Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Petersberg Climate Dialogue IV "Shaping the Future" on May 6, 2013, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

7 May 2013 · Petersberg Climate Dialogue IV · ewerks, Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Petersberg Climate Dialogue IV in Berlin on May 6, 2013, urging progress toward a binding global climate agreement ahead of the Warsaw COP19.
Main themes
Climate change mitigation, international climate negotiations, two-degree target, CO2 emissions reduction, Kyoto Protocol, Paris Agreement preparation, climate justice, industrialized vs. developing nations, European Union climate commitments, binding global climate agreement, technological cooperation, Copenhagen Accord
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,131
77th percentile
Sentences
174
86th percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
10.4
24th percentile
Syntax
2.97
43rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 67%67%
  • Economic 16%16%
  • Geopolitical 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Institutional 2%2%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

174 sentences in 30 paragraphs

Dear Minister Korolec,

dear Minister Altmaier,

above all, dear participants in this Petersberg Dialogue, which, as we can see, is not taking place on the Petersberg, but in flat Berlin, in the capital – but at least you went to the roof of the "ewerks" last night to enjoy a bit of mountainous horizon –,

I warmly welcome you on behalf of the Federal Government here in Berlin. I believe this will be an important meeting where we will work towards achieving good results at the conference at the end of the year in our neighboring country, with our friends in Poland. If we analyze where we stand in the spring of 2013, we must honestly say that the path to mitigating climate change is proving to be a complicated one.

Well, when I think back to my time as Minister for the Environment from 1994 to 1998, I am not really surprised. Because even then, this process was very difficult. We concluded the Kyoto Protocol; it was prepared at that time by a Berlin mandate. We subsequently saw – when I think of the European Union – that some progress was made. We have met our commitments, particularly the Federal Republic of Germany. But the disappointment was also that the Congress in the United States did not ratify the agreement. In this respect, we have experienced both light and shadow.

Then at the end of 2009, when it came to the question of how to proceed after Kyoto, the Copenhagen Conference was burdened with a multitude of expectations. As it turned out, it was ultimately overloaded. For me, the Copenhagen Conference is one of the frustrating experiences, although something was achieved at that time that has turned out to be not so bad in hindsight. We agreed – which was confirmed again a year later in Cancun – on the two-degree target. However, we recognized that the voluntary commitments made by individual member states under the so-called "Copenhagen Accord" do not, in sum, ensure the fulfillment of the two-degree target. I learned in Copenhagen that the commitment to the two-degree target is simple, but that the seemingly simple calculation of what that really means in terms of CO2 concentrations is much more complicated than one might think. Why is that? It is complicated because, with the two-degree target, one does not have to specify a proper base year. With the beginning of industrialization, some things remain vague. This means that in order to say what limiting warming to two degrees really means, we still have a task to complete. How much reduction in CO2 emissions does that really mean?

This table may seem quite unremarkable. But around it sit representatives from countries that account for about 80 percent of global CO2 emissions. This means that you and your governments, we all, have it in our hands how we move forward. We have known since Copenhagen – one could have seen this earlier – that if all industrialized countries were to commit to emitting no CO2 from tomorrow, we still could not achieve the two-degree target. This is now generally accepted. Therefore, from my perspective, it was a very important step that in Durban, South Africa, we managed to agree – which could then be further developed last year in Qatar – that we want to conclude a binding agreement for all by 2020. We did not want to leave it to the last minute again. So it was said: this agreement should be in place by 2015. Our French friends have the honor of hosting the climate conference in Paris. We will support them – just as we will support our Polish neighbors this year. Because we must now carefully consider what we still need to accomplish by the end of 2013, the end of 2014, and the end of 2015 in order to truly achieve the goal.

This also raises the question for which we need a convincing answer: What is justice in combating climate change? One thing is certain: We, the representatives of industrialized countries, have two obligations. On the one hand, we must achieve a substantial reduction in CO2 emissions. – Here in Germany, measured against the reference year 1990, we are on a fairly good path. – On the other hand, it is about a technological contribution from countries that have not yet been able to participate in the benefits of industrialization. We therefore need to develop technology so that for these countries, the increase in prosperity, the fight against climate change, and social concerns are not in opposition to each other.

That is why it is also logical that the European Union has said: We will continue to be a contracting party under the Kyoto Protocol. But it is somewhat frustrating when we see that now, besides the European Union, only a few countries remain. I actually thought that after the expiration of the Kyoto Protocol, the number of countries entering into binding commitments would grow, not decrease. To put it bluntly, it is important that Europe has committed to remaining a Kyoto contracting party, but alone we certainly cannot stop climate change in the world.

