Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel on the 50th anniversary of the German Atomic Forum e.V. on July 1, 2009, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

4 July 2009 · 50th anniversary of the German Atomic Forum e.V · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 50th anniversary celebration of the German Atomic Forum in Berlin on July 1, 2009, speaking on nuclear energy policy and Germany's energy future.
Main themes
Nuclear energy policy, energy supply security, safety culture in nuclear industry, phase-out of nuclear energy in Germany, radioactive waste final storage, pragmatic energy approach, German Atomic Forum anniversary, Chernobyl legacy, red-green coalition energy policy, industrial safety culture, Castor transport controversy, energy source transition
Duration
~17 min
59th percentile
Words
2,077
59th percentile
Sentences
97
61st percentile
Readability
42
42nd percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
3.00
47th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 30%29%
  • Environmental 26%25%
  • Institutional 13%12%
  • Social 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 11%10%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Not in focus 3%

97 sentences in 28 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Marx,

Dear Professor Baring,

Dear Ambassador,

Esteemed guests from France, Germany, and perhaps other countries!

Congratulations on the 50th anniversary of the German Atomic Forum.

I am very interested in this topic and I apologize for arriving late. This week is the last parliamentary week, not only before the summer break but also the last official parliamentary week of this legislative period. It is particularly hectic.

Professor Baring, it was very interesting to revisit with you the part of the historical development of the Federal Republic of Germany that has led to a division of societal opinions, indeed with far-reaching political implications for today’s party landscape in the Federal Republic of Germany.

I want to be very clear: When I stand before you today and speak, beyond the congratulations, about the question of energy supply and nuclear energy, I do so from a rather pragmatic approach, which you also emphasized in the last part of your speech. It is a pragmatic perspective when one knows that industrial societies and industrial locations need energy supply.

The sources of energy supply will change over time. But I believe, especially when I look at them globally, that nuclear energy has a perspective for a manageable period of time. It is in Germany's interest to contribute to this technically extraordinarily demanding energy generation for the foreseeable future. As far as the safety of nuclear power plants is concerned, Germany manages its energy supply very well. However, if one day we have entirely different possibilities for generating energy, we should not cling to nuclear energy for ideological reasons. But we all live in our time. In our time, I consider it an important contribution to energy supply.

I believe it is appropriate to say to the German Atomic Forum on its 50th anniversary that you have, of course, advocated for the promotion of nuclear energy, but that you have also repeatedly earned a reputation for fostering a factual debate. You have tried to convince with factual arguments, which, of course, is often a very different game in the context of emotionally charged conflicts. Therefore, it is very good that there is now an opportunity for discussion in society – Professor Baring also pointed this out – which partly allows for more factual arguments.

The important aspect of what nuclear energy and its use in the Federal Republic of Germany entails is that we are always extraordinarily focused on safety culture. One contribution of the Atomic Forum has been that we have repeatedly emphasized the safety aspect. Therefore, the incident in Chernobyl is one that says more about the lack of safety in dealing with industrial structures in socialism and communism – or however one might call it – than about the safety culture that we have always had in the old Federal Republic and in the West overall. I believe that Germany is a pioneer in this regard.

Life expectancy in the new federal states has only increased by more than five years in the last 20 years because previously all forms of industry were handled irresponsibly. There was generally no or a much too weakly developed safety culture in industry – whether it concerned the chemical industry, the Wismut company in Aue, or nuclear power plants. All the more, it was necessary to take action in this area in all sectors after German reunification.

Now we are in a situation where the red-green federal government decided in 1998 to phase out nuclear energy. Two years later, based on this, the well-known agreement with the energy industry was reached, about which much could be said – for example, how voluntary or involuntary it was, how necessary or unnecessary it was. However, I do not want to evaluate that further. I was myself the Minister for the Environment, dealt with Castor transports, and saw how the societal debate ignited with each Castor transport. We have overcome that with the phase-out decision. The Castor transport apparently is no longer so dangerous when it is established that one will phase out in ten or thirteen years. That is also an interesting thing. Demonstrations still occur when something is transported, but they are much smaller.

Here we address a point that the opponents of nuclear energy have set and to which we still do not have a conclusive answer, but which must come: that is the question of final storage. The image of an airplane that has taken off but has no landing place has always been kept alive by undermining everything that could have advanced us in building a landing place. A significant progress of the Grand Coalition is that we now at least have a final storage facility for low- and medium-level radioactive materials. Previously, it was not even possible to send X-ray images and similar items to any final storage. That this is now possible gives me hope that we may also achieve progress in other areas. However, it must be said that the problem of final storage is not resolved worldwide and that this is indeed a burden for the global interest in building more nuclear power plants.

Germany has always distinguished itself by developing the most modern nuclear power plants – also in close cooperation with France; that is why I am pleased that we have French guests among us today. We have developed the best reactors in the world. I think, for example, of the EPR.

