difficult precisely because there was ultimately a divided and not jointly capable Europe. And the lessons we have drawn from this so far are encouraging – I want to say that explicitly. We have achieved a lot in our dealings with Iran.

A few years ago, there were no European defense missions at all. We are now engaged in the Middle East, but we are also involved in individual European missions, for example, in securing the electoral process in the Congo. Anyone who sees how cooperation is now possible with such ease can also see what has already been created in Europe. I say this with great gratitude. When we were not making progress with our Bundestag resolution regarding our naval engagement off the coast of Lebanon or needed some time, the straightforward and unbureaucratic help from Greece, Italy, and France showed how closely we cooperate here, and this must continue.

Then follows as the fifth guiding principle what Mr. Weidenfeld spoke about so enthusiastically: Europe needs a future-oriented structure also in the form of a contractual basis. I believe this deeply. It was quite interesting to reflect historically on what has ultimately succeeded from failed operations. I will look into this again and see what we might succeed in.

There is a wise decision that was made at the last Council meeting under the Austrian presidency, which did not burden one presidency with everything regarding the future of the constitutional treaty. We know: We must have made decisions by 2009, and when time runs out, only minimalist decisions can be made. Therefore, we will approach the matter ambitiously. I do not want to say that the French presidency is responsible for the minimalist decisions; I hope that we have already achieved something in the meantime. But the German presidency must develop a structure for this timeframe.

I want to say this quite openly: I am personally skeptical when it comes to new councils of wise men who come up with something again or develop new text bases. That is not the problem. The problem now is a very concrete political one, behind which ultimately stand questions of the depth of integration, questions of the weighting of institutions, and also questions of the values charter.

At the end of our presidency, we will present a plan, a concept; given various election dates, this will not be possible even before the end of the presidency. The presidency does well – as does the future one – not to go public with specific proposals just yet. That makes no sense at all. The longing for specific statements is, of course, great, but the specific statement of one almost reflexively leads to rejecting statements from others, and therefore it will require a skillful process to find the commonalities here.

The fact is that we certainly need a solution in the institutional area. But I also say: The part on fundamental rights is very, very important to me because it says something about us, and because the discussion with the respective governments about this part on fundamental rights will show whether it is more than just a voting body. Europe is, of course, more. We also have additional competencies. This primarily includes the establishment of the office of a European Foreign Minister. Here, it already becomes clear every day how urgent that would actually be. Nevertheless, I am against cherry-picking. Now we must withstand the pressure and must not quickly take out what we believe we can do together most easily and leave the remaining basket, the rest of the torso, lying somewhere. We must approach the matter ambitiously.

It is no secret that some are also bothered by the term "constitutional treaty," as this naturally expresses the depth of integration and the individual member states have very different traditions here. But I still advocate that we do not name this structure we want to create "undercover" to avoid hurting anyone, but rather to have a very self-confident discussion at the beginning about the fact that the term "constitutional treaty" is not so bad.

Because the truth is: We have transferred essential competencies to Europe, and sometimes I have to smile about how incredibly difficult it is for us to express that in our national discussions. But it is indeed the case that we can no longer defend internal security as nation-states alone. Schengen is a transfer of national sovereignty. Anyone who does not express that ultimately does not engage in an offensive discussion about the question: What should happen in Europe and what should happen at home in the nation-states? The starting point of the constitutional treaty was precisely this discussion. We have certainly made a step forward, but it is not the last step.

Dear Commission President, I also believe that we need to come to an understanding among the member states again about what the Commission actually is – this has not yet been conclusively clarified by the constitutional treaty. The Commission is the administrator of the things that we, as sovereign states, have transferred to European responsibility. I advocate that there should not be too many gray areas in which we discuss matters in Europe for which Europe is ultimately not responsible. But I do advocate that we have effective decision-making mechanisms for the things for which Europe is responsible. In this regard, the fact that there is no discontinuity for directives is a handicap. Also, the fact that directors-general are not particularly bound by instructions from their commissioners is a completely unthinkable state for a German minister. Therefore, we must also discuss these matters again if we do not want an apolitical apparatus to develop with a political facade, but instead want a whole as a Commission that is subject to parliamentary control and thus must also exhibit a high degree of transparency.

In this sense, we still have a lot of work to do. I advise addressing things honestly, not sweeping differing opinions and slow actions under the rug. This is sometimes very laborious because we have become many in the European Union, but from my perspective, there is no alternative to this honesty and integrity.