We Europeans also repeatedly encounter limits. For example, we have introduced the CO2 emissions trading system for aviation solely for ourselves. This has not won us any friends in the world. I have had countless conversations outside of Europe where I have been asked what this is all about. I tell you frankly: We are now hoping to make progress at the International Civil Aviation Organization. We have now imposed a moratorium. But our pioneering role has not been appreciated worldwide; rather, we have been portrayed as outsiders and party poopers – accompanied by harsh threats regarding flying to Europe. So the conclusion is: Europe must strive for global solutions. We cannot make progress alone. Therefore, we are working with the International Civil Aviation Organization regarding aviation.

I return once more to the question of justice. We know it is about the two-degree target. We will eventually also know how many CO2 emissions that means in relation to a specific year. We fundamentally know that in the long term, when we look at the world population, each inhabitant of this earth should emit about two tons of CO2. Now many who hear this are initially very startled when it is mentioned. Our ally on this side is India. India has accepted this approach as a just approach. But one must be honest: Neither Europeans, nor Americans, nor the Chinese are very enthusiastic about it. Because they all already emit over two tons of CO2. And that essentially means one would have to start reducing now. We industrialized countries accept that. But a country like China says: Please look at how many decades you have increased your CO2 emissions; at our economic level, we cannot start reducing right now. – So you see the great challenge we face.

In Europe, we currently have a difficult economic situation. Our gross domestic product in Europe is stagnating, and in some cases, it is even declining. This means that we have not yet emerged from the crisis of 2008/2009 to the extent that all member states of the European Union have returned to the economic level they had before 2008. Germany managed to do that again in 2011. But we also experienced a huge drop in growth of over five percent in 2009, which we then compensated for by 2011. Currently, however, our growth rates in Europe are virtually stagnant. You all know the number of unemployed. You all know how many young people in Europe are unemployed. Of course, the question now arises: How do we return to economic growth, how can we combat unemployment, how can we get our public finances back on track?

Since 2009, we have been continuously dealing with crisis management, whether in the euro area or in the European Union as a whole. Now there is an effect that we did not foresee, namely that due to the declining growth rates, we have not experienced an increase in CO2 emissions in Europe as we had actually predicted. On the one hand, that is good. But on the other hand, it is not good for what we had in mind as a market-based instrument, namely CO2 trading. Now the discussion has flared up – keyword backloading –: Should we revise the assumptions we made? Or should we, if it is a market-based instrument, let the market forces prevail, from which the price then results?

Personally, I say: If you have a market-based instrument where the assumptions about growth rates play a significant role, and the growth rates are anything but what was assumed, then the question of whether it needs to be revised again cannot be a taboo. On this question, I say quite openly, we are not decided in Germany. Different forces are presenting their arguments because we have an additional problem in Germany. We have a rapid expansion of renewable energies. We need a capacity of 60, 70, or even 75 gigawatts in winter. We have now installed nearly 30 gigawatts of solar energy. We have about 25 gigawatts of wind energy installed. When the sun shines in Germany, there is usually also a bit of wind. This means we have hours in which we can cover almost all energy needs from renewable energies. However, we also have many hours of the day when we need base-load power plants because we do not have enough storage and have not yet built enough lines. Therefore, the German economy says: We are willing to discuss backloading as well. But we do not want to regulate everything individually; we need a comprehensive system.

One thing is clear: We must reform the generation of renewable energies in Germany on the legal basis of the so-called Renewable Energy Sources Act to ensure a harmonious further expansion of renewable energies, a better expansion of storage, and above all, a corresponding expansion of the grid systems. Electricity should, of course, not only be CO2-free and come from renewable energies, but it must also be affordable and must not jeopardize Germany's industrial location.

That is why I say: If we succeed in reforming the Renewable Energy Sources Act, which is currently very difficult – not only because we will soon have an election, but also because many have invested or want to invest in renewable energies and therefore are not very willing to show interest in the overall system – we will certainly be able to turn our attention to backloading again. I believe that then we will find a solution in the overall context. But to claim now that Europe is no longer a pioneer in climate protection because a decision in the European Parliament was made against backloading is, in my opinion, completely inappropriate. Europe is doing a lot. Europe will continue to do a lot. Our problem, looking beyond Europe, is rather that we are doing everything alone while simultaneously being in a difficult economic situation. The problem is not that we are doing too little.

Germany will continue to feel committed to working intensively for a successor agreement from 2020 in 2015. I have no illusions about how much work lies ahead of us. I am counting heavily on our cooperation with China, India, the Gulf States, and the United States of America.

Regarding the United States of America, the following situation has now arisen: Due to large discoveries and the use of natural gas in the form of shale gas, CO2 emissions in the United States will decrease. Energy prices will be significantly lower than, for example, in Europe. But in the long term, the use of natural gas alone will not be sufficient for reducing CO2 emissions in the United States. This means that we also need to expand renewable energies here. Of course, the initial improvement also carries the risk that one might say: With this, we can get by for the next few years. This will not necessarily increase the willingness to take on long-term commitments.