We should be aware that we live in a time of scarcity. Given the population growth and economic growth in the coming decades, we will be dealing more with energy generation scarcity than with too many raw materials. In many countries, there is therefore a rethinking regarding nuclear energy; whether it is, for example, in Sweden, where they have solved the issue very interestingly – they publicly phased out, then retrofitted and modernized the nuclear power plants, and simply continued – or whether it concerns countries like Italy and others. We see a rethinking; we see in the energy planning and energy scenarios of many countries also the use of nuclear energy.

I personally worry greatly about what will happen if Germany one day should phase out this area, which I do not want; I want the extension of the operating time of nuclear power plants, and at the best technical level. I am very concerned that then an important voice for more safety in the production of nuclear energy in the world would be lost.

We have achieved a lot through our commitment to climate protection. I know that Germany cannot move everything. However, Germany can, for example, move a lot together with France and thus also make a significant contribution to a safety culture. But we have technologies in Germany that we ourselves want to participate in less and less. If the answer to climate protection now is that we must not have coal-fired power plants or nuclear power plants, then it will be the case that we will also have to rely on our good neighbor France for energy supply. However, this would not guarantee our security any better. Because as far as a potential accident is concerned, it would make no difference whether the nuclear power plants are in Germany or in France. We Germans – I am deeply convinced of this – cannot allow ourselves only exceptional paths from genetic technology to coal-fired power plants to nuclear power plants. That would weaken our industrial base.

I also want to say at this point: It is now being counted almost electronically whether we really need as much electricity as we can generate. It is said: We do not need to generate more than we need ourselves. I also consider this a rather petty view in a European context. If Germany, with good energy suppliers and good power plant manufacturers, should be a country that occasionally exports something to the European networks, and if the overall balance of exports and imports should be positive, then not only would the world not come to an end, but it could also be a very interesting source of income.

It has now been shown – and I see this as well – that one does not have to be against renewable energies just because one is for nuclear energy, but I consider energy saving and energy efficiency to be the most exciting path. We still have significant opportunities in the heating sector. However, in the electricity sector, we cannot and should not do without nuclear energy in the short term. It currently accounts for about 25 percent of our electricity generation. It is base-load capable in the best sense of the word.

We will see significant developments in renewable energies. When I became Minister for the Environment in 1994, I could not have imagined the progress that would be made in wind energy, regarding the operating times of wind turbines and the technical possibilities. If somewhere in the world a great storage medium is found, then we could significantly improve the base-load capabilities of some renewable energies.

But we should know with every form of energy: There is nothing for free. As the English say: There is no free lunch in this world. Every form of energy generation has its disadvantages. That is why we have always advocated for an energy mix in Germany. We have never relied solely on one form of energy generation. And thus, electricity generation should gradually shift to a high proportion of renewable energies, namely up to 30 percent by 2020. But then there will still be 70 percent.

Then we need to take another look at the regional distribution in Germany. In the south, where we predominantly have large industrial consumers, we have a high share of nuclear energy generation. When I see with what "passion" the general planning approval procedures for the construction of lines are being conducted today, I can only say: By the time we can direct all the electricity from offshore wind farms to the south, everyone in Temelin or elsewhere in Eastern Europe will have already sold their electricity from nuclear power plants.

We must therefore ensure that we also manage the timing sensibly and pursue a rational energy policy that does not ignore the risks and takes the necessary things into account. For me, this includes final storage and consideration of the real costs, which of course imply the final storage costs and, in light of CO2 certification and certificate trading, also the costs of new coal-fired power plants and, of course, the total costs of renewable energies.

I am enthusiastic – I say this very explicitly – about visionary projects like "Desertec." But those who believe that this could overnight save the electricity supply of all of Europe do not have any idea of the technical problems that still need to be overcome in this context. In this respect, we do well not to change our energy mix abruptly and not to spoil our export opportunities, but to pursue a balanced policy for an important industrial country like Germany.

I know that today many of those trained in the field of nuclear energy – engineers, operators, and so on – are receiving offers from other countries to work there due to their know-how. This is part of a problem that personally concerns me a lot, namely that in the end we have too many excellent engineers, scientists, well-trained skilled workers, and masters who are setting their main residence elsewhere because they have better job opportunities with what they have learned. Since we need those who also pay taxes in our country, who work here motivated, who advocate for innovations, it is so important that we do not deprive ourselves of too many areas in which one can earn money worldwide.

I want Germany to remain a future-oriented country. For me, this also includes nuclear energy for the foreseeable future – both in terms of export and as a bridge energy source into the future. Therefore, I can say at this point that this federal government does not look uniformly into the future. However, energy policy will not be the topic of the electoral debate in September, but it will be a topic.

Thank you. I can – as has already been seen today – certainly not convey the congratulations of the entire federal government, but I do so on my part as Chancellor once again. Thank you very much.