So, this is the situation in which the conference will take place in Poland. The good thing about the host Poland is: Poland knows all the problems of the transition from a heavily carbon-based energy economy to other energy sources. Poland also understands the issue of dependency, which one does not want to create, and the question that one's own energy security is worth a lot.

The next major task for Europe will be to create a basis of trust so that we do not have 27 individual energy markets. In Germany, we are sometimes accused of seeing everything only from a national perspective. Therefore, we must truly create an internal energy market from 27 national energy markets through better connection of our lines, through interconnectors, through a European network, through reliability in mutual energy supply. This means we must learn to think European. I believe advancing this is an important task for Poland as the host and then also for France as the host. Both represent, so to speak, the extremes of European energy production. Some generate energy primarily from coal, while France generates it primarily from nuclear energy, with the ambition to expand renewable energies in the coming years.

Europe must arrive at an emissions target for 2030. This is urgent – the federal government will not shy away from this – because the economy needs to plan, invest, and therefore know what framework conditions it must adapt to. Investment plans for 2018/2019/2020 are already being made in companies today, not just in three or four years. This means that if we want to continue on the path of CO2 reductions – and we do want to continue – then it is only fair and just that the industry knows from us – it has a right to know – how the whole thing will proceed until 2030.

If we in Europe can also manage to better coordinate the various areas of CO2 emissions – transport, heating market, electricity generation, industry, private consumption – with incentive instruments, then something would also be achieved for the overall strategy to combat climate change. Because we have taxes on electricity alone in Germany. We have certificates. We have more legislation and certain regulations for new buildings in the heating market. For existing buildings, we have incentive programs. Thus, each country in Europe actually has its own funding instruments alongside the European realities of emissions trading. This whole system needs to be made more coherent.

I tell you this because Europe, by doing this work, can certainly also serve as an example for other regions in the world that must go through the same difficulties. Germany, with its ambitions to become independent from nuclear energy by 2022 through the energy transition while also meeting CO2 reduction targets, is now prototypically going down this path. This path presents difficulties, but we as politicians are also here to solve difficulties. We are entering uncharted territory. Therefore, we must face the challenges.

I would like to mention a second aspect. If all that concerns the negotiations is progressing slowly and the major questions are not yet resolved, but clear objectives are in place, then it is all the more important that we make progress in practical areas. In Copenhagen, great promises were made, namely 100 billion US dollars for combating climate change. We are still some way from having these 100 billion US dollars truly available. When I meet with representatives of small island states at international conferences, the frustration is already great. However, I believe Germany has done a good job with its contribution. We are increasing this in 2013 from 1.4 to 1.8 billion euros. However, it is always a long way from the promise of money to the point where the money actually reaches those who are to implement the projects.

I was at the Protestant Church Day in Hamburg on Friday. There, I spoke with Helen Clark, the chair of UNDP, about the question: What can we improve?

There are two components. The first is that the money actually arrives. The second is that the countries submitting applications also have the capacity to process these applications so that they are approvable. What we must not do is for the industrialized countries to say: "Look, here is the money," but then whenever an application comes, to say: "No, it does not yet meet the requirements." Then the money is saved; and the countries submitting these applications feel completely overwhelmed. This means that we industrialized countries and the international UN organizations UNDP and UNEP or the World Bank must be ready to assist in preparing these applications so that the money that is available can be spent sensibly.

However, there are also some things that are progressing well. We had the lowest level of deforestation in Brazil last year, as satellite images have shown. We have a huge solar energy program in Saudi Arabia. The Dominican Republic has set a binding reduction target. In Bangladesh, which is among the countries most affected by climate change, a multitude of initiatives have been launched. In California, the cap-and-trade program has come into effect. The current five-year plan in China includes concrete targets for more climate protection. When the new Chinese Prime Minister Li Keqiang comes to Germany, climate protection will also be on our agenda. This means there are many individual initiatives. It is now essential to consolidate the quantity of these initiatives into an unchangeable stream so that the pressure to conclude an agreement in 2015 increases and one cannot say: We still have a little time until 2020. We must not lose time.

I am pleased that you have all come here. I thank you for being willing to contribute on behalf of your countries. This will certainly not be an easy path. But I keep reminding everyone of the Stern Report, which states: If we do nothing, the path will not become easier, but certainly more complicated. What we must always make clear externally is: Doing nothing does not mean that nothing happens, but doing nothing means that it will cost us much more overall.

One can debate for a long time about which climate fluctuations in which year are expressions of real change. There are many theories to consider. However, I believe the overall evidence – whether two years earlier or two years later – is so massive in climate change that it is truly lost time to argue about whether we need to do something now or perhaps later and whether we can still wait. Waiting is not an option.

Therefore, I say thank you. I wish you fruitful discussions.